Hellboy: 10 Flaws That Prove Hellboy 3 Would've Been Better

The failed reboot is a sad reminder of the del Toro sequel we never got.

By Kieran Hair /

Not only did Neil Marshall's Hellboy reboot fail to meet its original opening box-office projections, even making back its $50 million budget could be an uphill battle. Many critics praised David Harbour's portrayal of the title character, but found little else about the film to merit commendation. With the flick scoring only 15% on Rotten Tomatoes at the time of writing, moviegoers who stand by critical consensus will likely look past the current 64% audience approval rating and continue giving this R-rated adventure a hard pass.

Advertisement

While the new Hellboy draws heavily from the comics, one of the biggest obstacles standing in its way was not the source material, but rather Guillermo del Toro's previous adaptations. Fans of del Toro's films waited years for a Hellboy 3 that never came, and it's all too easy to wonder what we might have gotten if the director had remained on board.

The switch from sequel to reboot was a long process, and fans may never fully know what was left on the cutting room floor. A few details about the reboot, however, will make some disappointed fans pine for the sequel that they never got to see. The following ten flaws in particular are more than enough to spark mournful conjecture about what might have been...

Warning: Major spoilers for Hellboy ahead.

10. Behind-The-Scenes Rumors Are Too Believable

As detailed extensively by contributor Josh Brown, the Hellboy reboot has been the subject of numerous rumors that point to behind-the-scenes bickering and battles for creative control. Marshall was allegedly undermined by his own producers, while the script was supposedly rewritten by multiple cast and crew members without writing credits on the film. If these reports are to be believed, everything from the cinematography to the design of a single tree was grounds for in-fighting on set.

Advertisement

Since much of this press stems from anonymous sources, some readers may naturally take it with a grain of salt. Unfortunately, the overall dissonance of the film makes these rumors all too believable. The acting, design, and script all feel wildly inconsistent. At times, even the best performers - and the film is hardly bereft of actors with stellar credits to their names - deliver their lines without enthusiasm.

Ultimately, Hellboy has moments where you can tell a lot of work and passion went into it. Other times, however, it feels as if the cast and crew were simply trying to wrap up the shoot without caring about the end result.

There was never any doubt that Guillermo del Toro, Ron Perlman, and the rest of the cast and crew of the original Hellboy films collaborated well. They formed such a strong bond that Perlman wouldn't reprise his role without del Toro's involvement, a factor which contributed to bucking the sequel in favor of a reboot.

The del Toro films weren't always perfect, but they at least felt like part of a cohesive effort. Sadly, the same can't be said for the latest flop.

9. The Creature Designs Are Unimaginative

Joel Harlow should be counted among the many talented people involved in the Hellboy reboot who simply didn't deliver what he could have. This is not to say that his creature designs are necessarily bad, but they simply don't feel as incredible as they could have been. The giants and fairies are uninteresting, as are many of the CGI creatures that gather to celebrate Nimue's resurrection. Baba Yaga looks great, but feels like a derivative attempt to crossbreed the Deadites from Sam Raimi's Evil Dead movies with Tales From The Crypt's iconic Crypt-Keeper.

Advertisement

Del Toro excels at visually-creative designs, with Hellboy II's Chamberlain and Angel of Death standing out as particularly intriguing characters. Meanwhile, Harlow gives us an evil Bebop and a big cat. While both the Gruagach and Ben Daimio's jaguar transformation are true to their original comic-book designs, drawing so directly from the source material almost seems like a flaw when compared to del Toro's highly original take on Mike Mignola's comic-book world.

To his credit, Harlow does let his creativity shine through near the end. It was his goal to make the giant Hell monsters in the climax unique from anything else appearing in the film, and his Todd McFarlane-esque nightmares succeed wildly in that regard. Unfortunately, that's where his most imaginative creature designs both start and end. Everything else, from the beginning of the film to its final moments, fails to make much of a lasting impression. It's all just kind of there, flashing across the screen before vanishing in a forgettable haze.

8. It Wastes Fan-Favorite Characters

Were you excited to learn that Lobster Johnson was going to be in the Hellboy reboot? Too bad, because he barely appears. Mike Mignola was excited to have Lobster stand in for the Torch of Liberty in the revised origin story - and they couldn't have used the Torch anyway - but to hardcore fans of the character, it may feel like brief fan-service without much of a real payoff.

Advertisement

The disappointing flash of an appearance feels especially egregious considering that Thomas Haden Church was one of the best casting choices they could have made next to Bruce Campbell, as evidenced by the fairly decent mid-credits scene. While still short, this scene shows Lobster Johnson in ghost form, which will be familiar to comic fans who remember his early days of consulting with the BPRD. Nonetheless, it still feels as if a great character was shoehorned in just for the sake of being there, despite serving no greater purpose to the story.

When del Toro and Mignola considered centring Hellboy II on Roger the Homunculus though, they switched gears after they had trouble writing a decent story for the character. If they couldn't use the character well, they weren't going to use him at all. Del Toro did want to use Lobster Johnson in Hellboy 3, but presumably would have made a similar choice if the character's appearance didn't feel earned.

By contrast, the reboot throws a great character at you and expects you to be happy with the fact that he's there, despite Lobster doing nothing to earn his presence in the movie. Those unfamiliar with the hero will probably wonder why Lady Hatton's voiceover dialogue makes such a big deal of "the Lobster" just for the sake of a two-minute appearance. Then again, those who love the character will wonder the exact same thing.

7. It Retells The Origin Story For No Reason

Hellboy's Nazi-fueled origin story is always going to be a bit cheesy on-screen, but del Toro did what he could to spice it up with a bit of solid action and suspense. Marshall attempts to do the same, but it simply feels like a boring rehash of something that was never especially interesting to begin with. Moreover, much like Lobster Johnson's appearance in that same scene, the rehashed origin tale doesn't do much to earn its place in the narrative.

Advertisement

In some ways, it's nice for comic fans to see something a little closer to Hellboy's comic-book origin. Unfortunately, brief glimpses of familiar characters such as Rasputin and Kroenen feel wasted when those characters play no role in the actual plot of the film. It appears that this retelling only exists for the purpose of showing us that Trevor Bruttenholm was originally supposed to kill Hellboy. Curiously, it doesn't actually bother showing the moment when he decides to adopt him instead.

Either way, knowing that Hellboy was supposed to be killed is a pretty minor detail in the grand scheme of other issues that the film wants you to focus on. It didn't need to be rehashed so elaborately, especially in a scene that doesn't pack half as much punch as the version we got in 2004. Since the reboot goes on to establish an entirely different chapter of Hellboy's origin story - his rightful heirship to the Throne of England - the scene with Lady Hatton just becomes another example of the reboot's irritating obsession with voiceover exposition. The planned sequel could have spared audiences the tedium.

6. More Rehashed Introductions Might Be On The Way

Marshall's choice to focus on a new team involving Ben Daimio and Alice Monaghan was arguably one of the smartest decisions he made when crafting his reboot. Rather than rehash the introductions of familiar characters such as Abe Sapien and Liz Sherman - the latter of whom would have inevitably been quite different from Selma Blair's depiction - audiences get to enjoy different characters with different abilities. Any attempt at a sequel, however, will likely destroy the good will earned by this decision.

Advertisement

At the end of the reboot, Hellboy and the BRPD infiltrate the Oannes Club. Fans of the comics already knew where this was headed, although viewers familiar only with del Toro's films might have been surprised to see Abe Sapien's reveal at the end of the scene.

Del Toro never bothered giving Abe Sapien much of an origin story, possibly because it's not the most film-friendly story. In the comics, Abe was originally human, turned into a walking fish stick by an ocean-obsessed occult society. It's an interesting backstory for a comic book, but it's hard to imagine that type of narrative fitting into the heavy metal world of the new film.

More importantly, wasting time on another origin story means that a character we've already seen in two movies will get less time to actually show us what he can do. Del Toro avoided that mess by simply introducing him while he was already in his prime, yet here we are back t the beginning. Fortunately (and also somewhat unfortunately), the reboot's box-office failure likely means we'll never fully see Marshall's version of Abe Sapien anyway.

5. Hellboy's Irritating Daddy Issues

In case it's not clear from the past few entries, many of the reboot's problems are fairly common across reboots in general. When a film decides to retread tired ground that audiences don't need anymore, it feels like a slog. If a Batman film casts Thomas and Martha Wayne, or a Spider-Man movie casts Uncle Ben, most fans already know not to get too attached. Likewise, to fans of the Hellboy comics or the del Toro movies, the inevitable death of Ian McShane's Professor Bruttenholm was one of the reboot's most predictable plot points.

Advertisement

McShane did a fine job portraying the character, but Bruttenholm's death couldn't have come sooner. Hellboy's daddy issues are far more emphasized in the reboot than the del Toro films, and they grow tiresome less than halfway through the picture.

Unfortunately, this movie decides to team Hellboy up with a spirit medium, ensuring that even Bruttenholm's death won't put an end to Hellboy's penchant for repeating the same argument time and again with his father. Even once Bruttenholm is buried, we're treated to another scene of Hellboy moaning next to his gravestone. Perhaps it's a bit cynical to say, but one of the better prospects of Hellboy 3 would have been that Bruttenholm was already dead.

David Harbour and Ian McShane could have had an amazing chemistry as Hellboy and his adopted father, but the script apparently didn't know it had been written for actors with actual talent.

4. The End Credits Set Up A Boring Villain

Between the Abe Sapien reveal, Lobster Johnson's allusion to an imminent struggle and the mysterious post-credits sequence, the Hellboy reboot tries hard to generate excitement for a sequel. Unfortunately, the latter of those scenes suggests that such a sequel might not be much more exciting than the reboot itself.

Advertisement

There's actually no telling who Baba Yaga's supposed to be talking to at the end of the film, but some fans of the comics have already ventured a fairly plausible guess. The dialogue suggests an immortal villain who will be working for Baba Yaga: Koshchei the Deathless.

While traditional Slavic folklore rarely depicts Koshchei and Baba Yaga in the same story, the two are inextricably linked in the world of Hellboy. The comic version of Koshchei is a slave to Baba Yaga who can't die unless she releases his soul, and she won't do that until he brings her Hellboy's head. She specifically wants his eye, albeit for different reasons than in the film.

The problem with Koshchei's story is that he doesn't actually do much. His appearance in Darkness Calls is largely an extended action sequence. There are some moments that would look great on film, such as a tree growing through Koshchei's tortured body - although rumors of on-set arguments may humorously call into question who would design the tree. In terms of narrative, however, he doesn't have much to offer outside of a later story in which he simply hangs out with Hellboy in a bar and divulges his backstory.

Only two approaches might make Koshchei a decent villain for a possible sequel. First, Marshall could combine Koshchei's action in Darkness Calls with a separate comic arc, but drawing from multiple arcs already failed in the reboot. Second, he could draw upon actual Slavic folklore for new ideas. That actually feels a lot like what del Toro might have done if given the character.

3. It's Afraid To Be As Dark As It Wants

For all the gore accompanying Hellboy's brief moments as a horned bringer of doom in the reboot, the carnage is fairly short-lived. Daddy shows up to share some encouraging words, Hellboy breaks off his horns, and that's it. Take away the bloody action and giant monsters (which are only briefly seen), and it's basically what happens at the end of del Toro's first Hellboy movie.

Advertisement

The closest we get to a real apocalypse is a brief vision of Hellboy riding a dragon and slaying some badly animated victims with a flaming Excalibur. It's a shame, because this scene feels so much like a live-action take on Heavy Metal that it's impossible not to imagine what a full-blown apocalypse might look like. If we'd gotten Hellboy 3, we might actually know the answer.

Del Toro indicated that Hellboy 3 would, to some extent, involve Hellboy coming to grips with his destiny and bringing about the end of days. It's not clear if this means Hellboy would have been the villain of his own movie, as del Toro stated in a Reddit AMA that there would be at least one other villain for Hellboy to defeat while telling IGN that the results would be tragic. In the comics, Hellboy's attempt to stave off the apocalypse resulted in his death, and that might very well have been del Toro's plan. On the other hand, his willingness to diverge from source material indicates that we could have possibly spent more time with Hellboy's evil side.

Regardless of whether Hellboy would have ultimately given in to his demonic calling, the strong implication is that Hellboy 3 would have focused much more on the apocalypse than the reboot or either of del Toro's first two Hellboy films. It's odd, for a reboot this in-your-face about its violence, that they were afraid to show more of the apocalypse than they did.

2. Even The Apocalypse Would Be Funnier Than This

Hellboy 3, with its implied promise to show us the end of the world, would probably still have had a few better comedic beats than the reboot. Del Toro blended comedy and darkness well in the first two movies, particularly the second. The Golden Army was fairly dark and nearly apocalyptic, yet it still took time to have its characters get drunk and sing along to Barry Manilow.

Advertisement

This scene worked not only for its humor, but because it was humorous in a way that still showed character growth and helped develop the plot. Abe's acceptance of his love for Nuala was essential in allowing Prince Nuada to gain the upper hand and usher in the climax of the film, as was - to some degree - his and Hellboy's drunkenness. The humor earned its place by actually playing a hand in the grim events that followed.

What kind of humor does the reboot deliver? A few easy references to modern technology, along with quips that feel tired the moment they escape their characters' lips. One notable example follows the death of Lady Hatton, when Hellboy explains to Ben Daimio that she was a psychic. "Clearly not psychic enough," Daimio remarks. If that joke sounds vaguely familiar, it's because everyone with a Twitter account heard an only slightly different version on endless repeat the day Miss Cleo died. If it wasn't clever three years ago, why would it be clever now?

Del Toro promised a darker Hellboy 3, but even the darkest of films typically lift the audience's spirits from time to time.

1. There's Really No Replacing Ron Perlman

This might be one of the more controversial entries on this list, simply because David Harbour truly does an admirable job. Furthermore, this version of Hellboy really isn't the same as the version portrayed in del Toro's movies, which focused more on Hellboy's softer, cat-loving, romantic side. Unfortunately, those differences don't always matter when rebooting a popular character. Just as many will always consider Heath Ledger the only Joker, there will be some fans and critics who simply can't dissociate Hellboy from Ron Perlman.

Advertisement

In that light, this reboot already put Harbour in the unfortunate position of walking in a shadow that he can't possibly overcome. The makeup team, which decided to give him a hairier, greasier appearance, didn't help. There's technically nothing wrong with changing up a character for the sake of a movie, and Hellboy's altered appearance in the reboot serves its intended purpose of making him look slightly younger.

Perlman, however, looked and felt like the comic book character he was portraying in every sense. After two movies with an actor whose look was a perfect fit - and after years of waiting for him to take on the character a third time - Harbour was never going to feel good enough by comparison.

What this actually proves more than anything is that nostalgia can take its toll before a project is even completed. Fans who waited years for Hellboy 3 were always going to feel at least a tiny bit gypped when getting a reboot instead. Perlman himself would have loved to give fans the closure of finishing out the trilogy, referring to Hellboy 3's cancellation as "an open wound." Suffice to say, now that fans have seen the new film, he's not the only one feeling a little sore.

Advertisement