So it looks like Gambit is getting a spin-off movie. The card-flinging, Cajun-speaking, New Orleans-born pick-up-artist has been one of the most divisive and inexplicably popular members of the X-Men introduced during the comics' resurgence in the early nineties, appearing in the phenomenally popular animated series and countless video games and action figures guises. He already making a big screen appearance, too, played by Taylor Kitsch in X-Men Origins: Wolverine (generally considered to be the nadir of the franchise in all respects). Well, presumably thanks to all those time travelling reboots in Days Of Future Past, Kitsch is out and Channing Tatum has been cast as Remy LeBeau, due to debut in the next X-Film proper, Apocalypse, before getting his own solo flick. Which is pretty brave, considering how terrible his last appearance in a solo X-Men film was, and rather daring for a series that has only just gotten back on track after a bunch of painfully mediocre-to-awful entries. Tatum's a great actor, the character has potential, but Fox have definitely mucked up worse before with better raw materials. What's to stop them making the same mistake thrice? Here are the ten lessons the Gambit movie has to learn from previous X-Men movie failures.
10. Play To The Actor's Strengths
James Marsden is a fine actor. He's shown his range through roles both comedic (Sex Drive, Death At A Funeral) and dramatic (Robot & Frank, Bachelorette). Similarly, Halle Berry managed to get an Oscar for her performance in Monster's Ball, and Famke Janssen was a deliciously demented bad guy in Goldeneye. Yet none of these totally great actors got a chance to show off their chops in the X-Men films, were each was totally miscast in the totally bland roles of Cyclops, Storm and Jean Grey, respectively. Honestly, not much could've been done for the wet blanket Scott Summers was written as in the script, but it also didn't help much that nobody suited their role in the original X-Men films as much as Hugh Jackman. And maybe Anna Paquin. Rather than being slavishly devoted to their comic book characterisations, the filmmakers should've played to the stars' strengths - similarly, hopefully Channing Tatum's Gambit will be an interesting, funny, charming character, rather than a one-dimensional slimeball with a silly accent.
9. No Political Subtext
The political parallels between mutants and various oppressed real-life groups have been somewhat overstated, in both the comics and X-Men movies. For one thing, it's a little offensive to draw parallels to things like the Civil Rights movement and the struggle of queer people in modern America with duelling opinions of Professor X and Magneto, since they're two crusty old white dudes who wield phenomenal power. It's also started to getting a little tired, despite fun new twists like Days Of Future Past taking the comparison to the Nixon administration. It's getting tired, and it really doesn't suit Gambit as a character. Remy LeBeau is not a character who is designed to carry any sort of heavy political subtext, or really a whole lot of dramatic weight at all: he's a more fancy free, consequences-be-damned sort, owing to his early life as a professional thief and con man. A Gambit film should be more like a caper flick, or else a big silly action film, with everybody being witty and charming and nobody pointing out the similarities with what Martin Luther King, Jr went through.
8. A Proper Costume
What would you prefer? Yellow spandex? Yes, actually, to be honest. Hollywood often struggles with putting a superhero costume on screen and having it not look stupid since, well, people running around in colourful costumes just looks inherently goofy. That's why all these real-life superhero types engender ridicule rather than respect. Not that the outfits of the movie X-Men have been a whole lot better, going down the utilitarian/S&M black leather route of The Matrix. It's just as naff and nonsensical. But that's not a patch on the sort of stuff Gambit wears in the comics. His get up in X-Men Origins: Wolverine wasn't great, but at least those were clothes you could imagine somebody wearing in real life. Not a good person, or a person with any sense of style but, well, compared to the comics, it was the height of fashion. Since his introduction in the nineties Gambit's rarely been seen without his costume which couldn't be more nineties if it was comprised solely of belts and pouches: trench coat, weird neon pink armoured top and blue breastplate, and that weird headpiece like somebody cut the face out a ski mask. Get Tatum something proper to wear.
7. Good Special Effects
The quality of the visual effects in the X-Men films has varied - which is more of a big deal in an X-Men film than any other, really, because whether or not you buy the mutants and their superheroic abilities hinges on whether or not said powers look realistic. The original movie did a pretty good job with Cyclops's optic blasts, Storm's weather powers, and in making Magneto's mastery of metal looking a bit more impressive than a Uri Gellar trick on steroids. X-Men Origins: Wolverine, meanwhile, had CGI claws. Which looked about as good as you'd expect. Gambit's powers a little more subtle, but that just means all the more work for the visual effects boffins. He showed off that skill set a little in the first Wolverine spin-off - the ability to infuse objects with kinetic energy, which usually amounts to him chucking exploding playing cards at people - and it certainly wasn't as bad as the claws, but nor did it make his powers seem impressive enough for him to be anything but a bit part in a larger ensemble. Something more impressive for Gambit's big solo debut please!
6. A Real Supporting Cast
Part of what makes the X-Men films work so well is that they have a rich ensemble cast, with multiple different personalities clashing and a character that appeals to every kind of audience member. Cyclops is stoic and by-the-book, Wolverine is rebellious, Jean Grey a little uptight, Storm immensely powerful but centred, Magneto not wholly evil, all that good stuff. The Wolverine films, too, benefited from pretty decent supporting casts. Or at least they were on paper, before Deadpool got silenced and Will.i.am got cast. The second Wolverine film fared a little better, but still fell back on some fairly cliché stock character archetypes when bringing the likes of Silver Samurai and Mariko to the big screen. Gambit isn't blessed with a particularly memorable supporting cast in his few solo comic book series, so it's likely those teaming up with him in his solo film will be original creations: just make them a bit more well-rounded than The Blob or whoever all those killed off in First Class were, eh?
5. Create Decent Villains
Another thing that Gambit will struggle with is in crafting a decent antagonist. After they realised they couldn't just use Ian McKellen's peerless Magneto in every film, the makers of the X-Men movies struggled to fill that vacuum, usually plumping for some new crackpot scientist working on a "cure" for the mutant population, or else casting yet another person as William Stryker. Or else they went for Sabertooth, which nobody really bought, least of all because noted character actor Liev Schrieber doesn't have a whole lot in common with noted WCW wrestler Tyler Mane. Again, Gambit doesn't have a proper nemesis in the comics - or at least not one anybody cares about. Nobody needs to see Mr Sinister on the big screen any time soon. Or ever. So much like the potential supporting cast that will be appearing alongside Remy in his solo film, it's likely that the villains will have to be new creations too. Ones that don't lean on the political subtext, aren't Magneto, and aren't William Stryker being played by yet another actor. Perhaps somebody from his criminal past back for revenge? Otherwise, Ego The Living Planet.
4. Don't Lean On The Comics Too Much
Really, the one big lesson that should be coming through here is that the Gambit film shouldn't be too beholden to its source material. Remy LeBeau has starred in a few solo titles and stories over the years, but they haven't been much to write home about; nor are they the sort of thing that could sustain a feature length motion picture. But they should also stop caring about the comics so much because the previous X-Men films have been severely hampered by their devotion to them. While Days Of Future Past played fast and loose with the particulars of the classic comic storyline of the same name, part of what made the third film in the series - The Last Stand - such an ungainly mess was that it tried too hard to jam as much of the comic onto the screen. It just didn't work. The films are there own thing. Same with The Wolverine trying to adapt the Chris Claremont/Frank Miller eighties miniseries, and failing spectacularly, making some sort of mediocre Frankenstein monster of comic and movie. Just let it be its own thing.
3. Be Light On Continuity
Similarly, the X-Men films need to stop caring about continuity so much. Not in the same way that X-Men Origins: Wolverine was just gleefully ignorant of everything that happened before and after it, recasting characters and mucking up the established timeline like it was going out of style, but not being quite as obsessed with making everything work as a cohesive fictional universe as Days Of Future Past was. That film was a lot of fun, but it was also a ninety minute reboot happening in real time. We're past that now. The Gambit solo film has the opportunity to open up a whole new avenue for Fox's X-Men cinematic universe (which, it's been rumoured, could end up crossing over with their upcoming Fantastic Four films). The rest of the franchise has been one big, epic story, and it's been worse off because of that. Everything had to have the same tone, similar characters, the same themes, because it was following a single line of continuity. Gambit is a spin-off. I should be something different, something new.
2. No Wolverine
Recently Marvel courted controversy (and increased comics sales) by killing Wolverine off in, fittingly, a major crossover event and miniseries called Death Of Wolverine. Logan won't remain buried for long it's not in his nature, and fan-favourite characters rarely stay dead but it spoke to something readers had been feeling for years. Wolverine was being spread thing. What was once a mysterious, enigmatic outsider had become the opposite, as he appeared in almost every X-book going and frequently cameoed in other books too. The market was saturated with Wolverine. The X-Men movies have the same problem. What works so well as an ensemble in print has totally become Hugh Jackman (And Friends) on the screen, with Wolverine being front and centre of every single X-Men film released so far except for First Class - and even then he stole the show with a five-second, four-letter cameo. So here's a novel idea: don't kill Wolverine off, but cool it with the appearances for a while. Jackman would probably appreciate a break. And when you're introducing a new character like Gambit, he doesn't need to be overwhelmed by an established, beloved one like Logan.
1. Don't Make Him A Creep
If it wasn't already clear, then the absence of nuance in the X-Men film casts are quite a problem. Wolverine is the only three-dimensional character in the franchise, and that's because he's had more screen time than anyone else; Ian McKellen has elevated Magneto into being one of the more intriguing screen "villains" of our time, and Patrick Stewart and James McAvoy can't help but make Charles Xavier more interesting than his do-gooder nature suggests. Everyone else is either a total bore (the rest of the X-Men) or a ridiculous pantomime villain (every bad guy thus far). Gambit isn't really any of those things. He's a little sleazy, a little difficult to trust, with the confidence of a thief and the sly charm of a scammer. He's not wholly evil or wholly good, but his motivations are also strikingly different to Magneto. He's a different type of character, which means that the X-Men filmmakers haven't got a track record with his sort before. Here's hoping he won't be reduced to a stereotypical creep with a silly voice. Like he usually is.