Last year The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey arrived with a bang and exited with a whimper. While the technological advances were huge, the storytelling seemed to take several steps back from the level of maturity achieved in The Lord of the Rings trilogy. Of course, maturity is not necessarily the first word that comes to mind when one thinks of The Hobbit. It's a story originally intended for children, even though J.R.R. Tolkien himself attempted to rewrite it in later years, to match the complexity of his Rings saga. Jackson is now making the same attempt with his Hobbit trilogy. But with the first film he made the mistake of attempting to broaden and dramatize a story that just didn't have the weight he needed it to. He attempted to fix this problem by adding in material from Tolkien's appendices that didn't really fit. Moreover, the pace of the movie was so slow that Bilbo and the Dwarves may as well have been belly-crawling to Erebor. This mix of unneeded material, bad CGI and bloated pacing slowed The Hobbit down into disappointing muck. So why was Desolation of Smaug so much better? This is the question we'll explore over the next 5 sections. Just why Desolation of Smaug was such an improvement, and the things Jackson is hopefully keeping in mind as he moves towards completing the film film. These are the 5 lessons from Desolation of Smaug that will make the third film great.
5. The Appendices
Unlike in the first film, the inclusion of material from the appendices works in tandem with the main quest of Bilbo and the Dwarves. Why? Because the structure of the movie is utilized to match Hobbit-proper material with Appendices-material. In the first film, the rhythm of the material was uneven. After a good 45 minutes was spent introducing Bilbo, the dwarves, and their quest, the movie promptly veered off in order to spend an elongated chunk of time with Radagast the Brown and his assortment of pets. There was a similarly huge problem during the first council of Elrond scene, in which Gandalf, Saruman, Elrond and Galadriel have a long discussion about Sauron. While this was Jackson's attempt to set up a sense of brooding doom for the events to come in Lord of the Rings, it just played like a less important version of the same scene from Fellowship of the Ring. But in Desolation of Smaug, the appendices material actually serves to punctuate and build the main story. This is accomplished mainly through improved editing and purposeful cross-cutting. Rather than featuring extremely long appendices sequences, the extra material is sliced up into shorter portions, blended in at times that nicely mirror or contrast with the actions of the main story. For example, when Gandalf meets Radagast in the tomb of the Ringwraith, there's a looming feeling of dread, and the scene arrives as a contrast to the new sense of relief felt as Bilbo and his companions safely arrive at Laketown. The cut to the tomb serves to prevent us from lapsing into any sense of false calm, reminding the audience that no one is safe from the coming reemergence of Mordor. Here the departure from the main story serves as an important contrast, while later on it serves as a mirror image. Bilbo's climactic encounter with Smaug in Erebor is trumped only by Gandalf's encounter with Sauron at Dol Guldur. Here the clumsy puzzle pieces set up in the first Hobbit pay off as the Necromancer reveals himself to be the dark lord of Mordor in the most exciting battle with Sauron since Fellowship's prologue. The scene packs a wallop on its own terms, but is made all the more effective by its pairing with Bilbo's confrontation with Smaug. Both Bilbo and Gandalf separately reach the conclusion of their journeys, while possible doom and destruction is laid out on both counts - and both sequences proceed with palpitating action and suspense. The two scenes serve as an example of fine cross-cutting. Had this fight with Sauron come at a different point, or been drawn out like many of the confrontations in the first film, the scene wouldn't have packed the punch it did. This Sauron scene builds up to the Battle of Five Armies in the third film. That's where the main quest of the Dwarves and the side quests of the appendices will finally intersect, and hopefully give us the most cohesive Hobbit film yet. Judging from the result of Desolation, Jackson has figured out how to utilize his two sources separately, finessing them to match one another. Now all he has to do is bring them together.
4. Kili, Bard, And The External Characters
Peter Jackson has always been good at fleshing out Tolkien's characters. Tolkien was adept at exploring his world and its many cultures, but he wasn't so precise in writing his characters. People like Frodo, Aragorn, and Legolas seemed like cyphers for delivering Tolkien's histories, poems and songs, never emerging with distinct personalities. But Jackson managed to levy each of his characters with a unique personality and purpose. Frodo, Sam, Aragorn, Eowyn, Gandalf and many others emerged with their own distinctive voice within the narrative. Looking at the original Hobbit film, it was therefore surprising that all of the new characters seemed just as flat as Tolkien wrote them. Of all the things Jackson chose to adapt faithfully in the first Hobbit, he correctly adopted the Dwarves' lack of personality - except for Thorin, who he made even more unlikable. All of the other Dwarves were memorable only for their rhyming names. Oh yeah, and Bombur was fat. Thankfully, Jackson has rectified these mistakes with the second Hobbit. Returning to his old LOTR ways, he gives several of the Dwarves standout personalities. Balin has become the moral center of the group, guiding Bilbo with wisdom and kindness. Thorin has now taken on his book counterpart's more heroic qualities. He's still stubborn and bull-headed, but it's clear that he wants to do the right thing for his people. His morals are questionable, but these differing qualities serve to make him more nuanced, and more interesting to watch. Of course, the standout Dwarf here is Kili, who emerges from being a nothing character in the book/first movie, to a sweet, good-natured soldier with a clever tongue and an interesting back story. He even gets his own romance subplot (more on that later). The result is a character we can actually care about and root for. I suspect that Jackson did this to give us a connection with Kili so we can actually be saddened by his impending death in the next movie. Which is a brilliant move - Fili's and Kili's deaths were handled as a mere afterthought in the book (something that always annoyed me) and now hopefully they can finally get a proper sendoff. Bard is also set up masterfully, containing more distinctive character traits than his book counterpart ever did. If readers recall, Bard wasn't properly introduced until about three pages before he shoots and kills Smaug. It's not until after the dragon's death that we learn about his history. But even then we never get much about his personality or the type of life he led at Laketown. I always felt it was a strange way to introduce the slayer of Smaug. Having your book's villain killed by the equivalent of Joe Shmoe is not the best way to cap a climax. In the film, it is Bard who brings the Dwarves to Laketown, hides them, gives them weapons, and prepares them for the end of their journey. He also factors significantly in the politics of Laketown (An interesting creation in its own right) which serve to reveal his noble character traits. This is all great foreshadowing to set him up as the future ruler of Dale. Bard also relays his back story, and the tale of Smaug's near-defeat, as a nice set-up for his eventual conquest of Smaug. All of this works to introduce Bard as an important player for part 3. Overall, this increase in three dimensional characters serves to give us more to chew on. Jackson's laid the groundwork for some brilliant pay-offs to come in There and Back Again. With the added characterizations of Kili, Thorin, and Bard, we're set to be properly invested in the end of their journeys. An epic battle filled with heroic conquests and sacrifices needs to contain the proper amount of dramatic weight in order for you to care. Desolation has made this possible. As a wise wizard once said, the board is set. The pieces are moving.
3. Romance and Love Triangles
Just as important as the improvement on existing characters, is the creation of original ones. The female Elf Tauriel has been a subject of debate amongst Tolkien fans, as she is the first entirely original character created by Peter Jackson. Many fans feel this is an infringement upon the sanctity of the author's works. But let's not forget that this isn't exactly the first time the director has, ahem, mingled with creative liberties. For example, the inclusion of the Lothlorien elves at the battle of Helm's Deep, or Gollum tricking Frodo into sending Sam away. But these changes actually helped along the story, increasing character dynamics and adding substance to Tolkien's mythos. But really the closest example is the role of Arwen. While she may have been a Tolkien character, her role was expanded upon enormously by Jackson. He lifted the mention of an Aragorn and Arwen romance from the appendices and used it as fuel to build an entire relationship. This served not only to expand upon the limited female roles in LOTR, but also to bring added dimension to Aragorn's journey. Any good fantasy series can use a little romance, especially one that eventually clocks in over 12 hours long. Following the success of the Arwen role in LOTR, it seems reasonable that Jackson would seek to create for the Hobbit a new concoction from the same recipe. Enter Tauriel, the female Elven warrior and romantic substitute for Arwen. In fact, Tauriel blends the best of both Arwen and Eowyn. She proves to be a fierce warrior, slaying a variety of Orcs and rescuing our heroes, particularly Kili, who she develops a fascinating fondness for. Here she becomes more Arwen than Eowyn, with the budding romance between Kili and Tauriel becoming the cross-species substitute for Arwen and Aragorn. And while Man and Elf may have a certain scandalous undertone, Dwarf and Elf just sounds plain dirty. I think this particular pairing appeals to the "Beauty and the Beast" fetishists in all of us. Throw in a little jealous Legolas, and you have the ingredients for one hell of unique love triangle (and a hilarious porn parody. Two Elves and a Dwarf?). As someone who usually hates love triangles, I think this is one of the few that actually works. Many will disagree, but I think the raging hormones adds a bit of humanity to the proceedings. And in world chock full of Elves, Dwarves, Wizards, and Hobbits, it's good to see our characters still possess feelings that remind us of our own natures as human beings. This gives us more to connect to, more to invest in, and more dimensionality to an already bright and brimming three dimensional world. Since I mentioned Legolas, I also have to mention that his presence here is a very welcome one. The first Hobbit suffered from what I call "Look, remember this character!" syndrome. Anytime someone from LOTR showed up, be it Frodo, Galadriel or Saruman, I had a creeping feeling that these characters were only there to remind us that they exist. Not so with Legolas. Not only does he provide us with some more of his bad-ass Legolas moves, he also rounds out the Elven cast nicely, giving them a more distinctive presence. He's both a familiar face and a newly fleshed out character. We learn about his origins, who his father was, and some of the conflicts that drive him. He feels like a completely different character. I'm actually going to go out on a limb and say I like him more here than I ever did in LOTR. I know he's a fan favorite, but I can't help but think that's because he had a bow and arrow and shot it a lot. He never struck me as having nearly the strong personalities that his companions Aragorn and Gimli did. When he wasn't shooting his arrow he just kind of stood around looking pretty and saying the occasional wise word or two. Now Legolas has a definitive purpose all his own. I'm looking forward to seeing how Tauriel's relationship with Kili develops, and how ultimately she will be involved with the actions that lead to his demise. I'm guessing she will be a part of Kili's final battle, probably fighting alongside him. Her reaction to his death, where her character goes from there, and how Legolas will be involved, are all going to be interesting elements to watch come together. Will Legolas attempt to console her and rekindle their romance? Will she accept? Will she die in battle with Kili? Where the heck is she during LOTR anyway? These are all questions that have yet to be answered, and the fact that Jackson has made me interested enough to ask them is in itself an accomplishment. And if others are asking the same questions, then it looks like Jackson is doing right by Tolkien.
2. A Consistent Tone
In terms of film technique alone, Jackson maneuvers his camera with a far steadier hand. The movie feels purposeful and motivated, like it knows where it wants to go. The first Hobbit gave off a sense of sheer meandering. Simple things like character entrances seemed to drag on and on. The arrival to Rivendell, for example, was needlessly dragged out by having our heroes informed that Elrond is away, only to have him then dramatically arrive on horseback 5 seconds later. Similar entrances were given to Saruman, who magically appears in a corner, and Galadriel, who dramatically turns around as the camera slowly takes in her obtuse glory. Scenes like this caused the pacing of the film to ground to a halt. Desolation on the other hand is stuffed with relentless action, never letting up. Where the character entrances were formerly slow and indulgent, now they are swift and purposeful. Legolas arrives with a bang, leaping from a tree and firing arrows into Orc heads. Bilbo saves his friends without a second thought, tearing his way through trees and jamming Sting into spiders' bellies. It seemed often in the first Hobbit that the characters were just posing. Taking grand positions and waiting for the camera to do its work for them. Here everything is much more potent, as the characters are dizzyingly swept into their world. There's no time for lingering camera angles, the characters are too busy delving into the action of the movie. From the early chase with Beorn to the spiraling darkness of the Mirkwood spider battle, from the rollicking barrel ride into Laketown to the intricate maze of Smaug's dungeon, the action is relentless. Desolation is the first of the Middle-Earth films that can be classified an action picture. And while this classification may be considered a step down from the Rings days, it's a hell of a lot better than what we got the first time. The first film never seemed to have a good handle on what it wanted to be. Ominous exchanges between Gandalf and Radagast were abruptly broken by Radagast choking on a cricket. Uproarious Dwarves tossing cutlery around Bilbo's kitchen was paired with intensely dramatic slow motion as Gandalf handed Thorin a door key. The lighter fare from The Hobbit novel and the more dramatic material from LOTR were awkwardly thrown together. Instead of deciding on a tone, Jackson just let the ingredients sit in a blender separately, never mixing them. But for Desolation, he finally hit "blend." The result is a movie that drops the overly dramatic and the painfully unfunny, and arrives at the healthy medium of action fantasy/adventure film. Even when the film slows down, it's only for character development. The film is structured like a cat-and-mouse game: Run-stop-hide-run-stop-fight-run. Even the breaks in the action act only as a pause button, continuing to generate energy until the film hits play. The action never truly halts until the heart-stopping cliffhanger, dropping like a massive crescendo. For a third movie that will likely be primarily battle scenes, it's very important that the pacing and tone be maintained. We can't have any meandering about. The battles in the final film need to be vivid, intense, and purposeful. Jackson seems to have discovered the tone he wants the second time out, now all he needs to do is enhance it. The tragedies that will befall our beloved characters should hand over plenty of natural material for true drama. That combination of drama mixed with palpitating action (aka "The Return of the King" mixture) should be just what Jackson needs to give us an epic send-off for Middle-Earth.
1. Villains And Smaug
No action/fantasy film is complete without a good villain, and Desolation delivers on all fronts. Jackson has created in Smaug a lifelike threat, breathing new life into a rather cartoonish character and morphing him into the most convincing dragon ever to appear on the silver screen (Sorry, Dragonheart). A major issue I had in becoming fully immersed in the first Hobbit was the overwhelming usage of CGI. The Orcs, played by real people in LOTR, were replaced with CGI replicas in The Hobbit. The result was half the effort and half the believability. This was particularly problematic when depicting Azog, who Jackson tried hard to sell as a formidable threat to our heroes. But Azog was not a particularly interesting villain, and whatever effect he may have had was ruined because he looked completely fake. While Azog himself still looks like a CGI creation, many of the other effects have been improved. You can see the detail in every scale ridged along Smaug's back, every drop of moisture in his breath, and every flare of color in his fire. Smaug possesses a palpable sense of weight. Azog and the rest of the Orcs had the Star Wars prequel effect of blending in too well with their environments, to the point where it appeared that our human actors were merely interacting with a screen. Smaug, on the other hand, stands in stark contrast to his environment. The colors of Smaug's body pop out vividly against the sparkling gold of his treasure kingdom. When he moves, the gold cascades around his feet in waves, every piece creating a distinct ripple. The sound of gold echoes around the cavernous domain, and the voice of Smaug booms out mightily over it. Indeed the sound mixing here is notable, as Benedict Cumberbatch delivers Smaug's lines with tremendous gravitas and sneering disdain, enhanced through a powerful mechanical boosting effect. It's fascinating how delivery, effects, and staging can really add to material. The dialogue exchanged between Bilbo and Smaug is essentially the same as in the book, but here there's a convincing sense of dread. In the book, Smaug's depiction seems almost whimsical, his riddles with Bilbo exchanged with a wit and high-minded loftiness. This makes for great fun, but it's not exactly terrifying. And though Bilbo reacts to him with terror, as readers we never feel it. On screen, Bilbo's reaction to Smaug is equally felt by the audience, as we all shudder beneath his size, his voice, and his horrifying intelligence. It helps too that the material with Smaug has been greatly expanded upon. For a book that spends the majority of its pages building up to the Smaug confrontation, it doesn't actually spend much time on Smaug himself. The entire exchange between Bilbo and Smaug lasts less than 10 pages, after which Smaug is quickly offed by Bard. This leaves readers wanting more, and Jackson has successfully capitalized on this desire. He fleshes out Smaug in size, scope and presence, extending the confrontation with Smaug to include not just Bilbo, but the Dwarves as well. The scene opens up from Smaug's cave and encompasses the halls of Erebor, creating a fantastic structural action set-piece, on par with the best movie thrillers. This is particularly important for Thorin, as it creates for him a genuine confrontation with the dragon. In the book Thorin speaks about the dragon often, and he is built up as an arch-enemy of sorts. But Thorin never once confronts Smaug in the book, and this leaves something to be desired in tying up Thorin's loose ends. I always thought it should have been Thorin, not Bard, who slays Smaug. It would have seemed like the natural ending of Thorin's arc. But though Jackson couldn't change that particular bit, he did smartly give Thorin the confrontation with Smaug he deserves. There is a sense of satisfaction as Thorin faces Smaug atop the statue of his grandfather, exchanging words of promised vengeance before releasing a wave of liquid gold upon the beast. Not only is this an awesome moment in suspense and execution, it's a striking visual bit, with more excellent CGI in animating the flowing gold. It tops off an intense half hour sequence that richly enhances the material from the book, and far outshines the extremely subpar, slow and overblown final confrontation with Azog from Unexpected Journey. It bears mentioning that Smaug is not the only good villain here. I was surprised to find that even the underwhelming Azog was more enjoyable this time around. His CGI may still leave something to be desired, but his motivations are clearer and more interesting. The first time we understood little about him, except that he wanted Thorin's head on a platter because he cut off his hand. Now we know that he was, in fact, summoned to go after the Dwarves by Sauron himself. Sauron makes everything more interesting. And though this has the effect of removing Azog's independence as a villain, it gives him a new sense of purpose. He's no longer carrying out his own boring mission, but a much grander scheme. He functions as a lieutenant, like Gothmog from Return of the King. The overall combination of great heroes and great villains make for a distinctively more complete film than we got last year. Now that Smaug has been introduced so well, Jackson is set to bring us an epic final confrontation with the dragon next year. I'm sure, like the end of Desolation, Bard's battle with Smaug will be greatly expanded upon, delivering a proper amount of action and buildup before the final execution (pun intended). The Battle of Five Armies, which was largely told in aftermath in the book due to Bilbo being knocked unconscious (A cheap trick that Jackson neither could nor should want to get away with) was an underwhelming conclusion. But in There and Back Again it could prove to be among the series' best battles. It will be the first to feature armies from ALL of Tolkien's major races: Dwarves, Men, Elves and Orcs will all clash for the first time on screen, and since we are now invested in characters on all sides of the fence, we will have the fascinating experience of supporting everyone and no one. Perhaps we will not know who to root for now that we'll have a stake in Thorin and the dwarves, Bard and the men, and Legolas/Tauriel and the Elves. Through Bilbo's eyes, perhaps the right side won't be so clear. Jackson's efforts have really come a long way, and my faith in him is renewed. If There and Back Again takes shape in a manner that avoids the worst of Unexpected, and utilizes the best of Desolation, we just might find ourselves interested, invested and cheering on our characters to get there and back again. Questions? Arguments? More suggestions for how Jackson should handle the final movie? Sound off in the comments below!