Frozen 2 Review: 5 Ups & 5 Downs

A middling - if gorgeous - sequel.

By Jack Pooley /

Disney

Frozen 2 is finally now in cinemas worldwide, and no matter what critics think of it, it's sure to dazzle its young core demographic and ignite the box office.

Advertisement

Reviews have skewed broadly positive for the film so far, deeming it a mostly worthy sequel to the hit 2013 Disney animation, even if it doesn't get close to topping or even really matching what came before.

Indeed, Frozen 2 is a totally fine animated sequel, but given the potential for it to expand the lore and deepen the emotional canvas for these characters, it ultimately just feels a bit...standard.

Advertisement

Again, the hardcore crowd will still find plenty here to enjoy, but if you're a more casual fan of the original film, don't expect to be bowled over by a superior, improved sequel.

This is effectively a decently-executed money-spinning follow-up made more for financial concerns than because the filmmakers actually had an interesting story to tell.

Advertisement

As such, despite its technical proficiency, its heart doesn't always feel in the right place, and the result is an end product that resembles an oddly pedestrian, garden variety Disney sequel...

Downs...

5. The Messy, Convoluted Script

Disney

By far the most problematic element of Frozen 2 is its script, with returning screenwriter-director Jennifer Lee clearly struggling to live up to the enormous hype following the first film's meteoric success.

Advertisement

Despite the marketing suggesting a sequel which would expand this world in imaginative and emotionally gratifying ways, the film as a whole is propelled forward by overly expository dialogue and convoluted storytelling that allows events to unfold just a little too neatly.

Furthermore, a number of the big, grandstanding reveals are so obvious (to adult viewers, at least) that they're robbed of much of their power. Again, a problem with ladling out so much of the plot through ham-fisted, tell-us-a-story dialogue.

Advertisement

The decision to separate many of the principal characters into their own distinct subplots for so much of the movie also feels like a big mistake, not to mention the fact that some of these subplots - especially Kristoff's (Jonathan Groff) - aren't particularly fresh or interesting.

Compared to the charming simplicity of the first film, Frozen 2 aims for greater complexity but just ends up feeling like a more manufactured and contrived tale, and one which may leave fans more bemused than dazzled.

Advertisement

4. The Total Lack Of Stakes

Disney

One of the most surprising - perhaps even subversive - aspects of Frozen 2 is that it doesn't really have a villain in the traditional Disney antagonist sense.

Advertisement

And while that's an intriguingly bold idea on paper, Lee's script forgets to include anything approaching real, palpable conflict or stakes in its stead.

Yes, this is a family-friendly animation, where everyone's probably going to be safe and sound by the end, but even so, it makes such little effort to convince the audience of any real sense of danger or turmoil.

Advertisement

There are several drawn-out sequences where major characters are placed in apparently mortal peril, but because we know nothing will likely come of it, it just comes across as hollow and insincere.

There are clearly a few characters who could've been left imperiled for the inevitable Frozen 3, but instead, everything's sewn up pretty neatly by film's end, lending it an oddly episodic, inconsequential feel.

Advertisement

This is admittedly a problem across many Disney properties - namely the MCU and Star Wars, also - but at least those franchises have the good sense to give the heroes a palpable force to face off against.

3. It's Too Fast Paced For Its Own Good

Disney

This movie moves fast, and while Frozen 2 was never going to be a methodical slog, would it have killed the filmmakers to let scenes breathe just a little longer?

Advertisement

The film's pacing is breathless to the point of frustration, where the expected journey element of a classic Disney adventure is mostly left on the cutting room floor.

Characters quickly move to wherever they need to go to the point that it deflates the epic scope the film is clearly aiming for: where is the sense that these characters have truly travelled?

Advertisement

It too often feels like the characters are simply being shuttled from one location to the next in order to set up the next song, and Frozen 2's frantic ending would've especially benefited from an extra 5-or-so minutes to resonate a little deeper.

2. The Underwhelming New Characters

Disney

Though the marketing teased a cast of compelling new characters, it has to be said that they mostly feel crushingly underdeveloped and, therefore, nowhere near as interesting as they could've been.

Advertisement

Disappointingly, only a scant amount of screen time is lent to the most significant new characters, Yelana (Martha Plimpton), the leader of the Northuldra tribe, and Lt. Mattias (Sterling K. Brown), a soldier trapped in the enchanted forest.

Their screen time typically consists of simply moving the plot forward with exposition, and we learn precious little of their actual personalities, which might've endeared them better to viewers.

Advertisement

Elsewhere, the additional Northuldra warriors just feel like filler characters, and most are unlikely to even remember their names by the end of the movie.

1. It's A Disappointingly Forgettable Sequel

Disney

All things considered, Frozen 2 just doesn't really feel like the caliber sequel fans would understandably be expecting after a six-year wait.

Advertisement

It certainly has its moments and is never less than totally watchable, but outside of the show-stopping songs, it just feels like your average, ho-hum Disney sequel created without much inspiration or imagination.

Given the solid foundation laid by the first film, the sequel had enormous potential to do so much more with the concept, and ultimately, most of the creative fan theories that did the rounds ahead of the movie's release are far more interesting than what we ended up with.

Advertisement

It does the job, but is that really enough?

However, if Frozen 2 isn't the for-the-ages sequel most were hoping for, it's certainly an artful animation with some outstanding elements. Here's what it got right...

Advertisement

Ups...

5. The Terrific Songs

Disney

After Frozen's marquee tune "Let It Go" became a pop-culture phenomenon, in addition to winning an Oscar and a Grammy, the sequel was always going to have a tough time living up to the same epic pomp.

Advertisement

But impressively, despite not quite matching the majesty of the original's signature track, Frozen 2 does deliver a number of terrific songs, and two which actually get surprisingly close to Let It Go's catchy thrall.

The spectacular "Into the Unknown" has been touted as Frozen 2's title track, though "Show Yourself" is arguably the film's real winner, a brilliantly bombastic climax which gives Idina Menzel and Evan Rachel Wood a soaring opportunity to riff off one another.

Advertisement

Elsewhere, "Lost in the Woods" is an hilarious 90s power ballad throwback starring Kristoff, and Anna's (Kristen Bell) "The Next Right Thing" is a shockingly affecting song about depression and loss.

You could certainly argue that Frozen 2 boasts a greater variety of memorable songs, even if those unreasonably hoping for a Let It Go-killer might feel ever-so-slightly deflated. The songs certainly deliver, though.

Advertisement

4. The Darker, More Mature Tone

Disney

Despite the aforementioned stakes issues, Frozen 2 deserves credit for taking a less fanciful and more mature, grounded approach to its story and characters.

Advertisement

The film dabbles with some genuinely dark themes, and death is frequently on the lips of all the movie's characters, even Olaf (Josh Gad), such that it's disappointing the actual spine of the story didn't reflect this more grown-up approach.

Nobody was asking for Frozen 2 to be a gritty, grimdark sequel, but the starker mood feels like an appropriate expansion of the first film's tone, accentuated by some of the more poignant and relatable songs.

Advertisement

And on the lighter side of mature, there are also a few hilariously demented adult one-liners that'll fly clean over the heads of any kids watching, thankfully.

3. It's Beautifully Animated

Disney

Unsurprisingly, Frozen 2 is an eye-wateringly beautiful movie, and without question one of the year's most visually stunning films, animated or otherwise.

Advertisement

If you've rewatched the original Frozen lately, it becomes clear just how far animation has come in even just six years, for Frozen 2's characters look so much more expressive, and its lush, vast environments even more majestic.

But the various musical sequences is where the animation truly shines, allowing the filmmakers to make the most of Frozen's fantastical themes and aesthetic, especially during the jaw-droppingly beautiful show-piece for Show Yourself.

Advertisement

While Frozen 2 for the most part isn't an improvement over its predecessor, the more ambitious and artful visuals most certainly are.

2. Olaf Steals The Show

Disney

It's fair to say that hyperactive magical snowman Olaf was a divisive character in the first movie: kids loved him, of course, but many adults found him more obnoxiously irritating than charming.

Advertisement

Thankfully Frozen 2 streamlines the more objectionable aspects of Olaf's personality and, in turn, makes him the movie's most purely entertaining character.

From some clever sight gags involving his malleable snowman form, to the fact that Olaf spends most of the movie suffering through an existential crisis, the character is given a far meatier role this time around, yet never in a way that feels cynical or driven by merchandising concerns.

Advertisement

If you hated Olaf the first time around, Frozen 2 probably won't change your mind completely, but you might be pleasantly surprised by how tolerable, even likable, he is here.

1. The Remarkable Voice Acting

Disney

Much like the original, Frozen 2's voice cast is absolutely exemplary, be it during the many operatic tunes or the more conventional scripted story itself.

Advertisement

Idina Menzel and Kristen Bell are the obvious standouts as Elsa and Anna, though with Olaf's expanded role, Josh Gad confirms just how expertly cast he is in the part, and Jonathan Groff again makes for an effortlessly endearing Kristoff.

The entire ensemble kills it, even with some of the peripheral supporting roles proving disappointingly piecemeal, and like the first film, it's clear that the production was more concerned with finding the right actors, as opposed to stars, to fill the parts.

Advertisement

It's a shame the cast doesn't have stronger material to work with, sure, but they can't shoulder any of the blame whatsoever, because their work is uniformly terrific throughout.