Joker Trailer Review: 9 Ups & 1 Down
"Is it just me, or is it getting crazier out there?"
On the back of an exceptional first poster for Todd Phillips' strange origin story, we've now got the first trailer. And boy does it leave a mark.
While there were - inevitably - some pretty vocal complaints about the project's existence (and others about where it was coming from AND where it would slot into the existing DC cinematic universe), the hype should have just been turned up massively. Because it looks suspiciously like director Todd Phillips is delivering on his promise of a movie inspired as much by Taxi Driver, Mean Streets and The King of Comedy as it is by any Batman comic.
Here's the trailer...
Now, inevitably, there are lots of points to discuss here and not all of them are positive, but by God, this might be the best Batman-universe trailer there's ever been. And that's saying something when that first Suicide Squad trailer exists.
First the negatives...
Downs
1. Well, Now It's Just A Tragedy He's Not In A Batman Movie
Honestly, admit it: you expected there to be way more negatives than there are after this. It's a movie made by a comedy director with a grim subject and aspirations to emulate Martin Scorsese. It shouldn't work at all. But it looks legitimately brilliant.
The only issue here is that we're not going to get to see this version of the Joker in a Batman movie. Because he's trapped in this Elseworlds bubble because of the agenda to protect the DCEU from confusing continuity (even though it doesn't even deserve it now), we're robbed of the chance (probably) to see him in Matt Reeves' new Batman trilogy.
Please, PLEASE fix that, Warner Bros.
And now to the positives...
Ups
9. The Obvious Killing Joke Lean
By the look of it, Todd Phillips is leaning heavily on Alan Moore's seminal The Killing Joke and in particular the now infamous line that explains where the Joker came from:
“All it takes is one bad day to reduce the sanest man alive to lunacy. That's how far the world is from where I am. Just one bad day.”
Even the most cynical of critics who came out to lambast the idea of a Joker origin would have to concede that Moore's vision for the Joker's story deserved telling on the big screen and the decision to use it so consciously as a reference point will delight a lot of people.
Watching a man break apart psychologically might not make easy viewing, but it's a really, really compelling way to tell this story. And by the look of it, there's no agenda to exploit mental health issues, which is refreshing.
8. The Shot Choices Make It Look Legitimately Gorgeous
One thing that you'd rarely accuse comic book movies of being is overly focused on cinematography. They're generally more concerned with character work and plot and very few of them consciously try much in terms of visual artistry (aside for the films that have tried to emulate comic strip aesthetics like Ang Lee's Hulk and Avengers: Infinity War's splash-page shots).
Looking at Joker, it looks nothing like a comic book movie. Visually, it owes a lot more to Martin Scorsese's work - which adds context to the desire to have him involved - and the shot choices in this trailer make it look like a real work of art. Considering this has been made by Todd Phillips - the most unexpected of sources for this sort of material - it's even more impressive that it looks this beautiful.
7. The Musical Choice
Let's bang that same drum again, shall we? A good musical choice can mean the difference between a good trailer and a great one. Suicide Squad knew it, the Guardians Of The Galaxy trailers knew it... And now Warner Bros have done it again for Joker.
Yes, it might be a very obvious choice when you think about the Joker origin they're going with, but since when has obvious been a bad thing when selling a movie? A trailer ought to be a slice of what we can expect from the movie, and the message of Jimmy Durante's "Smile" is delightfully apt here.
In the same way that Avengers: Age Of Ultron stole Pinocchio's "No Strings" to add a different meaning, Durante's song here is pushed through a darker filter to focus more pertinently on the "though your heart is aching". The idea of performance to hide pain is a brilliant one and that appears to be the message here.
And even better? They don't get some ridiculous indie singer who can't pronounce vowels properly to butcher it.
6. The Unwavering Focus On Arthur Fleck
There are lots of elements to this story and they're all pretty well hinted at in this trailer, but you emerge from it without any doubts over who it's about thanks to the decision to tighten on Phoenix's Arthur Flack all the way through.
Even with the temptation to big up the other moving parts - of Brett Cullen's Thomas Wayne, Robert De Niro's Murray Franklin, Frances Conroy's Penny Fleck, Zazie Beetz's Sophie Dumond or Marc Maron's Ted Marco - as any other trailer for a project THIS controversial would do. Because bear in mind, this film is no swing for the fences for Warner Bros, it's a bold choice and not putting out all of their wares so blatantly is as brave a move as it is a rewarding one for the watch experience of this trailer.
That decision also reinforces how much of a character study this is going to be - how much we're going to get under the skin of the Joker for the first time. And that in itself is probably the biggest selling point for fans of the character on film.
5. It's Almost Like A Body Horror
If you're looking for your film school cheat sheet of themes in Joker, it'll definitely include isolation, the pressures of adversity and transformation above all else. The story will effectively be the cocoon in which an unstable but safe man is pushed to the limits by a terrible series of events (the death of his mother, social injustice, his own ostracisation, the death of his performing dreams... all of that and more) and he's going to emerge as a beautiful, weird butterfly at the end.
The transformation from Flack to Joker is the most compelling part of that entire story and it's not just a matter of why it happens but also how. And by the look of some of the scenes, we're almost going to be getting a body horror type aesthetic as Phoenix's physical performance heavily emphasises the transition of his character into darkness.
Seeing Phoenix emaciated and twisted is horrifying in itself and that visceral impact is testament to how great he is and how inspired a choice he is as the character.
4. It's Absolutely Nothing Like A DCEU Movie
While it's a shame that this cannot now be linked to Warner Bros' "flagship" franchise, it's actually a good thing that it doesn't in any way draw from the DCEU's creative approach. Even with the implied darkness of the material, it is visually distinct from the physically dark movies under that banner and the difference is definitely a selling point in that respect.
Artistically, it's chalk and cheese, and this looks like the perfect advert for comic book movies that don't over-rely on inflated budgets and over-blown effects work.
There are definitely Easter Eggs and obvious reference points - both from the comics and other movies - but it's not being rammed down our throats. Like someone literally covered in tattoos referencing comic book stories might have done, for instance...
3. Joaquin Phoenix's Restrained Performance
Whether you care to admit it or not, every performance of the Joker is beholden to two things. First, it has to connect in some way to the comics source material, obviously, but it also has to deal with the parallels to the last time someone played the Joker.
In this case, Joaquin Phoenix could have done a lot of weird sh*t as long as he steered clear of sending people used condoms, wearing a grill and being an actual juggalo and he would still have compared favourably to Jared Leto's version.
And let's be honest here, the material also lends itself to a ridiculous performance, but it appears that we're getting a portrait of comparative restraint. Sure, there's weirdness and there's flamboyance, but the key is going to be that the Joker is sympathetic here. Remember that quote from Alan Moore.
If his humanity was unrecognisable, this wouldn't be anywhere near as compelling.
2. It Doesn't Spoil A Great Deal
As with the inevitable and understandable temptation to show off more of its flashier cast members to sell the movie to mainstream audiences, the film could have gone heavy on the spoilers to ensure cheap but effective impact on ticket sales. Thankfully, they've avoided doing that.
There are lots of hints in here that will inspire theories (like the link between Thomas Wayne and Arthur being closer than initially suspected), but it is careful to avoid being too much more than a mood board.
Broadly speaking, it's obvious the trajectory of the story, but there are few sign-posts and the specific twists in the road are not mapped out. And that's exactly as it should be for a trailer. Let's hope they stick to that approach as we get closer to release.
1. The Laugh (And The Voice)
When you're making snap judgements on Joker performances, you've got to look at three things beyond all else. First, you look at the look and we've had that for a long time thanks to the excellent faked make-up test. We already knew that Phoenix looked the part.
Of more concern for this trailer was how he sounds as the Joker. Because Mr J's voice and his laugh are just as important in his characterisation as the warpaint he puts on.
So it's pretty great to be able to report that both are great. Arthur Flack seems to be a bit of a muse of a man with the weight of the world on his shoulders, but also wearing that pressure just under the surface too. There's a calmness to his voice that feels like performance and we definitely see the mask slip a couple of times in the trailer.
And then when he laughs - both as Flack and when he's clearly losing control and becoming the Joker - it's great. It's creepy and memorable without being as stupid as Leto's affected take and it's far more like an oddball than a cartoon.
What do you think of this trailer? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.