Joker: Every Character Ranked Worst To Best
How do Gotham's newest residents fare?
Joker is what many film-makers aspire to make - a revelatory, transgressive character piece that focused unflinchingly on its subject and explores some incredibly important subject matter through that filter. It is the tale of one man's transformation, but he is very much at the epicentre of a world that includes other key characters, mostly played by some incredibly gifted actors.
You probably already know the answer, but who comes out of it best is a pretty loaded question - particularly with Joaquin Phoenix rubbing shoulders with the likes of Brian Tyree Henry, Brett Cullen, Frances Conroy and of course Robert DeNiro.
In truth, the film COULD have been a one man show and it would still have been utterly intoxicating, such is the strength of that one character, but the decision was made to include an entire roster of characters. And it's fair to say that not all of them were quite as equal as others.
13. Ted Marco
Originally announced as Arthur's agent, Marc Maron's Ted Marco is on screen twice in Joker for a grand total of about 40 seconds in total. It feels very much like the majority of his role has been left on the cutting room floor, because all he gets to do is admonish Arthur for daring to call Murray Franklin "Murray" and not "Mr Franklin" and witnessing the conversation between Murray and Arthur about why he's dressed as a clown and why he wants to be called Joker.
Fundamentally, he could have been left out of the film entirely and absolutely nothing would have changed, which is a travesty when you consider how brilliant Marc Maron is. It's no more than a cameo and it might have been okay if it wasn't announced beforehand as if he had some relevance at all.
12. Gary
Most notably seen in Get Santa and as the actor playing Tyrion Lannister in the street players' company, Leigh Gill isn't a particularly well-known actor and he gets a slightly unfair deal in Joker. Presumably included as a means to show Arthur's affinity for other people who face struggles, Gary is a dwarf who works for the same clown company as him.
Unfortunately, any attempt at drawing lines between the two is undone pretty horribly by the script's insistence on jokes at his expense. Obviously, there's some intention to just reflect how awful Gotham's people are generally, but it's a shame they went this way.
And equally unfortunately, when Gill is asked to be the reaction gauge to one particularly brutal scene, his acting is... not good.
11. Bruce Wayne
As was promised well before release, Bruce Wayne isn't a major presence in Joker. He turns up only a couple of times, once when Arthur goes to Wayne Manor to find out more about the truth of his past and once right at the end in one of the film's most brilliant moments. No spoiling that here.
We all know how great a character Bruce is and there's a lot to be said about how the film portrays a key part of his story, but this is absolutely not his film and he's almost entirely undeveloped as a real character as a result.
There's no fault in the performance really, because there isn't one and there's no reason to really want more of him either. But it's hard to say too much positively about him either.
10. Alfred Pennyworth
Imagine a world where Alfred - Batman's kindly, almost matriarchal protector and servant (and much more than that besides) - is reimagined as a far more prickly, far less likeable character... That's this world.
Rather cruelly, that's the lot given to Douglas Hodge, a brilliantly talented, multi-Olivier award-winning actor (watch him in Catastrophe, it's genius and so is he). And while it might seem unfair to mess around with such a beloved character, it does make sense, because it's key to remember that everything that happens in this movie happens through the filter of Arthur's eyes.
The backstory for the Waynes and the crossover with the Fleck family is a delicate matter and there is obviously a lot of trauma there, so it's understandable that Alfred reacts as he does to Arthur, but given what he SHOULD know about Arthur's past, it's weird that a care-giver would be so cold to someone who'd been through so much.
9. Burke & Garrity
As with Marc Maron's casting, the decision to hire Shea Whigham and Bill Camp - two very good character actors who have previously been great in meaty roles - to play the two detectives investigating key murders around Gotham looked like a masterstroke. They add not only a familiarity element, but their profiles also validate the film's credentials even more.
Except, they're not really given anything to do. This isn't a police procedural and though the duo would be eminently watchable in that sort of set-up, the film here just sort of leaves them behind. In the end, they feel like stunt-casting, hired to disguise how little they're involved, which is all well and good but it does mean it's a little disappointing.
They do get to be involved in a key sequence and Whigham's acting does mean you can't fail to be swept up in the emotion of it, but it's just so little for two such fine actors to do.
8. Arkham State Hospital Clerk
Brian Tyree Henry's casting is once again a case of an incredibly gifted actor being an exciting inclusion on the castlist and then doing largely nothing of note. He ranks slightly higher than the others in the same bracket, however, because his scene with Arthur is a little more entertaining.
He plays an administrative clerk working in Arkham Asylum, who tells Arthur why people end up locked up there (it's a low-key VERY important bit of information if you choose to interpret the film in a certain way I again won't spoil here). He's also pretty terrible at his job, because he retrieves the file Arthur asks for and while telling him he can't release it without the key paperwork, reveals the information Arthur is looking for and then allows him to run away with the file, despite being behind an attack-proof meshed window.
Henry's performance is good - and he seems to be the only person who actually treats Arthur as a normal human might - but again, he just hasn't got a great deal to do.
7. Debra Kane
Sharon Washington's role is a rather thankless one as she plays the therapist at the forefront of Gotham's failure of Arthur. She's not an unsympathetic figure, but she's symptomatic of a broken machine, under-funded and unable to care for the people who need it most.
As such, their sessions - as Arthur says - devolve into her asking the same thing over and over and him genuinely feeling worse than he did before he started. It's a stark revelation, but it's something that genuinely does happen for people struggling with mental health issues and it's something that we've not seen explored nearly enough in films and TV shows.
She's one of the only characters to express any sort of concern for Arthur, but in the end, she's forced to give up on him, as the trailers revealed.
6. Randall
Randall is an awful person, make no bones about it. He's one of Arthur's fellow clown agency employees, played by Glenn Fleshler, who has a great track record in lots of really fine TV shows (including True Detective and Billions). He also seems to be everything that Arthur hates because he betrays him.
Randall appears to have Arthur's best interests at heart, but when the time comes to choose between protecting him and his own self-interests, he turns rat immediately. And he gets his comeuppance in one of the film's most dizzyingly intense scenes, which somehow perfectly blends brutality with pitch black comedy.
He basically lives for that scene to happen, because it helps explain certain distinctions in Arthur's character, because it proves he's not a fully realised monster. Or at least that he has his own moral compass still in place.
5. Sophie Dumond
Because of an incredibly clever quirk of the film's narrative, Sophie is a strangely undeveloped character, remaining sort of ethereal. There is a very good reason for this, which sets the tone for the rest of the film's elusive narrative trust, but it does come at a necessary cost to her as a character. She's the way she is, because that's how Arthur sees her, effectively.
Considering how many people threw around accusations of Arthur being an incel and being inspired to become a monster because of Sophie's rejection of him, it's good that the film refuses to be drawn on such an obvious choice and we get something far more interesting in its place.
For what it's worth, Zazie Beetz does well with the material she's given, particular the last scene she's involved in and it's a restrained performance that is a lot cleverer than it might be given credit for, because at no point does it give the game away.
4. Penny Fleck
The true mark of how impressive Frances Conroy's performance as Penny Fleck is is that she COULD have very easily have been something a lot more obvious and a lot less subtle. But because this film genuinely seems to care about its portraits of mental health issues, she appears entirely "normal" in stark contrast to other characters who might typically be considered her narrative siblings.
Penny is at the heart of the film's big twist, which we all thought she would be - even if it's not quite the same one as was suspected - and while she could have been involved a little more, it actually does make sense that her screentime is limited. All Todd Phillips wants us to see at first is how her closeness with Arthur - who she calls "Happy" completely transforms his demeanour.
She's harmless and vulnerable and she represents Arthur's soft centre, and to that end, Conroy does very well.
3. Thomas Wayne
As with the portrait of Alfred, this universe's Thomas Wayne is a different prospect to the legacy of the character that typically hangs over Batman movies. He is an instrument of corporate greed and lack of humanity, a self-appointed idol for the rich who will throttle Gotham into submission for its own good if he's elected.
But there are two Waynes here, it's important to note, and it's very much key to challenge whether this portrait of Wayne is true, or whether it is a result of what Arthur is being told to think. His mind is a vessel into which lots has been poured and it inevitably shapes how he sees people. Because we see his story through his eyes too, we see Wayne as he does.
In that respect, Brett Cullen is great. He's regal, believably detached and thoroughly detestable without really doing TOO much to earn it. And when it's required, he's also crucially sympathetic.
2. Murray Franklin
Robert DeNiro's role in Joker is like a walking Easter Egg - or at least a tribute to the two major narrative influences to this movie's story: Taxi Driver and The King Of Comedy. His casting almost feels like a thanks for gifting Todd Phillips those movies to riff off.
Murray Franklin - a wildly popular late night talk-show host and comedian whose power over his viewers Arthur imagines to be as powerful as it is over he himself - is also a full circle role for DeNiro who was cast in The King Of Comedy as a similar figure to Arthur opposite Jerry Lewis. It's a genius bit of meta casting.
He's not actually in it a great deal, but his observations of a certain type of entertainment show host (right down to his slightly too fake, too white teeth and his slightly too fake-tanned skin) are perfect and he lends a good bit of credentials as you'd expect.
1. Arthur Fleck
Take away everyone else on this list and Joker would still be a great film. It might lack some narrative depth, but watching Joaquin Phoenix explore the performance in even more detail would not be a bad thing.
The final testament to how good he is is that this subtle, nuanced, incredibly layered performance should and very much could land him a Best Actor award at the Oscars next year. If he doesn't win it will be because of a stunning performance in the next few months that we haven't seen yet.
Phoenix is horribly watchable, a visceral embodiment of a man born out of trauma. His physical performance, helped gruesomely by his dramatic weight loss is mesmerising and the way he switches between layers of performance (as his characters, rather than in acting terms) is utterly brilliant.
Which of Joker's characters did you like best? Share your assessments below in the comments thread.