DCEU: 10 Comics It Must Adapt To Beat Marvel
The MCU might be heading for Phase 4, but can DC actually catch them?
The Marvel Cinematic Universe is currently in the midst of experiencing potentially its most important year yet, but another comic book movie franchise has been experiencing changes of its own too - the DC Extended Universe.
Back when it was conceived in 2013, the DCEU was set to be Warner Bros' answer to the MCU. Zack Snyder, albeit a divisive filmmaker, had a proven box-office draw and what better way to mount that challenge, they thought, than with Superman?
The story since has been anything but smooth sailing, with Man of Steel, Batman v Superman, Suicide Squad and Justice League all floundering amongst critics, while the latter failed to make any waves financially either. Couple that with a future slate of films that failed to really inspire any kind of confidence amongst audiences, and it's clear that, until recently, the DCEU was in dire straights.
However, it's equally true that some have been too quick to pronounce the series' death. Both Wonder Woman and Aquaman were immensely successful, and achieved that success by divesting from the original vision optioned by Snyder in his first two films.
Now, with a markedly different set of upcoming projects, a new Batman and a new direction, WB might finally be able to mount the challenge they hoped Man of Steel would in 2013. Here are the comics they should look in order to make it happen.
10. Batman And The Monster Men
There are a whole host of Bat-books that should inform Matt Reeves' upcoming interpretation of the Dark Knight, but none more-so than Matt Wagner and Dave Stewart's Batman and the Monster Men.
Until recently, it was rumoured that Reeves' Batman film would take place early on in the Caped Crusader's career, which contrasted heavily with Zack Snyder's Dark Knight Returns-inspired interpretation of the vigilante. Such a move would've necessitated Ben Affleck's exit from the role, and low and behold, last month, that very thing happened.
In the wake of Affleck's decision to leave the part behind, the actor seemed to confirm those earlier rumours that Reeves' film would show Batman towards the beginning of his crimefighting career.
"I'm looking forward to it. They've got a great director. They're doing a kind of, I don't want to give away anything because they get... but they're doing a young version, a more starting-out version with a younger guy... I'm sure it will be great."
If this is the case (and it seems almost nailed on now), then Reeves should look no further than Wagner and Stewart's story. It depicts Batman just after the events of Year One, but with the added wrinkle of him encountering his first ever 'supervillains'. It'd be a fascinating dynamic to explore on screen, especially since fans tend to forget Bruce only became Batman to fight not the mob and not the eccentric characters he'd encounter later in his time as the Dark Knight.
9. Suicide Squad: From The Ashes
James Gunn's firing from Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3 proved to be Marvel's loss and DC's gain, as the writer/director is now attached to helm a new version of the Suicide Squad for Warner Bros. in the coming years.
Dubbed simply 'The Suicide Squad', this new iteration of the team will supposedly leave behind most of the first film's cast in favour of a brand-new lineup. Will Smith is out as Deadshot, Idris Elba is in, and while it's still unconfirmed as to whether or not Margot Robbie's Harley Quinn will appear, given the renewed focus on the character, one would expect her to feature in one way or another.
Again, as with Batman, there are plenty of brilliant Suicide Squad stories Gunn could look to for inspiration. Perhaps the best, though, would be From the Ashes, a comic helmed by Suicide Squad creator John Ostrander.
The main problem with the first film (apart from the jarring soundtrack and cumbersome editing), was that it didn't really justify the Squad's creation. Pretty much any super-team could go ahead and deal with a public world-ending sky-portal, whereas the Squad are usually deployed to handle more covert matters. How better to go back to basics, then, than with the original creator's book?
8. Deathstroke: The Professional
Deathstroke's status in the rapidly changing DCEU is somewhat confusing. At first, it was announced that Joe Manganiello would play the character in Ben Affleck's solo Batman movie, but with Batfleck out and Reeves in, it's still unclear as to whether or not he may appear. It's also unknown as to whether the post-credits scene from Justice League will actually lead to anything either, while the Gareth Evans-helmed Deathstroke standalone movie's status remains unclear.
However, irrespective of whether or not there is a future for Slade Wilson in the DCEU (let's just assume there is), WB would do well to take inspiration from the character's most recent comics. They're sublime, and have been orchestrated by renowned comic book writer Christopher Priest, and even involved the legendary Larry Hama on the first volume's layouts.
Put simply, Priest's Deathstroke is genius. The character may not be the first one you associate with genuinely clever storytelling, but the character's Rebirth years have been nothing short of spectacular, imbuing the villain with a hefty dose of espionage fiction, politics, and even some feuding with the Dark Knight himself.
7. Cosmic Odyssey
If you were looking for the comic that is pretty much DC's Infinity War, look no further than Cosmic Odyssey.
Although there's a decent argument to be made that pretty much any of the Crises would also fill that requirement, most are also pretty complex. There's nothing wrong with that of course - the Crises are some of the greatest DC stories ever told - but something more self-contained would potentially be better.
Enter Cosmic Odyssey, a 1988 series written by Jim Starlin and drawn by Hellboy creator Mike Mignola. It is Starlin's name, however, that'll make those Infinity War comparisons immediately apparent, as the writer also helmed the saga that's currently inspiring the MCU's cosmic-based Avengers films.
Just like Infinity Gauntlet, Cosmic Odyssey brings together some of the biggest names in the DC Universe to tackle a whole new threat, with the New Gods, Batman, Superman and Green Lantern just some of the names involved. With that in mind, if WB look to bring the Justice League back together in the future, this is the comic they should look to.
6. Aquaman By Peter David
James Wan's Aquaman film may have worked fine enough by taking the bulk of its story from Geoff Johns' stint on the character during the New 52, but there's plenty of other material to look to that predates the writer's run.
Although it's only recently that King Arthur Curry has found mainstream recognition, the character hasn't been a joke in the comics for over three decades. One of the writers who was instrumental in tackling that stigma was Peter David, who gave Aquaman a whole new makeover from 1994 onwards. Visually, audiences can probably already see comparison's between the writer's version of the character and the one portrayed on screen by Jason Momoa, but there's another element that's completely missing: the hook hand.
Look, love it, or just plain old hate it, the hook hand makes Aquaman look like a bonafide warrior. Given how the DCEU has leaned into that interpretation so far, and also how Momoa would probably own that look and then some, Aquaman 2 should make the bold decision to lop his hand off and replace it with a mechanical spear.
See? The nineties weren't all that bad after all.
5. Batgirl: Year One
Barbara Gordon may not feature in the upcoming Birds of Prey, but she's bound to play a part in the DCEU at some point.
A Batgirl film featuring Babs was announced a few years ago with Joss Whedon originally at the helm. However, Whedon soon exited the project and a new writer was brought onboard - Christina Hodson, who penned Bumblebee for Paramount as well as the script for Cathy Yan's aforementioned film.
Hodson only has about three films under her belt, but she's on the rise and her work on Bumblebee was sublime. With that in mind, and with WB potentially encouraged by what they've seen of Birds of Prey so far, her involvement in Batgirl is very exciting.
Given the last time audiences saw Barbara Gordon onscreen came in 1997's Batman & Robin though, it's perhaps inevitable that the upcoming film will be an origin story. Fortunately for readers and Hodson, there've been loads of brilliant stories that have chronicled Gordon's burgeoning years as a crimefighter, including the aptly titled Batgirl: Year One.
Recent forays into the character's time as Batgirl worth mentioning include pretty much everything Gail Simone has done with Barbara, as well as the Batgirl of Burnside books helmed by Brendan Fletcher, Cameron Stewart and Babs Tarr.
4. Mister Miracle (2017)
Of all the upcoming DC projects, it is Ava DuVernay's New Gods that should get fans most excited. After all, DuVernay is a superb director, and she now gets to work her magic on some of the most inspirational and creative stories that DC has ever published: Jack Kirby's Fourth World Saga.
Kirby is often considered an architect of Marvel Comics - and that is true - but his time at DC fostered a legacy comparable in scope to what he achieved over at the House of Ideas back in the sixties. At the core to this series was the conflict between the planets of New Genesis and Apokolips, the former ruled by the ostensibly benevolent High Father, and the latter by the indisputably tyrannical Darkseid.
Elements of the Fourth World were already shown off in Justice League, but audiences haven't seen anything yet. There's a really compelling conflict to examine between these two immortal civilisations, and at its core in recent years has been two perspectives - Scott Free's and Big Barda's.
In order to achieve a truce between Apokolips and New Genesis, the two leaders decide to swap their children (because obviously). Darkseid's boy becomes Orion, while High Father's son, Mister Miracle, heads to Apokolips, where he is then tortured for the rest of his days at Granny Goodness' orphanage.
Eventually, he falls in love with Big Barda and escapes to earth, which is where Tom King and Mitch Gerads' series comes in. It's haunting, honest, and though not nearly epic enough to inspire an entire film, embodies the relationship between Scott and Barda perfectly.
3. The Sinestro Corps War
Green Lantern, despite what the 2010 Ryan Reynolds-fronted film would tell you, has the potential to be DC's Star Wars. The IP possesses so much in terms of mythology, that it could easily make for an entire saga of its own.
Among the DC films currently hinted to release in the future is Green Lantern Corps, which according to rumours will also focus on Hal Jordan and John Stewart. The latter is a fan-favourite character, having featured heavily across various DC media in the early 2000s, and the buddy-cop potential in pairing him with Jordan is fairly evident.
The Sinestro Corps War may not necessarily be a Hal/John story, but it's the kind of one that should form the basis for WB's Green Lantern reboot. It's the very definition of epic, and with Sinestro a pretty charismatic villain, DC have all the components in place to make something truly special.
2. Supergirl: Being Super
Henry Cavill's exit from the DCEU might've been hailed as something of a worst-case scenario by the series' most ardent fans, but in truth, it was time for DC to try something different.
It's still unclear as to whether or not Superman will ever appear again, but we know for a fact that WB will now be focussing on Supergirl instead. Kara Zor-El is the Man of Steel's cousin in the comics, and has featured (like most DC characters) in some truly wonderful stories over the years.
Again, however, her upcoming movie might best be served by looking to the character's most recent adventures. Sure, there are plenty of brilliant, older runs to her name - with the likes of Peter David, Mark Waid and Sterling Gates all helming some fantastic books - but the recent Supergirl: Being Super provides the perfect blueprint for a Supergirl origin movie to work off.
Written by Mariko Tamaki and drawn by the ludicrously talented Joƫlle Jones, Being Super focusses on Kara as a teenager, adjusting to the challenges of High School, all while discovering her own powers. It's easy to see how it could work on the big screen, and if Supergirl is set to play as big a role as has been rumoured, you won't find a better place to start than there.
1. Justice League: New World Order
For over a decade, writer Grant Morrison made the DC Universe his own. Whether it was through Animal Man, Batman or Justice League, the writer always managed to bring some of the most inventive, creative and compelling stories going.
Justice League: New World Order might not be the most blockbuster League tale going, but it did bring the group back in a uniquely brilliant way. It also featured a definitive lineup, comprised of Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman, Flash, Green Lantern, Aquaman and Martian Manhunter. It's the exact lineup WB should look to emulate in the future, but with the League ostensibly on hiatus, that future could be a long way off.
In any case, New World Order presents the perfect template to bring a whole new version of the Justice League into being. It doesn't matter if there's no Superman, Flash or Cyborg (it does matter if there's Martian Manhunter though, let's be honest), what is paramount is that it gets to the core of what makes the League so fascinating.
They aren't just another group of Super-Friends with ridiculous powers, but a team with a proper legacy. That never really shone through in Joss Whedon's film, but with this kind of story informing a potential revival, WB could make the world fall in love with the team on the second go.