Casting Robert Pattinson's Rogues Gallery In The Batman
The Dark Knight is back, and this time he's out after Twilight.
The internet has gone wild over the past few days since the casting of Robert Pattinson as Batman has been reported by various credible news sources. After seemingly beating out Nicholas Hoult (though this is not 100% certain) who was also shortlisted, the former Twilight star will be starring in Matt Reeves’ The Batman.
While casual moviegoers would only know Pattinson as teen heartthrobs Edward Cullen or Cedric Diggory, he has amassed a very respectable portfolio of roles in recent years. He's gone under the radar by starring in underrated hits like The Lost City of Z and Good Time and is more than deserving of the role. The best way of suppressing early judgment is to make sure that he has an incredible supporting cast.
With Reeves insisting on a younger choice for Batman, his villains will likely be a mix of older established crime lords and equally young up and coming villains. However, before looking at who should be playing any of Pattinson's villains, there's one casting call that needs to be made...
12. Honourable Mention: James Gordon - Bryan Cranston
While not a member of the Rogues Gallery, Gordon is its curator, and there would be no better pick than Bryan Cranston. He has become one of the very best actors in the business in no small part thanks to his once in a lifetime performance as Walter White in Breaking Bad. An actor of his calibre would do wonders for the film and establishing him in a mentor role to Pattinson's Batman would give the new Dark Knight more than enough support.
Cranston has already made an appearance in one hollywood franchise, The Monsters Universe. He was praised for his performance in Godzilla which was cut far too short but a role as important as Gordon would ensure that Cranston would be around to entertain us for a long time.
Probably the best alternative to Cranston would be the man who was already cast during Ben Affleck's tenure, J.K Simmons. Both are incredible actors and Simmons is more than capable of retaining the mantle, but in spirit of refreshing the Batman character, perhaps offering the role to Cranston would be the best choice.
Now that we have our gordon, perhaps it's best to start with a villain already confirmed to appear in The Batman...
11. Penguin - Toby Jones
Penguin has already been confirmed as one of the first two villains in Reeves' film and while Robin Lord-Taylor has done a valiant job portraying him in Gotham, the perfect choice to play the crime lord is Toby Jones.
Jonah Hill and Josh Gad have both been mentioned, but neither quite has the range and depth to match Jones. Any actor that can pull off someone as loveable as Dobby and someone as utterly detestable as Sherlock's Culverton Smith deserves a tonne of credit and Jones doesn't receive nearly enough. If he were to get a role as a significant villain in a franchise like this, however, that may very well change.
The two faced persona of Culverton Smith would lend itself nicely to Oswald Cobblepot, who often doubles for a philanthropist in the comics by running the Iceberg Lounge as a front for his criminal organisation. He would be a phenomenal first villain for Pattinson's Batman to face, though he wouldn't be alone.
10. Catwoman - Jaime Alexander
Alongside The Penguin, The Batman has confirmed it will be starring Catwoman, and an unexpected yet great actress who could play her would be Jaimie Alexander. She would be one of many to jump ship from Marvel to DC after playing Lady Sif in Thor, but after proving herself as a competent lead in Blindspot, she has justifiably earned a shot at a top tier character like Catwoman.
While more established names like Emily Blunt and Eva Green are being deservedly thrown into the ring, Catwoman is a character who is worth taking a risk on just as much as Batman. Time and time again, both Marvel and DC have proven that unlikely castings make for fantastic performances such as Chris Pratt's Starlord and the most obvious one, Heath Ledger's iconic portrayal of The Joker.
Alexander has proven she has the acting ability and the action credentials to take on the role and could certainly repeat the success of those unlikely names cast before her. As for Batman's other significant female villain, there's one name that seems to fit perfectly.
9. Poison Ivy - Natalie Dormer
With Game of Thrones finally coming to an end, many of its actors will have had their status elevated beyond their wildest dreams. Some stars have been able to land prominent roles within the Superhero genre such as Sophie Turner as Jean Grey, and one actress who certainly deserves to play an iconic character is Natalie Dormer. She was a fan favourite throughout her tenure as Margaery Tyrell and would become a fan favourite once more if she took on Poison Ivy
While other names being thrown about are, once again, the likes of Emily Blunt, nobody seems to fit the character quite like Dormer. She has an innocent exterior but has proved through Margaery that she is far more cunning than that innocent nature would suggest. Poison Ivy's character often hinges on her ability to manipulate men and you need only look at the way she keeps Joffrey in the palm of her hand to prove she's a perfect fit.
Considering the special bond between Harley Quinn and Poison Ivy throughout comics and TV, putting two fan favourites like Margot Robbie and Natalie Dormer together is a recipe for success. Whether the Gotham City Sirens film goes ahead or not, we deserve to see this Poison Ivy in the DCEU
8. Mr Freeze - Ralph Fiennes
After everything that's happened to Mr Freeze, playing the character may feel like career suicide. Since Arnold Schwarzenegger's pun-filled monstrosity of a performance, it feels like all hope for the character has been lost. In fact, it would probably be wise for Reeves to ignore the character altogether. Nonetheless, he's a villain with a fantastically heartbreaking backstory and with a veteran like Ralph Fiennes behind him, we may yet see Mr Freeze's on-screen career saved.
Fiennes is one of the very best actors Hollywood has to offer and could channel Freeze's sympathetic character in his sleep. The tragic backstory established in Batman's animated series has brought new life to the character over the past few decades and made him become a fan favourite amongst Batman fans.
His character isn't the only thing that's great about him. He boasts a fantastic costume and powers that would be fantastic to see with modern technology as opposed to the awful comical effects in Batman and Robin.
7. Scarecrow - Adam Driver
Scarecrow was given a tantalising performance by Cillian Murphy in Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight trilogy but if the character were to return in the DCEU, the best choice for the character would be Adam Driver. Driver is currently the main villain in the Star Wars franchise and has proved his acting ability when making Kylo Ren a complex intimidating character. With Scarecrow, he could take that intimidation to a whole new level.
While Scarecrow is generally presented as a meeker physical presence reliant on his fear gas, some portrayals like the later seasons of Batman's animated series have presented him as a bulkier dominant presence. Driver's Kylo Ren certainly has this imposing stature and would be able to provide a physical as well as psychological challenge for Batman.
Star Wars is soon to be wrapping up and obtaining Driver while his stock has never been higher would be a major coup for DC. Despite the divisive nature of the films, one thing that critics and fans can agree on is that Adam Driver knows how to play a scary villain.
6. Hush - Taron Egerton
Another fantastic rising star in Hollywood is Taron Egerton. He shot to fame as the leading man in the Kingsman franchise and has recently put on a highly praised performance as Elton John in the film Rocketman. While Egerton has stated before that he doesn't want to play a superhero as he doesn't want to spend too much time on large franchises, playing a villain is a very different story.
Hush is relatively new on the scene (debuting in 2003) yet has already become one of Batman's most well-known villains thanks to the fantastic Hush storyline written by Jeph Loeb. He would be a refreshing villain for Batman to face and there would be no better man than Egerton to play him.
Considering Tommy Elliot is a childhood friend of Wayne, Egerton's similar age will give him the advantage over people like Matt Damon who some fans have been speculating over. This close connection would also make him a much more personal villain than Batman is used to, allowing Egerton to give Batman fans a unique viewing experience.
5. Two-Face - Oscar Isaac
Oscar Isaac has shown great range in some of his more notable recent performances. He's been charming and likeable as Po Dameron in Star Wars but has also played the deranged and obsessive Nathan in Ex Machina. If he were able to channel those two vastly different personalities into one performance, he would make one hell of a Harvey Dent.
Two-Face was already fantastically brought to life by Aaron Eckhart in Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight trilogy, though he spent most of his tenure playing second fiddle to Heath Ledger's Joker. Two-Face deserves far more as one of Batman's most famous adversaries and an actor like Oscar Isaac would be a more than suitable candidate to show Harvey Dent's decline into madness.
The best route for Isaac's Dent would be to first appear as an ally of Bruce Wayne, like Eckhart in The Dark Knight, and gradually show his decline into Two-Face over multiple movies. Perhaps, with an actor as good as Isaac at the wheel, Two-Face could become Batman's biggest adversary.
4. Bane - Dave Bautista
Since the announcement of James Gunn's move to DC to direct and write The Suicide Squad, many people have assumed Dave Bautista, who played Drax in Gunn's Guardian's of the Galaxy films, would follow him. Batista himself has said he wants to join Gunn and a role that seems almost made for him is the legendary Batman villain, Bane.
The most obvious comparison is their physique, as Bautista is more than big and strong enough to play the man who broke the bat. As well as this, many portrayals of Bane have seen him originate from wrestling, much like how Bautista started in the WWE before transitioning to acting.
Though Bautista may not be able to outdo Tom Hardy's fantastic performance as Bane, he would be a great presence in Gunn's Suicide Squad and would hopefully be able to provide a challenge for Pattinson's Batman to overcome.
3. The Riddler - David Tennant
While many of the names on this list who would be switching brands came from MCU films, David Tennant instead gave a fantastic performance in Marvel's now cancelled Jessica Jones on Netflix. He proved there beyond a shadow of a doubt he has the ability to play a chilling villain and one Batman foe he has said he would love to play is Batman's smartest adversary, The Riddler.
Tennant has stated that he would want to play Edward Nygma and was even rumoured to play him in Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight trilogy. Nearly a decade later, the former Doctor Who is still the best candidate for the role. He has always possessed an irresistible charm and could bring that to one of Batman's biggest villains.
Like Penguin, Riddler has recieved a fantastic portrayal from Corey Michael Smith in Gotham but an actor as good as Tennant could really take Riddler to new levels. So long as he doesn't force Batman to participate in tedious Batmobile races like in Arkham Knight, he'll surely leave a lasting impression.
2. Hugo Strange - Andy Serkis
Another villain that may lay claim to the title of Batman's smartest adversary is Hugo Strange. He is renowned for being one of the few villains to deduce Batman's secret identity and an actor that could make him one of Batman's most memorable villains is the incredibly underrated Andy Serkis.
Serkis has long been known as one of, if not the greatest actor in motion capture history with iconic roles like Gollum from The Lord of The Rings and Caeser from Matt Reeves' Planet of the Apes films. Recently, he proved his ability as a traditional actor by stealing the show in his brief appearance as Ulysses Klaue in Black Panther and would steal the show once more if he brought a similar energy to Hugo Strange.
Serkis has said that he would love to be a part of the film and there are so many roles he could play thanks to his fantastic range. Many have seen him as a great fit for Penguin while some have said his MoCap history would suit a character like Clayface but Hugo Strange would benefit from the kind of eccentric performance that only Serkis could give. It would take one of Hollywood's most underrated actors to make one of Batman's most underrated villains a big screen success.
1. The Joker - Joaquin Phoenix
Casting a good Joker is no easy task. We've almost been spoiled by the performances of Heath Ledger, Jack Nicholson and Mark Hamill and the bar has been set so high that even competent performances from good actors like Jared Leto pale in comparison. And next up we have Joaquin Phoenix, who looks the real deal again.
While fans have been divided over Leto's performance since the first photo of his Joker was revealed, the anticipation for Phoenix has been almost universal. The recently released trailer looks unbelievably promising and it feels a waste for Phoenix to only play The Clown Prince of Crime just once.
The Joker already being in Gotham prior to Batman's first appearance would create a more unique dynamic between the two and give the incredible Phoenix an opportunity to truly develop his Joker into one that can rival, and perhaps beat, all those iconic performances.