Fact Vs Fiction: Schindler's List

Spielberg's Academy Award winning movie is one of the best films of all time. But is it all true?

By James Weeds /

Schindler’s List documents the heroic tale of the man who managed to save over 1,000 Jews from being sent to concentration camps during the Holocaust. German industrialist, Oskar Schindler, capitalised on the wartime economy by taking over as manager of a small enamel wear factory in Krakow. Schindler was initially interested in hiring Jewish people due to their low rates under the Third Reich. However, as the treatment of the Jewish people across Nazi-occupied territories became increasingly worse, Schindler sought to help those most in need.

Advertisement

The factory manager began giving his employees better working conditions and access to more food in secret. As the war continued and the Nazis began taking more of their frustrations out on the Jews, Schindler knew that many of those close to him would be murdered without cause. Towards the end of the Second World War, Schindler had created a list of over 1,000 names and he was able to save most of them.

Schindler’s bravery led him to become an honoured member in the Jewish faith. The people he had saved from certain death were dubbed Schindlerjuden (Schindler Jews) and Oskar Schindler was laid to rest on Mount Zion in Israel. He was the only member of the Nazi Party to have had that honour.

10. FACT: Schindler Saw The Liquidation Of The Krakow Ghetto

In 1942, the Nazi Party decided to liquidate the Krakow ghettos and inserted all Jews in camps on the border of the city. During the liquidation, essential workers were lined up in the street, taunted, humiliated or shot. The survivors were sent to live in the newly built Plaszow Camp, where they were kept under constant surveillance and threat.

Advertisement

In the movie, while out riding his horse, Oskar witnesses the barbaric actions carried out by the Nazis during the liquidation of the ghetto. This caused him to change his incentive from financial profit to saving as many of his employees as possible.

In reality, this also marked a turning point for Schindler as he began to understand just how little hope his workers had. However, what the movie doesn’t document is that Schindler was aware of the upcoming liquidation days beforehand. He had ordered all of his Jewish employees to sleep the night in the factory to avoid conflict.

9. FICTION: Itzhak Stern Is One Person

In the movie, Schindler is assisted by his skilled accountant, Itzhak Stern. Sir Ben Kingsley plays the role of Schindler’s initially reluctant employee magnificently and earned a BAFTA nomination for Best Supporting Actor.

Advertisement

Stern is vital for Schindler’s efforts in saving as many people as he did. The character of the accountant also served as a valuable informant for how the Jewish people were being treated behind closed doors. Without Stern, Schindler wouldn’t have been able to have saved as many people as he did.

The film deviates from history, however, as Stern’s role was not carried out by just one person. In reality, Mietek Pemper assisted Schindler in many ways. As Pemper was positioned as the brutal Amon Göth’s stenographer, he had access to crucial information.

In one instance, Pemper became aware of the Nazi’s increased demand for armament and so was pivotal in Schindler’s plan to relocate his workers to Czechoslovakia instead of Auschwitz. Pemper also had the monumental task of helping to write the famous list which helped save so many lives.

8. FACT: The Girl In The Red Coat Was Real

In the movie, while Schindler witnesses the atrocities carried out against the Jews as part of the liquidation of the ghetto, he becomes fixated on the journey of the solitary little girl wearing a red coat. The film is shot almost entirely monochrome, so the addition of colour on this child’s garment makes it a poignant scene. Representing the innocence of the persecuted Jews as they were berated and slaughtered, the girl in the red coat acts as the ultimate symbol to motivate Schindler to become a hero.

Advertisement

While this is an iconic scene in movie history, it can be interpreted as an artistic choice by producer, Steven Spielberg. However, in reality, the girl in the red coat did exist. As a little girl, Roma Ligocka was well known throughout the Jewish community for her bright red coat before Nazi occupation. Only a one-year-old when Polish Jews were sent to live in the ghettos, Roma was one of the youngest people persecuted under the Nazi regime. Roma’s father was sent to Auschwitz during the early occupation, and she didn’t see him for several years.

The movie deviates from fact, however, as Schindler notices the girl in the red coat in a cart full of dead people when talking to the brutal Amon Göth. This scene acts as a further incentive for Liam Neeson’s character in his plight to save more people.

7. FICTION: Schindler Wrote The List

In the film, after he had been informed that the Nazis were moving out of Krakow due to an impending invasion by the Red Army, Schindler and Stern compile the famous list of Jewish workers set to be transported to a new factory in Czechoslovakia. Liam Neeson is almost belligerent with supporting actor Ben Kingsley in the scene where Schindler and Stern painstakingly remember all the names of those working in the enamel factory. While this adds a lot of tension to the drama, this is not entirely accurate.

Advertisement

After the Second World War, Schindler confirmed to his physician, Dr Stanley Robbin, that he had no part in compiling the names of all the people he ended up saving. While Schindler did argue for the transportation of his many workers, he didn’t write or dictate who should be included.

During the list's inception, Schindler was serving a small sentence in prison. However, Marcel Goldberg, a Jewish clerk working at the Plaszow camp began writing the list for Jews desired for transportation to the new factory. As time went on, Itzhak Stern began adding more names to the document.

While Schindler did play a pivotal role in the rescue of over 1,000 people, the titular list was not of his own doing.

6. FACT: Roads Were Paved With Jewish Tombstones

During the Third Reich, the euphemism for the annihilation of the European Jewish population was called The Final Solution. Using Jewish people as a scapegoat for all the wrongs in European History, The Nazi Party aimed to murder over 11,000,000 Jews in an attempt at genocide.

Advertisement

With the eradication of businesses, forced labour, and extermination in Concentration Camps, the Nazis displayed utter contempt for living Jews. This disdain was also exhibited towards the dead. The Third Reich hoard Jewish treasures and stole money from bank accounts.

In Schindler’s List, as the construction of the Plaszow camp begins, there is a scene where Jewish slave workers are digging up headstones from a local cemetery. Adorned with the Star of David, these tombstones are stolen from the graves of members of the Jewish faith. The concrete headstones were used to pave the road leading to the new work camp in a display which spat on deceased Jews as well as the living.

While the Paszlow Camp is no longer standing, the road paved with tombstones which once led there remained until the 1950s. The tombstones were dug out of the ground and assembled in a memorial statue in the New Jewish Cemetery in Krakow.

5. FICTION: There Was Only One List

As Schindler had nothing to do with the compiling of the names of Jewish labourers to be moved to Czechoslovakia, it is debatable whether the movie title, Schindler’s List, is suitable. Another fact which brings the movie’s title into question is that there was more than one physical list.

Advertisement

In 2017, a list containing the names of 800 male workers from the German Enamel Factory went up for sale. It was reported to have been written by Schindler’s secretary, Itzhak Stern. The document’s historic significance allowed the seller to receive over $2,000,000 for the sale but was reported to have been one of seven. As Schindler and his accomplices managed to save the lives of over 1,000 people, this appears to be correct.

Four of the alleged seven lists are known to still be in existence, with one being on display in the Holocaust Museum in Washington DC and two more placed in the Yad Vashem, Israel’s official Holocaust memorial.

4. FACT: Leopold Pfefferberg Saluted The Nazis

One of the understated characters in the movie is Leopold Pfefferberg. He assists Schindler in dealing in the black market and acts as a point of view from within the ghetto.

Advertisement

During the liquidation scene, Pfefferberg begs his wife to hide in the sewers with him, to which she declines. During the aftermath of the dissolution of the ghetto where many Jews were murdered and survivors sent to the Paszlow concentration camp, Pfefferberg runs through the streets which have been ransacked as broken suitcases lay on the floor.

SS soldiers approach the area, and Pfefferberg performs the Polish Army salute and lies that he has been ordered to clear the debris. The SS members mock his salute, but leave him to his supposed duty, sparing him in the process.

While this serves to continue the dramatic tension during the horrific liquidation scene, this actually happened.

As part of his Holocaust Survivor Testimony, Pfefferberg details the story of how he was still wearing part of his Polish military attire on the day of liquidation. Nazi patrolmen approached him, and Pfefferberg ‘clicked’ his heels in salute before telling the lie which saved his life.

While he was mocked for using the Polish salute, the fact that one of the soldiers on patrol was an officer, he enjoyed the fact that Pfefferberg was giving him ample respect. The officer and the other SS soldiers left Pfefferberg to carry out his ‘stupid order.’

3. FICTION: Schindler Only Employed Jewish Labourers

During the early parts of the movie, Schindler discusses employee rates with his accountant, Itzhak Stern. Stern informs Schindler that Polish workers cost considerably more money than the Jews. A typical Jewish labourer would work for a daily rate of seven reichsmarks, all of which would be sent directly to the Nazis.

Advertisement

Initially, Schindler is driven only by profit. He responds that if the Jews were cheaper, it wouldn’t make any financial sense to employ any Poles. This highlights Schindler’s early immoral attitude, as well as sets up his change in motivation as the film progresses. However, at that time, Schindler didn’t exclusively employ Jews.

Throughout his time managing the German Enamel Factory, Schindler employed over 1,700 workers. Over 1,000 of them were the Jews he had helped save by the end of the war, but the others were local Polish workers. Initially, having a majority Jewish staff body worked in favour of his profiteering.

However, as time went on, Schindler became more aware of the atrocities being carried out against his workers. He opted for more Jewish staff under the pretences of a higher profit margin but wanted to assist the Jewish community against the Third Reich.

2. FACT: Göth Was A Complete Bastard

In his portrayal of the brutal SS Commandant, Amon Göth, Ralph Fiennes was superb. The display of the drunken, devious leader of the ‘Death’s Head’ Unit at Plaszow earned the actor an Academy Award nomination for Best Supporting Actor and remains one of the most barbaric onscreen antagonists.

Advertisement

While commandeering the concentration camp, Göth delights in random sniper rifle fire, indiscriminately killing slave labourers around the area. He also lusts over his maid, Helen Hirsch. In a scene where his attraction reaches its precipice, Göth begins physically abusing Hirsch, accusing her of tempting him.

While some of these atrocities are exaggerated for the film, the real-life SS Commander was equal in his murderous abuse of power. On one of his birthday’s, Göth forced the Jewish concert pianist, Natalia Karp to play the piano for him. Had she refused or not performed to Amon’s satisfaction, he would have killed her and her sister.

Furthermore, Göth ordered that all children were to be sent to Auschwitz for annihilation to make way for the arrival of 10,000 Hungarian Jews. Göth fundamentally believed in the Final Solution and played his part in the extinction of over 6,000,000 Jewish people.

Fact and fiction deviate somewhat, as in Schindler’s List, it is implied Göth remained in control of the Plaszow concentration camp throughout its duration. However, after being charged with the theft of Jewish property, as in he didn’t send it to the Reich, Göth was relieved of his duties in 1944 and was executed for war crimes in 1946.

1. FICTION: Schindler’s Wife Wasn’t Around

In the movie, Oskar Schindler’s wife, Emilie is only present in a few scenes. Highlighting Oskar’s troubled personality, Emilie only agrees to stay in Krakow with the German industrialist if he promises he won’t commit adultery. The following scene shows Emilie boarding a train back to Germany.

Advertisement

While Oskar and his wife’s marriage wasn’t the most stable, ultimately ending in 1958, Emilie played a bigger part in the events of the rescuing of the Jews than portrayed in the film.

Emilie was present with her husband throughout the majority of his time managing factories in Krakow and Brnenec, Czechoslovakia. When Oskar began running out of money and feared the fate for his Jewish staff, Emilie began selling her possessions to supplement the factory’s income.

Later on in Czechoslovakia, Emilie dealt more on the black market and provided more food for the Jewish workers, and even opened a secret sanatorium in the camp. She traded for medicine and began aiding the sick and malnourished Jews under Schindler’s roof.

Maurice Markheim, one of the thousand-plus Schindlerjuden said, ‘behind the man, there is the woman, and I believe she was the great human being.’

In 1994, both Emilie and Oskar were honoured in receiving the Righteous Among the Nations award from Yad Vashem. It is a shame Emilie's role was so downplayed in the movie.

Advertisement