Iron Man 3: 5 Things It Got Right & 5 Things It Got Wrong

By K.J. Stewart /

Overall, I was very impressed with Iron Man 3. I'm a die-hard comic book fan who wasn't particularly impressed with The Dark Knight Rises or any of the X-Men movies, so for me to be impressed by it generally means it's doing something right - and in this case it got most things right. Of that there is no doubt. But it wasn't perfect. I may be being picky, but I did think that some aspects of the movie could have been handled better. Shane Black took over the directorial reins and the movie certainly had a different feel to it, in comparison to the previous Iron Man instalments, but that didn't take anything away from the quality of the movie. However, it definitely had some problems and to write a balanced article I'm going to look at both the positive and negative aspects of the movie. So, without further ado, here are 5 things Iron Man 3 got right and 5 things it got wrong (for those of you who are yet to see the movie, this article contains spoilers)...

5. Pepper Potts

Pepper Potts (Gwyneth Paltrow) was awesome in this movie. Although she has never been afraid to stand up to Tony Stark (Robert Downey Jr.), she was essentially his lapdog in the first Iron Man Movie. Iron Man 2 saw her hesitantly promoted to CEO of Stark Industries and her brief appearance in the Avengers movie confirmed her in that role and also as the girlfriend of Tony. Iron Man 3, however, saw her become the dominant half of the Stark/Pepper relationship - even threatening to leave Tony if he didn't become more attentive to her. However, the coolest thing about Pepper Potts in this movie was that she showed an ability to get her hands dirty by getting physical. First of all, she donned the Iron Man armour during the attack on Stark's mansion - and used it effectively - and then, having been infected with the Extremis virus, she saved the day when Stark was in deep, deep trouble at the hands of Aldrich Killian. It was a nice nod to the comic books, in which she has a suit of her own and becomes the super-heroine 'Rescue'.

4. Humour

Despite the general darker tone of this movie (thanks largely to Tony's emotional instability following the events of the Avengers movie), the humour is still as good - if not better - than ever before. Tony's wit and sense of humour is still evident even during his panic attacks, while his banter with Harley is fantastic and hilarious, and the moment in which he tried to deceive Pepper in to thinking he was wearing his armour 'around the house' is a gem. The funniest moment for me, however, came when Tony fought his way in to the Mandarin's mansion, only to be caught before escaping by calling his armour. Tony fought off a tide of henchman whilst wearing only one leg piece and one arm piece of his armour, before the rest of it had arrived. With only one henchman remaining, the poor schmuck declared "Dude, I don't even like working here! These guys are weird!" before being allowed to leave unharmed. Brilliant.

3. Tony And Harley

Following an attack on Stark's luxury Malibu mansion by Killian's forces, it is left destroyed and Tony is left unconscious in his armour. His armour, however, had already been set co-ordinates for rural Tennessee (to check out a previous scene of Killian's crimes) and JARVIS follows the flight-plan despite the fact that Tony is not awake to navigate. Upon his arrival, his suit and JARVIS are left non-functional and Tony is alone in the wilderness. He makes his way to a small town where he meets Harley - a young boy. Much to his initial chagrin, Tony befriends the boy and his help in finding Tony a place to settle and getting his hands on some key resources are decisive in Tony's progression through the movie. They build a rapport and the relationship allows us to see Stark's human side in more detail. After the initial shock of seeing him, Harley doesn't care about Tony's fame, fortune or genius - to him he's just a guy. But his fascination with Iron Man and the suits allows Tony to get closer to him and utilise him, whilst also genuinely coming to have affection for him. The chemistry between the two actors was great and enabled us to see a side of Stark that we had never before seen.

2. Special Effects

The Marvel Cinematic Universe's special effects have been pretty spectacular from the get-go, but Iron Man 3 stepped up a gear and really produced the goods. The scene involving the multiple suits fighting Killian and his henchmen was breathtaking (potentially even out-doing the final battle in the Avengers movie on the goose bump-generation scale) and the glow emitted by the Extremis soldiers was cool as hell, but the one scene that really blew me away was when Tony used to JARVIS to recreate the scene of one of Killian's atrocities. Tony's friend and 'Head of Security', Happy Hogan (John Favreau), finds himself falling victim to one of the Mandarin's attacks outside the TCL Chinese Theatre in Hollywood - being knocked out and in to a coma by the explosion - but not before pointing to a military dog tag while he faded into unconsciousness. At the time, the audience is left wondering why he's pointing to it and who he's doing it for the benefit of. But, using JARVIS, Tony accessed SHIELD's database as well as various government databases to piece together the Mandarin's crimes, culminating in an exact 3D holographic recreation of the Hollywood disaster scene, which allowed Tony to witness Hogan pointing to the dog tag, giving him the information he needed to find the perpetrator of the crime. The visuals were absolutely stunning in this scene and the movie's effects as a whole were out-of-this-world.

1. The Action

Another key aspect of the movie that stepped up a gear from previous MCU instalments was the all-important action scenes. As you would expect, the fight scenes when Tony was wearing his armour were outstanding - particularly when he utilised an army of his armours ('his boys') in the final battle with Killian and his henchmen - but Tony also got his hands dirty outside of his armour, proving himself to be a capable hand-to-hand combatant and action hero without it. The other scenes that stand out for heart-racing action were the attack on Tony's mansion, in which the Mandarin's forces blow it to smithereens with helicopter gunships, and the scene involving the President's aeroplane (Air Force One), in which thirteen passengers are falling to their inevitable deaths following Killian's on-board assault before Iron Man saves the day. Generally speaking, the action was a lot more relentless than in previous Iron Man films and indeed more so than other films in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Now let's look at 5 things Iron Man 3 got wrong...

5. The Mandarin

This one goes without saying, so let's get it out of the way first... So it turns out Ben Kingsley's character was just a drunken, bumbling actor playing the Mandarin and that the 'real' Mandarin is Aldrich Killian (Guy Pearce). Now, I'm not saying that a reinvention of the Mandarin was a bad idea - it certainly isn't, because a martial artist tearing Iron Man's armour with his bare hands wouldn't really work in the Marvel Cinematic Universe - but Iron Man 3 didn't really reinvent the Mandarin at all. It could have been done so much better. What Iron Man 3 essentially did was give the Mandarin name to a completely different villain from the comics, which ultimately means that the Mandarin doesn't really exist in the MCU. It would have been one thing to change the Mandarin character - Perhaps by giving him some tech to rival Tony's, such as making his rings tech-based instead of alien-magic-based to make him fit in more with what we've come to expect in the MCU, but what has actually happened is that the Extremis-enhanced Aldrich Killian - a villain who is memorable enough from the Extremis comic book arc to stand alone in a movie - has taken the name 'Mandarin' without taking any other elements of the character. This has basically denied the audience the opportunity to see a real on-screen interpretation of the villain who is essentially Iron Man's greatest foe. It's like denying Superman movie viewers the opportunity to ever see Lex Luthor or General Zod. It's like having a Batman trilogy without utilising the Joker. It's like giving Venom eight tentacles and calling him Doctor Octopus. As great as the film was, it leaves the audience (comic book fans in particular) feeling cheated with regards to the Mandarin.

4. The Ten Rings

The fake Mandarin was wearing ten rings and when the Mandarin broadcasted his messages around the globe there was a Ten Rings symbol that appeared on the television screen before the address was made but, other than that, Iron Man 3 was totally lacking in any real exploration of the Ten Rings organisation. Sure, they were supposedly behind the bombings that took place around the world (thanks to Killian's financing), but they were never deeply explored. Since the first Iron Man movie, when the organisation was responsible for Tony Stark's kidnapping in war-torn Afghanistan, movie-goers have been anticipating the Mandarin being the leader of the Ten Rings and being the big bad behind the evil plots of the previous two movies. Even the trailers for Iron Man 3 showed a close-up of the fake Mandarin wearing ten rings, leading us to believe they would be a key part of the plot of the third instalment. Sadly, that wasn't the case, and it was in fact Aldrich Killian's AIM organisation (Advanced Idea Mechanics) that were behind the creation of the Extremis virus in the movie, while the Ten Rings were comparatively only given a passing mention and were seen merely as an understudy to AIM. A bit of an anti-climax, to say the least.

3. The Post-Credits Scene

The post-credits scene in Iron Man 3 is simply Tony Stark sat talking to Bruce Banner (Mark Ruffalo) in a patient/doctor setting. The ending to the actual movie itself left doors open without setting anything in stone for Iron Man/Tony Stark, but I expected more doors to potentially open for universal expansion in the post-credits scene. Don't get me wrong, it was cool to see Bruce sitting 'listening' to Tony Stark recounting his experiences and I don't want to seem ungrateful - it's not as if Marvel have to put anything after the credits, after all. However, by introducing key entities such as Thor's hammer (Mjolnir), the Tesseract and Thanos after the credits in previous MCU outings, they've built up our hopes for something really interesting to occur after the credits in all future instalments. This scene just didn't seem to be enough for me. After waiting for what seemed like forever for the millions of credited names to roll by, I expected more. I know that Phase 1 of the MCU was all about expansion and Phase 2 is focusing more on the movie at hand, but I wanted more from this scene. Even if it was just a hint at the existence of another major character or item - something to keep me guessing. They could even have quite easily given us a sneak peek at one of the upcoming films that we already know is in the pipeline, such as Thor 2 or Guardians of the Galaxy. Sadly, this scene didn't really go anywhere and doesn't really seem to have any real use in the grand scheme of things.

2. Nobody Died

A bleak view, you may think, but the trailer's teased the potential deaths of both/either Pepper Potts or Happy Hogan - two people to whom Tony Stark is very close. Aside from Agent Phil Coulson (whom it would appear didn't really die anyway, given his imminent appearance in Marvel's SHIELD television series), there haven't really been any major casualties on the side of good in the Marvel Cinematic Universe and it's about time that changed. A key death of someone close to one of the main heroes would really change the dynamic and give them some real purpose and it would have been even more of a rollercoaster to see how Tony dealt with the loss of someone close to him. Of course, Pepper Potts seemingly died in the movie, only to reappear having survived due the Extremis virus, while Happy Hogan's life hung in the balance while he was comatose, but he regained consciousness at the end and watched himself some Downton Abbey. I know Disney are behind the MCU movies now, but these happy endings are getting a little bit repetitive and tedious.

1. The Arc Reactor Removal

Okay, now this bugged me a lot. For me, the arc reactor is an essential part of who Tony is, so to remove it feels like he's had his soul extracted. But that's not even my biggest issue with this. If it was so easy to remove the arc reactor and the shrapnel from Tony's chest, why didn't he do it sooner? Why did he make a new one when the first one started malfunctioning in the first movie? Why didn't he just get it removed there and then? More to the point, I'm fairly sure that it was explicitly pointed out in the first movie (during his cave encounter with Yinsen) that there was no way the shrapnel could be removed, as doing so would outright kill Tony. If it had been removed over a period of time, after extensive research in to it had been carried out and medical advancements had been developed, then it might have made sense. But it was like he just decided to have it removed willy nilly and next thing you know it was out. There was no way it should have been so simple and it devalued a lot of what had occurred in previous movies. Dishonourable mention: Why was there no AC/DC?! What did you thing Iron Man 3 got right? What did you think it got wrong? Do you agree with the points in this article? Let us know in the comments box below.