First Man Review: 8 Ups & 2 Downs
A blistering biopic for the ages.
Damien Chazelle's Neil Armstrong biopic First Man is out now in cinemas, and as won't shock anybody, the Ryan Gosling-starring drama is one of the best films of the year so far.
At once a tenaciously directed tribute to man's mission to the Moon and an extremely engaging study of Armstrong himself, the movie also ticks pretty much every box a film needs for Oscar recognition.
Critics have been tripping over themselves to praise the film ever since its Venice Film Festival premiere, and while it might prove a little too slow and lacking in broad melodrama for some audiences, it's filmmaking at an incredibly high level regardless, with wonderful performances in the bargain.
There's still so much of the Oscar race to be fought out, but First Man should certainly be considered a significant threat in most of the major categories, even if it's not quite a card-carrying crowd-pleaser on the level of, say, A Star is Born...
Downs...
2. Too. Much. Shaky Cam.
The vast majority of Linus Sandgren's cinematography throughout the movie is handheld, and though this does lend the film an extremely intimate quality, it also sometimes goes a little overboard.
It's certainly appropriate that the expertly-staged space shuttle sequences feature lots of shaking, but it becomes more of a problem when basic dialogue set-ups have the camera violently swinging all over the place.
It proves a little distracting during some of the movie's more meaningful dialogues between Armstrong (Gosling) and his wife Janet (Foy) in particular, and clearly a little more restraint here would've gone a long way.
1. It's A Little Slow In Places
Chazelle is clearly in no rush to tell his story, and for the most part that's a good thing, though it does also result in a few stretches where things feel like they could be tightened up somewhat.
After all, First Man is a meaty 141 minutes long, and considering the majority of the film revolves around the build-up to the Apollo 11 flight, there are definitely a few beats that feel a little over-stretched and repetitive.
It's a minor quibble considering the epic, operatic sweep of the entire movie, but it doesn't feel quite as tightly edited as Chazelle's punchier prior two movies.
And now, here are the many, many things the movie gets so very right...
Ups...
8. Ryan Gosling & Claire Foy's Phenomenal Performances
To the surprise of nobody, Ryan Gosling and Claire Foy give fantastic performances here.
Gosling in particular has a tricky role to play given that Armstrong was a famously cold and stoic man in real life, and the actor manages to convey that without making him seem flat or one-note. During the personal and professional turmoil throughout the film, Gosling gives a wonderfully understated performance that should net him an Oscar nod next year.
Claire Foy's role could easily have fallen into doting wife stereotypes, but that's promptly blown away by one magnificent scene in which Janet tells Neil to speak to his two sons about the possibility of him never returning home on the eve of his mission.
She spends a good deal of the third act off-screen as is a necessity, but Foy's compassionate work makes her an easy front-runner for the Best Supporting Actress Oscar as of now.
7. The Incredible Space Sequences Are Jaw-Dropping & Terrifying
The several spaceflight missions in this film are absolutely phenomenal, and it's really quite incredible what Damien Chazelle has achieved on a mere $59 million budget.
Most of the talk surrounding the movie will surely focus on the eye-popping, blisteringly intense Apollo 11 mission itself, and rightly so. The prolonged landing sequence blends seamless visual effects with mostly practical, in-camera work and incredible music to become one of the year's most visceral set-pieces despite the outcome being known.
What's perhaps most impressive of all is that these scenes manage to serve as a tribute to the ingenuity of humanity reaching space while also surrendering the utter, bone-rattling terror that such a mission entails. If you do head out to see this movie, look for the biggest screen you can find it playing on.
6. It's Surprisingly Emotional
Though the awe of the Moon landing is a quasi-spiritual experience in of itself, the story of Armstrong's arc throughout the movie is surprisingly affecting despite the man's obviously guarded personality.
It'd be crass to call the death of Armstrong's daughter in the movie's first 10 minutes a spoiler, but it's a heart-rending, scarcely lingered-on sequence which quietly informs the rest of the movie, paying off with a devastating, heartfelt gesture in the final minutes of the film.
That's not to forget the many engineers whose lives are lost over the course of the preparations for Apollo 11, clearly creating a huge emotional burden for Armstrong, albeit one he tries to conceal as much as possible.
Simply, don't be too surprised if you're wiping tears away by the time the end credits roll.
5. Justin Hurwitz's Oscar-Worthy Score
Justin Hurwitz has now provided the musical score for all four of Chazelle's movies, and after scooping Best Original Score and Best Original Song Oscars for La La Land, he should probably clear his mantle for the possibility that First Man will net him a third gold statue.
Hurwitz's score in this movie is nothing short of sublime, melding electronic and orchestral elements together in a manner reminiscent of Hans Zimmer, to the extent that aspects of the score will surely earn comparisons to Zimmer's for Interstellar.
The score's stand-out track is unquestionably "The Landing", a slow-building piece which lends the Moon landing sequence tremendous visceral weight, not dissimilar from how "No Time for Caution" is used in Interstellar's docking sequence.
Though Oscar season is really only just beginning, a mighty contender would be needed to knock Hurwitz off his perch, because this is God-tier composing right here.
4. It's Got One Of The Year's Best Ensemble Casts
As splendid as Gosling and Foy are, they're propped up at all times by one of the most mind-bogglingly stacked ensemble casts of not just this year, but any year.
Especially memorable are Jason Clarke as astronaut Ed White, the ever-reliable Kyle Chandler as NASA official Deke Slayton and Corey Stoll as a famously douchey Buzz Aldrin, though there are many more great bit-parts in the film.
In fact, it's a ton of fun spotting a new famous face pop up every few minutes, with the likes of Pablo Schreiber, Christopher Abbott, Patrick Fugit, Lukas Haas, Shea Whigham, CiarĂ¡n Hinds and others filling out the stellar cast.
Everyone hits their markers and gives it their all, ensuring that even the most stern and talky scene has plenty to savour.
3. Damien Chazelle's Masterful Direction
First Man represents yet another bold leap forward for Damien Chazelle, who at the mere age of 33 has released his third near-universally acclaimed major movie, and one that's sure to court awards as aggressively as both Whiplash and La La Land.
La La Land was an incredibly ambitious film as musicals go, but First Man is clearly on a whole other level, despite keeping its budget sensibly quite low (only costing double La La Land's $30 million price tag).
The peerless staging of the space sequences is one thing, but Chazelle does a marvellous job provoking a wide gamut of feelings from the viewer, making this a proud tribute to NASA's achievement and also an engrossing character study and family drama.
It's not easy to keep all these plates spinning at once, but yet again, Chazelle makes it look so damn easy.
2. The Gritty, Stunning Cinematography
Bar those aforementioned shaky cam annoyances, cinematographer Linus Sandgren - who won an Oscar for La La Land - does a splendid job rooting Chazelle's film in its period.
While many films opt to evoke the period feel by digitally adding garish grain effects in post-production, First Man's vintage look and feel was achieved in-camera, and if not for the presence of contemporary actors, it'd be easy to believe the movie was genuinely shot decades ago.
It would've also been easy for the state-of-the-art visual effects to clash harshly with the gritty cinematography, yet ultimately they're meticulously integrated into the staggeringly consistent aesthetic.
1. The Excellent Sound Design
And finally, it'd be remiss not to mention First Man's absolutely spectacular sound design, which has been a first-rate aspect of all three of Chazelle's Hollywood movies.
Though not as music-centric as either Whiplash or La La Land, the film places a great emphasis on the most subtle and minute sounds during the space sequences.
The sound of metal casually straining produces an enormous amount of tension, and adds tremendously to the already palpable feeling that we're locked inside the cockpit with Armstrong and co.
There's no way the movie isn't nominated for Sound Mixing and Sound Editing Oscars next year - it's a space movie, after all - with Chazelle smartly retaining most of his sound team from La La Land.
If it wins either or both Oscars, it'll certainly be well-earned, because the diversity of the effects and how they're all tied together, especially during the climactic Moon landing scene, is nothing short of exemplary.
What did you think of First Man? Shout it out in the comments!