Oscars 2013: Who Will Win, Who Should Win

By David Braga /

The Oscars. Hollywood€™s biggest night is always preceded by a stream of complaints against the system, reminders of past injustices, and cries in vain for the films that were snubbed. It€™s a night that many of us love to hate, and then, when they finally do roll around, everyone watches anyway. Regardless of how right or wrong the choices are, or how ludicrous it is to think that there is one definitive Best Film every year, the Oscars still hold an important place in the world of cinema. And so it€™s best to just try to have as much fun with them as you can, cause they aren€™t going anywhere. The winners are selected by an odd blend of momentum, studio politics, and actual merit, so trying to guess the who€™s going home with the statue is less about knowing who did the best job and more about realizing who€™s moment it is, or what film feels the most like an Oscar winner (see: The King€™s Speech over The Social Network). Still, we can dream, so alongside my guesses of who will take home the awards, we can ponder who should, in a perfect world, go home with the prize. And off we go;

Best Picture: Will Win - Argo

All signs point to Ben Affleck€™s relatively slick thriller taking home the big one. Not only has it pretty much swept the ceremonies leading up to Oscar night, it also has a certain Best Picture feel to it that should make it a lock. Argo has everything the Oscar voters seem to want to see: excitement, a positive resolution, easy to define good and bad guys, and an acknowledgement to the power of the movies. Is it actually the best film of the year? Of course not. But as the best €œpretty good€ film of the year, it€™s a safe, acceptable choice, and sometimes that€™s what matters most.

Best Picture: Should Win - The Silver Linings Playbook

Of the nine contenders, only the vastly overrated (and emotionally manipulative) Beasts of the Southern Wild truly doesn€™t belong. I have my reservations about Zero Dark Thirty as well, but those are for ethical rather than cinematic reasons; as a film, it€™s good enough to make the list. It€™s a bit ironic then that on a list full of solid contenders, there€™s no one film that stands over the others, no one picture that seems destined to become a classic (an outright classic, not a cult classic) as the years go by. But of the choices, Silver Linings Playbook is the best. It€™s the film that€™s stuck with the me the longest, and even if it€™s ending feels a bit too neat and tidy, the journey it takes is willing to get into some rough places, and it has enough manic energy to hold you in even during its (few) stumbles. There€™s still a slim chance that it could upset Argo (Harvey Weinstein has pulled bigger rabbits out the the hat over the years - I€™m looking at you, Shakespeare in Love), but look for it to lose out to Argo and take one or two acting awards home as a consolation.

Best Director: Will Win - Steven Spielberg

The Oscars love him. The world loves him. And Lincoln is a very good film. Couple all that with the fact that Ben Affleck didn€™t make the list, and it looks like a pretty safe bet that Spielberg will walk away with Best Director. Haneke, also a master, is still too much of an unknown in the US to be chosen, Behn Zeitlin is a first timer who already won his prize by (inexplicably) being nominated, and David O. Russel€™s film, while well directed, feels more like an acting achievement than a feat of direction, however unfair that may be. Chalk all that up to Spielberg walking away happy unless...

Best Director: Should Win - Ang Lee

Unless Ang Lee rightfully wins the award. Nobody else on this list (or off of it, since there seemed to be an innumerable amount of snubs) had as tough of a job as Lee, and what he accomplished with Life of Pi is astonishing. Not just in terms of the use of visual effects, but the ability to take what seemed like an unfilmable one man show and turn it into a gripping, life affirming ride was nothing short of pure magic. Life of Pi easily could€™ve been a disaster, or a schlocky, overly sentimental mess, but Lee found the perfect tone, summoned an incredible performance out of his leading man, and used 3D to actually strengthen the story and experience. Nobody else could€™ve made the movie that Lee did. He should be rewarded for it.

Best Actor: Will Win - Daniel Day-Lewis

There€™s not much need for explanation here, but here is a short story to show how much of a foregone conclusion it is that Daniel Day-Lewis is the best actor in the world right now: Upon seeing Lincoln, a friend of mine remarked that it was a lot like War Horse, except with Daniel Day-Lewis as the horse. Nothing about this shocked me, and when I thought about it later, I realized that it was because I wouldn€™t be at all surprised if Daniel Day-Lewis took a role as a horse. And he would nail it.

Best Actor: Should Win - Daniel Day-Lewis

See previous. But while we rightly praise Day-Lewis, let€™s also take a moment to look at two performances that were also incredibly impressive: Joaquin Phoenix in The Master, and Bradley Cooper in Silver Linings Playbook. Phoenix came out of the wilderness (self imposed wilderness, but wilderness nonetheless) and gave what was probably the best performance of his career, while Cooper reached unexpected depths and made me forget about The Hangover 2. Well done on both counts.

Best Actress: Will Win - Jennifer Lawrence

Earlier in the race it looked as though Jessica Chastain€™s restrained turn as a CIA operative in Zero Dark Thirty would be the primary competition to Lawrence, now it looks more like Amour€™s Emmanuelle Riva could be a sleeper pick. But this award has been Lawrence€™s to lose since Toronto, where Silver Linings Playbook premiered to rave reviews, most of which focused on the outstanding work of its young star. Her performance is full of big acting, which the Oscar voters typically love, but she also supplied some very quiet touches to her character that were equally impressive, if not more so. It€™s a complete performance, and Lawrence, receiving her second Best Actress nomination at only 22 years old, will win this one.

Best Actress: Should Win - Jennifer Lawrence

It doesn€™t have the predestined feel that Day-Lewis€™ win does, but that might only be because she doesn€™t carry the same reputation and command the same respect (yet, anyways). Hers was the best performance of the year, and it deserves to win. Side note: How is Marion Cotillard not on the list of nominees?

Best Supporting Actor: Will Win - Tommy Lee Jones

This might be the most wide open competition of any of the big awards, but my money is on Jones. He gives a great performance in Lincoln, and the Academy voters may be anxious to throw the film more consolation prizes since it doesn€™t look like it will be taking home Best Picture. Jones is a great actor, and with this being his best work in years (probably since No Country for Old Men), my guess is he€™ll be rewarded for it. The rest of the field has plenty of strength, though. Christoph Waltz won the Golden Globe for his work in Django Unchained, but it€™s hard to think that he€™d win again so soon after Inglourious Basterds, especially since he€™s playing something of a similar character. Arkin was one of the best parts of Argo, although it feels like he and John Goodman should share the nomination based on how well they played off one another. Robert DeNiro could be a surprise winner; like Jones, DeNiro€™s work in Silver Linings Playbook is his best in a long time (a much longer time than Jones, to be clear), and with him also being an Academy favorite, it might not be too shocking to hear his name get called.

Best Supporting Actor: Should Win - Philip Seymour Hoffman

Is it possible that Philip Seymour Hoffman is under appreciated? That we€™re so used to seeing him be exceptional that it€™s stopped being a big deal? Hoffman is so many different things in The Master - loving, charismatic, vicious, unforgiving - but above all he is hypnotizing. He€™s able to make his following, the cult-like Cause, appealing, even attractive, though we know should know better. He draws in the audience the same way he draws in Joaquin Phoenix, and by the time we realize what he and The Cause really are, it€™s too late. The Master was a bit too out there to earn nominations for Best Picture, Director, and Screenplay, but if nothing else, it was an absolute acting masterclass. Hoffman should be recognized for it.

Best Supporting Actress: Will Win - Anne Hathaway

This race, much like Best Actor, seemed to be over months ago. But unlike Day-Lewis, there is a legitimate chance that Hathaway could lose her hold on the trophy. Sally Field, as a complicated and challenging Mary Todd Lincoln, is a very legitimate contender for this award, and with much more screen time and much more to do than Hathaway, she could pull off the upset.

Best Supporting Actress: Should Win - Amy Adams

Since Sally Field is a very legitimate contender, I€™ll leave her out of the should win spot and instead focus on someone who hasn€™t been mentioned enough: Amy Adams. Amy Adams has always been placed in cheery, good girl roles, but the darkness she conjured in The Master was not only impressive, but at times, downright frightening. As Peggy Dodd, wife to Philip Seymour Hoffman€™s cult leader, she held a sort of quiet control over the proceedings, the kind of woman you fear crossing. Only as the film unwound did we learn how important her, um, handy-work, was to The Cause itself. It was a great performance not only for how far she played against type, but how easily she made us forget that we ever thought of her as a princess, muppet associate, or museum exhibit come to life. Of course, it€™s often impossible to know what the Academy is thinking, which is half of what makes the Oscars fun (and infuriating). Feel free to comment with your predictions or what films you€™d like to see win on Oscar night.