Lightyear Review: 6 Ups & 4 Downs
Lightyear is fun to a point, but struggles to justify its own existence.
Pixar returns with their second and final feature film release of 2022 - following Turning Red back in March - and their first movie to get a theatrical release since Onward back in early 2020.
Toy Story spin-off Lightyear, styled as the movie that inspired Andy's Buzz Lightyear obsession back in 1995, is out now around the world, and the critical reception so far has been broadly positive - albeit with some major caveats.
Indeed, Lightyear is a decent way to pass the time - a moderately enjoyable film albeit one that does a lot less to make itself feel "necessary" to the Toy Story canon than you might expect.
The irony, as some critics have already noted, is that Lightyear feels like far more of a Disney+ movie than the likes of Soul and Turning Red in particular - a not-bad offering with some gorgeous visuals, yet held back from being anything close to greatness by its underwhelming script.
Needless to say, if you're hoping for a sci-fi adventure on the level of the Toy Story movies, your expectations need to be massively lowered, because this is far from the studio's strongest output - in fact, almost quite the opposite.
For any other animated studio that'd certainly be good enough, but let's face it: Pixar's spoiled us so much over the years that anything less than great just feels a bit deflating.
And so, here's what Lightyear doesn't get right...
Downs...
4. The Disappointingly Generic Script
Far and away Lightyear's biggest weakness is its script, which for a spin-off from Pixar's most beloved franchise feels shockingly run-of-the-mill, even flat-out generic at times.
This is for the most part an over-familiar sci-fi adventure that borrows liberally from so many superior genre entries - perhaps most surprisingly of all, Christopher Nolan's Interstellar - without offering much of its own creative spin.
Almost everything about the story and characters is laid out in highly matter-of-fact terms. With the foreshadowing being brightly neon-signposted for the most part, there are very few instances in this film where audiences - adult ones, anyway - are likely to be surprised.
Though the first act is certainly promising, the second reel feels massively padded out with filler, ahead of a third that's just totally lacking in ambition and imagination.
Even with its likeable characters and oft-entertaining fan service, Lightyear's script isn't nearly as charming as you'd expect.
3. Zurg Is An Underwhelming Villain
Lightyear's villain is of course Buzz's iconic arch-nemesis from the Toy Story movies - yet who is ultimately revealed to be his father in the second film - Emperor Zurg.
Without giving too much away, fans may think they know where Zurg's portrayal in this film is going, but Pixar has a trick up their sleeve that's sure to heavily divide the Toy Story die-hards.
Though James Brolin does a solid job voicing the villain, ultimately the direction that Zurg's characterisation takes feels derivative of a number of sci-fi and superhero movies of recent times, while tinkering with established Toy Story lore in ways fans may find frustrating.
It doesn't help that Zurg's introduced relatively late in the movie, not showing up properly until the end of the second act, and even then his presence here will surely sharply polarise the fanbase.
2. The Humour Is Incredibly Hit & Miss
Even the most serious-minded Pixar movies have a well-developed funny bone, and so it's incredibly rare for their films to prove this uneven on the comedy front.
There are certainly hilarious moments throughout Lightyear, yet the script's gags are generally far more hit-and-miss than expected from the studio, with many one-liners failing to land with the desired, gut-busting impact.
The humour generally feels very mid-brow at best and often outright unsophisticated, bar a few inspired sight gags and slivers of dialogue.
In conjunction with the relatively generic space adventure story, this ensures that Lightyear lacks the special sauce audiences expect from even mid-tier Pixar movies.
Pixar has proven that their films don't need to be gag-a-minute chuckle-fests, but their signature sly wit is sorely missed through much of this effort.
1. It Struggles To Justify Its Own Existence
Prior to Lightyear's release, some fans commented that "nobody asked for it," and while that may be true, do we really ask for most movies?
There was certainly room for a Lightyear movie to earn its existence in our minds, yet this oddly pedestrian sci-fi romp really isn't it.
Given that the film wants to convince us that this is the formative cinematic experience that inspired Andy's love of Buzz back in 1995, it really feels like it should be so much more - funnier, smarter, and more creatively action-packed.
The result is a film that's among the weaker Pixar efforts to date, and it's tough to imagine it making much of a cultural impact with either Toy Story fans or wider audiences.
While Lightyear is projected to turn a solid profit for Disney, is anyone going to be speaking of this movie with great reverence 20 or 30 years from now, as we all do with the Toy Story movies today?
So Lightyear isn't a great film, but that doesn't mean it's not a fun time. And so, here's what it gets right...
Ups...
6. The BEAUTIFUL Animation
Something surely everybody can agree upon is that Lightyear is a stunning film from a purely aesthetic perspective.
Despite its boilerplate story, Pixar's animation team has done a characteristically phenomenal job across the board, from the eye-wateringly photoreal landscapes and spaceships to the more stylised character designs.
The moment-to-moment animation is fantastic throughout, ensuring that even in its weakest scripted moments, Lightyear is at least a real looker and certainly something worth checking out on the big screen if you don't want to wait 45-ish days for the Disney+ drop.
Armed with a stonking $200 million budget, Pixar at least ensured to capture the thrill of spaceflight and exploring uncharted space from a visual standpoint.
5. Chris Evans' Terrific Performance As Buzz
Tim Allen is Buzz Lightyear to the extent that replacing him is so extremely tricky, and so Chris Evans' inspired casting feels like a minor masterstroke.
Evans' calm yet authoritative voiceover does justice to both Buzz's integrity and sneakily sardonic side, undeniably informed by his prior portrayal as Captain America - a character who, as it turns out, has an unexpected amount in common with Buzz throughout this story.
Evans had tough shoes to fill here but has done a mostly bang-up job making this version of the character his own even while feeling recognisably cut from the same cloth as his forebear.
There are sure to be those who wish Allen simply played the part himself, but Evans manages to bring just enough of his own spin to the role to make this iteration of Buzz feel appropriately same-but-different.
4. Sox Steals The Show
As is often the case with Pixar movies, the adorable mascot character ends up stealing the show in Lightyear - in this case Buzz's robotic cat companion Sox (Peter Sohn).
Voiced with a delightfully deadpan tone by Peter Sohn - who directed Pixar's The Good Dinosaur and is helming next year's Elemental - Sox makes for an hilarious foil to Buzz and his comrades, stealing most every scene he's in with his quirky, regularly unexpected hijinks.
Though Sox's mere existence creates a bit of a Toy Story plot hole - because why wouldn't Andy own a Sox toy too, right? - his inclusion is nevertheless worth it because he brings the charm and personality that so much of the movie is otherwise lacking.
Given that character's immense popularity in early reviews, don't be shocked if we get some Disney+ shorts featuring Sox in the near-future. One can only hope so.
3. The Amusing Fan Service & Easter Eggs
At the end of the day, if you're a Toy Story fan - and, if not, you're probably not watching this - you're going to get at least some periodic chuckles out of the many, many Easter eggs, references, and general fan service thrown your way.
Sure, some of it isn't particularly smart or clever - such as having Evans' Buzz recite the action figure's most beloved one-liners - but the sheer abundance of visual nods to the Toy Story movies at least makes it clear that this was a film constructed with a major fondness for the IP (script issues notwithstanding).
Older viewers will also get a kick out of the many references to the '90s time period in which the movie was made, such as the A.I. module for Buzz's ship resembling a SNES video game cartridge, which Buzz even has to blow on. This is just one example, but there are many more throughout.
While Lightyear doesn't offer up a ton of rewatch value, some will at least relish the opportunity to pore back over every last frame in pursuit of all those sneaky Easter eggs when it hits Disney+ in the near-future.
2. Michael Giacchino's Evocative Musical Score
Regular Pixar collaborator Michael Giacchino returned to compose Lightyear's score, and it's easily one of the movie's big highlights.
Giacchino is certainly no stranger to scoring sci-fi movies, having created the iconic scores for the recent Star Trek reboot trilogy, and that clearly serves him well here.
The score, defined primarily by an epic orchestral sweep, pays loving homage to the heart-swelling scores of classic space operas, while bringing just enough newness to the table to feel distinct in its own right.
Giacchino also nails the smaller, more intimate moments, such as an affecting montage in the film's first act which portrays the passage of time between Buzz's time-consuming missions - in a fashion reminiscent of Up's iconic opening sequence, in fact.
While unlikely to be remembered as one of Giacchino's very best scores, it's yet further confirmation that he's one of the most skilled composers in the big-budget game right now.
1. The Strong Supporting Cast
Though Chris Evans and Peter Sohn are the sure highlights among the cast, everyone brings something worthwhile to the table here.
Most recognisably we have Taika Waititi as Morrison, the wet-around-the-ears member of Buzz's impromptu team, but the heart and the soul of the story is really shared between Uzo Aduba and Keke Palmer, playing Buzz's Space Ranger pal Alisha Hawthorne and her granddaughter Izzy respectively.
Elsewhere Isiah Whitlock Jr.'s distinctive vocals should give fans of The Wire a chuckle when he appears briefly as the surly Commander Burnside, and James Brolin is perfectly cast as Zurg, no matter the issues fans might have with the character's direction in the film.
Pixar admittedly rarely puts a foot wrong with their voice casting choices, and while Lightyear's script is hardly great, the cast does the absolute best possible with what they've got.