Finding Dory Review: 7 Ups And 3 Downs

Mother of mercy, the FEELS.

By Simon Gallagher /

Pixar

Finding Dory shouldn't have worked at all. It's 12 years since the first film, the story robs the original of one it's most subtly complex moments, and there was a distinct whiff of Minionitis about it. But damnit if Pixar haven't done it again.

Advertisement

The film is a richly coloured, complex and emotional joy, which might not break the mould in story terms but manages to trade exceptionally well on all of the things that made the original so popular. It's not quite up to the standards of Toy Story 3, but there's not another Pixar sequel that can outstrip it or its commitment to advancing the story, building on established chemisty and successfully introducing new characters.

There are a couple of slight distractions, inevitably, but nothing is enough to draw away from a definite, solid 4 star rating, and it is undoubtedly a film that deserves to be seen as widely as the original. Here's exactly why you should go and see Pixar's latest, with a couple of footnotes of concern bolted on for good measure.

Advertisement

First, to the positives...

7. Hank

Pixar

Ed O'Neill's crotchety octopus (well, septipus as Dory so elegantly points out) is easily the most substantial and the most successful of the sequels new characters. He has a defined arc thanks to his initial desire to be left alone and not have to face life in the open ocean again and the subsequent revelation. And he's exceptionally entertaining, with great chemistry with Dory herself.

Advertisement

O'Neill's performance isn't exactly a challenge for him: his two most defining characters in his career (on Modern Family and Married With Children) are both spiritual siblings to Hank and the experience shows. He might be grumpy and occasionally quick to anger, but he's also emotionally vulnerable and wounded by something not quite explicated until the great Touching Pool sequence.

6. The Visuals

Pixar

When Finding Nemo came out, it marked a watershed moment for Pixar: it was a beautifully crafted canvas, almost photo-realistic in a way that its predecessors weren't and it looked and felt very much like a labour of love.

Advertisement

With years of technological progress since then, there was always a danger that Finding Dory could have been - pardon the pun - an exercise in treading water. Or at least that it could have been perceived that way because the audience is so used to being wowed by Pixar's visuals. But it goes way beyond that.

In fact the best thing to be said about Dory's environment is that it doesn't actually feel like just an expression of technological advancement. It's not showy in a manipulative way, but the underwater worlds have more depth and more complexity and there are shots in there that look like paintings (again). And beyond even the beauty there's an eery, unnerving quality that suits the moments of darkness and actual terror (and make no mistake there are some).

Advertisement

5. The Truck Stunt

Pixar

As much as Pixar are masters of crafting an expanded, linked universe full of rich characters, meta-references and rich environments, it's often the moments and set-pieces that are the most memorable. Finding Nemo actually didn't have many of those sharp punctuations, but in the glorious, hilariously funny truck sequence.

Advertisement

The idea of Hank driving while Dory navigates from a glass on the dash is funny enough, but the slow-motion jump through the air to the sound of Louis Armstrong's doleful "Wonderful World" is worthy of being considered a crown jewel in the entire Pixar catalogue.

4. It Doesn't Try Too Hard To Reinvent The Wheel

Pixar

A lot of people are going to complain about the fact that Finding Dory is basically a redone Finding Nemo with some new elements added, and while that is somewhat reductive (see the other side of this list), it is in no way fatal because of what we get in place of innovation at times.

Advertisement

Pixar ingeniously use a new framing device - of flashbacks to Dory's devastating formative years as it's discovered how she ends up being lost - to give us an insight into what it's like living from her perspective. We get more of her tagi-comic act, more of her disarming charm and more of the easy chemistry Ellen Degeneres' performance brings.

And in wider terms, the universality of the themes being explored - particularly the nagging, harrowing fear of abandonment that looms over the film like a pitch black squall - and the redemptive power of love and family are worth exploring again. Plus, if character models work, there's no sense in reinventing them too much is there?

Advertisement

It's not like sequels that port the established characters into a weird, unfamiliar environment and an alien experience ever work, is it?

3. Piper

Pixar

If Pixar's run of form in their mainline films is pretty damn impressive, the consistency they bring to the shorts that precede them is absolutely stunning. These little preludes to the main event are heavily invested in emotion, despite the time to develop broad ideas, they're visually stunning, despite the lack of time for immersion and they have just as wonderfully painted characters (even when they don't speak).

Advertisement

And Piper - the story of a little sandpiper bird learning to live and fend for itself - is another successful swing for the fence. The story is simple, the animation beautiful and the character itself is hilarious, adorable and dripping with charm.

The film also explores some of the same themes as Finding Nemo and Dory: the fear of growing up, the dangers of the outside world and the ultimate conquering of both. And it's literally about a bird eating molluscs on a beach. It's like bloody sorcery.

Advertisement

2. The Reunion

Pixar

When Dory and her parents are finally reunited (it's a little conceited, but let's allow it because it's gorgeous), it's one of Pixar's most loaded emotional sequences.

Advertisement

I kid you not, never has a cinema screen got so dusty so quickly since the "daddy, my daddy" bit in The Railway Children. It's literally as powerful as that.

It's contrived that such a happy ending could happen, but the way it's framed and captured, and the way it ends Dory's arc that we see through the flashbacks is perfectly played.

Advertisement

1. Baby Dory

Pixar

If you're a future Pixar film-maker (or even an old one), and you have an agenda to create the cutest character ever seen in the studio's catalogue just give up trying now. Baby Dory is the pinnacle in Pixar's adorable achievements, making Baby Nemo look like a bedraggled od hobo by comparison.

Advertisement

Through her eyes we see fear, the devastating reality of loneliness, redemption and sorrow, and it's as shocking to see such a seemingly manipulatively designed character land so many complex blows.

But then that's the story of the entire film: where else would you get such hilarity and such a rich story and broad spectrum of emotions alongside subtle body positivity messages that normalise disabilities (something Finding Nemo was praised for more than a decade ago)? It's a stunning achievement, really.

Advertisement

Special mention must also go to Becky the idiot duck and Gerald the idiot sea lion, both of whom prove that idiots are easy to love.

And now on to the less positive distractions...

Advertisement

3. It's Just A Little Too Familiar

Pixar

Despite the success of the brand, it's a little frustrating that we didn't get a little more innovation. At times Dory feels a little like it's been made by a focus group who openly loved the first movie. Yes, all of the bits that we loved about the first one: heart, adventurous set-pieces, colourful characters and familial exploration and identity are there, but beyond that, there's nothing particularly new.

Advertisement

Marlin is replaced by Hank, Dory is Nemo, the dentist's office is the Institute and the band of characters who help them get to their reunion are transferred characters. Perhaps it's a conscious attempt to comment on Dory's own mental condition (in which case, kudos), but even something slightly braver like killing off one of Dory's parents (or both, if you want to destroy the entire audience) would have added a whole new dynamic.

After all, Toy Story 3 was forced to deal with the biggest issue that haunted the other two - the permanent loss of Andy - and it soared because of it. Perhaps Dory just needed the added boost of a more difficult ending?

Advertisement

2. The Extrafication Of The Other Stars

Pixar

It's probably right that Nemo and Marlin are brought back for the film, but they're largely unimportant as anything other than narrative devices. And brief ones at that: it's a shame, but if you removed them from 80% of the film, the plot simply wouldn't change (since other minor characters could fill their roles in the various set-pieces later on).

Advertisement

The pair are just sort of there, bickering about Marlin's cynicism and enabling more interesting things and characters to happen, like Becky and the sea lions. It's inevitable, of course, because this is Dory's film, but it's so noticeable that it actually ends up being pretty distracting.

1. Marlin Has Not Progressed At All

Pixar

It's the most annoying thing in the world when a major character forgets the single most important lesson they learned between one film and its sequel. It's basically Ghostbusters 2 syndrome: where something irrevocable happens, characters change and learn and grow and then they come back for the sequel and nobody remembers the giant ghost they overcame and the universe resets.

Advertisement

Marlin is the big issue in Finding Dory. Having learned that being an over-bearing father and a bit of a grumpy prick (a role Albert Brooks still performs masterfully) is terrible in the first film, he's now reset to being exactly that. He's fathering Dory just as much as he is Nemo, and it feels like a betrayal of his journey and of the sympathy he earned through it in the first film.

Did you love Finding Dory? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.

Advertisement