Whenever there's a new Christopher Nolan film out you know the closing credits aren't the end of the experience. Dissection of the themes and theorising over its high concepts are all part of the fun. And that's certainly the case with Interstellar, Nolan's latest, which has set the internet alight over the past weekend, although quite in the way we're accustomed to. Unlike Inception or Memento, Interstellar's story is tightly wrapped up by the end with little ambiguity, most of its overarching elements explained explicitly. But that doesn't means there's not some dangling questions that remain unanswered. Today we're going to look at ten of those lingering musings about the film, whether it's concepts shrouded in ambiguity or plot threads still dangling. Naturally spoilers abound from here on in. One question on many people's lips is that, with Cooper influencing his daughter and past self and future humans helping their less-evolved kin, surely there's a big paradox here. How can he go to NASA if he himself needs to tell him to go to NASA? This is a common issue with movies that treat time as a closed, unbreakable loop, but is really more logical than Marty McFly simply fading out of existence - imagine jumping about on a straight line. See The Terminator or 12 Monkeys for more big screen examples of the similar method of time travel. And with that out of the way, let's get on to the ten remaining questions.
10. What Exactly Happened To Earth?
Interstellar opens on an utterly ravaged Earth, where dust storms cloud the landscape and crops are slowly dying out, leading to widespread famine and a back-to-basics humanity. Clearly this science hating, war-free species haven't yet reached the Soylent Green point just yet But while we know the motivation for Cooper and the rest to travel into the stars (literally), there's not actually an explanation for where the problems come from in the first place. Dust storms wouldn't become a regular occurrence in America overnight, while a worldwide blight would have to have some index case. Are the two at all linked? And if so, which came first? They could very easily be co-dependent, but it's less explained than how love is the biggest power in the universe. John Lithgow's Donald comments on how the consumeristic attitude in the present were a damning element of humanity, suggesting that, to some degree, it's our own doing, but the specifics of that are incredibly vague. Potential Answer: Given the institutionalised marginalisation of science, it seems likely that it was humans who initially started all this. You maniacs! Damn you all to hell!
9. Whens It Set?
Speaking of the state of Earth at the start of the movie, one detail completely overlooked is an actual date for the events of the film. Most sci-fi love to proudly state when their version of the future is - Interstellar's touchstone, 2001: A Space Odyssey has it in the title - giving a very concrete view of the future. The obvious danger with this is that when we do get to that year (2015 is, finally, the year Marty McFly visited in Back To The Future: Part II) it all looks a little silly. Nolan probably understands the longevity of his film and kept things vague on purpose, but that doesn't stop it being a niggling question in need of solving. We know that the blight hasn't been around for generations - Donald, Cooper's father, talks about humanity in a time before things went tits up from first-hand experience, while Murph's teacher directly talks about the excess of the 20th Century, meaning our actions now lead directly into the general events of the film. Potential Answer: Using the actor's ages for reference, Donald is probably in his late-sixties and Cooper in his early-forties. As the former has strong memories of the present and the barrage of new gadgets, we can assume he was born in the 1990s or 2000s, putting the latter's birth sometime in the 2020s. This implies the blight is in our near future and the film probably starts in the 2050s or 2060s, running through to the next century.
8. What Happened To The Machines?
As if starvation and suffocating clouds of death dust weren't bad enough, the near-future of Interstellar also sees a reversal of much of the technological development of the past century or so. Much of this has been done consciously to keep humanity's gaze Earth-bound - faking the faking of the moon landings destroys any hope of space exploration. Various technical machines - Cooper's wife died of cancer due to it not being discovered in time - have been deemed useless, no longer functioning either out of conscious choice or general lack of interest. We've not just travelled back to the stone age though; cars and automated farming vehicles still work. What's happened with humanities lack of interest in certain technology? It's entirely possible that only farming-specific machines were kept as they were of the most pressing importance, but that still leaves the question as to whether it was a willing downgrade, or something gradual as things got worse. Potential Answer: As the reliance on basic crops increased, more and more people had to forsake just about every other element of life in favour of farming. NASA was probably one of the first to (officially) go, but costly MRI, which requires a specialist to operate, would be next.
7. Where Is This New Solar System?
The Endurance takes our heroes through the wormhole to a brand new, visually striking solar system. A set of planets orbiting small (and therefore it is assumed stable) black hole, the space dilation of the wormhole means there's no way to know where in the universe these new worlds are. No doubt an astronomer could look at the star patterns and present a solid argument for some location, but until that happens there's little to go on. So what do we know? Water is in high abundance, much more than in our home (there's only one planet where it's entirely prominent, compared to at least three here), but that's hardly geographical. Potential Answer: There's nothing to suggest anything other than it not being our own galaxy. Beyond that it's guesswork based on nothing concrete. In fact, it seems that even NASA themselves don't know where the astronauts are heading. Humanity clearly figures it out though; once they evolve into five-dimensional beings they're able to transport us there.
6. Why Did Tom Become A Dick?
Interstellar may have a protagonist who manages to save humanity through the love for his daughter, but cast isn't short on less well-meaning characters. Dr. Mann is revealed to be a crazed madman who refuses to face the bigger picture, while Professor Brand takes it upon himself to decide the fate of every human being on the planet. But at least in those cases it's people working in extreme situations, making decisions well above what one person should be responsible for. More inexplicable is Tom, Cooper's son, who goes from likeable child to sister-hating hick. In the pre-mission scenes Tom plays a rather minor role, being a more by-the-numbers child character to contrast with the ghost-believing Murph. When he's grown up into Casey Affleck (one of the film's "oh yeah, he's in this" moments) things get a little more interesting - he initially keeps up contact with Endurance, but, after a lack of transmission while Cooper is on the hours-into-years planet, he gives up. He loses his first born son and at some point his relationship with Murph deteriorates, to the point where her even trying to help his second son sends him into a fit of rage. Christmas must be awkward. Potential Answer: It has been joked Tom became aggressive out of resentment over how Cooper shows more affection to Murph, but the characterisation is probably built out of more adult concerns. The loss of a son is a life-changing moment and Murph's refusal to return to the farm house, forsaking everything their father did, could easily sour their relationship.
5. Why Have The Mission At All If Plan A Is A Lie?
When Cooper flies off into the stars the explicitly stated goal is to find a new home for the humans of Earth. This is revealed to be a massive lie, with Plan B, which sees a new brand of human created from embryos populate the new world, with those on Earth left to die, the only viable option. Mass exodus from Earth is, it seems, scientifically impossible. It's a pretty gut-wrenching twist that brings the film's notion of preservation of the species over the self to the fore, but it doesn't do that without raising a pretty large question. If the plan was always to start a new branch of the human race (it clearly was before Dr. Mann left), why didn't they send the embryos in the first place? Bump up the number of astronauts on each of the original twelve scout missions, give them all embryos and send them off to set up colonies if their planet ends up habitable. Sure, you're sending more people to potential death and greatly increasing the cost of the initial mission, but surely it'd be cheaper than the sending the Endurance out there years later. Potential Answer: The only real explanation of this plot hole is that, with NASA more unpopular than Matthew McConaughey five years ago, the prospect of a way for Earth-humans to survive needed to be maintained to keep people working towards the ultimate goal.
4. How Did Time Work In The Singularity?
Like Inception before it, Interstellar showed off Nolan's love of time dilation. This time, instead of deepness of dream levels, it was strength of gravity that led for things to go squiffy. When visiting the planet near the black hole, an hour translated into seven years, so it is to be assumed in the singularity itself this effect would be amplified. That seems to be true to a degree. Cooper spends about ten minutes in there meddling with time and is spat out over fifty years later, a speed up that in general terms fits science theory. But with him leaving linear time all together, things don't appear to be that simple. From when he discovers the bookshelves, Cooper has entered into a three-dimensional version of the fifth dimension, meaning that time isn't passing for him at all, at lest not in the conventional sense. It's not really a plot hole, rather a lack of information means the exact mechanics of the singularity are (unlike the wormhole, which got its layman explanation) incredibly muddy. Potential Answer: Cooper is perceiving the fifth dimension, but that doesn't mean he's left three-dimensional space - time is still moving for him slightly, hence why he can make it to his future. Now why did he get deposited as Saturn?
3. Was The Fifth Dimension Natural Or Human Induced?
If you ejected yourself into a black hole you'd not make it anywhere close to the centre. This is where the "fi" part of sci-fi really comes into Interstellar - after a lot of grounded science-fact Interstellar jumps gleefully into the unknown with the singularity. And, just as the logic of its time-flow is uncertain, the exact reasoning behind what Cooper experiences in the black hole is vague. Realising that the beings who have been helping humans are not aliens, but us from a distant future, Cooper appears to assume this whole experience has been orchestrated by a higher power in the same way he's just helped Murph. This makes the trip into the singularity something incredibly similar to 2001's stargate; just as Bowman isn't just going inside the monolith, Cooper isn't actually inside the singularity. But that is a mind-f**k in its own right. As TARS is able to discern the key to the gravity equation, clearly they are at the centre of the black hole, meaning this could just be what happens when you venture into one. Potential Answer: Taking a bit of both you get a somewhat logical (in the film world) explanation - Cooper is being helped through the singularity by future humans. But that's still highly contentious.
2. Will The Embryos Be Used?
The real motivation behind the Endurance is to sow humanities seeds in the stars, with the species continued through fertilised embryos at the sacrifice of those still on Earth. This is born out of the belief that the gravity equation has no solution, something that Cooper's singularity meddling reveals to not be true; science mumbo-jumbo from the black hole means that somehow we can all escape the pull of Earth with ease. At the end, with humanity by the Saturn wormhole and gearing up to head to their new home, it appears the whole of Plan B is rather unnecessary. But that doesn't mean the embryos are going to go unused. Dr. Brand has no conformation that TARS managed to get any usable information from the black hole, so for all she knows Plan B is still the only option. To that end she'd probably try her best to continue the species, bringing the first generation of Edmund's-planet humans into being (assuming the technology exists for this to be done single-handedly). Which poses another question - how does Plan B work logistically? Can the new humans be grown test-tube style, or do they need a human womb? And if it's the latter, why was only one woman sent on the Endurance mission? Potential Answer: Even if she heard about Murph's eureka moment, the scientist is unlikely to assume this is immediate salvation - going forward there'll be two branches of humanity.
1. Why Hasn't Dr. Brand Aged?
The end of the film takes place almost a hundred years after the opening, with Cooper 124 years old (turns out black holes are the best defence against ageing) and Murph an old woman. The final shot, however, reveals Dr. Brand on Edmund's planet looking much the same as she did throughout the film. If we're to assume this is taking place at the same time as Murph implores Cooper to go find her, then it poses a massive timeline snafu. The effects of the black hole on time dilation across the new system are unclear, but as Edmund's planet is further out than Mann's there shouldn't be that much difference in the passage of time between Earth and the new world. So after Cooper's sacrifice, time should have moved concurrently between Brand and Murph, meaning the astronaut should be in her seventies by now. There is of course the possibility for time dilation when slingshotting around the black hole to have allowed for her to age slower, as well as the added possibility that the image of Brand is just how Cooper imagines it, but as nothing's confirmed it's all theoretical. Potential Answer: It's all sneaky editing, presenting multiple timelines as happening simultaneously. Dr. Brand has probably already got a settlement set up, whether with more humans or not is, as previously discussed, unknown. What questions do you still have about Interstellar? And do you have an concrete solutions for ours? Get the discussion going in the comments below.