Cafe Society Review: 6 Ups & 3 Downs

A charming (if familiar) delight.

By Jack Pooley /

Lionsgate

Just like clockwork, Woody Allen's latest effort is here, and while it's not a classic of his filmography, it's still been earning solid reviews for the most part, and is largely an entertaining entry into the filmmaker's sizable canon.

Advertisement

Yes, it's not the most challenging or original task the iconic writer-director has ever tackled, but like usual, Allen has assembled a cast to die for and serves up an entertaining mixture of wit, humour and melancholic longing.

Above all else, it's a good sight better than his mediocre prior two movies, Magic in the Moonlight and Irrational Man, which have pretty much been forgotten already. This one shouldn't suffer the same fate, what with its infectious charm, visual delights and memorable performances.

Advertisement

Here are 6 ups and 3 downs from Cafe Society...

Downs

3. It Feels Like A "Greatest Hits" Of Allen's Movies

Lionsgate

For all of its many pleasures, Cafe Society is basically a compendium of Woody Allen's most successful tropes. Jesse Eiseneberg is basically playing an Allen substitute here, an endlessly neurotic man tirelessly persistent in pursuit of a more attractive woman, with a script that intermittently muses on the nature of love and death.

Advertisement

It's fair to say that Allen doesn't do a whole lot new here: some might say he's even coasting or spinning his wheels, though given the generally enjoyable nature of the film that seems a tad harsh. Unambitious seems more apt: it doesn't see Allen making any major strides creatively, but at this stage in his life and career, that's not hugely surprising.

2. It's A Little Too Light For Its Own Good

Lionsgate

Cafe Society is light and breezy to the point that it's also difficult to care all that much about what's going on. Allen does nonchalant patter like nobody else in Hollywood, but it does occasionally result in the film feeling a bit lethargic, especially when it comes to the stakes of the central romances.

Advertisement

Some can argue that this is the point, and Allen's lightness of touch certainly works when it comes to the movie's darker elements (as realised by Corey Stoll's outrageously violent mobster), but the film is almost so relaxed and lacking in urgency that it's actually to the love story's detriment.

1. It's Ultimately Mid-Tier Allen At Best

Lionsgate

As fun and charming as the film is, it's still basically a mid-tier Woody Allen movie at best, as has been a disappointingly common remark in the filmmaker's late career.

Advertisement

Sure, they can't all be Annie Hall, Manhattan, Midnight in Paris or Blue Jasmine, but as Allen's career will likely begin winding down sooner rather than later, fans are naturally hungry for him to turn out some truly unique, dramatically potent work before that happens.

It's sharply-written, charming, well-acted and gorgeous to behold...like at least half of Allen's back catalogue, so enjoyable though it is, it's certainly not a classic and doesn't really distinguish itself too much in his filmography.

Advertisement

And here's what Woody Allen got right in his new movie...

Ups

6. It's One Of Allen's Best-Looking Films

Lionsgate

Easily one of the film's most striking elements is its absolutely gorgeous cinematography, by way of legendary Oscar-winning lenser Vittorio Storaro (Apocalypse Now, The Last Emperor).

Advertisement

This is also Allen's first movie shot on digital, and it's a damn fine start: Storaro makes the most of both the Hollywood and New York locations, painting the former as glossy and sun-bathed while the latter is more muted and Earthy.

Allen also employs fantastic use of long takes and transports his camera around during shots far more often than normal. Hell, there's even a beautiful, Manhattan-esque shot of the Brooklyn Bridge for good measure.

Advertisement

Allen's films normally pop visually and make terrific use of their gorgeous locales, but Cafe Society just might be his most visually lavish effort since Manhattan.

5. Kristen Stewart Is A Charming Surprise

Lionsgate

Even champions of Kristen Stewart probably wouldn't describe her as "charming". Her best roles have typically exuded a certain uncomfortable awkwardness, and yet trust Allen to be the one to bring her out of her shell and deliver her most effervescent work to date as the lovely Vonnie.

Advertisement

Stewart is by far the movie's most interesting character, beginning as an staunch immaterialist whose complicated love life forms much of the movie's dramatic crux. Stewart's chats with Eisenberg's Bobby are effortlessly engaging due in large part to her unexpected radiance, aided no doubt by the aforementioned luscious cinematography.

It's popular to rag on Stewart for lacking affect and emotion in her performances, and though those detractors probably wouldn't touch an Allen film to see themselves proven wrong, this is proof perfect that she possesses more range than most likely expected.

Advertisement

4. It Features One Of The Year's Funniest Scenes

Lionsgate

Easily the funniest scene in the movie occurs early on when Bobby has arrived in Hollywood and decides to call up a hooker new on the job, played by Pitch Perfect's Anna Camp.

Advertisement

What follows is a masterstroke of cringe comedy, as the two awkwardly negotiate their impending coitus, with a series of miscommunications resulting in the two essentially talking the transaction to death.

It feels like the most classically Allen scene in the entire movie, and is terrifically played by both actors. It's witty, silly and slightly vulgar all at once: Allen at his best, then.

Advertisement

3. The Terrific Ensemble Cast

Lionsgate

It would be remiss to only praise Stewart for her chops here, because the entire cast is terrific. Eisenberg is a home run of an Allen protagonist, while Steve Carell also fits like a glove as his talent agent uncle Phil, and there are memorable roles for Parker Posey, Corey Stoll, Paul Schneider and best of all Blake Lively.

Advertisement

Lively impressed earlier this summer with her surprisingly solid performance in The Shallows, and follows it up with another that proves she has more to offer than many perhaps expect. As glitzy divorcee Veronica Hayes, Lively looks every bit the 1930s starlet you'd expect, and Allen's camera totally loves her. Her chemistry with Jesse Eisenberg is also surprisingly strong considering how utterly mismatched they seem at first.

Allen can get pretty much any cast he wants, and this is definitely among his better ones in recent memory.

Advertisement

2. Allen Narrates The Movie (And He's Great)

Lionsgate

Woody sadly (if understandably) doesn't appear in his movies very often anymore, though fans will be pleased to learn that he does provide Cafe Society's occasional voiceover narration.

Advertisement

It comes as a bit of a shock at first, frankly, because Allen's voice has deepened and changed considerably over the years, so it sounds distinctly different from the widely-parodied version of his accent that's been doing the rounds for years.

Still, voiceover narration can so often come off as trite and lazy, but here it enhances the vintage texture of the film, and Allen's recognisable tenor is itself always a welcome flourish. It's abundant, though at the same time not distracting away from the core narrative.

Advertisement

1. The Outstanding Costume & Production Design

Lionsgate

And finally, in addition to the beautiful actors, scenic locales and sharp cinematography, on a pure production level this is a top-notch movie. For starters, the costumes look terrific throughout, especially pretty much everything that Blake Lively wears (namely that red dress), and the classy retro locales help evoke the classical charm Allen's clearly searching for.

Advertisement

Allen can pretty much knock period fare out in his sleep by now, but it's still tough to deny the snazzy allure of the below-the-line crafts the movie has to offer.

What did you think of Cafe Society? Shout it out in the comments!

Advertisement