Charlie Chaplin: Ranking His 8 Masterpieces

By Paul Sorrells /

Charlie Chaplin might not have invented movies, but he had an almost unparalleled influence on their development and evolution. He practically invented the comedic film and he became a legend for his ability to blend melodrama and pathos into his comedies, resulting in some of the most enduring films of his era and, subsequently, film history in general. His life was almost as interesting as his movies as he experienced the highest of highs and lowest of lows. Seemingly destined for a career as an entertainer, Chaplin made his first appearance on stage at the age of 5 and throughout his early life he gained a variety of skills that would suit him in his future career. He made his debut in 1914, with his Tramp character being introduced later that year, and he quickly became a sensation for a number of short films. By age 26 he was one of the highest paid people in the world and in 1921 he directed, starred in, edited, and composed music for his first feature length film, The Kid, which was an instant success. With the advent of the sound era, starting in 1927 with The Jazz Singer, it seemed as if Chaplin might become obsolete but he bucked the trend and made two more enormously successful silent films with his last one, Modern Times, coming nearly a decade after the rest of Hollywood had completely converted to sound. After World War Two, Chaplin's popularity waned because of his political beliefs and a series of scandals and because of what many saw as pro-communist sentiments, Chaplin was essentially exiled from the United States after 1952. He only directed two more movies after his exile and neither of them were as well-received as his previous work. Years later, after the political landscape changed a bit, Chaplin's films were re-examined and his later works especially gained a renewed appreciation. In 1972 Chaplin was allowed to return to the U.S in order to receive an honorary award at the Oscars where he was greeted with the longest standing ovation in Oscar history. Through his iconic Tramp character, Chaplin became one of the richest and most famous people in the world and it's often said that at one time, Chaplin's Tramp was the most famous image in the world. Chaplin was a supremely versatile artist who wrote, directed, produced, edited, scored, and starred in most of his films. A notorious perfectionist, Chaplin often spent years working on his films in an era where many directors turned out multiple movies a year. By my reckoning, Chaplin made eight indisputable masterpieces, out of his eleven total, and many of them are often ranked among the greatest movies of all time. He was one of the few silent performers who was able to switch to sound without losing any effectiveness whatsoever and his films have already lasted nearly 100 years without showing any signs of growing old or stale.

8. The Circus

Despite its now classic status, The Circus endured an agonizing production that led to its release being delayed eight months. Chaplin overcame the death of his mother, a bitter divorce from his second wife, a scratched film negative, and a major studio in the process of delivering one of the highest grossing films of the silent era. In The Circus, Chaplin's Tramp unwittingly becomes the star of a struggling circus after stumbling into the middle of one of the shows. Unfortunately, the Tramp can only be funny when he is not trying to be and he soon falls out of favor with the ringmaster and the audience. Released in 1928, one year after The Jazz Singer became the first sound film, many critics have since interpreted the ending, which showed the Tramp walking away into the distance as the Circus leaves him behind, as showing Chaplin's fear that he too will soon be left behind by the sound age. Fortunately for everyone, Chaplin was not even close to finishing his remarkable run of classics. An enormous success upon its release, The Circus garnered Chaplin a special Academy Award and it has remained one of the most adored of all silent films.

7. Limelight

Chaplin's last masterpiece, Limelight is a semi-autobiographical film made during some of the most difficult years of the his life. After World War Two, Chaplin's reputation and popularity was severely affected by rumors of his communist political leanings and various other controversies. Chaplin was essentially exiled from the U.S before its release and Limelight was not permitted to be shown in many American movie theaters. It was not until 1972, twenty years after its premiere, that Limelight was finally given a major release in the U.S and since then it has become something of a classic. In stark contrast to his better know films, Limelight is not a comedy, although it does contain some humorous moments. Instead, Limelight is an excellent drama about a once famous stage clown named Calvero, who has since become a lonely alcoholic that can't find work anywhere. After taking charge of a former dancer in his building who attempted suicide, they both help each attempt comebacks. A smart and affecting film, Limelight is particularly notable for being the only time Chaplin and fellow silent movie icon Buster Keaton ever appeared on screen together. Keaton himself had fallen on hard times and so Chaplin included him in the film's climactic scene where they perform a comedy set together during Calvero's comeback performance. Chaplin is simply brilliant as Calvero, not only does he perform his trademark comedic scenes, he also convincingly pulls off nearly every emotion possible as he is in turns depressed, mirthful, wise, and childish. Although not his last film, Limelight is a fitting finale to Chaplin's career as he proved once again his brilliance at both acting and directing. Thematically, the movie shows the passing of the torch from Chaplin to the next generation of entertainers and is a near perfect way to end his string of great films.

6. The Great Dictator

Probably Chaplin's most well-known film to the average moviegoer because of its iconic final speech, The Great Dictator was his first film that completely embraced sound. A scathing criticism of Adolf Hitler released at the height of World War Two, Chaplin plays two characters: one an unnamed jewish barber and the other the tyrannical dictator Hynkel. Although stupendously successful upon its release, The Great Dictator marked the end of Chaplin's thirty year run as the world's most popular entertainer. In the coming years, Chaplin would receive much criticism for his political beliefs and a seemingly unending amount of paternity suits. While The Great Dictator has a number of classic scenes such as the final speech, the opening battle scene, a haircut set to Brahm's Hungarian Dance, and Chaplin's hilarious Hitler impersonation, the film as a whole is bit more uneven than the best of Chaplin's work and despite its earnestness, is a bit dull at times. Still, The Great Dictator is arguably the most important film Chaplin ever made and many hail it as one of his best. It was the third highest ranked Chaplin film on both Sight and Sounds 2012 list of greatest films and on IMDB's top 250. Despite its flaws, the film's boldness and audacity make it a better movie than most directors could ever hope to create.

5. City Lights

Often hailed as his best film, City Lights proved that Chaplin could be successful even well into the sound age. In City Lights, Chaplin's Tramp becomes involved with two people: an alcoholic millionaire that he saves from preventing suicide, and a blind flower girl that he tries to raise money for in order to send her to a doctor who can cure her. From beginning to end, City Lights is filled with great moments. There is the opening scene where the city officials dedicate a new statue and discover the Tramp asleep on it. There is the boxing match where the Tramp manages to keep the referee between him and his opponent, another when he saves the rich man from drowning himself with a stone but ends up almost drowning himself, and the scene where the flower girl finally sees the Tramp for the first time. The list of great scenes goes on and on, but if City Lights was just a collection of great stunts, it wouldn't have been considered one of the all-time great movies for over 80 years. What puts City Lights into the upper echelons of silent films is the complexity that is hidden beneath the surface. In his excellent review of the film in his Great Movie series, Roger Ebert pointed out that " In City Lights, his only friendships are with people who don't or can't see him: with a drunken millionaire who doesn't recognize him when he sobers up, and with a blind flower girl."Chaplin plays with not only our sense of humor but our emotions as well; this is what made him such a great filmmaker and City Light is one of the best examples of his genius.

4. The Gold Rush

Chaplin often said that The Gold Rush was the film he'd liked to be remembered for and it's easy to see why; not only is it arguably Chaplin's best comedy, it's one of the best comedies by any director. In The Gold Rush, The Tramp sets out for the Yukon to seek his fortune during the Klondike Gold Rush. The first part of the film finds The Tramp taking shelter during a blizzard in a cabin with two other prospectors: Big Jim and the fugitive Black Larsen. After some hilarious scenes including The Tramp having to eat his own shoe because of hunger, the trio split up and The Tramp settles in a small town where he gets a job watching over another prospectors house while he is looking for gold. Enormously successful upon its release, The Gold Rush was the fifth highest grossing film of the sound age and has long been considered one of the finest comedies ever made. It features one of Chaplin's trademark happy endings and might just be the most satisfying of all his films.

3. Monsieur Verdoux

Chaplin's most criminally underrated film, Monsieur Verdoux is a darkly comic picture that marked the first time Chaplin completely abandoned his famous Tramp character. Loosely based off a real-life story, Monsieur Verdoux was originally set to be directed by Orson Welles but Chaplin thought it would be a brilliant idea for a comedy and eventually bought the rights to it. Monsieur Verdoux is at once an incredibly fascinating character study, a critique on capitalist culture, and a complex, captivating work of art. Henri Verdoux is one of the most charismatic and oddly sympathetic villains in film history, even though his crimes are horrifying. He seduces and marries older women before killing them for their insurance and property. He appears to do this to support his "real" family that live in a pastoral home in the country but as the movie goes on, it becomes more and more clear that he has completely lost his way. Monsieur Verdoux was Chaplin's first commercial and critical failure for a variety of reasons: first, it did not have the appeal of containing Chaplin's signature Tramp character, second, it was much more overtly philosophical and examining than his earlier works, and lastly, Chaplin's reputation had taken a remarkable hit in the preceding years due to what some people saw as anti-american sentiments, a string of paternity issues, and mysterious tax problems. Monsieur Verdoux did have some early champions as famed critic Andre Bazin triumphed it at its release and James Agee, another well-known critic, called Chaplin's performance the best he had ever seen up to that point in time. The film was also one of Chaplin's favorites and subsequent years have seen its reputation grow considerably and I had half a mind to put it number one because of its complexity and daring.

2. Modern Times

Nine years into the sound age, Charlie Chaplin continued to defy logic with Modern Times. Although there were sound effects and a few spoken lines, the majority of the film is silent and The Tramp, in his last film appearance, does not speak the entire film except for some gibberish. Arguably Chaplin's best blend of comedy and melodrama, Modern Times was a thinly veiled critique of the modern industrial world, which at the time was right in the middle of the Great Depression. It begins with the Tramp working on a production line at a factory, where the menial but demanding labor causes him to have a mental breakdown. Now unemployed, he meets an orphaned girl on the streets and they set out together in an attempt to find work. After run-ins with the law and brief success as entertainment at a cafe, the film ends with the two walking down a road to an uncertain future. The ending is a bit deceptive sounding as Modern Times is a typically hopeful Chaplin film and is filled with some of the most memorable scenes in silent film history. Chaplin's last silent film, and the last important silent film for many years, Modern Times was also his last unmitigated success as the coming years saw him become more active politically, which had a disastrous impact on his reputation.

1. The Kid

Often forgotten in Chaplin's extensive oeuvre, The Kid is the strongest display of Chaplin's cinematic genius. His first feature film, The Kid clocks in at only 68 minutes long but it fits more in those minutes than many films twice as long. The Kid is a simple but brilliantly told story. A broke mother abandons her newborn son in the back of a car because she cannot afford to take care of it. Eventually, the child winds up in the hands of Chaplin's Tramp, who cares for it as his own. The two become partners in crime as the child throws rocks through windows only for the Tramp to show up minutes late to fix it for a small charge. When the boy becomes sick, the doctor discovers that the Tramp is not his father and the authorities attempt to place the boy in an orphanage. After a brilliant chase scene, The Tramp and the kid are reunited in one of the most emotional scenes in Chaplin's filmography. After a tough night on the run, the boy is reunited with his mother, who has since become extremely wealthy, and the film ends with all three walking together into her house. A phenomenal success upon its release, The Kid is one of the greatest of all silent movies and cemented Chaplin's status as a titan of film once and for all. The film fully showed off his talents as writer, actor, and director, and while it doesn't have the philosophical content or social importance of his later films, The Kid is the most purely entertaining and affecting of his films and might be his most rewatchable work.