Oscars 2010: If We Picked the Winners (Best Actress)

By Christopher Lominac /

With the dearth of well-written roles for woman over the last few decades, Best Actress commonly isn't the star-studded affair it use to be when you had the likes of Katherine Hepburn, Bette Davis, Joan Crawford, Olivia De Havilland, and Ingrid Bergman competing for the Oscar. The movies from which the Best Actress nominees come from now are also typically smaller, lesser known films than the films their leading male counterparts are nominated for. In fact, over the last twenty years, only two Best Actress winners have belonged to films that won the Oscar for Best Picture (Shakespeare in Love and Million Dollar Baby) and eight times the winner of Best Actress came from a film that wasn't even nominated for Best Picture. The lineup of actresses nominated for Best Actress in 2010 proved to be no exception, because while the performances themselves were relatively strong, with the exception of the winning actress' film, very few people actually saw most of these films. Despite the small exposure these films and performances received, it is a pretty solid lineup and there aren't really any substitute performances egregiously snubbed that I would propose for replacement with one great exception: Lesley Manville in Another Year. Of course, as is almost an annual occurrence for some "bubble" performances, the likely reason for Manville's absence from Oscar's big party was category confusion. It was hard for many people to decide whether Manville belonged in the Best Supporting Actress category or as a lead in the Best Actress category, and her lackluster campaign did not really get a clear message across as to which category people should have voted for her. Her role in the film is a genuinely tough one to categorize, but had I been able to vote, I think I would have included her as a Best Actress nominee. Either way, it really is a shame she was not included in one of the two categories though, because she gave the best performance of any female of 2010. The only other performance that I might have included instead of some of the other nominees is Julianne Moore in The Kids Are All Right. While her partner, Annette Bening (who did give the better performance in my opinion), was nominated, a large part of the film was about the interaction between the two women, so it would have been fitting for both of them to have received nominations. Getting two lead nominations from the same film though is an extremely rare occurrence, so it was not too surprising only one of them received a Best Actress nomination. That's enough speculating about the "could of"s and "should of"s, let's get on to the actual nominees.5. Nicole Kidman - Rabbit Hole Nicole Kidman lives and breathes melodrama, which means as a general critic of the genre, you won't see me signing up to be the president of the "Nicole Kidman Fanclub" anytime soon. I find her performances quite often to be too self-conscious and mannered for my taste, and the movies she appears in are often worse than that. Surprisingly though, Rabbit Hole is an effective movie (especially relative to its typical peers), and this is in part due to a decent performance from Ms. Kidman. The strongest part of the film, as well as Kidman's performance, is in her interaction with the young man who accidentally killed her young boy in a tragic traffic accident. The connection between the two characters is very tepid, almost laid back, as neither person (especially the young man) knows quite how to act in this situation. As the frequency of the meetings grow though, both characters are able to become slightly more comfortable with one another, engaging in real meaningful conversations that serve as a cathartic process for both people. As good as her performance is in these scenes though, they are some painfully weak moments whenever she has to show how bitter and angry her character has become. During the confrontational climax of the film, when, after nipping and biting at one another throughout the film, Nicole Kidman and Aaron Ekhart's husband and wife characters finally have it out, all of Kidman's "I'm angry" mannerisms come off as painfully premeditated and non-naturalistic. In all parts of the film where she is portraying her bitterness, something just doesn't click right. While this sort of response to the death of a young child is definitely plausible, something about Kidman's portrayal is just too self-aware, someone imitating a devastated grieving mother instead of inhabiting that character. Overall, Kidman's performance is a mixed bag. When she's good, she's good; when she's bad, she's bad. The good probably outshines the bad by a small margin, but not enough for me to rank her above any of her fellow nominees.

4. Michelle Williams - Blue Valentine

Blue Valentine wasn't very widely distributed or seen by the larger movie-going public, but from the moment the film started touring the festival circuit, buzz immediately began to swell around the film's two lead performances by Ryan Gosling and Michelle Williams. It was an uphill battle the whole way (including an initial NC-17 rating controversy), but when the nominees were announced, the film managed to be half way successful, securing a nomination for Michelle Williams, but failing to do the same for Ryan Gosling. I found the choice a bit bewildering, because of the two performances I definitely felt Gosling's was stronger, but Williams' performance was by no means weak. Playing the same role at two different points in a relationship (it's magically irreverent beginnings and its bitter solemn ending), Williams quite understated performance portrays a woman making lemonade out of lemons, doing the best she can under difficult circumstances. The result is a doomed relationship of obsessive admiration on one side and not fully requited love on the other. Williams gives her character the feel of someone always on guard, holding something back, which makes sense given the household she was raised in and her hurried relationship with Gosling's character, but it is also alienates her from the audience, making it hard to sympathize with her as much as you want to. It may have not been written in the script, or maybe Derek Cianfrance purposefully directed Williams to act this way, but there is some spark of shared humanity missing from her character which makes me hesitant to heap as much praise on the performance as I might otherwise. The only moment where we even get a hint at any sense of humor from Williams character is in her hilariously dark joke about a boy and a pedophile who are walking in the woods, but other than this, her character is unfortunately distant. Williams' performance is a good one, but there is just something intangible lacking, making it short of the emotional punch in the gut it was meant to be, which is why I rank it fourth among the nominees.

3. Jennifer Lawrence - Winter's Bone

Jennifer Lawrence's performance as Ree in the indie hit Winter's Bone proved to be far from a mere one-off success from a talented young actress, but rather proved top be an announcement of a new star and one of the strongest female thespian forces in the business. As impressive as the performance in the film is, both the movie and the role feel a bit inauspicious for your typical "star-maker" roles, but luckily merit actually won out for once, and a mere two years later Jennifer Lawrence has become an A-list superstar and an Oscar-winning actress. Playing a teenage girl from an impoverished family in the Ozark mountains of Missouri, Jennifer Lawrence's Ree is forced to become the "man of the house" after her father puts up their household for bail and then is nowhere to be found. In order to keep the house from going into foreclosure, so that she can maintain a roof over the head of her younger brother and sister as well as along her emotionally shot mother, Ree is forced to do some investigative digging into the dark criminal underbelly of her extended family's crystal meth business. The unwritten rules of the land are "look straight ahead and don't ask questions", so the perturbation caused by Ree's inquiries into her father's whereabouts are none too welcome by her larger hillbilly family who are far from the warm "milk and cookie" variety that many associate with the word. Determined not to let her family become completely destitute, Ree perseveres with the reluctant help from her uncle Teardrop (John Hawkes), despite the mounting threat from her drug-dealing kin. This undeterred perseverance ("true grit" you might even say, to borrow a saying from one of the year's other Oscar contenders) is the most memorable feature of Lawrence's performance. Whatever comes her way, she stays the course, willing to do what is necessary (even if it means losing her life) in order to save the land and house she lives on. This is not only communicated through Lawrence's dialogue, but also through her eyes, as her determined stare never once wavers. The only weakness (if you want to call it that) that keeps me from ranking the performance higher, is this one-note is pretty much all there is to the performance. The movie is the cinematic equivalent of Donkey Kong perpetually throwing barrels for Mario to jump over, and we never get to see Lawrence's Ree out of her Mario-mode. Regardless, it is still a great performance and the pronouncement of the arrival of what I think may be, looking back many years from now, one of the best actresses to emerge in quite some time.

2. Annette Bening - The Kids Are All Right

Playing the stricter, more responsible half of a lesbian couple, Annette Bening's role is one of the keys to the success of The Kids Are All Right. Bening basically plays the consistently underrated role of the "straight man" (I promise you no pun is intended), while all the more care-free characters, such as the two children, Julianne Moore, and Mark Ruffalo, are wrecking her most carefully laid out plans. In any comedy, this is a tougher role to play than people tend to think, because while you must appear exacerbated by all the mishaps caused by the people around you, if you come across as too much of a downer, it becomes impossible for the audience to sympathize with you. The role is made all the more complicated by the fact that The Kids Are All Right is not a straight up comedy, but a dramedy, which means Bening also had the responsibility of bringing at least partial realism to the character, and this is where her performance shines the most. I imagine it was very tempting to portray her character as a holier-than-thou individual who is nothing but a complete victim in the narrative's tale of infidelity and betrayal, but Bening smartly resists these urges and instead opted to create a fully functioning human being, flaws and all. Bening's character is quite annoying at times. She nags at everyone in the household and meets the textbook definition of a control freak, but it is actually these flaws that allow the audience to relate with her character (even if they don't particularly like her) and then sympathize with her later on. When she discovers her partner's unfaithfulness, instead of righteous indignation (an all too common choice for film and television shows dealing with infidelity), Bening's character is genuinely hurt and lost for answers. The reaction yet again humanizes her character, showing a vulnerability and weakness we did not see before. Smart decisions and believable execution such as these examples illustrate fine craftsmanship on Bening's part. She did not quite make it to the top of my list, but had she won, it is a turn that would have been worthy of the saying "Academy Award winning performance".

1. Natalie Portman - Black Swan

Other than the aforementioned categorically ambiguous performance from Lesley Manville in Another Year, there was no female character that drew me into her world and predicament as much as Natalie Porman's performance as Nina Sayers in Black Swan. In this supernatural Gothic thriller set in the highly competitive world of New York City Ballet, Nina must make the tough decision between grounded sanity and artistic sincerity. At the beginning of the film, Portman's Nina is about as sweet and naive as someone her age could be (probably unrealistically so for a girl who has made it as far as she had already, but then again, Black Swan ain't about realism, to put it mildly), but as we watch Alice plummet deeper into the proverbial rabbit hole, it becomes apparently clear that there is no getting off this acid trip. The pressure Nina feels from all sides is extremely intense (like the water being held back by the Hoover Dam), and the at first subtle deterioration of the human mind caused by this sort of pressure is handled with appropriate intensity on Portman's part. She does her best to handle it all in stride, but soon holes begin the spring in the dike and the stress begins to manifest itself in strange ways. The important part of Natalie Portman's performance is to never let on that she even has the slightest clue to what is really happening. The slightest wink of the eye throws the whole thing off, but Natalie does not even for one second show her hand and play for camp, keeping the audience riveted to their seats. The only part of her performance where it begins to tear at the seams, and this is especially true for the movie as a whole, is in its over-the-top and all too fitting finale, where the film starts to become a bit predictable. As Nina completely lose her mind, the insanity is laid on a bit thick by Portman, but I believe the problem here lies more with the script and direction than her performance. Despite this small criticism, Portman's is a wonderfully captivating performance, creating one of the best heroines in modern cinema. That's my take on the category, but let know your feelings on the nominees, as well as performances you think should have been nominated, in the comments section down below.