Logan Review: 9 Ups & 2 Downs
An instant comic book classic.
Logan is finally here, and what a fantastic movie it is. Critics and fans alike are tripping over themselves to praise Hugh Jackman's final outing as Wolverine, and it's difficult to imagine many coming out of the film disappointed.
It may not be perfect, as no film is, but Logan is without question not only the best of the X-Men movies but also the best superhero film in years. Seriously.
Expect this one to go down as a solid gold classic, to be regarded in years to come as a high benchmark for the genre, especially as far as direction, tone and, most of all, performances are concerned.
Here are 9 ups and 2 downs from Logan...
Downs
2. The Villains Could Be Better
Logan is a movie so intently focused on its heroic trio that it's not too surprising the villains end up taking a backseat.
It's not a deal-breaker, but it definitely feels like more could've been done with Boyd Holbrook's Donald Pierce, who never really feels like a major physical threat and rarely actually gets involved in all the action.
And of course, there's Dr. Zander Rice (Richard E. Grant), who shows up in the film's second half but has a scant amount of screen time and isn't particularly interesting or well-developed.
Again, the film is so much about Logan (Hugh Jackman), Xavier (Patrick Stewart) and Laura (Dafne Keen) that it's ultimately just a small complaint, but more compelling bad guys would've made the film even better.
1. There's One Ridiculous Subplot
Without saying why exactly, things get a little daft (even for the standards of a comic book film) with a certain element introduced in the movie's second half.
Though it's ultimately a rather small part of the film, its inclusion is sure to raise some eyebrows as it clashes somewhat with the more gritty, grounded tone of the film prior.
It basically ends up working as well as one could have expected, but tweaking this revelation slightly could've made it feel a lot less silly.
It's the closest the movie gets to flirting with the over-the-top nonsense of the other Wolverine films, and you'll know exactly what it is when you see it, that's for sure.
But now, here's why you absolutely must see Logan...
Ups
9. Hugh Jackman Gives An Oscar-Worthy Performance
If Logan came out in October or November, Fox would probably be mounting an Oscar campaign for Hugh Jackman, because he gives not only his best performance as the character, but turns in the best work of his career here.
Completely creatively unrestrained, you get the sense that Jackman is giving the portrayal of Logan he always wanted to, and of course, it's tremendously fitting given this being his apparently final time playing the character.
Jackman completely surrenders the sadness, the desperation and the anger of his character, living in a post-mutant world where all he wants to do is buy a boat to escape from everything.
It's tremendous work with an enormously cathartic payoff, and Fox would be dumb not to push Jackman for a Best Actor nomination at year's end, unlikely though it probably is.
8. It's Mature In Every Sense Of The Word
Deadpool is "mature", but not really mature: it's violent and sweary, but also willfully immature for the sake of uproarious comedy. Logan is no such film.
Logan features countless severed limbs and appendages and a sailor-like level of bad language, but thematically, it's also got more in common with a western like Unforgiven or No Country for Old Men than a typical superhero film.
James Mangold does a fantastic job devoting more time to characters than action, and the result is a film that works as both a straight-up drama and a gloriously violent spectacle. That's immensely rare, and should help Logan strike a special chord with a wide range of audiences.
7. James Mangold's Incredible Direction
James Mangold is a terrific director, and shouldn't really be blamed for 2013's The Wolverine going off the deep end in its later sections.
His prior works, such as Walk the Line and the 3:10 to Yuma remake, are proof enough that he has a fantastic handle on both drama and action, which combine in Logan to make a smoothly controlled whole.
There's never a moment where Mangold feels like he's out of his depth or working with a plot point that's beneath him, and it certainly helps that he co-wrote the script.
As far as superhero movies go, the patience and technical prowess on display here makes Logan one of the genre's best-directed movies, right up there with the work of Christopher Nolan.
6. Patrick Stewart Delivers His Best Xavier Yet
Hugh Jackman isn't the only legacy X-Men actor giving his absolute best: Patrick Stewart gives fans the most complex and intriguing Charles Xavier yet.
This version of the character is an unmistakably sad sight for any longtime fan, being riddled with Alzheimer's and struggling to maintain his grip on reality.
During his periods of lucidity, however, Xavier is also a fantastic comic relief character here, with the script and Stewart both playing off the easy chemistry between himself and Jackman, generating much-needed humour that often follows moments of dire brutality.
Stewart has confirmed that, like Jackman, he is also retiring from the role following this film, and also like Jackman, he's gone out on a stupendous high-point.
5. Excellent Action Sequences
The action in this movie is absolutely superb, from the sheer R-rated insanity of Wolverine slicing off arms throughout to a brilliant car chase that echoes both Mad Max: Fury Road and Terminator 2, and so much more not worth spoiling.
The blood and gore is just one part of it, though: Mangold clearly relishes the opportunity to scale back the visual effects, opting mostly for practical action that looks suitably ugly, brutal and realistic.
While those seeing the film primarily for the set-pieces might be a little surprised at how few there are peppered throughout the film, they are extremely effective when they do appear, and in some cases are among the genre's very best to date.
4. The Pacing Is Near-Perfect
Many comic book fans are fed up of the rather over-indulgent run-times of most superhero movies these days: the MCU and DCEU are both guilty of producing films that needlessly creep close to the 2.5-hour mark, but Logan is a rare superhero movie that actually earns its epic length.
Clocking in at 137 minutes, Logan honestly could've been a little longer without a problem. Mangold and Oscar-nominated editor Michael McCusker do a fantastic job with the film's pacing, and it sure as Hell helps that the lengthy dialogue-driven scenes are incredibly involving and not merely a means to get to the next shootout or stab-a-thon.
The action then feels earned, and once a set-piece is done with, you'll probably be glad for the breather to soak things in.
Mangold really lets character beats and action alike breathe, and the film is all the better for it, considering how many superhero movies end up feeling overly bloated or rushed.
3. Dafne Keen Gives A Child Performance For The Ages
Much of the film's success hinges on the character of Laura (aka X-23), played by young actress Dafne Keen.
Though she is largely mute throughout the film (save for some visceral screams during fight scenes), she gives an impressively physical performance and manages to convey a lot without speaking, which is no easy ask of an adult let alone a child.
Her murderous antics will inevitably cause her to be compared to Kick-A**' Hit Girl, but she stands on her own as an incredibly compelling, fully-developed character with a ton of potential for future movies.
But an X-23 movie should only happen if Keen agrees to come back, because she totally killed the part.
2. The Tone Is Balanced Incredibly Well
There was a lot of hand-wringing pre-release that Logan could be yet another movie that promises one thing in its trailers and serves up something totally different in reality.
Thankfully, the trailers do indeed sell a style and tone wholly indicative of the final product. This is a bleak film but it's far from self-consciously "grimdark", reveling in the humanity of its characters and finding welcome light in bursts of dry humour.
Basically, both the MCU and the DCEU could look at this film to see how to handle seriousness and comedy, because it does a top-tier job at juggling them both, even with the added visceral baggage of ultra-violence.
1. It Benefits Massively From Being Standalone
One of Logan's greatest assets is that it's almost a totally standalone film, providing only vague references to events from previous X-Men movies and having no responsibility to set up yet another film.
Yes, an X-23 film may happen, but there's a pronounced feeling here that Jackman and Stewart are committed to their retirement from their characters, and this really does feel like the perfect leaping-off point.
Logan is to that end a testament to movies that aren't part of a complex cinematic tapestry but able to function largely on their own without overt consideration for what studio executives want.
In short, more superhero movies could benefit from taking a singular, "what if?" approach to continuity, especially in a franchise like X-Men where the timeline is borderline incomprehensible anyway.
What did you think of Logan? Shout it out in the comments!