The Hobbit: 10 Worst Changes Peter Jackson Made

By Alexander Podgorski /

10. No Explanation For The Eagles

The Eagles were important examples of Deus ex Machina in both the Hobbit and the Lord of the Rings stories. They were used as some sort of last resort to save the characters from impending doom, and appeared to be more or less all-powerful characters. One of the biggest criticisms of both of Jackson's film series is that there was no explanation for how the Eagles were used. The film saw Thorin€™s company dropped off on a rock of sorts, without offering any explanation. Yet those viewers who have never read Tolkien€™s book have often asked €˜why couldn€™t the Eagles just carry them far closer to the Lonely Mountain?€™ An explanation for this plot hole was given in Tolkien€™s book: The Eagles (who could talk, which was another important characteristic from the book Jackson omitted), and told Thorin€™s group that the closer they got to the dwellings of men, the more likely they were to get shot at by arrows. As such, they feared flying too close to wherever humans lived. None of this was explained in the films, even though Gandalf could€™ve offered one line to explain this, and a major plot hole could€™ve been covered. Instead, viewers were treated to more running and more attention to new characters (more on that later).