Oscars 2013: Ranking This Year's Best Pictures

By Mike Reyes /

It's the biggest night in Hollywood, the night where several of the year's supposed best films are going to fight it out for top honors. It's been an interesting year for films, and an even more interesting year for awards, what with Argo making its way on the path of Awards Glory. But the one question always pervades: were the films that were nominated any good? Surely Hollywood is going to favor something the public won't always buy, and vice versa. Not to mention, some of these "prestige pictures" don't even make it to the wide theatrical market, and are instead consigned to indie cinemas and best picture package runs at your local theater. Well, look no further, as I've endured all 9 best pictures, and have lived to tell the tale. I've seen more French people die than I could care to remember, been cast into the seas and pitched a case to believe in God. I've been through The Civil War, both the historical and the precursive alternate historical sides, and through the mystical Bathtub to square off against ancient beasts. Also, I hunted Osama Bin Laden, saved U.S. embassy employees from Iran in the 1970's and danced with Jennifer Lawrence. But was any of it any good? Stick around and find out, as I now rank the 9 "best" pictures of 2013, starting at the bottom...

9. Les Miserables

Initial Impression: Despite my misgivings about Tom Hooper, and the fact that The King's Speech was a good, but terribly overrated film, I still found myself drawn by star power and love of the source material. It's Les Miserables! If any play should have been turned into a movie before Phantom, it should have been this! Epic French costumes, drama and intrigue with a dash of romance, sweeping scenery, and all of this PLUS a musical? How was this NOT used as bait for the Oscar hook before? Alas, the more I read reviews citing everything from Russell Crowe's rather subpar singing voice to a mid-film dip in quality that supposedly rendered the first and last act's greatness useless , the more I began to worry. Again, I LOVE Les Mis, and the last thing I wanted was a film that took something I loved and turned it into a sterile, joyless affair. If I'd wanted that, I'd have stayed home and watched Jurassic Park III again. I was primed and ready to relive a show that I'd experienced on the stage through the medium of film. The Verdict: Jurassic Park III would have been a more preferable option after sitting through this disaster. Tom Hooper has once again managed to turn something that could have been interesting and intriguing, and turned it into a milquetoast affair with his "directing". His musical numbers turned out looking like 1990's music videos for the likes of Duran Duran, and he never lets his camera truly explore the sets as he forces his leads to sing in front of the camera, never allowing them to move past 10 feet from the camera. As if that wasn't bad enough, the music was altered enough that actual Les Mis fans would notice. Lines are cut, melodies are pitched down and instead end up sounding more depressing than somewhat energetic, and that damned ending on the barricade! Hooper misery bangs the audience with a story that was already sad enough on Broadway, but manages to be sadder with Hooper's decisions. By the time Gavroche got gunned down, I pretty much threw up my hands and said "I'm done!" I honestly don't remember being hammered with the message, "God's in charge, just leave it up to him" so heavily when I saw the play on Broadway, and the film just ended up leaving me cold. The one thing it does get right though is, predictably, "I Dreamed A Dream". Anne Hathaway's performance during that number assured her the Oscar she's been promised since the beginning of awards season. Her balance of hellish vulnerability and wistful remembrance works perfectly. That's not to say any of the other actors aren't good at their jobs, it's just to say that out of a film that was directed to Hell, one angel arose. Final note: Russell Crowe wasn't that bad of a singer. How quickly you all forget Pierce Brosnan in Mamma Mia.

Advertisement

8. Beasts of the Southern Wild

Initial Impression: Every year, there are one of two films I dread watching, simply because they look like they're trying too hard. Be it the way they're marketed, or even the way the Oscar committee presents them like Simba upon high, there's always a movie or two that I feel like I'm being forced to watch. This, along with Amour, were the two I felt like I was going to be clawing at the seats in an attempt to stay awake during. I'm sorry, but if I see a little girl running with sparklers down the center of a poster that's supposed to say "Indie adventure with social relevance", I tend to be a little... apprehensive. I do have my reasons though: the concept of a whimsical story connecting itself to Hurricane Katrina had already played itself out with Benjamin Button, the fact that the film was being sold by the pre-requisite plucky young (and naturally Award Nominated) protagonist made it seem rather annoying, and on top of all of that it looked like it was filmed as a hybrid "Indie Film/Levi's Commercial". Jubilant Southern folk reveling in their poor yet somehow happy life, with sparklers in hand and semi-blurry handicam work, and a soundtrack that screams "INDIE!"; this didn't sound like my cup of tea. Though to be fair, The Help didn't sell me on its inclusion before I saw it, and that film ended up bowling me over in my attempts not to like it. The Verdict: So I'm supposed to believe that this little girl started off a chain of events that would kill her father, push global warming further, AND release a mythical beast? On top of thinking that this girl should be slavishly devoted to a really, really lousy father; and that she should be happy to grow up in squalor pre and post natural disaster, because it's "home"? This played more like a horror film for me than anything, because even a fellow member of the audience and I wondered just what type of message was this pushing? I get it: Katrina was a massive failure on the part of the U.S. Government, FEMA in particular. But does that mean the hospitals are evil, and that the folks who are at least trying to help are the ones that aren't to be trusted? I was seriously rethinking the end of E.T. after this film, as the escape from the displacement shelter really had me feeling a twisted Spielbergian vibe. I was not impressed with this film, and as adorable as its young lead is, this wasn't a Best Actress worthy nomination. She acted like a kid on camera, which is basically what was happening. I give the leads in the film props for seeming like a convincing father/daughter team, but over all this seemed like a blend of Harry Potter and Precious, which did not go over with me.

Advertisement

7. Life of Pi

Initial Impression: I honestly was enthusiastic about this film, as it looked absolutely beautiful. The 3D element helped sell me on this film, considering the lush imagery that the film was selling through it's trailer. On top of that, it was based on a best seller, it came from a director I've defended before (I enjoyed the first Hulk film. Sue me.), all of which intrigued me even more. My apprehension lied in the supposed spiritual nature of the storyline. Don't get me wrong, I don't mind if a film indulges in some Deus Ex Machina storytelling, but as you saw with Les Mis, when God basically seems behind the whole damned story, it stops looking like a movie and more like a tract against man's free will. The Verdict: Again with the God complex, Hollywood? Really? From the moment this film started its cutesy "move the titles like the animals do" credit sequence, I knew I wasn't going to enjoy this. And then I was taken, albeit briefly, while learning of Pi's childhood. Maybe it was the engaging portrayal of this young boy and his family, mixed with AMAZING 3D imagery and a dash of whimsy. Maybe it was the smooth narration of Irrfan Khan' s older version of Pi that helped settle me in at first, but I thought I was going to be eating my hat on this one. Then something happened... something that was bound to rear its ugly head again during this best picture showcase...heavy handed symbolism. From the moment the "three passengers" metaphor began its obvious trajectory, I was beginning to loathe this film. And then a flash of something beautiful, and possibly profound, would occur and leave me almost ready to believe again. But by time Pi actually yells into the rain asking God what more he wanted, I was done. Forrest Gump was lucky it got away with that, but this wasn't the time or the place to lay that stuff down. The cherry on the garbage sundae was the moment where for 10 - 15 minutes, we sit there and we listen to Pi weave the "fake" story of what happened. You mean to tell me that in film where we've seen a carnivorous island, a soulful tiger, and various images of water looking gorgeous as anything, we can't put together a semi flashback sequence that would help keep the previous momentum of the film going? No, instead Ang Lee decided to let the film hit a brick wall in terms of pacing and the result is even more agonizing than the reveal of said carnivorous island. (Which probably ties the island from Lost as the most nonsensical thing ever, in terms of water surrounded land masses.)

Advertisement

6. Amour

Initial Impression: I couldn't believe it when I had heard that this was nominated in the field for top honors. The only Haneke film I've ever seen is his American remake of Funny Games, and honestly that was enough to put me off of his filmography, considering how utterly pointless it seemed. Two dandies randomly visiting violence on a family, only for one of them to stumble across Adam Sandler's remote from "Click" and undo a moment they didn't like? Seriously, that's the plot twist you're going with? On top of my displeasure with Haneke, I just didn't feel like watching the first 15 minutes of Up in live action and with subtitles. That's not to say I don' t like foreign films, but I think that sometimes the Academy goes a little overboard with nominating films for two top honors categories, when you know well they're only going to win in one category. Much like Up, Amour is nominated for Best Picture and the secondary category of Best Foreign Language Film. Guess who's winning Best Foreign Language Film this year? The film that was never going to get Best Picture and took up an extra spot on the already crowded schedule. The Verdict: I surprisingly did not hate this film. Haneke went a long way to restoring his name in my eyes, and hearing these two old folks in love speaking their native tongue is extremely beautiful. A film that is meditative on both loss and declining quality of life, it managed to not be what I had feared it would be. Emmanuelle Riva and Jean-Louis Trintignant play a married, loving couple so brilliantly that it's crushing to see them slowly part. But alas, even this film had its superfluous flaws, granted they weren't worse than the films below it on the list. Haneke likes to show us shots that have nothing to do with the film, or even in some cases linger a little to long on the subject in question. A maid vacuuming the house, a concert audience during a show, these are two instances where he should have cut sooner, so as to preserve the economy of story. Also, the pigeon chasing metaphor was ridiculous. This is Amour, not a hero's quest picture. Suffice it to say, it's the best film of the ones I'd never watch again from this list.

Advertisement

5. Lincoln

Initial Impression: Ever since I was a child, I've been a Spielberg aficionado: the way he tells a story and the way he uses emotions in his film have almost always helped me enjoy his films (Munich being a glaring example to the counter). Indeed, "The Beard", as he's affectionately referred by, knows his way around a good yarn, and he especially has proven himself to be a student and fan of history. This film already had two strikes against it: 1.) It took so long to make its lead, Liam Neeson, dropped out before production. 2.) It was another Tony Kushner pairing, and since Munich was the last story they worked together on, it seemed like a red flag. Of course, when it did go into production, it did so with great force and speed, casting a veritable who's who of actors from past and present glory. And with Daniel Day Lewis and Sally Field at the helm, one could expect nothing but greatness. The Verdict: Let's just put it out there that Spielberg is a sentimental man. His films, at their worst, can devolve into films that put too fine a point on emotion vs. action. (His sex scene inter-cut with remembrances of the murdered athletes in Munich was probably one of the most awkward things ever in his career. And this was after 1941!) At his worst, he'll hammer you over the head just as much as some of these other filmmakers will, and he did seem like he was going to almost do that here. Even in the ending, when we see Lincoln's visage in the flame of a lamplight, with him recently dying from his gunshot wounds, Spielberg was close to pushing it with what was already a partially dry film. And yet, it still managed to be entertaining and engaging in some ways. The political wrangling that went on behind the scenes was interesting enough for a film on its own, but what was also interesting was the portrait of Lincoln the married man. His spats with Mary Todd (Molly) Lincoln look like the antithesis of the man we've all come to know and learn about in this modern age. Lincoln came off as a man, not a spartan of virtue and temperance. The film balanced those two components rather well, and yes, Tommy Lee Jones probably stole this film from Daniel Day Lewis with his portrayal of Thaddeus Stevens. If anything, the film should have retained the title "Team of Rivals", as it was more of an ensemble piece than a showcase for Daniel Day Lewis, who does a fine job in this film with the uneasy task of bringing a historical figure to life, without dipping too much into the well of sentimental memory. John Hawkes, James Spader, and Tim Blake Nelson make the film entertaining; Day-Lewis makes it dramatic, and Sally Field, along with Tommy Lee Jones, make it emotional. What can I say? I'm a sucker for a good history flick.

Advertisement

4. Django Unchained

Initial Impression: If there was a "second Spielberg" when it comes to my preference of directors, Tarantino would definitely be on that list. Discovering Pulp Fiction for the first time is like reading the Bible and becoming a devout Christian simply by finishing Genesis. Much like his films, QT grabs you at the beginning and proceeds down his twisted tales of blood and glory with you by his side, as if to say "Ain't we all just screwed up?" But if there was a film that seemed set to upset the cart, it would have been Django Unchained. Inglorious Basterds was an amazing film, but it started his trend of taking history and rewriting it with a razor sharp pen and plenty of blood. On top of that, it was a Western. A Spaghetti Western, granted, but it had potential to alienate a good portion of the movie going public with its genre. Oh yeah, did I mention the ever touchy subject of racism? Yeah...it had that going against it as well. The Verdict: Speaking of good history flicks, this isn't one of them. Unless of course you go as far as differentiating that this is a history flick in the Tarantino Alternaverse. In which case, this is one hell of a history flick, and the kids in class are going to love it! Furthering along the homage phase he's been going through, Django Unchained takes us on a ride that's as thrilling as it is intriguing. And unlike Lincoln, this film handles the usage of rather charged racial epithets with a seemingly more authentic flare. Spike Lee has no reason to be butthurt, especially since he hadn't seen the film when he made his remarks. And as far as the casting went, Jamie Foxx has helped redeem himself from a one way ticket to Direct to DVD Hell, as his Django is both stoic and emotional, while at the same time comedic and vengeful. Also, and the following goes without saying, Leonardo DiCaprio was robbed of a Best Supporting Actor nomination, as his exploration into "racially charged meets cartoony" evil is something that was a sight to behold. The fact that he could pull off the scene where he cut himself on a glass, and do so without breaking character or scene, is quite frankly a testament to his craft. Naturally, Christoph Waltz is his usual charming self as Dr. King Schultz; and Tarantino's eye for imagery is one of two films that properly evokes the look of 1970's films, particularly with his long takes of western vistas and the quick zoom on certain action in said vistas.

Advertisement

3. Zero Dark Thirty

Initial Impression: Confession: I hated The Hurt Locker. I thought it was too boring, and it couldn't make up its mind between whether it was a deep character driven piece on the effects of long term warfare on the human psyche, or if it was an action packed adrenaline pumped thriller. That film seemed to have a foot in each pond, and couldn't decide which one to swim in. The only part about that movie that really effected me was the ending, and even in that case it wasn't tied enough to the central narrative for me to care completely. But then Kathryn Bigalow showed off massive stones in saying, "Hey...let's make a film about the hunt for Osama Bin Laden!" As if that didn't get my attention enough, the fact that we actually caught him gave the film the potential for a perfect, cathartic ending. Plus, Jason Clarke and Jessica Chastain's stars have been on the rise for some time, and Ms. Chastain's nomination for Best Actress showed that this could have been a film worth paying attention to. The Verdict: Wow. Just wow. Never did I think that I would be on board with a Kathryn Bigalow film, as up until now the only film of hers I could really say I enjoyed was K-19: The Widowmaker. (No, I wasn't a fan of Point Break. Blasphemy, I know.) When she was announced to be helming this film, I was dreading it would be a pseudo sequel to The Hurt Locker, especially with Mark Boal writing yet again. However what I got instead of a disappointing film was a film that made me appreciate the efforts of the CIA, Seal Team Six, and military intelligence worldwide. What's more, Jessica Chastain is ever continuing to impress with her acting chops as we see her go from green field operative to an ultimately worn down woman. Relieved that her job is finished, and that she can go wherever she wants, by time the final frame roles around she doesn't know what she wants. She probably doesn't even know what she'd call "home" at that point, as for almost a decade she's called her job the sum total of her life. Equal parts thrilling, dismaying, and ultimately triumphant, this film helped me see the Bigalow that everyone was talking about with The Hurt Locker.

Advertisement

2. Silver Linings Playbook

Initial Impression: All I really had to go on with this movie was the usual indicators of an Oscar film: previous award nominees, a comeback for a once maligned Hollywood player, a Director who's used to being invited to The Dance, and it was based on a best selling novel. But when that director is David O. Russell, and his previous film was The Fighter, I automatically was inclined to see this film. Then the awards nominations and buzz started to build, especially considering this film has the acting nods locked up. Hell, it brought DeNiro back out of Paycheck mode and it got Bradley Cooper his first nomination! Plus, Jennifer Lawrence in yoga pants. It doesn't speak to the quality of the film, I know, but they could have won some major votes if they'd filmed this puppy in 3D. The Verdict: Jennifer Lawrence has been getting the lion's share of awards attention with this flick, which isn't a particularly bad thing. She's earned the nomination, I believe she's earned a win, and ultimately she's ready for this. However, I'd like to draw attention to rest of the core ensemble to this piece: Jacki Weaver, Robert DeNiro, and Bradley Cooper. As a family unit, they're convincing. As equally broken and interesting people, they're convincing. As individual actors and performances, they're convincing. I cannot throw enough love to the core and even the extended cast of this film. Freaking Chris Tucker is even amazing! And Julia Stiles returns to movies with a small, but nevertheless important role. David O. Russell is on my watch list after this and The Fighter have proceeded to take tight knit casts and stories of dysfunction mixed with love, and turn them into Oscar gold. By the time this film wrapped up, I felt as if I'd sat through a typical romantic comedy arc, but one that was told with only the highest quality. In another's hands, say Adam Shankman or his ilk, this could have been a Valentine's Day hit. In the hands of David O. Russell, it's something that outweighs the king's ransom its inferior prospect could have ever made. No emotion wasted, no frame wasted, this is no fat storytelling, and I fell in love with this movie like Pat fell for Tiffany. (And seriously, a 3D conversion post award season would do you good.)

Advertisement

1. Argo

Initial Impression: If the impression wasn't clear before, I am a sucker for good historical films. We were lucky we got three good ones this year, and this was one of my most anticipated. I'm also a sucker for Ben Affleck directed films, particularly ever since I saw him blow the doors off of directing Gone Baby Gone. I'm not going to lie, seeing the trailer for this one had my hopes up in the stratosphere. In his short run as a director, Affleck has grown leaps and bounds in his technical prowess. With each move he makes, he draws more and more attention to his work, and he brings the accolades right behind it. The fact that this was Affleck's first foray into historical storytelling was also intriguing, simply because historical stories are a different bread and butter from fictional stories. You can't change the ending on history unless you're Quentin Tarantino, and even then it was in jest. You need to stick to the details if you're making a historical film, and if you take liberties they still need to fit somewhat plausibly into the framework of reality. Argo was either going to be really good or really cheap. The Verdict: This is it. This is the big ticket winner, the movie that not only matched expectations but also exceeded them. Ben Affleck, for being on his third film, has stuck the landing and managed to cross the bridge between fictional and non-fictional storytelling. He takes so many successful components of other awards films (ensemble casts, stories based on past historical exploits, a look that reflects the period the film is set in) and melds them into one successful product. What's also so great about Argo is that we're not only treated to performances from actor's he's previously used (Titus Welliver and Victor Garber, for starters), but we're also treated to performances from legends like Alan Arkin and John Goodman; all of which prove that Affleck is truly an actor's director. While it's mostly a historical picture, it's also a slightly funny look at Hollywood politics and real life politics co-mingling towards a common end. Instead this time, it wasn't in the name of propaganda...it was in the name of rescuing innocent lives. Affleck's film not only trumps the Best Picture field for this year, but it's also his ticket to stay on the A-List. What do you think of this ranking? Share your thoughts below.

Advertisement