The Academy is notorious for its short memory. Out of the 85 Best Picture winners, only 19 of them (about 22.4%) were wide released to audiences in the first half of the year, far from the equitable 50/50 split the data would be expected to approach if there were no inherent bias. Even when you expand your perspective to include all films nominated by the Academy for Best Picture, the breakdown doesn't get much better, with a mere 32.8% of Oscar nominated Best Pictures being released in the January-July window (while the month of December alone holds a whopping 22.27% of all Best Picture nominees, the greedy bastard of a month that it is). This undeniable preference towards films released in the latter half of the year can not simply be blamed on the fickle taste and long-term memory issues of the members of the Academy. From very early on in the Academy's history (probably since the monumental event that was Gone With the Wind's December release), movie studios have purposely saved up their films they feel will most appeal to Academy types until the proximity of their release is sufficiently close to the beginning of the nomination process. And in all honesty, it only makes sense that studios would want their movies to be as fresh in the minds of awards bodies as possible, because it is just the nature of the human mind to remember recent events more vividly than things that have been distanced through time. This is why I can't get in a furor over the Academy's calender bias, even if I understand the outrage in principle. After all, if the studios save their most substantial releases for the second half of the year, what is the Academy to do, give a Best Picture nomination to Fast & Furious 6? Obviously, I think not. However, I do think the Academy would do itself a service by giving some films, particularly smaller independent films, that are released in the early part of the year a bit more consideration. This is why I have chosen to highlight five films that I think should, and realistically could, get some awards attention at year's end. There will undoubtedly be many terrific films coming out once the festival season kicks everything off, but no matter how many high quality films demand our attention during the tail quarter, these five films at the very least deserve a second thought before the Academy inevitably decides to reward their new shiny toys instead.
5. Side Effects
I really wish there were more movie like Side Effects being made. It's not that Side Effects is some revolutionary or revelatory film, but it's the type of strong, solid effort (that doesn't have explosions going off every other minute or isn't infatuated with its own petiteness) that simply doesn't exist on the spectrum of cinema these days. Supposedly Steven Soderbergh's final foray into feature films (unless you live outside the United States, where his HBO Liberace biopic, Behind the Candelabra, is getting a theatrical release), Side Effects is an old-fashioned thriller set in the modern day and dealing with unquestionably contemporary issues. With an almost Hitchcockian flavor, the film's ingeniously crafted plot centers around a depressed young woman, Emily Taylor (Rooney Mara), who begins acting a bit erratically after being prescribed a psychotropic drug by her psychiatrist (Jude Law). Eventually, the drug's side effects lead Emily towards criminally tragic events that become a national news story and puts her unwitting psychiatrist into a load of hot water. The film, written by common Soderbergh collaborator Scott Z. Burns, is a bit of a brain-twister. Side Effects takes you one way, then sharply turns in a totally unexpected direction. What I love about the movie though, and what makes it stand above a lot of other "mind-bending" films of the genre, is the film is not about, or in love with, its own zig-zagging. While many films of its ilk are self-satisfied with their contortions and arriving at the inevitable "A-ha" moment, Side Effects has an interesting subtext to it. The ubiquitous use and prescribing of psychotropic drugs in 21st Century America, the extent to which we are still "ourselves" under the influences of these drugs, and the unhealthily cozy relationship between Big Drug and Wall Street are all tangentially touched on throughout the movie, not to the point where it distracts from the plot at hand, but just enough to give caper a certain gravitas that would make it yet another piece of disposable entertainment otherwise. Needless to say then, I definitely think the Academy should give the film's script consideration in the Best Original Screenplay category, but beyond this, I believe the Academy's Actors Branch should give the film's excellent performances some thought as well. The commonly under-appreciated Jude Law gives a terrific performance as a psychiatrist way in over his head who is forced to turn into a relentless sleuth, along the lines of a Sam Spade and Phillip Marlowe. It's unlikely the performance has a snowball's chance in hell of getting nominated in the always crowded Best Actor race, but it's one that deserves consideration nonetheless. Perhaps the best part of the film though is the performance by Rooney Mara. Ms. Mara has proven to be quite the talent in her young career thus far, earning an Oscar nomination for her portrayal of Lisbeth Salander in David Fincher's The Girl With the Dragoon Tattoo, and in Side Effects she is given the task of playing a character with a very difficult arc. In fact, the whole crux of the movie relies heavily on her performance, and she supports the film effortlessly. Again, I'm not expecting to Mara to receive a nomination for this performance, but I hope her name at least enters the conversation.
4. Before Midnight
If there is one film that has been the critics cause célèbre thus far in 2013, it has been Before Midnight. If you browse the cinema-centric web for "Best of 2013 so far"" lists, you will undoubtedly find a number of them have the third film in Richard Linklater's Before trilogy sitting atop their lists. Ever since the film's premiere at Sundance back in January, Before Midnight has been a constant conversation starter among cinephiles, but the question remains, will Before Midnight remain in the minds of Academy members a full twelve months following its premiere? Many pundits have been speculating that the film could receive a Best Adapted Screenplay nomination, which isn't unreasonable given that the film's predecessor, Before Sunset, received exactly this nomination. Among the varying branches of the Academy, the writers are typically the most adventurous anyway, and Linklater's Before trilogy is, first and foremost, a triumph in writing. A Best Adapted Screenplay nomination then is a pretty distinct possibility, but the real question is, can the film come away any other above-the-line nominations? The most obvious of these would be nominations for the two lead actors. What's interesting about the performances from Ethan Hawke and Julie Delpy in Before Midnight is that they do not exist in isolation, but rather in the context of their previous performances in the preceding films of the series. Coming back to these characters every nine years has allowed both actors the chance to evolve their characters and their mannerisms in fascinating ways, adding a level of depth to the performances that is simply impossible for actors to do in the typical "one-off" situation. Whether the Actors Branch sees it this way or not, I do not know, but of the two, I think Delpy has the better chance given the relatively less competitive Best Actress field. The film may also have a shot at two of the big kahuna categories, Best Director and Best Picture. It's a shame Richard Linklater hasn't received a Best Director nomination yet, but unfortunately, I don't think Before Midnight will be the film to bring him over the finish line. On the other hand, I do think the film has a decent shot at a Best Picture nomination. Ever since the Best Picture field was expanded beyond the traditional five nominees, the artistic-leaning members of the Academy have usually been able to coalesce around one high-brow film (A Serious Man, The Tree of Life, Amour) and sneak it into the Best Picture lineup, so if Before Midnight proves to be this year's "artistic film", then it may manage the Best Picture nomination. In all truthfulness, I'm not quite as enthusiastically in love with Before Midnight as most critics seem to be, but it is a great film. Any movie that is able to achieve and portray such realistic and deep conversations deserves kudos, and this film does so in spades, so the Academy would do well not to forget it.
3. Spring Breakers
You have to love Spring Breakers if for no other reason than the fact that it got a bunch a shallow, vapid college-age kids to go see an art film. Written and directed by radical filmmaker/prankster Harmony Kornine, Spring Breakers was advertised as a "Fight For Your Right to Party", MTV-inundated, reality-television-obsessed youth culture celebration of getting blitzed, buzzed, and banged. In actuality, the film was a semi-experimental morality tale, edited together in the "montage as movie" style that Terrance Malick has been working in lately, about the depths of material sociopathy that is prevalent in the "spring break" culture. In a genius bit of casting, the film stars former tween idols Selena Gomez and Vanessa Hudgens, along with Ashley Benson and Rachel Kornine, as a group of girls so desperate to go through the collegiate rite of passage (something they obviously feel is an inalienable right), that they decide to rob a restaurant to procure the necessary funds for the trip. Once they get to their destination though, things hardly become more kosher. After landing in jail for being involved with a massive drug party, the girls are bailed out by the mysterious rapper/gangster Alien, played as simultaneously frightening and hilarious by James Franco. The quartet of girls end up fractured as Alien proves to elicit the true nature of each one's personality (which vary fairly wildly), and from there things go really nuts, as some of them end up making decisions they can never walk back. Spring Breakers balances the very fine line between celebrating and condemning the hedonistic nihilism on display throughout the film, avoiding the "old man yelling at kids to get of his long" syndrome, but never humanizing the deplorable and selfish acts committed by the film's characters. The result is a film that feels objective without being detached, authentic without being apologetic, and the film's extensive use of dubstep (courtesy of Skrillex) is some of the best mix of music and film in any movie this year. The standout feature of the film though, and the only real shot the divisive movie has at an Oscar nomination, is the performance from James Franco. Now, there seems to be a lot of Franco hate out there, which probably has something to do with the arrogant pseudo-intellectual aura he has cultivated around himself, but whether Franco is actually a jackass or not, if you're not open to the full-bodied nature of this performance, you're the jerk. Some may call it over the top, others may say it even smacks of racism, but Franco's performance is Spring Breakers. The fairy tale-esque, hyper realism that characterizes Franco's performance holds together the film's final act, and it's just so damn enthralling, that to not even consider it for a Best Supporting Actor nomination would a sin almost on the level of some of the sins committed by the film's characters.
2. The Place Beyond The Pines
Derek Cianfrance received a lot of critical support for his directorial debut, Blue Valentine, upon its release in 2010. Starring Ryan Gosling and Michelle Williams, the movie focused on the contentious relationship between a young couple, jumping back and forth from when they first fell in love to a few years later, as their marriage begins to dissolve. The unflinching realism of the movie drew a lot of plaudits, and though some were disappointed that Gosling's performance failed to get Oscar recognition, Williams did manage to earn a Best Actress nomination from all the acclaim. On Cianfrance's second feature, The Place Beyond the Pines, unfortunately, much of the critical adoration and admiration has seemed to dry up. While the film does has some ardent supporters here or there, it's detractors have appeared to dampen the overall enthusiasm for the film, which is a shame, because this is one hell of a movie. Set in the backwoods of Schenectady, New York, this epic film explores the inter-generational consequences of "the sins of the father" and is one of the best movies ever in its exploration of the father-son dynamic. One of the things that I love so much about The Place Beyond the Pines is its intermixing of styles. The omnipresent "realism" that was so praised and loved by critics in Blue Valentine is still here and accounted for, but while in my humble opinion, that film was ultimately harmed by its obsessive need to be "real", The Place Beyond the Pines embraces the cinematic canvas with which the film is painted on. Particularly in film's interesting structure, which takes the triptych approach, the film embraces a grand sense of narrative story telling that was nowhere to be found in Blue Valentine. In some ways, The Place Beyond the Pines has the feeling of a great Greek tragedy, and the film's perfect karmic symmetry has seemed to be the most common criticism from the film''s detractors. While I understand, and even agree to some extent, with these sentiments, to let something of as relatively little consequence spoil a film with so many great aspects to it seems equivalent to complaining the Grand Canyon isn't all that majestic because it happened to be raining on the day you visited. Unfortunately, I think The Place Beyond the Pines' odds at landing any Oscar nods are pretty slim, but I am holding out slight hope for one nomination: Ryan Gosling. It's a bit unclear which category he would be placed in, lead or supporting, because the part of the film he is in, he is unquestionably the star, but the overall fraction of his screen time may cause many voters to consider him a supporting player. Whichever category you think he should be placed in though, he should be nominated. No single performance from a film released so far this year (not even Franco in Spring Breakers or another fantastic performance I am about to mention momentarily) top Gosling's performance as a stunt biker/bank robber trying to create a life for his impromptu family, and the fact that Gosling has only once been nominated for an Oscar in his career is ridiculous. Members of the Academy, please, do the right thing and nominate this performance.
1. Frances Ha
I first saw Frances Ha at the Toronto International Film Festival last year. Having been a fan of some of director Noah Baumbach's previous work, such as The Squid and Whale and Greenberg, I was looking forward to seeing the film, but it was hardly my most anticipated film of the festival. I was quite stunned then to find that, not only was Frances Ha my favorite film at Toronto, but it was one of my favorite films of the last few years. Had Frances Ha debuted last year, it would have topped my personal top ten films list, which isn't insignificant because I felt 2012 was a fairly strong year for movies. Frances Ha chronicles the misadventures of Frances (Greta Gerwig), a late-twenties wanna be professional dancer who sort of slums out an existence in New York City. Frances thinks she wants to dance for a living, but as an apprentice at a dance company, her future doesn't look too bright. She lives with her best friend Sophie (Mickey Sumner), but when Sophie decides she's ready to move on with her life, it leaves Frances scrambling to find a new place to live. Enjoying the present, but no eye towards the future, Frances is living life adrift in the Big Apple, stuck in an emotional limbo she doesn't really want to escape. The word zeitgeist is thrown around a lot, but even more than the "spirit of the age", Frances Ha captures the psychology of a generation. Like John Hughes in the 1980's, or Richard Linklater in the 1990's, Noah Baumbach (along with Greta Gerwig, who co-wrote the film's screenplay) shows an intuitive understanding of a group of young adults who have had the privilege of living in a world that protects them to the point of not feeling entirely real. Frances is about as affable as they come, and she shows no sense of malicious entitlement, but her inability to take things seriously leaves her in a kind of addictive suspended animation, unable and unwilling to move forward. Beyond this brilliant and shockingly apt character study aspect of Frances Ha though, the reason why the movie is unquestionably my favorite of the year (and may very likely remain there by the end of the year) is that above all else, Frances Ha is a pure expression of cinema. No other film I have seen that was released this year pays homage to and takes advantage of the narrative techniques that are unique to the medium of film as much as Frances Ha does. Shot in a beautiful black-and-white and filled with the very essence of contemporary New York City, Frances Ha will and has immediately drawn comparisons to Woody Allen's classic Manhattan, and for good reason. Beyond this most obvious comparison though, the film is also extremely reminiscent of the French New Wave movement. In particular, Francois Truffaut's The 400 Blows comes to mind in how brutally yet lovingly honest the film is in dissecting the protagonist's motivations and insecurities. Realistically, the film probably has two shots at Oscar recognition. The first would be a Best Original Screenplay nomination. As I previously stated, the Writers Branch more than any other branch sticks up for smaller independent films that would get no awards love otherwise, as was the the case with Baumbach's The Squid and the Whale, whose sole nomination was for Baumbach's script. The other possible nomination would be a Best Actress nod for Gerwig's remarkable incarnation of Frances, but this will depend on how stacked the field is. Of course, at this stage of the game it's tough to say how many legitimate contenders for Best Actress there will be, but just from the synopsis and the actresses involved, it looks to be a crowded year. Alas, if I had my druthers, just for the scene of Frances running and dancing through the streets of New York City to the sound of David Bowie's infectious Modern Love, the film would be the front runner for Best Picture, but I'll settle for any nomination just so Frances Ha can claim to be an Oscar nominated movie, as it deserves to be. Those are my five films I would like the Academy to remember when filling out their ballots in late-December/early-January, but let me know in the comments section below which movies released so far this year that you would like the Academy not to forget come nomination time.