MCU: 10 Things You Learn Rewatching Thor

Why does Thor spend 80% of this movie just hanging out with Kat Dennings?!

By Josh Brown /

Marvel Studios

Though it might not seem like it now, considering the character has taken over the world with his latest movie and become one of the most integral parts of The Avengers, 2011's Thor was one of the biggest gambles of all the Phase 1 Marvel movies.

Advertisement

Where other flicks released in that initial run, most prominently Iron Man 1 and 2, had established a semi-believable world that was grounded in science-based explanations for why there could be robot men and big green monsters crashing through New York City, Thor's focus on Norse Gods threatened to throw all of that into disarray.

However, moving the action off-world and introducing an entirely new cosmos of possibilities paid off for Marvel in spades, setting the groundwork that made the likes of Guardians of the Galaxy possible.

Advertisement

That said, while it eventually proved to be the right move, the initial transition wasn't easy, and it puts the original Thor in a strange position on a rewatch. Trapped between needing to mesh with the science-based Iron Man but also wanting to tell a full-on story of Gods, magic and monsters, the character's introduction resulted in one of the most interesting flicks in the entire MCU.

10. It Balanced Science And Magic So Perfectly

Marvel Studios

As mentioned in the introduction, the original Thor had one of the most difficult jobs of any of those early MCU flicks (bar The Avengers). While the universe wasn't as grounded in reality as, say, The Dark Knight, it was still set in the "real world", with everything being explained through scientific means - be it experiments gone wrong or futuristic technology imbuing billionaires with the power of flight.

Advertisement

Thor, on the other hand, is entirely based around a cosmic hero. Not only did it have to establish the fact that Earth wasn't the only planet to house intelligent life, but it also had to explain how Norse mythology and actual living, breathing Gods fit in Marvel's world without completely jarring with what had previously been depicted.

The film certainly plays it safe with the cosmic elements - setting a huge chunk on Earth and grounding the titular hero as a person first and deity second - but there's no denying how elegantly it explains how there being a race of Gods makes perfect sense.

Advertisement

It's stated that while Thor's powers may look like magic to humans, it's simply another form of science. He explains that if you showed the internet or even electricity to ancient humans, that too would have probably looked like magic - which doesn't entirely explain how he can summon down electricity from the sky - but at least does a great job of introducing Earth to a larger cosmos.

9. The Frost Giant Story Should Have Been The Whole Film

Marvel Studios

The first half of Thor pulls no punches in upping the MCU's sense of scale and spectacle. Introducing viewers to the bitter rivalry between the Frost Giants and the Asgardians, the promise of an ancient war about to reignite is tantalising, especially when a bloodthirsty and naive future king like Thor is thrown into the mix.

Advertisement

In fact, the best story beats and character interactions in the movie are born out of this bubbling conflict. Thor's thirst for revenge in the opening act results in some incredible action scenes on a scale not yet seen in the MCU, all the while introducing a multitude of imaginative otherworldly locations that are still striking to this day.

Similarly, this action acts as the staging ground for Loki's winding plan to become King of Asgard not by allowing his father to be killed by his arch-rivals, but by orchestrating an assassination attempt on Odin only to conveniently thwart it at the last minute and look like the hero.

Advertisement

This plot thread is brilliantly executed, and does far more to further his development as a complex villain than his melodramatic rivalry with Thor, but unfortunately it's undercut because...

8. None Of The Drama On Earth Works (But The Comedy Does)

Marvel Studios

As soon as Thor crash lands on Earth, the film similarly grinds to a halt. After tantalising viewers with imaginative off-world locations and giving them a taste of cosmic politics, the hero is stripped of his powers and banished to the arse-end of nowhere.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, once he's there, what was once an intergalactic, Shakespearian action movie becomes yet another run-of-the-mill origin story where the hero has to learn that with great power comes great responsibility, or whatever.

Admittedly, Thor becoming more human was necessary to ease him in for an audience as well as for his character arc - but all of that is accomplished in the comedy, rather than the actual dramatic threads.

Advertisement

The character demanding "another!" and waltzing into a pet store to find something "big enough to ride" is hilarious, and does a great job to highlight his arrogance, which only makes it such a shame when it's dropped and the focus is put on predictable beats like Thor needing to learn to be "worthy" to reacquire Mjolnir.

7. All The Good Action Is In The First Half

Marvel Studios

Not only is the drama suddenly lacking once Thor hits Earth, but the action takes a turn for the worse as well. There's only two major set pieces to speak of, and the first, which pits the now-mortal God of Thunder against a string of faceless S.H.I.E.L.D. operatives, is completely lacking in tension as well as any sort of visual flair.

Advertisement

Yeah it's sort of fun to see Thor wrestling in the mud, but the entire sequence is so uninspired (not to mention the cameo appearance from Hawkeye is totally wasted) that it's hard to get excited by what's going on. Especially when you know that once Thor does bash his way through all of these goons, he's not going to be able to lift his hammer anyway.

The climactic battle against the Destroyer fares even worse, though. Sent down to Earth to destroy Thor and his companions, everything from the setting to the personality-free hunk of metal that's supposed to be imposing falls totally flat.

Advertisement

Thor finally getting his powers back is an admittedly solid, punch-the-air moment, but the actual fight is a pretty dire, CGI slog that could have been cut out entirely.

6. Stripping Thor Of His Powers Is Necessary, But Lame

Marvel Studios

The split between Asgard and Earth is where most of the problems in Thor can be found, but it's clear that this approach was needed as Marvel didn't want to overload viewers with too much, too soon, and grounding the action back on Earth more elegantly links the movie with the rest of the cinematic universe.

Advertisement

The same can be said of stripping Thor of his powers. It's not exactly easy to relate to a God, but by going out of their way to literally humanise the character, the studio made him one of the most beloved Avengers.

Still, although the decision works on paper, it doesn't make for a particularly fun movie. Especially after spending so much time with the character operating at full capacity, limiting his skill set means the Earthbound sequences lack the creativity and imagination that the rest of the movie thrives on.

Advertisement

5. Chris Hemsworth Is The MCUs' Most Underrated Actor

Marvel Studios

For the most part, Chris Hemsworth hasn't had many opportunities to flex his acting muscles as Thor. He's never been bad, but his characterisation throughout the movies has often been that of a grand, regal meathead, never really requiring the actor to get emotional or show any range.

Advertisement

That changed entirely with Thor: Ragnarok, which unlocked a side to the character Hemsworth had only flirted with previously, but going back to this original movie it's evident that he's always been a damn fine talent. Not only can he nail the Shakespearian grandeur as well as excelling at being an arrogant bonehead, but he brings a rather surprising amount of pathos to the role.

In particular, the scene where Loki visits him on Earth to spin a lie that Odin has died is beautifully played. Hemsworth channels the raw emotion necessary to wring every bit of drama out the scene, and this showcase acts as the first real sign of his depth, which sadly wouldn't be truly tapped into until years later.

Advertisement

4. It's The First Visually Stunning MCU Movie

Marvel Studios

For as good as the early MCU movies were, they didn't really offer anything new from a presentation standpoint that hadn't been seen before. That's partly the fault of the settings they used though, as there's only so many different ways you can capture a bland desert or the same cityscape that shows up in every comic-book movie.

Advertisement

Thor, on the other hand, was the first MCU film to really capture the colourful world of its comic-book inspiration. A setting like Asgard demanded a sense of spectacle that Marvel hadn't yet attempted to replicate, but fortunately the filmmakers were up to the challenge of bringing the cosmic side of the superhero universe to life.

Asgard itself, in all of its lush grandeur, is a fully-realised setting, but it's the more colourful locations such as the Bifrost and the never-ending backdrop of galaxies which are the most impressive. They helped massively in establishing a distinctive visual style that was entirely unique to the MCU, something which the series is otherwise tragically lacking in.

Advertisement

3. Natalie Portman Just Doesn't Want To Be There

Marvel Studios

Although they've moved away from the practice now, in Phase 1 every hero needed an obligatory love interest. To be fair on Marvel though, they didn't just cast any old actor for the part, scouting out charismatic and skilled people like Gwyneth Paltrow for Iron Man, Liv Tyler for The Incredible Hulk and, of course, Natalie Portman for Thor.

Advertisement

However, as good as Portman most certainly is, it's so obvious that she wants to be pretty much anywhere else than on a Marvel set playing Jane. Not as much as she doesn't want to be there in the sequel, of course, but her disinterest in the material is still extremely obvious.

In a way though, you can't really blame her. Once again the character is given more to do than simply swoon over the titular hero - here being an integral part of understanding where the Asgardians came from and unpacking the science behind their race - but those interesting threads get pushed to the side in favour of Jane only being around to eventually snog Thor's face off.

Advertisement

2. Thor's Humbling Is One Of The MCU's Best Character Arcs

Marvel Studios

It wasn't bombastic action that made the original run of Phase 1 movies so popular, it was Marvel's firm belief in character. As a result, audiences flocked to the original Iron Man to see Robert Downey Jr. as Tony Stark, not the titular hero, and the same can be said about Thor.

Advertisement

Here though, it's harder to draw a line between the superhero and the actual person. They're one and the same, but that actually made it possible for Marvel to craft a protagonist that's different from the others in their stable. Unlike Iron Man or Cap, Thor starts out as a God and has to learn how to be human, rather than the other way around.

This thread is what makes the original Thor still exciting to revisit today, as his development from being an entitled douchebag to a humbled king worthy enough to wield the power of Mjolnir acts as the backbone of the entire film. In fact, it's handled so well, and the character transforms so much, that he practically had nowhere to go from there until he was reinvented in Ragnarok.

Advertisement

1. Loki Has The Same Problems As Other Marvel Villains

Marvel Studios

It's long been posited that Marvel has a "villain problem". It's easy to see why that narrative took hold, too; unlike other superhero franchises like Nolan's Batman trilogy, Marvel's focus has always been on the heroes, and in building them so well the villains have mostly fallen by the wayside. Phase 2 perhaps fared the worst, with Whiplash and, uhm, that guy from Thor 2, being some of the most one-note and forgettable baddies in the entire genre, never mind this universe.

Advertisement

Thor's Loki has always been said to have avoided the same pitfalls that consumed those other villains though, and while that's true, the reasoning could simply be because he's been kept around the longest, and thus has had more opportunity for character development.

If he got the straight one-and-done treatment as everyone else in Phase 1, looking back, he probably wouldn't be as revered as he is. He still has more depth than other Marvel big bads, with his winding conspiracies and sibling rivalry with Thor giving him a distinct personality, but that's undone when he goes from being a bit of mischievous dick to murderous psychopath in the space of about 5 minutes of screen time.

Advertisement

His thoughts of betrayal and his family issues all provide great drama, but the character loses any sense of relatability with audience when he suddenly becomes yet another blank-slate punching bag.