Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice does, admittedly, look pretty excellent going by the trailers, but there are also a great many traps into which it could fall judging by the most recent additions to the Batman and Superman franchises. Man Of Steel was divisive, to put it lightly - the fan backlash makes the film's ending destruction of Metropolis look slight by comparison. Even its staunchest defender, however, would concede there are some big things that need addressing as we go forward into the DC Extended Universe. Superman's a hard character to get right and while adding Batman may seem like an easy shortcut, there's a fair bit that needs tweaking for a truly memorable film. Sometimes filmmakers can become so close to their creations that they lose perspective and can't see the wood for the trees. Or, more accurately, they can't see the ridiculously overlong third act for the wicked cool slow-mo punching sequences. And that definitely applies to Zack Snyder. Here are the big changes that need to happen if Dawn Of Justice is going to be stand on its own two feet and succeed on its own terms. Otherwise, we'll be right back where we were with Man Of Steel. Or, shudder, Superman Returns.
8. Drop The Wobblecam Theatrics
One thing that the Avengers saga has got right consistently is the choreography and direction of its fight scenes. They manage to balance the big wallops and bangs and crashes with character-development tidbits, and infuse the whole thing with a sense of clarity. Those wallops and bangs and crashes actually feel like they mean something when they land, which is an achievement. By contrast, Man Of Steel went for a mixed approach. Half of it was standard epic photography, but intermittently through the action scenes Snyder made a big deal of jacking Cloverfield and the Bourne trilogy's tactic of making it look like it was all filmed on a handheld camcorder, with lots of smash zooms and refocusing as a way of saying, "Guys, look: this is, like, totally relevant to these modern times because of, like, YouTube and the Twitter and, uh... is MySpace still relevant?" It's a clunky contrivance now rather than the fresh new direction it was ten years ago. There are ways of making your adaptation of fantastical source material feel grounded in reality without making your audience feel like they're watching the film while trapped in a washing machine, you know.
7. Get Some New Filters For Christ's Sake
Oh, excellent. Everything is a muddy greyish brown. What a fantastic point you've just made about how gritty and sinewy this world which you've made for your noble-but-actually-quite-troubled heroes. How very modish and dangerous of you to depart from the cartoonish excesses of the mid-90s. It's like watching a classic piece of film noir, except in this instance Humphrey Bogart can fly and shoot lasers from his eyes. Man Of Steel's grain was noticeable from the first frame and was never really used for anything creative, other than to repeatedly hammer home that this was different to the brightness of Christopher Reeve's movies. To paraphrase the previous point: there are ways of making your adaptation of fantastical source material feel rooted in reality without making your audience feel like they're slowly developing cataracts, you know. The Dark Knight Trilogy was grounded without having to go in for such tricks, and that's regarded pretty well.
6. Try Harder With Your Strong Female Characters Than You Did Last Time Around, Zack
Lois Lane got pretty poorly served in Man Of Steel: she was perky enough, but that was more down to Amy Adams' general perkiness and verve than because she was given anything particularly interesting to do or say. Too often, modern blockbusters pay lip service to the idea of 'strong female characters' by just giving them a better job than they might have done in the past and occasionally having them mildly disagree with the main character before having to be rescued from some diabolical scheme or other. It's worn pretty thin now, to be honest. And not only do we have Adams returning for Batman V Superman, but also the introduction of Gal Gadot's Wonder Woman. Now, characters who are blooded in other characters' films with a view to setting up their own films can get pretty badly shafted and end up with only a tokenistic relevance to the actual plot - prior to Age Of Ultron, that's certainly something which fans of Hawkeye levelled at Marvel - and that's an aspect which Dawn Of Justice needs to address. But with a female character that's even more of a risk - Hollywood at the moment just can't quite get past the whole damsel in distress idea. Wonder Woman's a very important character, both in the comics and the DCEU going forward, so she's one Snyder can't afford to mess up.
5. Please, Please, Please Use Less CGI
There's a bit of a movement building against using computer generated effects right now - witness the gurglings of joy from Star Wars fans when JJ Abrams announced that he was trying to ensure that The Force Awakens will use practical effects as far as possible - and Dawn Of Justice would do well to heed that. The over-application of CGI was one of the biggest drawbacks of Man Of Steel. Yes, admittedly, it's quite hard to simulate a man flying through the air without it looking distinctly ropey by modern blockbuster standards, but I'd take that over the dismal display of widespread devastation which Superman left in his wake during the film that, because of the way it was animated and directed, felt dutiful and perfunctory. It wasn't a gob-smacking, shock-packed thrillride. It was an endless, one-paced, completely pointless smashing up of a city you didn't care about because it didn't feel like it had any weight to it whatsoever. It was, as Shakespeare probably would have said after he'd seen the movie, a tale told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing. This one's quite unlikely to be heeded, judging by the trailer's depiction of the destruction of Wayne Tower or the clearly fake Senate building, but one can only ask.
4. Give The Action Some Purpose
Superhero movies have always favoured massive action finales like Stan Lee has favoured alliteration, but Man Of Steel's ending took the biscuit. However, the problem wasn't that it is necessarily bad for a movie to go balls to the wall destructive, especially if the fate of the world is at stake, but that there was no real reason for us to care anything about it. This is kinda an extension of the previous point, but even if there was top-tier CGI the finale of Man Of Steel still wouldn't have been engaging. The attempts to stop Zod all felt very flat, and none of the human characters involved had been developed to a point where their lives being in danger had an impact; give us a reason to invest in what's on screen beyond gasping at fireworks Batman V Superman does appear to have a lot of big action from the trailers (a shocker given the title), with several shots of mass devastation, although we'll have to wait until the movie's released before we know if there's a real purpose behind it. Let's hope the titular duo's fall out isn't over a bit of petty name calling.
3. Somebody Get Superman A Sense Of Humour Transplant Please
Superman Returns was a great damp fart of a thing, beloved of a very, very few. That was partially because it was so portentous and full of its own importance; before long, you began to wish that someone was around to take the piss out of Superman a bit because he took himself so very seriously. Man Of Steel wasnt any better. In fact, it went much worse. I realise that the guys basically a god and that that comes with its own problems, and I know that losing one's parents and home-world can turn one into a bit of a Debbie Downer, but even Nolans Batman trilogy, which had gritty realism tattooed across its knuckles, managed to crack a few gags here and there. In fact this is one of Superman's great problems: up to now he's felt a little like a hero who we ought to respect because everyone in the film does, rather than because he does anything particularly fun or interesting. Hes worthy to the point of being actually quite irritating. Who can connect with a hero whos pathologically incapable of cracking a smile?
2. You Don't Have To Be Aggressively Different
Man Of Steel changed a big chunk of the Superman mythos (at least when compared to how it's perceived in the mainstream), and while some of it was a lot of fun (the spaceship Fortress of Solitude works surprisingly well as an idea), at points it verged on trying a bit too hard to be very new. Now Henry Cavill's Superman is established, a sense of consistency should be expected, although keeping up the revisionism could still hurt Batman V Superman, especially given that it isn't just a Man Of Steel sequel. Ben Affleck's Batman is (obviously) going to be a key part of Dawn Of Justice and it'd be very tempting to make him every supporting character the polar opposite of the version in The Dark Knight Trilogy (it looks like it's already going that way with the hipster Joker). But if it's done without purpose then it'll just fall flat. Yes, Jeremy Irons shouldn't just repeat Michael Caine's shaky voice, but that doesn't mean he needs to be a badass. Biggest of all is Bruce Wayne himself, and thankfully it looks that, while Affleck's take is going to be unique, there's no forced differences between his and Christian Bale's performance (although that voice doesn't really need to be as mechanical).
1. Find A Less Obvious Way Of Working The Superman-As-God Angle
This one doesnt look like a particularly likely one to be fulfilled, going by the trailer. Hes referred to as an angel, hes followed around by hordes of the great unwashed looking to rub Supermans Superpecs for good luck, and his statue gets tagged with the phrase: FALSE GOD. Theres even a bit where a woman reaches out toward the floating Superman looking for supplication while golden rays of sunlight pour from the heavens behind him, like in a Renaissance painting. They might as well have Superman going, DO YOU GET IT GUYS IM REALLY POWERFUL LIKE JESUS EXCEPT LOOK IM FLYING WHEEEEEE!". Theres a reason why Biblical epics went out of style, you know: everyone got bored of being made to feel bad about themselves in comparison to all these paragons of virtue, and struggled to connect with them emotionally rather than just intellectually. The same thing goes for Superman. Work the alien-as-flying-Jesus angle, of course, but spare us the sermonising. It does look at first glance that the bombast and pomposity of Man Of Steel has, lamentably, survived intact into Dawn Of Justice, but then again 120-second adverts arent exactly an arena to which subtlety and understatement are regular visitors. What other big Man Of Steel issues does Batman V Superman need to address? Share any we missed down in the comments.