Film Theory: Finding Nemo Doesn't Have A Happy Ending...

Marlon's going though the five stages of g-reef.

By Ashleigh Millman /

Pixar

With a backlog of animated movies that have entertainment generations the world over, Pixar has defined itself as a household name for heart-warming films for both the young and old. Bringing tales such as Toy Story, Monsters Inc, and more recently The Incredibles sequel into colourful existence, the studio is renowned for its whimsical touch that turns the everyday into something special. Finding Nemo is no different, delivering an adventure across the ocean in which a father clownfish, Marlin, attempts to reunite with his kidnapped son, Nemo.

Advertisement

Employing the help of forgetful blue tang Dory as well as plenty of other fishy comrades, on the surface, Finding Nemo seems like the usual Pixar fare: but if you take a dive deeper into the movie, a dark secret soon emerges from the depths.

Utilising a closer look at Marlin’s behaviour throughout the film serves to reveal that the adventure may not be all that it seems, at least for adult eyes. Much in the same way Up was absolutely heartbreaking and Inside Out hid a devastating portrayal of mental health in its rainbow animations; Finding Nemo can actually be read as an allegory for grief, with Marlin experiencing the five stages of it after losing his son (and all of his other children) in the initial barracuda attack.

Get ready to burn all your copies of the film and cry yourself to sleep, as this one will leave a gaping hole in your chest. Fish have feelings too, guys.

6. Nemo Doesn't Exist

Pixar

The very first sign that something’s amiss comes from Nemo’s name itself. Seemingly adopted from the famous Captain Nemo of Jules Verne’s novels, Nemo is actually translated from Latin to mean ‘no-one’, transforming the title of the movie into literally ‘Finding No-one’. It’s a strong case for Nemo being a figment of Marlin’s imagination, and if we apply the logic to the rest of the film, then other clues seem to take shape.

Watching the very opening of the film could be another case in point. As Marlin’s home is attacked by a rogue barracuda, his wife Coral sacrifices herself in an attempt to save their 400+ eggs, resulting in a stressed Marlin being knocked out in the conflict and waking up to the disappearance of everything he once loved.

When he explores the egg cave to see if there is anyone he can salvage from the attack, there’s a notable absence of just about anything. Everything is barren and tinged blue - reflective of his overwhelming grief. It’s only when he turns to look again does Marlin see that an egg has in fact survived; but did it really?

The bright orange egg, a tiny ray of hope in Marlin’s now-tattered life, is arguably a desperate bid at finding something worth living for. He wants to find something so much that he creates it in his own mind.

5. The Five Stages Of Grief

With this imaginary Nemo, however, comes some suspension of disbelief. Of course, Nemo interacts with other characters in the movie, so there’s an instant counter argument to the theory born from that alone.

Advertisement

It has to be believed that these conversations are sympathetic to the other inhabitants of the underwater town pitying Marlin and playing along, or simply, in the way of Fight Club or Black Swan, created in Marlin’s head to rationalise the situation. The theory is one that best lends itself as a lens to look at the film through - a certain duality of intent rather than a fixed provable ulterior narrative.

To begin then, Marlin’s own experience of the world around him is seen through five different steps as the film goes on, following the five stages of grief that have conjured this imaginary son for him to look after. These are as follows: 1. Denial, 2. Anger, 3. Bargaining, 4. Depression, and 5. Acceptance. Marlin has been suffering from this Denial since the barracuda attack, and continues to entrap himself within it by being constantly doubtful and protective of his son.

It’s only when seeing the other fish-children where he lives reach the age that Nemo should be attending school that Marlin’s mind begins to process the trauma he’s been through.

4. Anger And Bargaining

Anger is seen only in a small capacity, outlined in Marlin’s rage and subsequent argument with his son over him ‘touching the butt.’ In this scenario, Marlin is faced with the same open water he was originally so excited about moving next to with Coral, but now represents the deadly threats of the ocean that can come at any time. It’s important that Nemo disappears from this place as it’s the same one that saw the death of Marlin’s entire family - this is his realisation that Nemo hasn’t been there all along as he vanishes from sight when revisiting the drop off.

Advertisement

Bargaining is arguably the largest form of the film, in which Marlin desperately attempts to bring his son back in any capacity possible. Employing the help of Dory is the ultimate sacrifice to his mental state, continuously faced with having to explain his situation to someone that then instantly forgets. It’s a futile attempt at convincing himself his son is real and attainable, a representation of losing a loved one and the fear that comes with it of ever forgetting them. Her short term memory is his worst fear: forgetting his son, wife, and other eggs existed at all.

Repeatedly whilst searching for Nemo, Marlin is told to forget about him, that he hasn’t been seen, and to move on: all advice (albeit very bad advice) from those attempting to work him through the insurmountable grief the fish is going through.

3. Depression

Moving through to depression, there’s no clearer scene for Marlin’s intrinsic sadness than when he’s finally confronted with Nemo’s dead body - even if for narrative purposes, Nemo was faking at the time. At the dentist when planning his escape, Nemo acts as if unconscious so as not to be taken by the dentist’s niece, and gets flushed in the process.

Advertisement

It’s interesting that the first encounter Marlin has with his son after his disappearance is that of seeing him dead, a brief moment of lucidity that shocks him into true sadness. Marlin’s outward appearance is clearly that of a man suffering even before this moment though - he’s as tired looking as a fish can get and thoroughly melancholic, the only thing driving him is potentially seeing his son once more - and it results in the ultimate break when he is confronted with the truth of his death.

Marlin’s acceptance then goes through two stages. One, where his son is dead and he chooses to leave Dory, allowing her to forget and in turn, symbolise his own moving on from Nemo’s death - and two, where Nemo returns and Marlin is reunited with his son.

2. Acceptance

This reuniting comes when the fish are then captured in a heavy fishing net, being pulled to the surface. Marlin’s reality is breaking at seeing his son physically once more after moving through the stages of grief that he had conquered, and it’s enough for acceptance to then transform from a healthy realisation, into an acceptance of his own fragmented belief in Nemo’s life: this is the only way he gets to be with him in some form.

Advertisement

There’s something to be said of them being pulled to the surface in the net as if to heaven also, perhaps Marlin travelling out on his own at the end of his depressive stage resulted in his own death, and seeing Nemo again is something of a representation of the two uniting in heaven. They’re surrounded by identical, grey fish - perhaps the slog of souls also on their journey to to the same place. It would explain the incredibly happy ending and the change in Marlin's personality to then allow Nemo out adventuring: they've both made the ultimate sacrifice to now be together.

Far fetched, yes, but they do travel to the land Down Under… maybe one and the same with the underworld where Marlin decides life isn’t worth it if he can’t be with his son. Of course, this then opens a whole new can of worms in why Coral isn't there, and would point to her disappearing after the barracuda attack as something of a choice rather than her own death. Let's leave that for next time, though.

1. Other Very Important Scientific Musings

As a final tangential thought, if we’re looking at the real science behind our aquarium pals, there's a flaw that becomes clear. Pixar put a lot of effort into creating exact fish replicas for their film, going so far as to have biology lessons for all their employees to learn the precise fin strokes for animation. Coral's defensive reaction for her children is the natural reaction of the species and gender of Clownfish... but there's one thing missing from this entirely accurate exercise in scientific fish animation.

Advertisement

Clownfish in nature live in large groups, populated by an abundance of males and one alpha female. This alpha female mates with all the others in the group to keep the clownfish uprising going strong - and if anything were to happen to her, a male would change his hormones and take over the role of getting some.

That’s right, clownfish are hermaphrodites by nature, and adapt to the environments they inhabit. This means as soon as Coral passes away after the attack, Marlin would become a woman to keep the clownfish balance going strong.

Finding Nemo can still be read as a father overcoming the loss of his wife and son, but if we’re being accurate, he’d be Nemo’s mother by the end of the film. Not that it changes anything really, but it’s something to think about whilst you’re weeping into your pillow later. You’re welcome.

Advertisement