Before I continue I will preface this article by saying that I liked Looper from writer/director Rian Johnson - in fact, I really liked it, it's a Sci-Fi action piece that is, at the very least, competently made by a team that had a vision of creating a new-age morality tale. It gave Bruce Willis his best role since Sin City, continued Joseph Gordon-Levitt's winning streak of great roles since 500 Days of Summer and put its writer/director firmly on the map. However, let's not go for blind praise, because there are quite a few mistakes that Johnson and company should've avoided. Part of the fun of these high-concept Sci-Fi thrillers is to discuss them afterwards with the people that you saw them with, to find the plot or "Loop" holes in this case and see what kept it from being great. Oh, and it should go without saying but SPOILERS are ahead. I will be ruining the movie for the sake of finding what didn't work. Again if you haven't seen the movie continue no further. Alright, with all that out of the way lets examine what the filmmaker's should've avoided.
20. Uncannily Willis
Advertisement
So, in the movie, JGL is supposed to be Willis, just thirty years younger. This wasn't so much of a problem with me as it was with others that reviewed the movie. The make-up that makes JGL look more like a younger Bruce Willis didn't quite work for them. It's uncanny, not quite the genuine article. Part of the problem is that we all know what Willis looked like thirty-years ago from the Die-Hard movies and Moonlighting, and the other is the make-up used can be a little distracting. Listen, we've had to buy weirder older-younger self pairings before (I especially love the one in Guide to Recognizing Your Saints where we have to buy that Shia LeBeouf is a younger Robert Downey Jr...) and JGL looks alright for the part without the makeup. Just the colour contacts would've been enough, and as an audience we would buy the rest.
19. Telekinesis
This isn't so much a large complaint because I do like what they do with the concept, but seriously what is up with the "TK"gene stuff? Was it from exposure to radiation, fall-out from Nucs or genetic manipulation? I believe they mention something about Gene manipulation if so why? To what end? A little-bit more elaboration on this, since it becomes a crucial plot point, would've been appreciated. Again, I like that there is Telekinesis and it was exciting stuff, until they found out they could only float coins around, just could've used some more exposition.
18. Piper Perabo is the Hooker, Say It With Me, With a Heart of Gold
Now, alright Piper Perabo is a great looking girl, no doubt about that, and by some accounts she is a decent actress. Why go the hooker with the heart of gold route? It is a trope done to death, she is a working girl but is only doing so for her kid. Why not just have her be the full-on girlfriend Love Interest for younger Joe? It makes the older Joe's long hesitation at killing her child more believable. Creating a more serious rift between the old and young Joe's, the fact that old Joe believes that he has yet to meet their soulmate . Oh, that's right so we can have young Joe fall for Sara (I'll be getting to that soon enough).
17. Guy Blue
So, here's this seemingly incompetent Looper or hired gun for Jeff Daniel's Abe. He is berated by his boss, carelessly plays around with a loaded GAT and generally acts like a kid playing a man's game. He even gets his right hand broken due to his inability to deliver. Afterwards; however, he is the only one who discovers the old Joe is roaming around Piper Perabo's place and captures him single-handily. He doesn't kill him of course, he wanted to bring Joe in alive for his boss/father figure to see. I think in hind-sight Abe would've really liked to have seen a corpse more.
16. Old Joe Needs To Think Ahead, Or As Himself, Better
Old Joe warns his foolish younger self to leave town and to not get in his way on his labor of love. He knocks himself out, and then just leaves him there, sure without the truck but of course he just walks back to the city. Alright, why not just restrain himself, chain him (Even Sara Handcuff's him when he is on her farm) in an abandoned building somewhere and go release him after the deed is done. You need to make sure he lives too, having young Joe wander around with the loopers after him is not a good security policy. Not only does he pass this opportunity, but old-Joe gets another chance to do something about himself. He falls literally right in front of him, so what does he do this time? He places Joe near the Train Yard, not at the train yard or locked in a compartment on a train out of town just on the other side of the fence of the Train Yard. Did he really think that this time would be any different? That he would take the hint? Doesn't he know himself better?
15. Simple Living
So, we've just had the diner scene and the following shoot-out. Both of the Joes have made their missions clear, there is not going to be any reconciliation between two here. Then suddenly we get life on Emily Blunt's farm... it's a jarring edit. I hope this wasn't another "look at how simple and pure living off the land is, compared to urban life-style!" I really hope. I believe that it is a action break, but you have to ease the peddle down not abruptly stomp on it. So, we are treated to Sara taking care of a tree stump, loading the water unit, and putting her son to bed. Can we get more of the Blunder Busters vs. GAT shoot-outs? Or the conflict between the wants and priorities of yourself thirty-years apart?
14. Bruce Willis Gets His Die Hard Powers
Guy Blue brings Willis back to abe, again why not bring in his corpse, he is about to be executed when suddenly he remembers he was John McClain. While completely unarmed, tied-up and outnumbered he still manages to kill everything that moves at the hideout (except of course for Guy Blue). The loopers are professional killers and Willis is a 60 something man. The loopers fire every weapon in the world and can't even graze the guy, did the scripts for the new Die Hard and Looper get tossed together?
13. Abe Gets It... Off-Screen
As Joe goes on said killing spree against his former old friends and employer, as with video game logic he saves the boss for last. We get a build-up shots of Abe and his last two hench-men holding up in his office ready for Joe to burst in. Joe is about to kick in the door and then we cut to Guy blue... still alive to see the aftermath of the shoot-out. Abe and everyone else is dead... dignified way for an endearing character to go. But hey at least we know Guy Blue made it out alive, at least until the next scene.
12. The Police Finally Show... For Jack-Squat
All through this movie we are left to wonder where are the cops in all this? Well, they get one scene where they are seemingly about to raid the Looper Hide-out, it's why they are getting the silver into a truck and clearing the place out and then Joe goes and kills everyone in there. What were they doing just sitting there and waiting for god-knows-what? So, they presumably have the place surrounded how did Joe escape in the truck? Why have a shot of the Police at all? I think we can all assume that they have their hands full.