Doctor Strange Review: 8 Ups & 5 Downs
The Doctor will see you now...
It's been a long time coming, but the advent of the so-called Cosmic MCU was always going to be a major gamble for Marvel. Even with a great cast, a hugely talented director and a budget to really show off some stunning effects and set-pieces, Doctor Strange was never a sure thing, and given what potentially comes next, it was also one of the most highly pressured of all of the studio's releases.
Luckily, it's mostly excellent. It is pregnant with stunning visuals and has an unrivalled commitment to spectacle on a different scale to anything ever seen in Marvel films before. And crucially for Marvel, it not only offers hope for more supernatural MCU projects and a deeper exploration of the Multiverse, but it also offers instant promise for more Doctor Strange movies and for the MCU beyond Phase 3.
In short, it ticks every requirement Marvel must have drawn up for it at the very earliest planning meetings. Kevin Feige cane once more crow about a success, but it isn't flawless by any means, and drilling down into the detail reveals some things that hold it back from true greatness.
Here's exactly how Doctor Strange stacks up: please be aware that there's a general mild spoiler warning on this article.
Starting with the positives...
Ups
8. It Is A True Stand-Alone
One of the best things to say about Doctor Strange's narrative decisions is that it works perfectly as a complete stand-alone movie. It feels separate from the rest of the MCU - partly because of the very smart decision to set it initially at the same time as Iron Man 2 - but without any hint that it won't work when he comes into contact with the other Avengers.
There are obviously Easter Eggs - this is a Marvel movie after all - but they aren't blatant and they feel organic rather than shoe-horned in. There are background mentions of the Avengers - including a brief but brilliant explanation of why the Sorcerors do not intervene in protecting Earth from things like the Chitauri attack (their remit is only metaphysical threats).
And it also works as an origin. Perhaps because Strange isn't as well-established in the mainstream as some of the other Marvel figures, he actually needs an origin (also, his power is so inherently linked to the backstory of his hands that ignoring it would be silly), and having it feel sort of timeless and sort of as a satellite to the main MCU was an inspired decision.
7. The Music
Though a lot of Marvel fans won't want to acknowledge any short-comings, the MCU has suffered from a lack of musical personality so far. Guardians Of The Galaxy is obviously the exception, but that wasn't a case of a score working - it was more a gimmick that landed perfectly (and probably will again).
It's a strange shortcoming too, considering how tied theme music has always been to superheroes in the past, but Marvel have always seen fit to write orchestral but ultimately forgettable accompaniments to their action. There's a general shared brand to it, but it doesn't have great deal of charm.
Wth the introduction of the genius Michael Giacchino, Marvel have found a composer able to express that missing personality - he actually reintroduces the idea of Strange having a theme and it's a wonderful addition.
6. The Action Sequences
Obviously the effects of Doctor Strange will be endlessly praised when it's on wider worldwide release (and I'll get to them soon) but there's something massive to be said about the action sequences themselves.
The fight choreography is inventive and stunning to watch, incorporating ridiculous eye-watering effects sequences and brutal close combat and weapon work. And while they punctuate the plot in a very pointed way, they never feel perfunctory or like they're designed to distract from any of the film's narrative shortcomings.
The imagination that has gone into those set-pieces - in particular the first fight between The Ancient One and Kaecilius and then the time-bending finale almost defy description. They are absolute triumphs of effects, conception and effects, and it is they that will draw a lot of fans back for multiple viewings. Or at least they should.
5. Mordo Will Be A Compelling Villain
To get it out of the way, Kaecilius is not the greatest Marvel villain going: he's a bit of a mook elevated to the important role of vessel to an even bigger threat, but there's a sort of silent slasher movie monster spirit about him that works well for the film's requirements.
He's not the only villain on show of course, and as well as his boss we get the introduction of Karl Mordo, who initially starts as an ally to Strange. By the end of the film, his allegiance has flipped, and while he's not the same sort of villain as Kaecilius, he looks very compelling.
He's basically going to be a policing antagonist, reacting to what he sees as the over-reaching behaviour of the Sorcerors and protecting the Natural Laws. That instantly gives him a different level of complexity to any other MCU villain seeking personal gain or power: and while he's another mirror image villain, Chiwetel Ejiofor's performance was more than strong enough to suggest there are even better things to come.
4. The Effects
I don't say this lightly, but I have never seen a film like Doctor Strange before. Others like The Matrix and Inception have impressed with stunning visuals, but Scott Derickson has achieved an unbelievable feat in taking elements from both, adding his own new additions in the shape of the spells and incantations of this world and surpassing both.
Some of the sequences - including The Ancient One sending Strange down the rabbit hole to "open his eye" are flat-out incredible. They are artistic wonders on their own, pain-stakingly crafted out of the most wild and vivid imaginations, taking in the iconic artwork of the comics and a sort of LSD-infused dreamscape that is beyond anything you could reasonably imagine. This is absolutely next level stuff, and if it doesn't win an Oscar for the effects, something is badly amiss.
And not only that, but the lower level practical effects are also great: n particular, the make-up that goes into Strange's hands is spectacularly realistic.
3. The Implied Thor/Strange Team-Up
The mid-credits sequence features Doctor Strange entertaining Thor within the Sanctum in New York, as the pair swap pleasantries and Strange conjures the Asgardian some beer. Strange reveals he's already assuming his new role as protector, ironically setting up a watchlist of interesting parties and threats (the same kind of list he was on himself in The Winter Soldier) including Loki.
Clearly, something pinged on his surveillance "equipment" as Loki's presence in London with Thor (to find their father) instigated his meeting with Thor, and rather wonderfully, there's a big hint that we will see Strange in Thor: Ragnarok now.
He agrees to help Thor and Loki locate Odin (which is odd considering Thor so far thinks his brother is dead and his father is on the throne in Asgard). Perhaps this is actually a scene from Ragnarok, the same way Ant-Man's post-credit scene was lifted out of Civil War?
Whatever the case, the prospect of seeing Thor and Strange working together is great; they're basically mirror images of one another, both are the most magical MCU figures and both have an inherent theatricality. Adding Strange to the Ragnarok mix, even briefly, is a lovely decision.
2. The MCU's Heir Apparent
A lot has been said of Marvel's long-term problems with replacing their Phase One veterans. In particular the question of Robert Downey Jr's inevitable departure shone brightly because of how incredible his performance is. He is the glue that holds the MCU together, and it was on his shoulders that it was built.
Even with Captain America, without Iron Man the MCU would be seriously missing a senior figure, but they've now crafted one out of an established comics character who could very easily step into Stark's shoes. Strange might as well be a sibling of Stark: both are snarky, both arrogant and brilliant and both work best as slightly detached loners and have their own personal demons.
It's almost like he's being presented as the heir to Stark's throne and the next leader of the Avengers, and on the back of Doctor Strange that is absolutely not a problem.
1. Benedict Cumberbatch
What a pay-off for Marvel. They spent a long time trying to get Doctor Strange off the ground and trying to get their primary target for the role hired despite scheduling conflicts, and the reward is a brilliant performance by Benedict Cumberbatch. He is funny, charming, aloof and other-worldly in the right measures, offering promise of taking over from Robert Downey Jr as the leader of the MCU, and bringing a similar underlying emotional intensity.
As with Sherlock - a character very closely tied to Strange in genetics - Cumberbatch was made for this role (he was born to be the Sorceror Supreme, as the script states). He has an almost intangible alien disconnection, and his classical theatricality works wonders to build a definition between him and the rest of the grounded MCU.
Seeing him jibe with the other Avengers is going to be brilliant.
And now on to the less positive aspects of the film...
Downs
5. The Rag Doll Effects
The importance of The Matrix to this movie really shouldn't be understated: whether because they share similar ideas on mysticism, the Chosen One and alternate realms, they look like siblings.
Unfortunately Doctor Strange appears to have learned something else a little less welcome from its forebear: the effects of computerised human bodies in flight and combat. It just doesn't look like any of the lessons of the Matrix sequels were learned, because the first big set-pieces have some of the worst rag doll physics you're likely to see.
It's all covered nicely by the 3D, but once you notice it, it's horribly off-putting, precisely because of how excellent the environmental work is in comparison. To then see bad video game sprites jumping around is very poor.
4. The Plot Is A Bit Contrived For Convenience
There's a lot going on in Doctor Strange and inevitably there are some trade-offs on substance to fit it all in: that's sort of the fundamental issue with origin stories. They have to set up backstory and introduce characters, but there's also a requirement for drama and the MCU obviously also requires some level of future-seeding, no matter how briefly. It's a lot of balls to have in the air, particularly when the director has a very specific agenda to show off some seriously stunning effects.
Unfortunately because of the preciousness of time, the film's plot feels like it gallops a little too quickly at times. It's contrived in a way to advance swiftly, missing out key explanations or robbing important reveals of the space for impact by forcing them a little.
It's not a fatal issue by any means, but it does give credence to those who will criticise it for considering plot a secondary concern to spectacle.
3. Some Of The Humour Is A Little Distracting
Don't get me wrong, a lot of the humour in Doctor Strange is great: the dynamic between the humorous Strange and Wong is particularly nice (and has a charming pay-off), but there's also some humour that sticks out horribly. The mention of Beyonce in particular is awful and Strange asking if Wong only has one name "like Adele" pulls you out of the film a little too much.
Also, how much shelf-life do references to Beyonce and Drake have? Maybe it's because I'm not a massive fan, but they just look like unnecessary flirtations with making the film dated.
2. Christine Is Entirely Redundant
Marvel still doesn't have a great track record with strong female supporting characters and Rachel McAdams' Christine is another who didn't really affect the plot a great deal. Sure, she was there to put the pieces back together, but she could have been given more to do than that and reacting with bewilderment at Strange's new powers. I also find it hard to buy that she would suddenly forgive him for being an absolutely titanic douchebag simply because he's got a new beard and creepy magic powers.
It just doesn't ring true, no matter how irresistible beards can be.
Unfortunately she's not the only one. The Ancient One is a little under-nourished, Kaecilius' side-kicks might as well be actual cannon fodder and the Masters of the Sanctums are entirely pointless. It would have been nice to feel something about them considering their fate was so tied to the escalation of the plot's drama, but it just wasn't there.
Obviously some trade-offs had to be made to release a film that wasn't four hours long, but it's just a shame so much of that economy came in the form of character development.
1. Dormammu
I have absolutely no issue with Dormammu being introduced into the MCU - it's actually a great move, since he's so key to Strange's importance as a protector of Earth, but there are two pretty major issues with the way he's presented in Doctor Strange.
Firstly, he's missing his iconic, fiery design, which is about as iconic as Marvel villains come, and the replacement look is... silly at best. He might be enormous and hugely powerful (and the sequence he appears in is brilliant), but he doesn't actually look threatening enough. He's a bit... kids TV.
And then there's the fact that he's now done: the way the plot presents him makes it almost impossible for him to be a perpetual background threat to Earth and Doctor Strange, which somewhat undermines Strange's role as the Sorceror Supreme. I worry that Marvel may have written themselves into a corner and they'll need to find a villain even bigger (because sequels and escalation go together like Hulk and anger issues). DC have already been guilty of that and it didn't exactly turn out too well.
What did you think of Doctor Strange? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.