How They Should Have Made Ghostbusters III
We ain't afraid of no sequel.
As a brand, Ghostbusters has been threatening complete exhaustion since the beginning of the decade. From the constant talks of a possible third movie, to its abrupt cancellation, controversial reboot and touted expanded universe, we just cannot seem to get away from this one simple but great idea from over 30 years ago.
And just when you thought the idea of a third movie was long dead, director Ivan Reitman recently hinted at SD Comic Con that we might see the original team back together again in some form. Following that, Harold Ramis' daughter, Violet Ramis Stiel, spoke out about a possible CG recreation of her father in future GB movies.
Almost out of nowhere, the rumours regarding Ghostbusters III have fired up once again.
While interesting, it all seems too little too late. The loss of Ramis, as well as the divisive reaction to the 2016 reboot has probably soured the idea of continuing the series in any form. Ghostbusters III is something that would have been joyously welcomed ten or even five years ago, but now, the idea just seems tired and problematic.
Among various other issues, there's no respectful way to make it without the ever-reluctant Bill Murray or (a flesh-and-blood) Ramis. But had it happened when the time was right several years ago, how should it have all gone?
The Ghostbusters III fans initially envisioned now has zero chance of being made, so much of this list is obviously wishful thinking. It's nonetheless fun however to speculate on what could have been...
7. Reunite The Key Players
The original film primarily works because of the funny and charming performances from its principle actors, anchored by an enlightened and concentrated director. The Ghostbusters framework alone isn’t enough to make a great movie; it requires the essential creative players to give it familiar tone and spirit.
At its best, the chemistry between Murray, Aykroyd and Ramis is something that simply cannot be replicated, and is ultimately the signature mark of the series. Supplemented by the stable Ernie Hudson and Sigourney Weaver, as well as the madcap Rick Moranis, the film amounts to an offbeat but very well balanced comedy.
But yes, there was the issue of Bill Murray. In various interviews, he seemed fairly back and forth on the idea of returning, but he never outright said never. It's fair to assume he would have committed if the script was unique and good enough, and not just derivative of the first two movies. Whatever the case, the film would have had a very hard time without him.
In fact it would have been depressingly empty if any of the cast were limited to cameo roles or disregarded completely. Each of them were a cornerstone in crafting an ultimately very special franchise, and their absence would have only rendered the film disrespectful and probably kind of pointless.
6. Give The Original Characters Narrative Focus
As already stated, the cast needed to return, but once again in a major capacity.
Every time Aykroyd updated us on the script’s development, he rarely neglected to mention the casting and general structure of the movie. He typically stressed that the original Ghostbusters would be taking a narrative back seat, with focus insteadon a new and younger team with Aykroyd and co. as their mentors.
“Passing the torch” movies are always an uncertain gamble, particularly for a comedy. For it to work, you would have needed an equally funny and talented group of actors, with unmistakable charisma and relationships. Not to say this couldn’t have been done, but there’s a very minor chance it would have captured similar magic.
The preferable route for Ghostbusters III would have kept the cast relatively small-scale. A strong focus on the same crew would have made a satisfying conclusion to the trilogy, giving them one final adventure together and a proper send-off.
But if Aykroyd felt that passing the torch was the best way to go, the story could have dipped its toes into new character territory. Whereas an instant replacement team would feel like overkill, one or (maximum) two younger Ghostbusters would have made a better experiment, and provide a hook if the franchise were to continue without the original cast.
5. A Far-Out Premise
In a story sense, Ghostbusters II was certainly a step in the wrong direction. From a lack of interest on everyone’s part, it mostly felt like an uninspired repeat of something we’d seen before, only not as good. To successfully revive and redeem the series, III should have offered us the polar opposite.
Another play-it-safe movie was definitely not welcome by anyone, and Dan Aykroyd’s various pitches from the past two decades seemingly reflect that. They generally involve the Ghostbusters in unfamiliar territory, ranging from the team going to hell, adventures in alternate dimensions, and Venkman dying in the first act (only to return as a ghost himself).
While this might sound too insane for some fans, one can’t deny that seeing the Ghostbusters under radically new circumstances would at least be interesting and refreshing. This is also what makes Ivan Reitman integral to the series - to serve as Aykroyd's voice of reason. In the midst of the eccentric Aykroyd's insane ideas, it's Reitman's job to scale it back where necessary, and keep the tone and humour on point.
4. A Different Kind Of Threat
Gozer and Vigo both served as mysterious and effective villains who were fairly uninvolved with the Ghostbusters up until the climax of each movie. To give III a different flavour and structure though, we would've needed something a little different.
Emphasising and rounding out the film's antagonist wouldn't have been a bad direction. Rendering them more of a solid character, they could be fully aware of the Ghostbusters and motivated to destroy them rather than just vaguely taking over. With some more backstory and screen time with the team, it could possibly amount to a successful rivalry/revenge movie.
A different option would be not to have a central villain per se, and instead have a threat arise from a grave environmental situation; the Ghostbusters trying to heal a dimensional rift or restore some kind of universal imbalance would be nicely outlandish, and would help offer some story variety to the trilogy.
3. Being Scary, As Well As Funny
0While thought of as a relatively goofy comedy, Ghostbusters is still surprisingly effective in the scares department. The morphing library ghost, Gozer’s vicious dog minions, and Sigourney Weaver's possession could all potentially occupy any straight horror film out there, strictly because they were treated as genuine, intimidating threats.
This is the key to what makes it a successful horror-comedy, and any sequel should follow suit. Other than Slimer, the only comedy comes from its human characters, and an alarming villain maintains the drama; this also saves the movie from becoming overly wacky or farcical. Be it demons, ghosts, monsters or zombies, they should all be gross and fearsome.
In relation to this, they should have refrained from looking too cartoony, and only have been CG where appropriate.
2. Hold Back On The Fan Service
Sequels (particularly belated ones) all share a trivial but blatant tendency to repeatedly reference their source material, now matter how inappropriate it is to the scene. Think the Lost Ark's cameo in Crystal Skull, or the entire third act of Star Trek Into Darkness; it's a strange tool that filmmakers feel they have to use to score points with a fan base, when it's rarely ever essential. Even Ghostbusters 2016, despite existing in a new canon, inexplicably acknowledged the existence of Slimer, Stay Puft, Zuul etc.
Nostalgia is fine in small doses, but you can never be utterly dependant on it. It's mostly redundant and dissatisfying, and indicates a lack of faith in your new material.
For Ghostbusters III, it's probably enough that we're seeing our beloved characters in costume again. The series' usual staples (the fire house, the Ecto-1, Slimer, Ray Parker Jr.'s theme song) all make for nice icing on the cake, but the film overall should have held its concentration on new jokes and imagery, scaling back references to the first two movies.
1. Last Resort: Make It A Cartoon
This is actually an option still potentially open to Sony.
Several years ago, as word on Ghostbusters III was tediously slow, Aykroyd said that the film would probably see light as an animated venture. While it was never mentioned again and has never since been elaborated on, it was an interesting prospect, and is currently the most respectable way to make Ghostbusters III, should it ever happen.
As The Real Ghostbusters and the 2009 video game proved, there's no stipulation that GB has to be live-action to be successful. The writing can still be top-notch and the voice-acting seamless, brought to life in colourful and vibrant animation.
With a cartoon, they can write around a multitude of problems that a live-action film would present. Firstly, a cartoon is time-fluid, and can effortlessly be set in past or present; five years or 30 years after the second film. There'd be no reason to have older Ghostbusters if the story didn't require it, and so could retain their "classic" looks from the original movie.
Another reason is the passing of Harold Ramis. While never the same, a re-casted voice would be much easier to tolerate than a live-action replacement, or worse, a creepy digital stand-in. Additionally Bill Murray (who's no stranger to voice over work) might be very accepting to an animated piece, having done two Garfield movies despite being indifferent to the scripts.
Unlike the other points, none of this is impossible. Ivan Reitman and his Ghost Corps team are already pursuing multiple Ghostbusters ventures, one of which is an animated project. It's clearly something that Sony are willing to explore, and maybe they'll see sense in giving the original boys in grey one last go-around.