Mank Review: 7 Ups & 3 Downs

Gary Oldman's searing performance anchors David Fincher's tricky period biopic.

By Jack Pooley /

Netflix

Though the elgibility deadline for the 2021 Oscars has been extended from December 31st to February 28th of next year, studios aren't wasting any time ensuring their biggest awards hopefuls are out there by the end of 2020.

Advertisement

By far one of the most anticipated films in this year's awards race is David Fincher's 11th film, Mank, a biopic of Citizen Kane co-writer Herman J. Mankiewicz (Gary Oldman) which clearly ticks a number of the Academy's favoured boxes (namely, movies about Hollywood itself).

What's clear about Mank from minute one is that this is quite unlike anything Fincher has made before: a lovingly crafted if at times confounding film sure to puzzle almost as many as it enchants.

Advertisement

But there's little denying the astonishing filmmaking and acting craft on offer throughout, ensuring that whether it fully wins you over or not, there's plenty worth respecting.

Whether it can triumph over more outwardly accessible Oscar hopefuls like The Trial of the Chicago 7 and even Nomadland remains to be seen, but Mank is nothing if not another expertly assembled work of cinema from one of our most consistently brilliant filmmakers.

Advertisement

Is it Fincher's finest film to date? Absolutely not, but he once again brings his sublimely meticulous eye to the fore and yields (mostly) outstanding results...

Downs...

3. Not Enough Tom Burke Or Charles Dance

Netflix

Mank boasts one of the most enviable ensemble casts of any movie released this year, and so it's not terribly surprising that not every actor gets their fair shake over the film's 131-minute runtime.

Advertisement

But there are two alluring performances in particular which just don't feel like they get nearly enough screen minutes to fully breathe.

First off, Tom Burke is incredible in his small role as Citizen Kane director and "co-writer" Orson Welles: his vocal register matches that of Welles' with a shocking authenticity, while also carrying the hefty aura of the man's sheer presence.

Advertisement

And while it bears repeating that this is a movie centered on Mankiewicz rather than Kane or Welles, it's a shame that Fincher didn't give Burke more to do, because he's absolutely terrific for his 10-ish minutes of screen time.

Charles Dance is also remarkable in a small part as William Randolph Hearst, the real-life media mogul who famously served as the inspiration for Welles' Citizen Kane protagonist Charles Foster Kane.

Advertisement

Again, Dance is terrific in the few scenes he gets, but his truncated role doesn't quite allow the character to feel fully fleshed out.

2. It's Inaccessible To A Fault

Netflix

Mank is going to surprise a lot of people with just how little regard it has for audiences who possess only a limited knowledge of classic Hollywood.

Advertisement

Only a cursory attempt is made to cater to more mainstream audiences by refusing to just spell everything out, which while in theory a good thing, may also cause some viewers to end up feeling a bit lost.

With its complex, time-hopping narrative which spans the gamut of filmmaking and political chicanery in '30s California, it's a film which requires the audience to pay full attention - watching it with subtitles, if only to keep track of the bevy of names thrown at you, is definitely a smart move.

Advertisement

Still, even those familiar with the history of the subject may struggle with Fincher's sure-to-be-divisive depiction of Welles as a man who basically muscled himself a co-writer credit he apparently didn't deserve - a possibility which remains hotly argued to this day.

It's also easy to see how some might see Mank as a little too emotionally guarded for its own good, especially compared to Fincher's fiery prior work - The Social Network in particular - even if those prepared to pay attention are sure to be rewarded by the sharp writing and superb acting on offer.

Advertisement

1. Some Of The Stylistic Excesses

Netflix

Mank is more often than not a beautifully crafted movie which captures the vibe of '30s Hollywood with stylistic panache, though there are perhaps a few moments where Fincher gets a little too cute for his own good.

Advertisement

In what feels like the sort of vaguely hack-y move a lesser filmmaker would defer to, Fincher intentionally muffles all of the film's dialogue in order to give it a period feel, as is sure to annoy anyone watching the film on a quality sound system expect razor-ship dialogue quality.

But the issue is more that Fincher doesn't go hard enough with these flourishes: the musical score still sounds totally pristine, and the cinematography is presented in crystal clear 4K HDR with a contemporary aspect ratio.

Advertisement

If Fincher wants to present the film as of the period, why not go the whole hog rather than just make the dialogue sound muddy while everything else is still totally gorgeous?

These issues aside, Mank is absolutely well worth watching if you're a fan of Citizen Kane or are even remotely interested in the history of Hollywood. Here's everything Fincher gets right...

Advertisement

Ups...

7. Gary Oldman's Sublime Performance

Netflix

What just about everyone is going to agree on is that Gary Oldman gives a masterful performance as the titular screenwriter.

Advertisement

The actor veers far away from his penchant for hammy caricature and delivers a thoroughly convincing performance of Mankiewicz as both a legendary storyteller and and an even more legendary drunk.

Oldman does a remarkable job conveying the man's clear inner turmoil as a creative and a scarcely functioning alcoholic, yet never turns the performance up to 11 where it threatens to distract from or overpower the character drama.

Advertisement

Oldman is a lock for a Best Actor Oscar nomination at this point, and though he'll face stiff competition from Chadwick Boseman (Ma Rainey's Black Bottom) and Anthony Hopkins (The Father) in particular, it just might be the high-point of Oldman's career.

Above all else, it's certainly a performance more deserving of the gong than his scenery-devouring turn as Winston Churchill in Darkest Hour.

Advertisement

6. It's A Fascinating Look At Hollywood & Politics

Netflix

What Mank does better than anything else, even in its trickier moments, is offer a unique window into the intermingling worlds of Hollywood and politics.

Advertisement

As much as the film is focused on Mankiewicz attempting to complete the Kane screenplay amid major personal strife, a large chunk of the story is also devoted to the inside baseball studio politicking of the era, especially the single-minded, penny-pinching efforts of MGM's sleazeball co-founder Louis B. Mayer (an excellent Arliss Howard).

A surprising amount of the film also covers 1934's California Gubernatorial battle between Democrat Upton Sinclair (Bill Nye) and Republican incumbent Frank Merriam, which sees Hollywood exert its own unique influence on the election through fabricated propaganda "news reels" intended to keep Merriam in power.

Advertisement

The result is a mutli-faceted film albeit one that again proves more challenging than your average Fincher joint, and if you feel like you didn't grasp every single facet of its nuance the first time around, you shouldn't feel bad about it.

5. The Excellent Ensemble Cast

Netflix

Beyond Gary Oldman, Mank is a sure embarrassment of riches as casts go. For starters, Amanda Seyfried gives easily the strongest performance of her career as actress and wife of Hearst, Marion Davies.

Advertisement

Though our first impression of Davies might be that she's a typical bombshell starlet, it quickly becomes clear that Marion is far smarter than her faultless exterior might suggest, and every scene Seyfried shares with Oldman is absolute gold.

She's therefore a lock for a Best Supporting Actress Oscar nod, and if the winds don't change months from now, she could even win the thing outright.

Advertisement

Elsewhere we've already discussed the fine efforts of Tom Burke, Charles Dance, and Arliss Howard, while Lily Collins and Tuppence Middleton make strong impressions as Mank's secretary and wife respectively, Tom Pelphrey is terrific as his brother Joseph, and Jamie McShane is unexpectedly affecting in a small role as Mank's aspiring filmmaker friend Shelly Metcalf.

It won't surprise anyone that another Fincher film has attracted a killer ensemble, and it's sure to make Mank a fierce contender at next year's Screen Actors Guild Awards.

Advertisement

4. The Deliciously Witty Script

Netflix

Mank's screenplay was written by David Fincher's late father Jack back in the 1990s, and the filmmaker originally intended to make the movie after completing The Game in 1997, yet his insistence that the film be shot in black-and-white prevented it from ever going before cameras.

Advertisement

Almost 25 years later, Mank is finally hitting screens, and it has to be said that Fincher's devilishly witty screenplay is one of the easy highlights.

As frantically as it sometimes whips between time periods and characters, this is a wonderfully literate script packed with both smart nods to Hollywood history and heaps of pithy one-liners.

Advertisement

There's a rat-a-tat quality to the back-and-forth dialogues in its best moments, where much like The Social Network, talking between fired-up parties becomes a frantic tennis match of put-downs.

And while the end result is certainly more measured than in Fincher's Facebook drama, the script still provides a sturdy platform for Oldman and co. to stage a rich and absorbing depiction of a man swept up in the Hollywood maelstrom.

Advertisement

3. David Fincher's Smoothly Controlled Direction

Netflix

To the surprise of not a single solitary soul, Mank is an expertly crafted drama that, aside from those few aforementioned stylistic embellishments, is another home-run for David Fincher.

Advertisement

Despite its more restrained period style, the director's camera movements are as motivated and slickly smooth as ever, making the absolute most of every actor's physical movements and facial expressions, let alone their actual dialogues.

Fincher is easily one of the strongest actors' directors working today, and that again is something he aggressively confirms here.

Advertisement

As much as Fincher allegedly shot up to 200 takes of certain scenes, there's never the feeling that the director compromised or delivered anything but exactly what he wanted.

And though this is without question the director's most niche movie to date, it also demonstrates another facet of Fincher's filmmaking nous far away from the more heightened stylishness of, say, Fight Club or Zodiac.

Advertisement

2. Trent Reznor & Atticus' Ross Surprising Musical Score

Netflix

Mank once again sees Fincher collaborating with composers Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross, who deliver a musical score quite unlike anything they've ever made before - either for Fincher or as artists in their own rights.

Advertisement

Rather than employ pulsing synths, the pair only used instruments that were authentic to the period, resulting in a soundscape you'd never traditionally attribute to the duo.

Indeed, much of the musical score evokes the style of a brassy orchestral score from a '30s or '40s studio picture, albeit tinged with a sinister undertone you'd more typically expect from Reznor and Ross.

Advertisement

It's entirely possible they'll pick up their second Best Original Score Oscars for their work here, fittingly coming a decade after they scooped their first gongs for scoring The Social Network.

1. The Gorgeous Cinematography

Netflix

And again surprising few, Fincher's film is absolutely ravishing from a visual perspective, largely thanks to the eye-watering, note-perfect cinematography of Fincher's Mindhunter collaborator Erik Messerschmidt.

Advertisement

It's all too apt that a film centered around the creation of Citizen Kane - itself a cinematographic landmark with Gregg Toland's groundbreaking deep focus - takes similar advantage of its monochromatic presentation to deliver rich contrast and deep depth of field.

It's in this sense that Mank is perhaps best observed as a true love letter to classic Hollywood, even if it also has much to say about the toxic aspects of the era.

Advertisement