Justice League Dark Review: 4 Ups & 5 Downs
Batman and Friends.
The long-awaited Justice League Dark animated film is available now on all good VOD platforms, and like many of Warner Bros' recent DC animations, it's honestly a bit of a mixed bag.
Fans of the titular group will no doubt get a sure measure of joy out of seeing Constantine, Zatanna and Deadman getting their own film, especially with an R-rating, but it's also abundantly clear that some big concessions have been made in order to get it out to the masses.
It's certainly not frustrating on the level of last summer's controversial adaptation of The Killing Joke, but it absolutely leaves the viewer craving more and wishing that Warner Bros. had a little more faith in audiences to turn out for a faithful rendition of the comic book counterpart.
Here are 4 ups and 5 downs from Justice League Dark...
Downs
5. Too Much Of Batman & Friends
In an ideal world, Batman would be nowhere near this movie, but Warner Bros. know how well anything featuring him sells, so essentially shoehorned the Caped Crusader into a story where he's a passive spectator for the most part.
Batman takes front and center on the film's box art and posters in order to lure the casuals in, and he basically ends up being an audience surrogate, allowing other characters to explain things to him without it seeming too obvious that they're basically talking to the viewer.
Ultimately most of the action is of the supernatural variety, so Bats isn't much of a fixture and often just stands around watching, and things get even more egregiously pandering when you factor in cameos from the like of Superman, Green Lantern and Wonder Woman.
They've got no business being in the movie, and all it says is that Warner had no confidence in releasing the film on its own, which is a damn shame.
4. Mediocre Animation & Character Designs
The Killing Joke clearly took a hit on the production side in order to get its R-rating, and the same sadly seems to be the case here, as the animation quality is all over the place.
Compared to some of Warner's better animated DC movies of recent years, this feels cheap and quickly churned out, with establishing shots of the city-scape looking especially rancid and rushed. Combining traditional animation with some CGI elements also results in a number of moments that look downright ugly.
Character designs outside of the central group are also likely to be controversial: Superman in particular looks absolutely ridiculous (his head is far too small for his body and his face is bland to look at, but at least he only appears in cameo form), and Wonder Woman's design isn't great either.
3. The Totally Uninteresting Villain
The film focuses on the titular team-up (and all those extra heroes too) at the expense of a compelling villain, while fielding out at least one bait-and-switch too many.
Felix Faust was marketed as the core villain, but he doesn't properly show up until well past the half-way mark, is fairly dull and isn't even in fact the ultimate antagonist.
The final villain doesn't show up until the tail-end of the movie, comes after another red herring is thrown out and, again, just isn't very interesting. Granted, even the acclaimed Marvel Cinematic Universe struggles with its bad guys, but one hoped there might've been just a little more effort put into building up a palpable threat here.
2. Not Enough Swamp Thing
Swamp Thing is a much-loved component of the Justice League Dark team, but he's unfortunately not in the movie for more than a few minutes, with several scenes scattered throughout to make it feel like he's in it more than he actually is.
He basically shows up to help guide the heroes on their way and re-appears later on during a battle, but he barely makes a dent, and this really feels like a gigantic missed opportunity given the character's popularity and integral nature in the group.
Couldn't Batman's role have been chopped down a little to make more room for the big guy?
1. It's Too Short & Rushed
Justice League Dark clocks in at just 76 minutes, which in fairness is in-line with the short lengths of most DC animated movies (The Killing Joke was 77 minutes, for instance).
Still, chop off a few more minutes for the credits and you've got something that only scarcely feels feature length. Plus, with having to introduce so many characters for the sake of the casual crowd, it seems immensely rushed and can rarely take enough time to dig down deep with all of its heroes.
It's clearly a financial decision, no doubt influenced by that R-rating, but wouldn't it be awesome to see DC animated movies clocking in at the 100-120 minute mark in the future?
It sure wasn't all bad, though, so here are 4 things that actually worked in the movie...
Ups
4. Matt Ryan As Constantine
One of the biggest reasons to be excited about this movie was the returning presence of Matt Ryan as John Constantine, who of course played the character in NBC's disappointingly cancelled TV show.
Ryan absolutely delivers as you'd expect, especially his sassy back-and-forth banter with both Zatanna and Batman, as well as hilariously calling the villain a "w***er" at one point.
Of all the characters in the film, his is the most effervescent, and he easily rises to the top even with the presence of Batman attempting to stifle him somewhat.
With Ryan also returning for The CW's Constantine animated series, hopefully he'll keep running with the ball considering how much people like his interpretation of the character.
3. It Sure Is Dark
In fairness, the movie sure does live up to the "dark" in its title, with an immensely grim opening sequence in which citizens begin to hallucinate monsters roaming the streets, causing one woman to mow down a bunch of innocent people in her car, a man to murder his entire family, and a young mother to attempt to hurl her baby to its doom after envisioning it as a beast (Batman saves the baby, but the mother not so much).
Though the film doesn't quite make the most of its R-rating, at least there's no gratuitous sex this time (unlike The Killing Joke), and the adult content is mostly pointed towards violence and disturbing concepts. Seeing Batman apologise to the baby he just rescued because its mother took a plunge onto the sidewalk is nothing if not memorable.
It could've taken the darkness further, sure, but it definitely didn't rest on its laurels in this regard either.
2. The Group Dynamic & Banter Are Great
Even though it's a shame the movie focuses too much on Batman at the cost of other characters, the central group dynamic is actually a ton of fun to observe.
The wise-cracking and wordplay feels ripped straight out of the comics and somewhat compensates for the movie's glaring flaws, though again, if the movie had been longer perhaps these asides wouldn't feel quite so rushed.
Hopefully the movie will do well enough that the group can be reunited for another movie in the future, because there's just way too much potential here not to be exploited, even with Deadman's kinda-goofy voice proving a little distracting.
1. Entertaining Action Sequences
And finally, yes, the action mostly delivers. There are three big set-pieces in the movie, basically one for each "act" of the film, and they do a solid job of showing off the diverse power set of the team, even though, as mentioned, their opponents typically aren't all that memorable or interesting.
It'll definitely leave you craving more and wishing some of the characters were able to do more, especially Swamp Thing, but the action often makes up for the dopey, dull storytelling, even if you sometimes might just want to skip through to the set-pieces (on repeat viewings, assuming there are any, at least).
What did you think of Justice League Dark? Shout it out in the comments!