Blade Runner Vs. Blade Runner 2049: Which One Is Better?

Did Denis Villeneuve beat Ridley Scott at his own game?

By Jack Pooley /

Warner Bros.

After a 35-year wait, Blade Runner's much-anticipated sequel is finally out in the wild, and though it's been rapturously received by critics and fans alike so far, the question remains: is it actually better than the original?

Advertisement

It's proving to be an incredibly divisive question already, with some fans deeming Blade Runner 2049 incapable of matching the original's entrancing power, while others who see more flaws in Ridley Scott's 1982 movie might favour Denis Villeneuve's different approach in the new film.

Whatever your own opinion, they're both fantastic movies, but only one can be the definitive Blade Runner movie, and so it's time to compare the two projects in every major facet of their conception, from the direction and acting through to the cinematography, musical score and so on.

Advertisement

Does Scott's cyberpunk masterpiece endure as an unflappable classic, or has Villeneuve done the impossible and somehow outdone one of the best-loved sci-fi films of all time? It's time to find out...

12. Direction

Warner Bros.

Let's start with arguably the toughest question of all. Though Ridley Scott's output is decidedly uneven these days, there's no denying that he directed the hell out of the original 1982 movie, favouring a slow-burn approach that allowed audiences to soak in the immense detail of dystopian 2019 Los Angeles.

Advertisement

Then there's Denis Villeneuve, arguably the most exciting director working in big-budget prestige cinema today, whose similarly patient approach does the most unlikely of things: produce a magnificent sequel to a much-loved 35-year-old movie.

Winner: This isn't easy, but Villeneuve's stunning work just about clinches it. Both films have their moments that don't work, but Villeneuve's helming feels like a monumental achievement that's even more epic and ambitious than the original thanks to a larger budget (even factoring inflation) and canvas.

Advertisement

11. The Protagonist

Warner Bros.

Harrison Ford's Deckard is one of the most iconic protagonists in the history of cinema, a classic film noir detective roughed up and hurled into the future. Ford is, of course, terrific in the part, from the mere look of the character to his rather ambiguous nature and, yes, that nagging mystery regarding his true identity.

Advertisement

Ryan Gosling's K could so easily have been nothing more than a lazy Deckard rehash, but thankfully that's not the case at all. K is arguably better-developed than Deckard with a more detailed backstory and the film's greater focus on him as a "person", while Gosling gives one of his very best performances in the role.

Winner: Again, not an easy choice, but Ford's Deckard isn't easily topped, and considering how iconic a character he is, and how K is certainly indebted to him in more than a few ways, he has to take the win here. It's close, though.

Advertisement

10. Narrative

Warner Bros.

Blade Runner's overarching narrative is actually fairly simple for the most part, touting a killer set-up before Deckard ventures off on a breadcrumb-following quest to "retire" the replicants, ahead of that stunning ending. It's a film driven as much by its style and themes as its plot, and does great things with its minimalist approach.

Advertisement

Though 2049's narrative is of course built off the foundation set by the original, it is somewhat more ambitious, taking a less-repetitive investigative approach and spinning many more plates at once.

It retains certain mysteries will rustling up plenty of new ones, and smartly manages to feel relatively self-contained while both being a worthy follow-up and leaving the door open for more stories should Warner Bros. wish.

Advertisement

Winner: 2049 edges it, by doing some extremely impressive things with the pre-existing mythology and not feeling quite as repetitive as the original, even if you can argue that the film sags a little in the middle.

9. Supporting Cast

Warner Bros.

The original movie's supporting cast speaks for itself: Sean Young and Rutger Hauer are especially impressive and iconic, but Edward James Olmos, M. Emmet Walsh, Joe Turkel, Daryl Hannah, William Sanderson, Brion James and James Hong all contribute terrific work to help create truly memorable characters.

Advertisement

2049 is no slouch in this department either, with Harrison Ford taking a meaty supporting role in act three, while the cast is also filled out by the fantastic Robin Wright, Dave Bautista, Ana de Armas, Sylvia Hoeks, Mackenzie Davis, Jared Leto, not to mention smaller appearances from the likes of Lennie James, Barkhad Abdi, David Dastmalchian and Wood Harris.

Winner: Both films are fantastic in this regard, but 2049 clinches it by leaning into the ensemble factor a little more, and absolutely making the most of its fantastic roster of performers.

Advertisement

8. Music

Warner Bros.

Vangelis' synth-driven, jazz-like score for the original movie is pretty much peerless in the sci-fi genre, a ground-breaking masterwork that's endured as one of the film's most distinctive elements. It is a perfect accompaniment to the gorgeous visuals, and unsurprisingly had fans begging him to return for 2049.

Advertisement

Though Vangelis didn't come back for the sequel and 2049's original composer Jóhann Jóhannsson was ditched during post-production, Hans Zimmer and Benjamin Wallfisch stepped in to save the day, providing those eye-watering images with a soundscape that honoured the original while introducing some of Zimmer's more typical, bombastic elements also.

Winner: 2049's score is undeniably driven by Vangelis' original themes, so due to its influence and unquestionable impact, the first film has to win out here.

Advertisement

7. The Villain

Warner Bros.

Though there's plenty of moral ambiguity in the original movie, the closest thing it has to a villain would surely be Eldon Tyrell, the mastermind behind the creation of the replicants, a God figure to them, who poetically ends up killed by his own design when Batty demands an extended life. Joe Turkel's performance is great, even if the character is a fairly small fixture all things considered.

Advertisement

2049 has a far more palpable and clearly-drawn villain in Jared Leto's industrialist Niander Wallace, and while like Tyrell his screen time is ultimately quite minimal, he has a compelling and unsettling presence throughout. Sylvia Hoeks' replicant underling Luv arguably makes more of an impact, though.

Winner: Leto's lyrical dialogue is tailor-made to be more divisive than Turkel's performance, and as the iconic figurehead that sets both of these stories in motion, Tyrell wins out easily. Both films keep their antagonists on the periphery, though, because they're about so much more than just that.

Advertisement

6. Visuals

Warner Bros.

It goes without saying that the original film is a visual masterpiece, with Scott's direction, Jordan Cronenweth's incredible cinematography, and the legendary Douglas Trumbull's special effects work.

Advertisement

That the film has aged so absurdly well almost four decades later is nothing short of extraordinary, and proof of just how well the largely practical production stands the test of time.

Though 2049 uses decidedly more digital elements in its world-building, these are without question some of the best-integrated visual effects in the history of blockbuster cinema.

Advertisement

That's without mentioning Roger Deakins' astonishing cinematography, which will most likely win him his long-overdue Oscar.

Winner: Though the original film arguably does a better job of depicting the hustle and bustle of a futuristic Los Angeles, 2049's far more expansive visual palette and Deakins' unforgettable work pushes it over the top.

Advertisement

They're two of the best-looking movies ever made, so there's no shame in losing here.

5. Pacing

Warner Bros.

Though the 1982 film clocks in at just 117 minutes, you might feel like it's much longer than that due to Scott's deliberate, "slow" pacing. He's in no rush to tell his story, and while this does result in a few dips of interest, for the most part it helps build up the movie's atmosphere and allows audiences to soak in the world.

Advertisement

2049 follows in its stead, but brings with it the baggage of a 163-minute runtime, which has been one of the film's most complained-about elements. There are a number of scenes in the middle of the movie which arguably drag on longer than they need to, though for the most part it sustains such a long time incredibly well.

Winner: Though they both have their indulgences that could be trimmed down a little, 1982 is certainly less of a slog overall.

Advertisement

4. Thematic Content

Warner Bros.

The first movie did a fantastic job exploring fascinating humanist themes in ground-breaking fashion, namely what it means to be human, the ability of people to "play God", the effect of technological innovation on society and so on. It goes without saying that Blade Runner has had a huge influence on the sci-fi genre ever since, and a large number of sci-fi movies today owe a huge debt to it.

Advertisement

2049 explores many of the same themes but manages to avoid merely raking over them in similar fashion. The major revelation around which the film revolves takes the original's commentary one step further by pondering transhumanism and the nature of creation in provocative and thoughtful ways.

Winner: 1982's film did it first and created the bedrock for 2049's expansion, so it has to take the win, really.

Advertisement

3. Action Sequences

Warner Bros.

It's fair to say that neither Blade Runner movie is an action-packed set-piece-filled extravaganza, but the original's smaller action beats are nevertheless well-remembered, especially Deckard's "retirement" of Zhora and the final showdown against Batty. The action isn't the point of the movie, but it's stylish and intense for the most part.

Advertisement

2049 boasts a little more action, perhaps by virtue of its runtime above all else, with the opening fight scene against Dave Bautista's replicant and the third act's mad dash to save Deckard proving the most entertaining. It's all shot through with the beauty and restraint you'd expect from Villeneuve.

Winner: Villeneuve's action feels more urgent and brutal (especially that opening fight against Bautista), whereas Scott's has a few goofy affectations (such as Batty sticking his head through the wall) that arguably hold it back a little. 2049 all the way.

Advertisement

2. Iconic Status

Warner Bros.

This is difficult to talk about simply because the original movie has had 35 years to stew in the public's consciousness, while the new movie is, well, the new movie.

Advertisement

Scott's film wasn't warmly-received upon release and only grew in esteem over the years, especially as superior alternate cuts were released, to the point that it's near-universally agreed to be one of the greatest sci-fi films ever made.

From the unique visuals to the aforementioned action, music and, of course, Batty's unforgettable death soliloquy, there are so many moments destined to endure as long as cinema exists.

Advertisement

2049 is disadvantaged right out of the gate by being a sequel and having to follow the act of what came before, but all things considered, it doesn't seem likely that many of the movie's ideas or dialogues are going to permeate pop-culture in the same way that the original did.

Winner: The original, without any doubt.

Advertisement

1. Overall

Warner Bros.

And finally, we come to the scores at the doors. After looking at the eleven most prominent aspects of both movies, Ridley Scott's original Blade Runner comes out on top with six wins, while Denis Villeneuve's sequel nabs a close five victories.

Advertisement

Though the original wins out, it's clear that Blade Runner 2049 is one of the most staggeringly impressive sequels ever made, damn-near matching the original pound-for-pound where it counts the most.

It won't end up as relentlessly quoted and parodied as the original, but it's a fascinating post-script to the 1982 film that defied just about all expectations.

Advertisement

Which Blade Runner movie do you prefer? Shout it out in the comments!