Ghostbusters: Every Cameo Ranked From Worst To Best
Weaver: Great. Murray: Poor.
Love it or hate it, there's no denying that the new Ghostbusters knows exactly where it came from. Despite director Paul Feig's publicly expressed desire to make something so different to the originals that it defied direct comparison, the film is bursting with fan-service, Easter Eggs and in-jokes that make the relationship impossible to ignore.
And inevitably, despite some of their fervent reluctance to do any more Ghostbusters films, the reboot included cameos (of sorts) to all but one of the principle cast of the originals. Rick Moranis might not be entirely retired (he says he's just picky), but his lack of actual activity in the industry for years made it supremely unlikely he'd ever agree.
Since the film was released, a significant amount of the analysis dedicated to it has centred on its relationship to the source). Perhaps because of the irresistible narrative that the film has RUINED CHILDHOODS, that was always going to be the case, and it seems a lot of its detractors (myself included) have focused on the most explicit references back to the originals as problematic.
To go even further, some of the cameos of the original stars are actually more distracting than they are celebratory, and there is definitely a big gap in quality between the best and the worst of them. That idea definitely warrants further discussion, so, here are all of the cameos, ranked from worst to best...
9. Ozzy Obsourne
Role: " Rock Star" (Seriously, he's not even allowed his own name!)
It's a God-damn tragedy to see what's become of Ozzy Osbourne since the early, glory days of Black Sabbath. He's now a comedy act when he's not on stage with the band (as they wind down their final tour), thanks to those awful reality TV shows. This sort of unnecessary cameo - just because - is the final insult to him and his legacy.
Ozzy turns up as a befuddled, angry rock star during the rock concert sequence that sees a ghost terrorising the audience and Ozzy demanding to know from Sharon if he's daydreaming. It's unimaginative, a waste of an appearance fee and completely pointless: a walk on designed to get a reaction that it absolutely does not warrant.
Why couldn't he have actually been the rock star singing at the gig that actually has his bloody name on the billboard outside?!
8. Bill Murray
Role: Martin Heiss
It sort of fits that the most resistant member of the original team would turn up as a world famous debunker and naysayer, who attempts to prove that the Ghostbusters are fake. And an on-form Bill Murray would have been great as the skeptical Heiss.
It's just a shame that an on-form Murray didn't turn up, and that the character - who is as interesting a subplot as Walter Peck was in the original, at least on paper - is under-fleshed, under-used and a little too knowing for his own good. And there's really no need to kill him off: the film pretty much goes out of its way to avoid needless bloodshed (to the point where the climactic "apocalypse" is pretty toothless), him dying sticks out like a sore thumb. Particularly as nobody even seems to bat half an eyelash.
7. Ernie Hudson
Role: Uncle Bill
How appropriate that the character most screwed over by the original (in terms of him being a stereotype who was then pretty much written out of the script later) would turn up in the most perfunctory of cameos. Even in the reboot they couldn't give him a better job than undertaker, despite the shockwaves caused so infamously around his and his neice's perceived lower social class than their white counterparts.
Uncle Bill turns up right at the end of the film, demanding to know where his missing hearse is after Patty "borrowed" it earlier (and it subsequently went into the vortex driven by Slimer and his wife). It's pretty much an afterthought of a performance (especially when he could have been one of the cops investigating the Ghostbusters or even the mayor as a politicised gesture of sorts).
At the end of the day, the role's biggest crime is it's just another forgettable one.
6. Slimer
Role: Slimer (obviously)
It was inevitable that Slimer would appear, given his popularity as a character in both the originals and the Real Ghostbusters animated series (which was actually retooled to have him as the main character by the end). But there was an opportunity here not to make the famous green ghost just an annoying, floating snot.
The nod to his appearance in the original (I'm pretty sure he's attacking the same hotdog stand, albeit with upgrades) is nice, but everyone seems to forget that Slimer is a Class 5 entity (and thus higher than Vigo). He's supposed to be difficult to catch and a genuine menace: but in the new film he's an idiot who comes with a seemingly fellow idiot wife FOR NO REASON and who is tricked into killing himself. Despite the fact that he clearly knows how to drive, and as such should know where the bloody brake pedal is.
If he's coming back for a sequel, they need to give him the billing he actually deserves.
5. The Stay Puft Marshmallow Man
Role: Stay Puft Ghost Balloon or something.
I have an absolutely massive problem with the Stay Puft Man's appearance in Ghostbusters: he's a floating plot hole. Not only is it illogical that balloons would have souls (and therefore impossible for there to be such a thing as a ghost balloon), but he's also defeated in a way that makes absolutely no sense within the film's stablished logic.
For the entire film, ghosts are beaten or blasted to bits using proton streams, as we'd expect, but somehow when he incapacitates three of the Ghostbusters, Stay Puft is literally popped using a conventional Swiss Army Knife. How? He's not an actual balloon, so that makes no sense, and ghosts can't be hurt with normal kitchen ware, so that doesn't either. Are we supposed to just accept this? It's criminal.
Still, at least he looks good and offers far more of a threat to the Ghostbusters than any of the other ghouls on show, including Rowan.
4. Dan Aykroyd
Role: "Cabbie"
it's rather unfortunate that Dan Aykroyd can't act any more. The former SNL genius gave up trying some time ago after a string of hits in the 1980s and 90s and seems to get by mostly on cameos in Adam Sandler movies (as well as that unforgivable Yogi Bear atrocity).
And while his line delivery - and the ridiculously trite appropriation of "I ain't afraid of no ghost" - is enough to make your eyes rolls permanently back into your head, the idea of his character is at least funny. The punchline basically being that a New York cabbie wouldn't allow something as piffling as the apocalypse to make them go further than they planned on jobs.
Plus, he scores extra points for the little noticed Easter Egg that he appears to be wearing the exact same outfits as the ghoulish cab driver from the oriignal film. Which possibly ranks as the best reference in the entire movie.
3. Annie Potts
Role: Desk Clerk
There's not a great deal to say about Annie Potts' cameo other than it being a briefly funny moment and the only one that doesn't completely defy the expectations attached to the original characters.
When faced with the revelation at the Mercado Hotel is the epicentre of Rowan's plot (and also his place of work), the Ghostbusters haul ass there, and demand to know his whereabouts. They're rather comically met by Potts' Desk Clerk who greets them with Janine's iconic "whaddayawant" (which Kevin later steals for his phone message at Ghostbusters HQ).
This is how the cameos should have been done (if at all): her character is an extension of Janine in the originals. She's in the same spirit, has the same personality and feels like more of a reference than the others, who are just shoe-horned into roles that could have been filled by any actor.
2. Sigourney Weaver
Role: Rebecca Gorin
Her character too might be a betrayal of her former role as Dana in the originals, but the idea of Rebecca Gorin as a similarly kooky mentor for Kate McKinnon's Holtzmann is actually pretty funny. She turns up in the very final seconds of the film, running her eye over the 'Busters' equipment and advising on the developments they need to add, despite appearing to be pretty unstable.
There is almost certainly potential there for her to return in the sequel if Sony want to give her another contract (though the others might be a little miffed that she's the only cameo who graduates to a more substantial role). I'd certainly watch her in a better sequel, that's for sure, as she adds to the backstory of Holtzmann, who has quickly become a lot of new fans' favourite characters in the film.
Then maybe we could see an actual confirmation IN THE FILM that Holtzmann is gay, rather than the weird revelation coming from the director outside of it. That was a big opportunity that he seems to have missed simply for the sake of it.
1. Harold Ramis
Role: None (he's memorialised instead)
Given Paul Feig's agenda to make sure his Ghostbusters was as different to the originals as possible (in order to consciously avoid direct comparison), I probably would have accepted a complete lack of actual cameos from the original cast. It certainly would have been less distracting.
But the one thing that absolutely had to be done within the film was some sort of acknowledgment of the passing of Harold Ramis. Just as the Jurassic World statue of John Hammond stands as a monument to actor Richard Attenborough, the bronze bust we see in the background of Erin Gilbert's opening sequence is an appropriate, fitting nod to Ramis.
Obviously, it stretches the rules of cameos, but the lingering camera and the manner of the appearance definitely confirms that it is intended to be taken in a similar celebratory spirit.
How would you rank the cameos in the new Ghostbusters? Share your rankings and observations below in the comments thread.