Black Christmas Review: 2 Ups & 7 Downs
A late entry for 2019's worst film.
If you weren't even aware that a second remake of the 1974 cult classic horror film Black Christmas was in the works, you'd be forgiven, considering how Blumhouse and Universal's marketing campaign was almost entirely non-existent.
It's almost as if the studios might've realised they've got a turkey on their hands and are simply dumping it quietly in cinemas for a quick return-on-investment, especially given its mere $5 million budget and the generally unfussed habits of even genre-savvy horror fans.
And while the trailers for Black Christmas 2019 at least suggested an amusingly satirical contemporary spin on the Yuletide slasher flick, this depressingly low-effort film is actually quite terrible in almost every single way.
Were it not for its decent performances and acceptable technicals, there would be almost nothing positive to say about this movie, which is without question one of the worst theatrically-released films of 2019.
We've still got Cats to go, of course, but it'll need to be mighty terrible to top this tripe. Even if you set your standards accordingly low - and they can't really be low enough - buyer beware...
Downs...
7. The Clumsy Social Commentary
The most intriguing element of Black Christmas' marketing was the implication that the film was trying to update the original's sorority slasher premise for the #MeToo era, and on paper, it's certainly a compelling idea which could've made for a pressing, urgent horror film.
But the manner in which the film deals with themes such as toxic masculinity, rape culture (especially in American fraternities), and the remnants of PTSD, is so eye-rollingly on-the-nose and lacking in nuance that even the most ardent social activists are likely to find it patronising.
There's literally a scene in the film where a male character pulls the "not all men..." card, and there's a weird smugness to the film's examination of the (undeniably horrifying) gender power dynamics at play in society.
Black Christmas' anger at the patriarchy is justified and interesting for all of about three minutes, before the script starts ladling out the platitudes with no subtlety whatsoever, and the film effectively becomes more of a lecture than a smart satire of a male-dominated society.
6. It's Just Not Scary
The 1974 original is absolutely soaked in creepy atmosphere from first minute to last, but this lousy re-do lacks it almost entirely.
One of the big problems is the decision to have the killer send DM messages to their victims, which is neither remotely cinematic nor in any way scary, compared to the original film having the killer make extremely disturbing phone calls to the girls.
There's barely a single moment where there's an actual incentive to care about the fates of these thinly-drawn characters, and the killer itself lacks much of a palpable screen presence compared to the original's brilliantly shadowy, anonymous stalker.
Even younger viewers new to the genre aren't likely to find much bone-chilling to take away from this.
5. The PG-13 Violence
Though a PG-13 rating isn't inherently the kiss of death for a horror movie, for a film called Black Christmas it most certainly isn't the smart way forward.
The result, naturally, is a film largely lacking in inventive or even basically bloody kills beyond a few faint spatters of the red stuff, which totally undermines the visceral potential of the death scenes.
The original film itself was fairly sparing with the gore, but it nevertheless made its blood-letting count, whereas here it just feels cynically sanitised to maximise the film's box office potential.
But given that this remake was made for a mere $5 million, would it really have killed Blumhouse to make it R-rated? The script would still be fundamentally atrocious, but at least we might've got a few gnarly deaths out of it.
4. It's Terribly Directed & Edited
Even were the film's script up to par, it'd still have to deal with a sloppy directorial job from indie filmmaker - and the film's co-writer - Sophia Takal, who clearly lacked the skill necessary to make sense of the thrown-together screenplay.
It's painfully clear that she didn't get enough basic coverage of scenes due to the choppy and often nonsensical nature of the editing, especially during the film's action sequences, which are cut into incomprehensible oblivion for the most part.
There are also countless shots where ADR dubbing is blatantly visible, with actors' mouths either not moving in sync or perhaps not even moving at all.
It adds up to a slipshod end result that, during its more intense moments is actually quite the headache to watch.
3. The AWFUL Jump Scares
When all else fails, what else will cynical, lazy PG-13 horror movies resort to but jump scares? And while Black Christmas isn't as rife with them as some other recent terrible horror flicks, it does use them in a totally unimaginative and irritating way.
The periodic jumps are nothing more than cheap attempts to jolt a likely otherwise snoozy audience, but there's no basic inventiveness or technical panache to them whatsoever.
A loud noise plays, a character is startled, and rinse and repeat every 10-or-so minutes.
It's the blandest element of the entire movie, and at least if it didn't have any jumps, it'd be one less thing you could ding the movie for. It would've actually registered as restraint, honestly.
2. The Trailer Almost Spoils The Entire Movie
If you were worried that the movie's trailers - if you even saw them - seemed to give away the entire movie, well, almost.
The oddly involved trailers for the movie show footage from pretty much every single major scene, and worse than that, literally spoil the (admittedly obvious) twist regarding the character of Professor Gelson (Cary Elwes), as well as the nature of the final action sequence.
Worse still, numerous character deaths late in the film are shown like they're no big deal, seeming to confirm just how little regard the studios had for the movie as a whole.
And you can basically understand where they're coming from: with a film this terrible, why not just fill the trailer with all the "best" money shots and hope for the best? Scoop up that opening weekend box office and move on.
As frequent a complaint as it is that movie trailers ruin movies these days, Black Christmas' spoilerific marketing is quite something else indeed.
1. The Hilariously Awful Plot Twist
No spoilers here, of course, but there is one big reveal that hasn't quite been given away by the trailers, though if you're looking close enough there's a chance you could figure it out.
Though probably not, given that this third act twist comes so utterly out of left-field and changes the nature of the movie so fundamentally that few are likely to see it coming.
The twist basically shifts the movie's logical goalposts while wrapping its big reveal within yet more howlingly unsubtle social commentary.
You'll probably laugh, but without the self-aware tone to imply the filmmakers are also in on the joke, it's just a jarring note on which to close things out.
So, Black Christmas 2019 is an abject failure, then, but here's what little it actually gets (mostly) right...
Ups...
2. The Solid Ensemble Cast
Easily the film's biggest plus is the ensemble cast of primarily young women who play the movie's embattled sorority girls.
The chemistry between cast members is palpable throughout, even when they're forced to rattle through head-smackingly terrible dialogue that most all actors would surely want to laugh at.
Leading the pack is, of course, the ever-reliable Imogen Poots, who tries her absolute damnedest to sell her character's trauma, while Aleyse Shannon makes the best of her role as the outspoken Kris.
Cary Elwes is meanwhile having some hammy fun as Professor Gelson, perhaps the only actor here acutely aware of exactly what kind of movie he's actually in.
But on the whole, the cast doesn't embarrass themselves despite how easily they clearly could have.
1. The Decent Cinematography & Musical Score
And the only other positive? If you can deal with the aforementioned headache-inducing editing, the movie is relatively well-shot, with cinematographer Mark Schwartzbard emphasising appropriately warm colours - especially bright neon - to evoke the expected Christmas vibe.
A musical score from Will and Brooke Blair is also sufficiently intense, even if it's largely wasted on the film's empty, scatter-brained suspense set-pieces. But the film would certainly be even worse without it.
These elements combine to make Black Christmas 2019 at least basically acceptable to the eyes and ears for the most part, except whenever director Takal tries to move the camera or her characters too much.