Joker: Every Death Ranked
The bloody emancipation of one Arthur Fleck...
In case you missed the implications of the R rating or the fact that this film is about one of the most famous serial killers in all of comics history, Joker is a fairly bloody movie.
It's disturbing and perverse, but it doesn't wade into Tarantino-like exploitation waters, mercifully, and unlike the comic book movies that kill cannon fodder for effect, every death in it matters to the narrative. They range in type though and it's worth going through them all to explore what they mean and which ones left the biggest marks...
OBVIOUSLY, SPOILERS WILL FOLLOW FOR JOKER.
7. The Innocent Clown
We don't ever get to learn his name, but the clown protestor killed on the Gotham train when Arthur escapes from Detectives Garrity and Burke (wonderfully cast, but woefully underused) is the real trigger moment for Gotham burning. It's also an important moment in Arthur's transformation.
Up until that point, Arthur felt kinship with the clowns without feeling a part of their movement - as he says, he "believes in nothing" - but seeing the clowns effectively protect him (at least that would be his take) reinforces the final change in his character. It's that moment that turns him into Gotham's clown prince.
The death itself would be the central tragedy in another movie - an exhibit of police brutality - but it's almost throw-away here. He struggles with Burke as he pulls his gun and ends up shot and killed. A harsh end, but an important moment.
6. The Cops
Right at the end of the movie, you get the feeling that Arthur is headed for justice, because though this is a dark, grim world, there's still a semblance of lawful order (it's just not all that effective). Plus, what he did can't exactly be glossed over, given the pageantry of it.
But just as he's heading to the police station after his arrest, his cross-Gotham journey is interrupted by a stolen ambulance smashing into the side of the police car and killing the cops in the front. It's a typically unflinching moment and its brutality still comes as a surprise, but it's a great way to cement Joker as a misplaced symbol of Gotham's defiant rise against the rich.
5. Penny Fleck
The film's greatest narrative trick is establishing a story that we all completely believed about Arthur's relationship with Thomas Wayne in the marketing and then playing around with ideas of reality and fantasy so much that while there's an alternative answer at the end, it's not entirely clear if it's real.
The important thing, though, is that Arthur comes to his own definitive answer, believing that his mother is a monster who hid the heinous crimes against Arthur of his youth - all of which shaped him as a man. She's revealed to be profoundly mentally ill but Arthur takes his revenge with great pleasure, suffocating her in her hospital bad while coldly calling her Penny to open the wound further.
It's a grim moment and one that marks the death of Arthur himself in a way, because the decision not to pull away from him as he pushes the pillow onto her face makes you feel almost complicit.
4. Murray Franklin
The culmination of the movie sees Arthur appear on Murray Franklin's show. This should be his dream realised, not only for Murray to validate him (he imagines him as his ideal father figure) but also him becoming a "real" stand-up star.
In reality, his appearance on the show ends up being the final step in Arthur's Oedipal conflict. Murray's perceived rejection of him (when he mocks his comedy act) sparks the final fire in Arthur and stunningly, he shoots him dead live on TV. He got his moment.
Crucially, this is also the point where Arthur - who is going by Joker at this point - reclaims his own image. He's called a clown and a Joker, so he turns up dressed as one and billing himself as one. And he shows surprising awareness, considering he's shown to be such a delusional fantasist up to this point - he refuses to be exploited and manipulated and he bites back in a deeply disturbing way.
3. The Three Yuppies
Some people will want to talk about the dangers of Joker's portrait of Arthur as a justified victim - as if Rambo, Taxi Driver and lots of other stories haven't already trod the same boards before - but there's no getting away from the fact that Arthur IS justified in looking for revenge. It's just that his means to do so are clearly warped.
His first three murders might as well be an anti-NRA PSA. Having been beaten up while working his clown job, Arthur is given a gun, which he very knowingly says he's "not allowed" (the insistence of the allegory here practically drips off the screen). And then when he's attacked again in public, by three drunken employees of Thomas Wayne's financial department he turns to the gun for protection, shooting all three.
It's presented as a breaking point for Arthur and Joker, but the interesting thing is that it may well be - at least partly - fantasy. The gun Arthur carries is a 6 shot revolver, yet he fires it 7 or 8 times without reloading before the bullets run out. It's another little trick to the performance and the film's portrait of fantasy that really adds to the moment.
2. Randall
The most brutal of the film's murders is also the most personal and cathartic for Arthur, even more so than that of Murray, because it's Randall's betrayal of him that robs him of his job, which he loves and which leads to him killing the 3 Wayne employees.
While there may be some genuine concern for Arthur in Randall's decision to give him the gun, as soon as Arthur accidentally reveals he has it, Randall flips on him and tells their boss, leading to him losing his job. When he tells the police the same thing to protect himself, Arthur clearly thinks he's gone too far.
When Randall and Gary turn up to Arthur's home in the wake of Penny's death, they find him celebrating. Arthur takes his chance, stabbing his supposed former friend in the neck and eye with a pair of scissors and then smashing his head against a wall. It's bloody, incredibly violent and makes for very difficult viewing.
1. The Waynes
In one of the film's biggest shocks - considering we were told this wouldn't be a Batman movie in the strictest terms - comes right at the end when Joker's murder of Murray inspires the clown uprising that turns Gotham over to the mob. We get Batman's origin thrown in.
By this point, Thomas Wayne has been outed as a monster who thinks of the poorer classes as "clowns" who need to be "fixed" and who Gotham needs to be saved from. He and his family are caught in the mob uprising and a protestor recognises him, follows him into that fateful backalley and shoots him and his wife. The film's mantra of Kill The Rich comes full circle.
Ultimately, it COULD be a fantasy by Arthur, because there's no way he could have witnessed it, but it's a brilliant way of setting up Batman's story and if they don't tie the Dark Knight to this version of the Joker, they'll be missing a trick.