MCU: 14 Things You Learn Rewatching The Avengers
Since when was Loki this much of a bad-ass?!
Back in 2012, there was an idea to bring together a group of remarkable people, see if they could become something more. That wasn't only true in-universe of the superhero team but in business terms for Marvel Studios and their Disney paymasters and boy did it deliver.
Despite having lots of things riding against it - the unenviable need to balance lots of moving parts, a satisfying escalation to justify the team-up and also the perpetual, cynical suggestion of a superhero bubble pop - the movie made an absolute fortune and made Kevin Feige's dream of a shared universe a reality. It was not only incredibly entertaining, but also hugely important as a keystone of the MCU's further expansion plans.
As a side note, in some markets, The Avengers was called Avengers Assemble, which might be the most needless and annoying title change in the history of cinema. If it was done in order to avoid links to the Sean Connery/Uma Thurman movie, then everyone who thought it would be a confusing problem ought to have been fired.
So, what did we learn from rewatching the first super ensemble in the MCU?
14. Loki Is A Bad-Ass
The Loki who initially appears in The Avengers is far removed from the "brainy weakling" archetype he becomes in Thor: Ragnarok. Yes, he's conniving and blade-sharp, but he's also a bona-fide bad-ass too. His first appearance is a reminder that Asgardians (and Frost Giant runts) are genetically superior to humans in every way.
He smashes his way in, kicks a soldier away almost effortlessly and seems immune to bullets, and later he manages to beat Captain America up. Very few characters manage that - it's like he's a different character entirely.
But along with that tougher edge, Tom Hiddleston also offers depth and nuance to the performance. Watching him and Thor argue towards the end on Stark tower particularly shows that, and the fact that Loki sheds a tear - almost accidentally - is testament to that subtlety. This is why he's still beloved as the MCU's best villain.
13. Hawkeye: Confusing Exposition Man
Hawkeye's introduction is just weird: not only do we get the silliness of him being in his nest "as usual" (it literally never happens again), but he's also - somehow an immediate expert on intergalactic wormhole travel. Or maybe he's not, because his claim that there is a "door" on the other side of the Tesseract - through which Loki arrives - has to be bull, because it's literally never mentioned again.
At no point is it ever explained how Loki manages to use the Tesseract - which Erik Selvig spends the entire first sequence calling "she" for absolutely no conceivable reason - from the other side. It's incredibly convenient and the kind of thing you'd normally assume might be explained, but nope.
Also, if it's the MIND Stone in Loki's sceptre, why does pressing it against a victim's heart lead to them being under his control? Is the mind bone connected to the heart bone in this world? And it's quite odd that the Stone turns Selvig into a grinning sycophant, but Barton into a cold zombie.
12. If They Wanted TO Make Black Widow A Skrull, They've Set It Up
When Black Widow appears for the first time, we get a real look at how great she is as an agent, but the deception she pulls on the Russians offers another story element that could be used later. There's a theory that suggests that she could be a Skrull and while it's pie in the sky at the minute, the fact that the Avengers shows her not once but TWICE convincingly disguising her true motives (she does it again with Loki, of course) is intriguing.
Could this have been early seeding? Even if it wasn't, it would be the perfect details to appropriate for a Secret Invasion revealtion.
Also, Scarlett Johnasson is wonderful in this movie: the tears in her eyes when Banner pretends to Hulk out is a brilliant touch and her interaction with Loki is stunning. Still, the performance isn't quite enough to hide the fact that in her meeting with Hulk she shows a picture of the Tesseract on her mobile, which is the weirdest debriefing ever, particularly as it suggests someone took the picture just for a lark.
11. Thanos Giving Away An Infinity Stone Will NEVER Make Sense
No matter how Infinity War deals with Thanos giving Loki the Mind Stone in the shape of the sceptre, it is never going to look like a huge mistake.
Even if it turns out he knew the Stone was inside the artifact and he was gambling on the chance to get the Tesseract AND the Mind Stone based on Loki's deceptive assessment of humanity as a push-over, it still makes Thanos look silly.
He was needlessly careless with something he was supposedly dedicated to finding and no amount of Loki's help could justify that. And The Other explicitly says that his agenda - and presumably Thanos' - is to access other worlds greater than Earth. That's not why he wanted it at all, according to his retconned story that emerges later, so it's clearly a story-telling oversight that Loki gets an Infinity Stone.
10. The German Sequence Is Amazing
Loki's German heist and attempt to subjogate the guests at the museum event is a truly great moment. It's charitably written for Tom Hiddleston, who takes great relish in his performance.
And then the one old man who stands up to him - clearly meant to be a survivor of the second world war and Hitler's reign of terror - offers a potted look at Captain America's entire MCU arc.
Him standing defiantly and saying "There are always men like you" is a great touch, as it matches precisely Cap's own spirit. Iron Man's entrance is a lot more rock and roll, inevitably, but it's still a great fan-baiting moment.
9. Tony Gets The Best Line
When he comes face to face with Loki in his tower, Tony Stark gets the best line of the whole movie:
"There's no throne, there is no version of this where you come out on top. Maybe your army comes and maybe it's too much for us but it's all on you. Because if we can't protect the Earth, you can be damned well sure we'll avenge it!"
There are lots of these Whedon moments in the script (and the "we have a Hulk" moment is pretty high up there too), but this just about eclipses Loki's speeches and his threats to Black Widow for the stand out.
Again, there's a little distracting element to Tony, though. When he first appears, he's flicking the switch on Stark Tower becoming self-sustaining under water. His armour works fine, but later in Iron Man 3 one of his Iron Legion armours is developed to allow him to operate underwater, which would be entirely redundant if he already could.
8. Coulson Should Have Died
He might be brilliant - particularly when he awkwardly fanboys over meeting Captain America and announcing that he's watched him sleeping - but there's a reason why Phil Coulson's death was so great in The Avengers. It's the same reason why retconning it for Agents Of SHIELD ruined one of the MCU's best moments.
Coulson is the human heart of The Avengers. He's charming and courageous beyond his limits and his likeability - which is key to uniting the Avengers is infectious. His death cuts deep and it brings the Avengers together in an even more concrete manner: he's essentially their trigger and removing that is incredibly disingenuous. After all, he says himself that it was never going to work unless they had something to fight for.
It's no wonder Whedon wasn't happy with it.
7. The Mind Stone Has WEIRD Powers
So far, the Infinity Stones' actual powers have been mostly quite guarded. We know that the Time Stone can affect time, that the Tesseract can help space travel, that the Power Stone is a hugely powerful weapon and that the Reality Stone can change reality, but when it comes to the Mind Stone all bets are off.
Because of the awkward way it's introduced, on top of the powers it has later - genetic modification, everything it empowers Vision with - it can also shoot like a gun, different types of mind control including persuasion (since Loki gets Barton to tell him all about Black Widow's past) and teleport characters to other places for meetings. On top of that it can apparently also make people grumpy enough to argue (in a play to get Banner to Hulk out) and has a tracking device built in. Basically, if you can imagine it, the Mind Stone seems to be able to do it.
At this point, it would have been better to call it the Plot Convenience Stone.
6. "I'm Always Angry" Was Better Than "I'm A Repressed Loner"
Though there is something to be said about the emotional repression of the first two actors who played the Hulk in modern Marvel movies, they're nothing compared to how good Mark Ruffalo is. And it's chiefly because of the different way he plays with the character's emotions.
Ruffalo's Banner is a man in control who is haunted by what he could become IF he lost control, rather than a man living on the knife edge of losing control. It's a subtle change, but it's the key evolution that made him a success.
There's more life to this Banner, more self-awareness and the crowning gloru of his "secret" that he's "always angry" is just wonderful. It also sets up Banner's entire arc for the MCU that is still unravelling into Infinity War.
Also, the first Hulk out scene is incredibly well done and the Hulk/Thor fight is great fun.
5. The Third Act Is Still VERY Tacked On
Regardless of how you feel about the rest of the movie and the apparent need for escalation in all blockbuster action movies, there's no getting around the fact that Loki's Chitauri invasion is tacked on for the sake of manufacturing greater thrills.
As a result, the Chitauri are a completely disposable race who are dropped in as cannon fodder and who are absolutely impossible to care about. And then it's hard to care about anything that is so flippantly treated by the film's own script.
At one point The Other says "The Chitauri grow restless" - how, exactly? They're robots, possibly, since they simply cease to work when the mothership is destroyed. And why wasn't this ever explored: seriously, what even are they?
4. That Hero Shot Is The Most Effective Single Shot In The Entire MCU
When you hire Joss Whedon for a movie like this, you do it because of a certain agenda: you want fan-baiting moments in the script, heart and emotional legitimacy, and most of all, big bombastic hero moments.
And while some of his camera work is a little self-indulgent (like the shot of Black Widow in the mirror at the start and all of the many slanty camera angles), there is no getting around the fact that the spinning hero shot from the Battle Of New York remains the single most impactful, fan-baiting moment in the entire MCU.
It's a little corny - just as all of the biggest Whedon moments (like the "there was an idea" speech) - but it's impossible not to feel something when you see it even now. It also makes an awful lot more sense than Thor's individual hero shot when he's in the field shooting lightning into the air for no reason.
3. There Are Way Too Many Convenient Rule Breaks
There's a LOT of convenient writing in The Avengers. First off, the laws of the Mind Stone in Loki's sceptre are completely malleable to whatever situation they're operating in. For instance how exactly does Dr Selvig simply wake up from his mind control without the same deprogramming Hawkeye went through? Why is their mind control different in both cases?
And how can Selvig resist his control enough to build the most convenient backdoor into the Tesseract portal device?
On top of that, Loki's body can deflect bullets, but Thor can be stabbed. Chitauri can be deactivated by killing the mothership but pulling wires out of their heads doesn't "kill them." Loki can phase away, as he does to get out of the steel trap, but he somehow can't when he's faced down by the Avengers at the end on Stark Tower. It's all very... convenient.
And then in the interest of a gag, Hulk can speak, despite the fact that it's later established in Thor: Ragnarok that he can only speak like a child because he's been in control of Banner's body for two years. In other words, when he says "puny God" it's impossible.
2. The HYDRA Theory Makes A Lot Of Sense
There is a theory out there that suggests that HYDRA brought together the Avengers in order to destroy them, using Arnim Zola's superpower algorithm to identify key targets and their infiltration of S.H.I.E.LD. to greenlight the Avengers Initiative. It's suggested as the only explanation for them allowing the superhero team to exist.
The Avengers feeds into that idea as well: given that Powers Boothe's Gideon Malick sits at the head of the World Security Council and it's him who sends the nuke to New York, it would seem that this was HYDRA's plan all along.
They wanted to bring the Avengers together for this sort of opportunity and Malick took his chance to try and sneak HYDRA's agenda to destroy them through. Sadly for him, he was thwarted by an uncharacteristic heroic sacrifice by Tony Stark.
1. Thanos Should Have "Courted Death"
The only thing that matters from the fan-baiting post-credits scene that introduced Thanos for the first time was the fact that the Mad Titan was on his way for a future storyline.
The idea that he would continue trying to take down humanity makes no sense because it's later revealed Thanos is only interested in getting all of the Infinity Stones and the only Infinity Stone (that he was 100% aware of) on Earth was the Tesseract, which Thor takes back to Asgard. If he was aware it was on Earth, why isn't he aware it's then moved to Asgard? And why would "ruling" mankind even be on Thanos' mind? That's not what he's here for.
Anyway, it's a real shame that Infinity War isn't going to be using Thanos' attempted seduction of Death as a key story element, because that "court death" line was clearly designed to set up a more pure adaptation of the Infinity Saga.
What else did you notice rewatching The Avengers? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.