Fantastic Four Reboot: 7 Rules Josh Trank & Fox MUST Follow

How to make the new version of the Fantastic Four better than the old one!

By Greggory Basore /

20th Century Fox announced at Comic Con that they're still moving forward with their reboot of Marvel's first superhero family Fantastic Four and that they've attached Chronicle director Josh Trank to helm the project. Going the route of reboots can be a tricky endeavor just as likely to back fire as it is to work. While The Amazing Spider-Man is raking in a huge amount of loot, many critics have voiced their disappointment with it and rumors were running rampant before its release that even Sony itself was unpleased. While some reboots can work out well (such as 2009's Star Trek) others aren't so well received (like 2010's A Nightmare on Elm Street which only grossed $63 million domestically and no one is waiting around to see a sequel of) and fall by the wayside. With such a dire stakes in the offing, we here at What Culture would like to offer up some thoughts on how Fox can make their new version of Fantastic Four more Star Trek and less Elm Street.

7. Don't Go Halfway, Make This A Fully Rebooted Reboot

You may or may not have noticed, but in the past few years two new hybridized forms of film continuation have arisen to stand alongside the reboot. There's the "requel" which includes movies like the aforementioned The Amazing Spider-Man where what was supposed to be a sequel instead becomes a reboot that still feels kinda sequelly. Harry and Norman Osborn's absence, plus the presence of Gwen Stacy along with Curt Connors makes it rather obvious that the plot was originally supposed to be Spider-Man 4. Same thing with The Incredible Hulk and Punisher War Zone. While it can be a good thing to salvage a decent sequel that can't be filmed into a reboot, it also closes off avenues of reinvention. Even more confounding and recent is the preboot, which stradles the lines between prequel and reboot but runs the risk of being too much of both and not enough of neither. A good example of a preboot is Star Trek (2009). The use of time travel allowed JJ Abrams to make a prequel that could still be radically different and let the audience know what's going on. A bad example would be X-Men First Class. While it's a great film in and of itself, most viewers walked away unsure of whether it's a prequel or a reboot. Hell I'm still not sure and I loved it anyway. If Trank and the other people at Fox are smart, they'll avoid this pitfall by going the Batman Begins route of starting over from the ground up. By cutting ties with the previous movies altogether, a new path can be set that allows the film to be completely unfettered. Although one thing that should not be considered requisite for Batman approach is showing how the ordinary people becomes the heroes they're meant to be...

6. Don't Retell The Origin Unless You've Got Something New and Important To Say

As I've said before, one of the reasons that Batman Begins is such a great movie is that it's the first cinematic telling of Bruce Wayne's origin in real time. Another thing that made his back story so compelling was that it was significantly different from the one in Tim Burton's movie. There's two words in that last sentence that you should pay attention to: significantly different. If Fox and Trank decide to retell the origin of Reed Richards and his pals, they need to make sure that it's a different enough origin to be worth telling. There's definitely room to improve on the origin from the first movie that was done in 2005, but it's not a vitally necessary element of a good FF reboot. Punisher and Hulk have shown that you can leave the origin to the side and still have a movie that stands on its own legs. If someone had seen either movie not being at all aware of the first ones, they would still hold up. The Incredible Hulk had an opening credits sequence that showed the new origin and a couple lines of dialogue. That was it. Warzone was even more sparse, it only had dialogue to tell the movie savy viewer that it wasn't the same version of Frank as the previous film. The reason neither film bothered to retell the origin of their protagonists is because the film-makers knew that the core audience was already familiar with the characters. That same principle of familiarity applies to The Fantastic Four. Anyone that's likely to be seriously interested in paying first run ticket prices to go see a new FF flick, is already the type of person who knows how they got their powers. A quick scene or a few lines of dialog should be enough to get the details out of the way so that the show can get on the road. Speaking of the show being on the road, for this tour there's one cat who should not be allowed on the bus...

5. Don't Hurry To Introduce Dr. Doom

While I don't really consider Dr. Doom to have ever appeared in a live action theatrical movie (the guy who played the villain in the two previous flicks is really just a poor man's Norman Osborn with 2nd hand knock offs of the powers possessed by Colossus and Electro) imdb and other sources disagree with me. With this in mind, it's a rather obvious page from the superhero reboot playbook to skip the lead villain from the first movie anyway, but more importantly the core team needs as much time devoted to developing their character arcs and motivations on screen without having the plot intensive heavy weight that is doom taking up too much precious screen time. Dr. Doom works best as a character that comes boiling out of the cauldron that is Reed's past, than as someone introduced to the audience along with Johnny, Sue and Ben. He's got a rich back story that is worthy of a film that doesn't have to worry about telling the audience who the team is and how they're different from the previous team.€ More importantly, there are a lot of villains that are waiting on the bench to be used in an FF movie, so while Trank should lead with a strong foot, there should be something better set up for the sequel. Guys like the Mole Man, The Trapster, Fin Fang Foom and the Puppet Master are all worthy starter villains. It'd be fine to drop some hints here and there about the eventual coming of Doom, and a post credit scene is always a good place to set up the next villain, but Doom is definitely a "2nd movie's villain is waaay more vicious" type a guy. Speaking of viciousness...

4. It Doesn't Have To Be "Darker and Grittier" To Be Better

This is another thing that's really important to pay attention to when rebooting a movie franchise. While it's important to present a different feel from the last movie, it's even more important to get that feeling right. A lot of reboots make the mistake of going darker and grittier than the previous iteration just because it's worked with some movies (by which I mean movies that have the words "Batman", "Dark" or "Knight" in their title). Fantastic Four is not and shouldn't be an inherently dark series. While some of the best loved story lines have had incredibly dark content, part of the reason they're so loved is that there's the lighter material interlaced through out that let those dark moments stand out. The last thing that Ben Grimm and Johnny Storm need to talk about is the deeply troubling ramifications of their actions on the social fabric of New York City and the USA and how they should best present themselves as archetypal champions of the common people. Unless that scene ends with a fart joke, then it's okay.€ One of the best things that happened to the X-Men franchise was spinning Wolverine off into his own movies, because it got the darkest grittiest character out of the way. While the Wolvie prequel was a let down (though not as much of a let down as the internet remembers) it still left an opening for the next X-Movie to have a lighter feel. The decision to take the story back to the 1960's and go with the more colorful costumes of the earlier eras of comics was a refreshing change of flavor from the dark palate of Singer and Ratner. In fact, if Singer and Vaughn had been willing to fully embrace the power of a reboot and make a clean break from the previous films in every way, First Class would have served as a much better opening to an X-Men franchise than X-Men did, instead of teasing the audience with cameos of actors from the previous movies and leaving fans like with the continued hope that we'll someday see a resolution to the end cap from X-3 and finally find out who the heck Charlie Xavier jumped inside of when Jean destroyed his goddamn body (seriously, if that lingering plot thread isn't resolved I am going to find everyone responsible after I die and haunt the hell out of them). Speaking of colorful costumes, First Class has another important lesson that Fox should learn from themselves for the next FF movie...

3. Give Us A Team And A Movie That Looks And Feels New And Different

I can hear some uh-oh level rejection of this idea building from the dark side of the nerdforce. Now hold on a minute, before we go much further... I'm not suggesting that there should be a different roster with one or two of the "fill in members" like that time She Hulk replaced The Thing (although I think we can all agree that would make for an awesome movie). I want Fox to give us Johnny, Sue, Reed and Ben. I just want them to give us a different kind of Johnny, Sue, Reed and Ben than the ones we got in 2005 and 2007. Like it or hate it, one of the things Sony did right with The Amazing Spider-Man was to have a Peter Parker/Spidey who feels like a different version of the same character. If you look at Batman/Bruce Wayne in the Nolan Trilogy versus Bruce Wayne/Batman in the Burton movies, it doesn't really feel like the same character. Bale and Keaton present two very distinct and different approaches to answering the question of "who is Bruce Wayne". This is very much what we need from a Fantastic Four reboot. Ioan Gruffud was excellent as Reed Richards and watching Michael Chiklis as Ben Grimm felt like seeing the character come to life after stepping off of a page in a literal sense. I don't want to see two actors try to repeat those performances or give us the same chemistry that Chiklis and Gruffud had. I want a Reed Richards who feels like he's lived a different life that turned him into a different kind of man than the one from the previous films. I want each of the main characters to have a different way of interacting with each other. Instead of a Sue and Johnny Storm that argue like childish siblings, how about a pair that actually kind of hate each other and avoid talking for most of the movie? Or a Sue that takes pity on her loser little brother who will never amount to anything and a Johnny consume by a burning passion to get out from under the shadow of a scientific prodigy who's always been held over his head by the rest of the family? Instead of a put upon Reed having to deal with Johnny's screwball sense of humor, what if Dr. Richards secretly nurses a bitter envy of a guy who feels comfortable in his own skin and always seems confident? How about Ben Grimm thinking of Sue Storm as a surrogate sister and being worried that she's wasting her time with a cold hearted ass-hat who isn't capable of giving her the affection she deserves and would rather see her hook up with another guy even if it means stabbing one of his dearest friends in the back? But equally as important to the success of reboot is to have a different visual style. While I personally don't care for the look of the new Spidey flick, I am glad that it looks distinctively different. While some fans complain about recasting of characters in superhero flicks (like Rachel Dawes in Batman Begins and The Dark Knight) I love it. This is essentially the movie equivalent to the penciler trying something different with a character or a new penciler coming onto the comic book series. That visual metaphor is important to be taken to it's logical conclusion in a reboot, we need to feel like a different artist is drawing the new series in a drastically different style. The best success in the field thus far is X-Men First Class. It's miles beyond any other reboot, requel or preboot in having a different visual interpretation of the source material. That's of course largely due to having the film set in 1960's which is by the way, something that would greatly benefit an FF reboot. Remember what I said about doing a new origin only if it's worth telling? Well an origin that reclaims the cold war backdrop of the original comics would be brilliancy of a level on par with bringing the X-Men back to the civil rights era roots. The whole reason that the original movie replaces the experimental rocket flight with the space station angle is because it was set in the modern day mid-aughties (a.k.a. 00's) time frame. It wouldn't have made sense to have Reed and his pals steal a rocket to perform a daring test flight into space because that technology was already firmly handled at the dawn of the 21st century. More importantly, the motivation would not make any sense in the modern era because the idea of "gaining space dominance ahead of the commies" is bemusingly archaic. Doing a Fantastic Four movie set in the early sixties would be able to capture that feeling of urgency at out performing the Soviets and allow (even necessitate) a new visual style. While some people might complain "that would just be imitating First Class?" what if it could do more like...

2. Integrate The Franchise With X-Men

There's one major thing that's totally baffled me about the decisions of people at Fox regarding their movie properties. For the better part of a decade they've had control of film right for two of Marvels best teams and one of its best vigilantes. Why the hell haven't they taken advantage of this? Sure one could argue that Sony is in a similar position by owning the rights to Spider-Man and Ghost Rider, but that argument would be dead bang wrong. If you got some top shelf comics writers and screen play geniuses into a room and told them to come up with the best possible movie crossing over Spidey and Ghosty, at most you'd get maybe 5 or 6 great ideas. More likely you'd have 2 or 3 great ideas that could be made on a reasonable budget and not go over the heads of most popcorn audiences or movie executives. Give that same room of talent a 2nd assignment of "come up with the best ideas you can of crossing over at least 2 if not all 3 of the franchises for X-Men, Fantastic Four and Daredevil" 20 great ideas would be produced by the end of the first day and the team would be back in the morning to get started on the next 20. Dr. Doom teams up with Magneto. That one sentence can lend itself to at least 3 different great ideas. Don't believe me? An amoral exploration of Cold War politics.€ A socio-economic exploration of how the wealthy class exploits minorities and gets them to fight amongst themselves.€ Why are cults of personality a dangerous thing and what happens when you have two of them collide against each other?€ What is the appropriate response to allegations of a sovereign nation harboring known terrorist and how should a member nation of NATO and the UN handle the matter when super human powers are involved?€ A man obsessed with righting the wrongs of the world and satiating the burning desire for vengeance against racial oppression must confront the question of how far he's willing to go for his goals while a third world dictator must balance the needs of his people against the looming threat of globalization and the two men are thrown together into a power struggle against ways of the world.€Is the enemy of my enemy truly a potential friend? How far can friendship be trusted when there is no honor among thieves? Oh wait, that was more than three. See what I mean? Now as I said, Dr. Doom should be avoided for the reboot, so this would necessarily have to be an idea for a sequel. But while they're introducing the new setting and the latest iteration of the FF team, why not let the audience know "hey by the way, this takes place in the same world as X-Men First Class!" and just to really throw them off, reveal that in the middle of the movie, then hit them with a mid-cap or end-cap stinger that tells them "Hey, Dr. Doom is out there ready to throw down with Reed for FF2!"

1. Have A Long Term Game Plan For The Future

Okay, this last one might seem like a no-brainer but it's an important no-brainer. One of the biggest criticisms against The Amazing Spider-Man is the rumored rewrites during production that derailed some key storylines and a mid-credits stinger that seems like a "we'll decide what that means later" moment. Part of the reason x3 is considered to suck so bad is that it was derailed by Bryan Singer's decision to abandon ship for Superman 3.2 (a.k.a. Superman Returns). The awesome plans he had for the threequel set up in the closing moments of X2 were squandered when Matthew Vaughn came aboard with some new ideas and then jumped ship a few weeks before filming leaving Brett Ratner with very little time to wrap his head around the project. Vaughn and Singer redeemed themselves with First Class, but they'll still have to knock another out of the park in the follow up before they can truly be said to have gotten the franchise back on track (as opposed to making the one good X-Movie in the middle of a bunch of sucky ones). Josh Trank could end up making a stellar movie that makes everyone say "dude got the juice, he got the flavor" but if there's no plan for the follow up it could all go sour just like the X-Franchise did. While a lot of people get sick of the whole "trilogy format" thing, there's a reason that it's used so much, because it works. If Trank and Fox can come up with a 3 or 4 movie over arching plot that builds up to an epic conclusion then the film gods will have smiled on us all, but there's more important things to consider than just the big plot points. One of the best things about the FF is that anyone member of the team would be an interesting character if they were to carry their own movie, but becomes so much more when they're combined. With that in mind, each character should have a journey that they're taking separately in the emotional and psychological landscape of the actors motivation for the duration of the franchise. More importantly, each journey needs to be charted on one big map so it can be seen where those paths cross and break. Reed and Ben need to have a different kind of interpersonal relation to each other after two or three movies. Same for Johnny and Sue. There needs to be a further emotional path outlined for the whole team that incorporates all four individual paths but has its own overall flow and direction. This same set of dynamics applies to the villains and the supporting cast as well. The Marvel Movieverse and the Nolan Trilogy have changed the nature of the game to the point where it ain't the same game anymore. It's now crucial to lay the seeds in the first movie for plot points that won't become apparent or a big deal for two or three more movies. It's no longer a sensible approach to look at one set of super hero movies without asking "how will this affect that set of movies". So Fox and Trank should really be getting Singer and Vaughn in the room so that they can talk things over. As for Daredevil... I think Fox should cut their losses and let him go. The FF and The X-Men franchises are more than enough to keep their plates full.