Deadpool 2 Review: 8 Ups & 3 Downs

Bigger, bolder, funnier...

By Simon Gallagher /

Fox

Remember when there were some whispers that Deadpool 2 had tested poorly? Yeah, that's yet more evidence that Hollywood needs better test audiences, because David Leitch and Ryan Reynolds have done something quite incredible with the Merc With A Mouth's second REAL cinematic appearance... They made it better than the first one.

Advertisement

At one point in the deliciously violent, beautifully outrageous sequel, we see that Cable's big f*cking gun has a dial that turns up to 11, and there's no better analogy for the movie than that. It's an escalation of the first film that doesn't jump the shark, doesn't sh*t the bed and manages to be funnier, cleverer, more emotionally true and even more infectious.

Anyone concerned with the removal of Tim Miller as director need not be: Leitch is a more than capable replacement whose past work brings something new to the franchise and who clearly knows 'Pool just as much as Ryan Reynolds. And it's the star who deserves the lion's share of the plaudits, really, because his enthusiasm for giving Deadpool fans the version they needed (while also taking shots at himself, quite gloriously) drips from every scene.

Advertisement

Sure, it's long, but there's a lot in there and there's no sag at all. And honestly, if Disney have ANY thoughts at all about cancelling 'Pool once they take the reins, we all ought to revolt. Because the world needs more of this, even if it's not an entirely flawless movie. But then again, Deadpool's always been a little rough around the edges, so perfection would have been misplaced.

So first, let's get to the negatives...

Advertisement

Downs

3. It Could Have Gone Further

Deadpool 2 Trailer

There are definitely some real gasp moments in there, but it isn't QUITE as subversive as you'd like it to be. Given how far we are into the culture of comic book movies (there are already cynics calling Deadpool 2 the worst example of over-saturation), it's the perfect time to skewer the industry, and while there's some of it in there, there's not a lot of lampooning going on.

Advertisement

The X-Force team-up sequence is legitimately genius in that respect, but Deadpool 2 doesn't quite go far enough to avoid becoming the things it (and its predecessor) sought to target with its barbed comedy.

At times, it definitely feels like they're pulling punches, though it's definitely not a major concern for most of the run-time.

Advertisement

2. TJ Miller COULD Have Been Cut

Fox

Given how long Deadpool 2 is, you'd think they'd have been happy to take any opportunity to cut superfluous elements, so it's very much a surprise that TJ Miller remains in the film, given the accusations of sexual misconduct against him (and his arrest for a fake bomb threat).

Advertisement

A precedent has been set to remove such problematic stars and no matter how much the studio insisted Miller couldn't be removed, he doesn't actually do that much in the film. Replacing him wouldn't have taken much and we wouldn't have had to endure too close-to-the-knuckle jokes about his "nervous erection."

1. The Logic Of The Ending Doesn't Quite Make Sense

Fox

Let's get this sorted straight out: the ending of Deadpool 2 is great, inverting the new fetish for emotionally loaded endings in the genre and giving Deadpool far more depth than the first movie. But there's still a big issue with it.

Advertisement

Without spoiling it, the logic of what Cable does in the film's final moments simply isn't there. For 99% of the movie, he's very singularly driven by one thing and one thing alone and then all of sudden he turns his back on his motivation in a moment that still feels a little unearned.

And what makes it worse is that as soon as he make his decision and acts, it's proven unnecessary thanks to another character's "prison wallet." It just seems like a falsely manufactured way of extending him into the franchise.

Advertisement

And now to the positives...

Ups

8. It's Really Bloody Different

Fox

Even off the back of Infinity War and its reinvention of the MCU, Deadpool 2 is a wildly different comic book movie that glories in its difference (even if it pulls a few punches).

Advertisement

It takes lots of expectations and turns them upside down, with Deadpool still talking to the audience, established tropes being ripepd to shreds and some of the most self-aware materisal ever seen in a comic book movie. Even in the wake of the first Deadpool's impact on other Marvel movies, this sequel proves that Ryan Reynolds still does it best.

They're definitely going to struggle to keep pushing the envelope in the inevitable third movie.

Advertisement

7. The Escalation Works

Deadpool 2 Trailer

The villains in the first Deadpool were a major problem because they simply weren't as interesting as Deadpool. They weren't even interesting enough to warrant his attention and it showed.

Advertisement

But here, the combination of Cable and a pair of other incredibly powerful antagonists means that there are some very real threats to Deadpool, which helps make the whole movie feel bigger, darker and more of a wildcard.

The set-pieces are more impressive, the characters better and there's definitely a reason for Deadpool to escalate himself and bring together the X-Force. The script definitely delivers on dialling up the odds.

Advertisement

6. The New Characters

Fox

There are a LOT of new characters in Deadpool 2 alongside the likes of Vanessa, 'Pool, Blind Al, Weasel, Negasonic Teenage Warhead, Vanessa and Colossus and they're all great additions.

Advertisement

Domino in particular stands out, but there's real genius in the way everyone else is introduced, including some of the one Fox and Marvel meant to keep close to their chest.

Basically, there's lots of promise for where the franchise goes, even as we might have to move away from some of the pillars of the character (his isolation, predominantly).

Advertisement

5. The Action

Deadpool 2 Trailer

The big appeal of hiring David Leitch to take over from Tim Miller was always going to be what he brings to action scenes. The former stuntman has already shown on John Wick and Atomic Blonde that he knows how to make uber-violence look like ballet and he's really pushed the boat out to make a similar sort of impact with Deadpool.

Advertisement

The first film's violence was nowhere near as memorable as what Leitch does and you can see his commitment to using 'Pool's specific powers creatively. It's like he's at John Wick and Atomic Blonde and then explored what it would be like if those heroes weren't just bad-asses but could also take an infinite amount of punishment.

The result is hard-hitting close quarters fighting that makes 'Pool look like a superhero smashed together with Garbage Pail Kids-style gross-out violence. And it's commendable because his healing factor - and the situations it leads to in the comics - is precisely one of the reasons Deadpool is such a popular character. Leitch doesn't just understand action and hyper-violence, he understands their relationship to his main character.

Advertisement

4. Cable

Fox

Though the majority of the new characters are great, Josh Brolin's Cable warrants his own mention, because he's great. If you weren't already loudly proclaiming 2018 the years of the Brolin after Infinity War, you definitely will be now.

Advertisement

He's the perfect straight guy opposite Deadpool, bringing a delightfully gruff edge to proceedings and a no-bullsh*t attitude that makes their dynamic hugely joyful. He's frequently the butt of 'Pool's jokes (particularly a long-running gag about his apparent racial prejudices) but not in a way that is at all victimising and he seems to spend most of his time rolling his eyes perpetually.

On top of that, Brolin's physicality is perfect for Cable too and there's surprising depth to him thanks to his emotional backstory that lifts him well away from being one-dimensional. This is the Cable that comics fans have wanted (and deserved) for years on the big screen.

Advertisement

3. The Easter Eggs And Surprises

Marvel/Fox

After the first movie claimed to have 100 Easter Eggs, it was inevitable that its follow-up would push the envelope on references and Easter Eggs - particularly because 'Pool's fourth wall breaking powers make him a pop culture gag shotgun firing references every couple of minutes. And there are some great ones in there, from mentions of Stranger Things and the Goonies to frequent MCU gags and obviously the X-Men.

Advertisement

The best thing about it, though, is how many HUGE surprises Leitch and Fox have got in there. Just as Infinity War did so well to protect their spoilers and at least one massive cameo, Deadpool 2 has a cameo the size of Matt Damon's Thor: Ragnarok appearance, some brilliantly funny X-Men appearances and a whole secret cameo (provided you've ignored the marketing teases). And then there's that mid-credits sequence, which might well be the best one in any comic book movie ever.

They're genuinely fan-baiting moments and they'll be what fans talk about for the longest after the credits roll. Just don't expect a post-credits scene.

Advertisement

2. The Emotional Stakes

Fox

Considering the temptation to think of Deadpool as just a "clown dressed up like a sex toy" (thanks, Cable), it's really quite stunning how well Leitch has done to balance the silliness and the hyper-violence with genuine heart.

Advertisement

The entire plot is driven by similar narrative beats to Logan (about belonging and finding your true "family" calling) with side-glances at abuse, mental health issues and genuinely devastating tragedy. None of it is done in a throw-away way either - it's all given correct reverence and the result is a gripping depth and complexity that completely changes the character.

This sort of complex story-telling was completely lacking from the first movie and it's genuinely incredible to think that there will legitimately be people who are brought to tears. Aha's "Take On Me" has a lot to answer for, that's for sure.

Advertisement

1. The Improvement In Humour

Fox

When you're faced with the prospect of outdoing a comedy, there's always a temptation to turn the dial up to 11 while also stripping out nuance and real intellect to make a sort of distilled version of the original to try and double down on the impact. Let's call it Minion syndrome.

Advertisement

But Deadpool 2 absolutely avoids it and is actually considerably more funny than its predecessor. The self-awareness is dialled up, there are better barbs thrown at Marvel and other comic book movie properties and the entire X-Force and mid-credits sequences will have you rolling around.

And thanks to more serious anchors like Domino and Cable, the comedy never outstays its welcome. This is not Jim Carrery's The Mash (and by God, it could have been), because Ryan Reynolds knows that Deadpool's shtick only works when there are people unwilling to suffer his bullsh*t.

Advertisement

In that respect, the writing is absolutely brilliant and honestly, the balance of comedy, action and real heart is about the most impressive thing of 2018's movies so far.

What did you think of Deadpool 2? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.

Advertisement