Interstellar: 10 Superior Philosophical Sci-Fi Films

Space smarts with 100% less Topher Grace.

By Tom Baker /

Christopher Nolan€™s latest has been endlessly compared to Stanley Kubrick€™s 2001: A Space Odyssey, and not without good reason. The director himself has cited Kubrick€™s sci-fi epic as an inspiration, and that€™s clear to see in Interstellar: whilst Nolan€™s blessed with several more decades of IRL space travel and research to draw upon, he has a similar dedication to getting things scientifically accurate, whilst also pinging off into the more speculative, hypothetical worlds of the human condition. Interstellar is about saving humanity from extinction as much as 2001 is about monkeys and space travel. Or at least, it tries to be. Where Kubrick€™s film is a deep exploration of our place in the universe, Interstellar€™s journey beyond the stars returns audiences to that most trite of Hollywood truisms: love is the most powerful force in the universe. Love is all you need. If The Beatles sang about it, it€™s probably not a challenging philosophical quandary. So perhaps Nolan€™s preoccupations aren€™t as deep as he thought (although they are profoundly shallow) (and pretty). Want something a little meatier to get your teeth into? Here are ten superior philosophical sci-fi films to Interstellar.

10. Sunshine

Danny Boyle€™s underrated second collaboration with screenwriter Alex Garland shares a lot of the same DNA as Interstellar, both in its influences and its mechanics. Garland and Boyle too looked upon real-world science to fuel their movie (in this case relying on now-celebrity astrophysicist Brian Cox), which was inspired in equal parts by the Kubrickian sci-fi Nolan went for as more popcorn-worthy blockbusters as Alien. Many were disappointed by the third act of Sunshine, when it shifted gears into a sort of slasher film finale, partly because the set up had been so interesting. Like Interstellar, the world in Sunshine is on the verge of extinction. That€™s because the sun that provides all life in our solar system is giving out, and it need to be "restarted" with a bunch of nuclear explosions. Similar to Nolan€™s film, the very premise has the voyage of the Icarus II an obvious suicide mission, bringing up ideas of people sacrificing their lives to save millions more. It also touches on multiculturalism, with the racially diverse crew, stuff about the "will of god" and whether humanity even deserves to survive - something Interstellar doesn't even entertain as a possibility.

9. Twelve Monkeys

When it comes to mind-bending sci-fi films, Nolan should've looked as much to Terry Gilliam as Kubrick. Where the director of 2001 only had one space-based film under his belt, the former Monty Python animator and writer has formed an eclectic and eccentric career making movies that deal with esoteric scientific concepts coupled with big philosophical questions, from the 1984-esque dystopia-disguised-as-utopia Brazil to the ethical concerns about time travel that Time Bandits brings up (okay, not really, but that is an excellent film, no?). Nowhere is that more clear than in Twelve Monkeys. Loosely inspired by the short French film La Jetée, Twelve Monkeys explores similar ideas about fate, predestination and humanity€™s ability to leave any sort of lasting impression on the world. Bruce Willis is continually sent back from a ravaged future Earth to try and stop the plague that will eventually destroy humanity; except when he€™s back in the past, he gets committed to a mental asylum, and has to conspire with Brad Pitt€™s radical animal rights activist to escape. Except Pitt might be the guy who accidentally unleashes the disease which will doom his species...or is it an accident? Twelve Monkeys keeps audiences guessing.

8. Close Encounters Of The Third Kind

The other big influence on Interstellar (and this is again coming straight from the horse€™s mouth) (Christopher Nolan being the horse in this analogy) is the more optimistic science fiction of Steven Spielberg. Nolan has said in interviews that he hoped to harken back to a previous age of sci-fi films, of the era that Spielberg was making things like Close Encounters Of The Third Kind, with the same sense of wonder and exploration humanity has lost in its space programmes, both in real life and in Interstellar. Like JJ Abrams with Super 8, he maybe should've kept quiet about that particular influence. Because when you start opening your big mouth about the films that have inspired your own, you€™re instantly opening them up for comparison. And rarely will you come out on top, especially when you€™re going up against a cinematic titan like Spielberg. Whether you€™re going with the theatrical release or director€™s cut (which has since been disavowed due to its radically different ending), Close Encounters is a superior film to Interstellar, but especially in its answer to the question about our place in the universe, and whether humans are alone as the sole intelligent species.

7. Timecrimes

Interstellar hints at elements of time travel, with Matthew McConaughey€™s Cooper eventually winding up in some fifth dimension beyond human comprehension, where time is visible not as a linear thing but as a physical object happening all at once. That final act twist has inspired plenty of fan theories about how earlier events in the film could have been the work of Cooper, or else some other fifth dimensional beings, messing with the fabric of reality, but it doesn't tie those elements up in a particularly satisfying (or even surprising) way. The eventual "twist" that Cooper was the ghost interacting with daughter Murphy wasn't all that shocking. For a time travel movie that's packed to the gills with insane turns and surprises, you could do worse than Nacho Vigalondo€™s Timecrimes, a Spanish-language thriller whose nested timelines and murder-mystery-throughout-time plot was ripped off by the likes of Convergence and Triangle. There€™s a lot in there about paradoxes, the nature of reality, and time as a flat circle, doomed to repeat. McConaughey knows something about that.

6. Stalker

Nolan likes to put cool little Easter eggs in many of his films, and Interstellar is no exception. Remember those sassy military robots who assist the astronauts throughout the film? Each is named for a different influence on Interstellar: CASE after pioneering astrophysicist Carl Sagan, KIPP after scientist Kip Thorne who came up with the initial idea for the movie, and undoubted star of the show TARPS after legendary Russian director Andrei Tarkovsky. Tarkovsky made many amazing, mind-blowing films in his career, but the pinnacle was almost certainly Stalker. Loosely adapted from the novel Roadside Picnic by fellow visionary Ruskies Arkady and Boris Strugatsky, Stalker is one of the strangest, most abstract road movies ever made. Set in a vaguely dystopian future, the titular character is charged with guiding a couple of clients on an expedition to "The Zone", an unpopulated area which has the supposed potential to fulfil a person's innermost desires. It€™s implied that The Zone was the sight of either some nuclear disaster or visitation by aliens, exploring similar themes to Interstellar and 2001, but in a much more satisfyingly bizarre way.

5. Solaris

Tarkovsky was also responsible for the first adaptation of Polish sci-fi author Stanis‚aw Lem€™s Solaris, but it€™s Steven Soderbergh€™s version in 2002 that hewed a little closer to the source material. Starring starring George Clooney and Natascha McElhone, Soderbergh€™s take on Solaris manages to be both more accessible that the 1972 version, whilst also delving deeper into a lot of the philosophical and psychological themes Lem was tackling in his novel. Don€™t worry, it still involves an intrepid bunch of astronauts venturing into space and happening across something they weren't expecting. It€™s just Solaris has a lot more to say than Interstellar. Set almost entirely upon a space station orbiting the eponymous, far-flung planet, Solaris is all about the nature of memory, and the way that it can become twisted, fractured, and affect our modern lives even when they€™re just ephemeral moments from the past. Like, heavy stuff, man. Clooney struggles with hallucinations of his wife, who had committed suicide years before; apparently, something in the planet is causing these painful memories to not only return, but almost come back to life. A tough watch, but a rewarding one to say the least.

4. Primer

Speaking of tough watches, it€™s pretty much guaranteed that you€™re going to have to watch Shane Carruth€™s singularly genius and incomprehensible time travel film more than once. Possibly with a book with which to take copious notes. Thankfully Primer€™s only 77 minutes long, which makes repeat viewings fairly easy; unfortunately, before he became a one-man film studio (he writes, directs, stars in, produces, edits and composes the music for the movie), Carruth was a college graduate with a degree in mathematics and a former engineer. And he is very much a believer in not talking down to the audience. All well and good until you decide to make the most scientifically accurate film about time travel to date. Like Interstellar, Primer deals with existing scientific concepts and extrapolates them a little further. What it never does is couch that in a conventional narrative, or ever "dumb down" all the jargon for the layman. You€™ll inevitably get lost. Even more so when the time travel causes alternate versions of the characters to begin piling up, manipulating each other and the stock market to make their millions, all the while bringing up questions about the nature of self when copies can be so easily created, and the ethics of playing god in such a way. Probably. Maybe another viewing is in order...

3. Upstream Colour

If there€™s one thing you could never accuse Shane Carruth of being, it€™s a sell out. And if there€™s one thing you can most certainly accuse him of being is wilfully obtuse. After the surprise cult success of Primer, which he made entirely on his own dime (the budget was a fairly modest $7000), Carruth decided to go all-out with his follow up. Again doing basically everything in the production besides the catering, Upstream Colour is a similarly bizarre and difficult to understand film as Primer, and it takes the philosophical underpinnings of that debut to even stranger and more complicated avenues. The loose "plot" of Upstream Colour, if you can call it that, involves a man and a woman whose lives are forever changed (unbeknownst to them) by a complex parasite which dictates their moods and behaviours. A parasite which later enters its second and third stages of its life cycle, where it inhabits pigs and orchids, but it€™s the first stage that€™s off most interest to the audience. Carruth€™s Jeff and Amy Seimetz€™s Kris both struggle to regain their very identities after the experience, and not like, they misplaced their driver€™s licences. They genuinely have trouble reconciling their very personalities after having seemingly lost them. That€™ll mess you up.

2. The Man Who Fell To Earth

The obvious joke about Nicolas Roeg€™s 1976 film is that it wasn't much of a stretch for its star - little-known musician David Bowie - to play a paranoid, fragile and skeletal alien being from another world. That€™s basically what he was like at the time, being well into his phase of consuming only milk, red peppers and copious amounts of cocaine, a state that Roeg took full advantage in crafting the character of Thomas Jerome Newton, an extraterrestrial who quite literally fell to Earth. The Man Who Fell To Earth is, essentially, a flipped version of Interstellar. Here Newton is an alien from a planet that is suffering a terrible drought, sent to our planet to find out if its a suitable place for his race to emigrate to. Where the astronauts of Interstellar find hope amongst the stars, however, Newton€™s naive and pure self is hopelessly corrupted by human society, as he falls to alcoholism, drug addiction, abusive relationships and eventual kidnap and experimentation by the US government. There€™s also some stuff in there about time dilation and aging, but ultimately, The Man Who Fell To Earth is like a pessimistic counterpoint to Nolan€™s film. Plus it has David Bowie, which is a pretty great selling point.

1. 2001: A Space Odyssey

Anyway, enough beating around the bush. Stanley Kubrick€™s 1968 film is the gold standard against which all later philosophical sci-fi films have been compared. That€™s why Nolan was a little foolish to acknowledge its influence so publicly; Interstellar can€™t really hold a candle to it. How could it possibly manage to do so, with 2001: A Space Odyssey being the monolith that inspired all that came after it? A film that spans the earliest moment in humanity€™s evolution before jumping forward to, presumably, the next big leap in our level of consciousness and understanding of the universe, Kubrick€™s adaptation of Arthur C Clarke€™s novel - which was actually being written concurrently with the film production - is a lot more open to interpretation that the source material. Look, it€™s even got a whole Wikipedia page dedicated to different readings of the film, from the infuriatingly literal to the slightly bonkers claim it€™s a retelling of Frankenstein. 2001 is a philosophical puzzle that, even half a century later, audiences have been unable to crack.