Oscars 2014: If We Picked The Winners (Best Adapted Screenplay)

Even though the field itself wasn't very deep this year, the actual nominees weren't too shabby at all.

By Christopher Lominac /

A former bastion for heavy weight Oscar films, the Adaptation category appears to be in a bit of a weird transitional faze at the moment. At one time, the films in the Best Adapted Screenplay category were too numerous to fit into one category, lately however, the Writers branch has had enough room to accommodate practically every single major Best Picture contender that qualifies (and then some in recent years). As the craze in young adult fiction and comic books has consumed much of the time of talented writers who specialize in the art of adaptation, perhaps the willingness of studios to hire these writers for adaptations of loftier literature has decreased. Even of the films that have found award success in this category over the last few years, many have come from sources that don't exactly qualify under the strict traditional definition of "literature". For instance, last year's winner in this category, Argo, was partly based on an article tilted "The Great Escape" that appeared in Wired magazine, while Aaron Sorkin's script for The Social Network was written more or less in conjunction with the book it was based on, The Accidental Millionaires, which itself was supposedly written with the express understanding that it would be adapted into a movie. The line between what is "adapted" and what is "original" is clearly becoming blurred. A film such as Toy Story 3, which was a completely original story that simply used characters established in previous films, somehow wound up as a 2010 nominee for Best Adapted Screenplay, while that same year, The King's Speech won Best Original Screenplay because it wasn't expressly based on any previously released material, despite the fact the film's subject matter was actual events in the life of King George VI. In 2014, we've run into this exact situation again, as Richard Linklater, Ethan Hawke, and Julie Delpy find themselves nominees in the Best Adapted Screenplay category simply for continuing a wholly original story about two middle-aged lovers, Celine and Jessie, while Craig Borten and Melisa Wollack are nominees for Best Original Screenplay despite what was an obviously highly researched script based on the real life of early AIDS victim Ron Woodruff. Apparently, categorization, as beauty, is in the eyes of the beholder. For this year's crop of Best Adapted Screenplay contenders though, the Academy needed the widest possible definition of "adapted", because the dearth of deserving contenders in 2013 was striking. From very early on, this race was wrapped up, with the eventual nominees, 12 Years a Slave, Before Midnight, Captain Phillips, Philomena, and The Wolf of Wall Street, simply receiving a conformation rather than a nomination when the final lineup was revealed. The only contender that actually had a shot of breaking into this preordained quintet was Tracey Letts' adaptation of his own Pulitzer Prize-winning play, August: Osage County, but as soon as the film premiered to a rather chilly reception among critics, Letts' hopes at an Oscar nomination were doomed. What other technically eligible screenplays outside the Academy's typical purview deserved some consideration in this category you ask? Not much. The one film that should be among the nominees in an ideal world is Hayao Miyazaki's The Wind Rises, which has one of the most beautifully insightful and traditionalist screenplays in quite sometime, but even though the Writers' branch does stick up for foreign films more than almost any other major branch of the Academy, the chances of a Japanese animated film receiving a Best Adapted Screenplay nomination were always small. The Secret Life of Walter Mitty had an interesting adaptation of James Thurber's famous short story (even if many critics weren't too enthused), but declaring it worthy of an Oscar nomination is a bit of a stretch. The Great Gatsby nearly topped my personal top ten list this year, but I wouldn't say the film's script was one of its strongest points. And beyond that... Grown Ups 2, perhaps? (Just so we're clear, and before my film writing license gets revoked, that was a joke). Even though the field itself wasn't very deep this year, the actual nominees weren't too shabby. As you will see momentarily, some are definitely stronger than others, but there was no real embarrassment, which is always a plus. Here then is my ranking, from worst to best, of this year's Best Adapted Screenplay nominees.

5. Steve Coogan And Jeff Pope - Philomena

Philomena is a mixed bag of a screenplay. On the one hand, there are elements of Steve Coogan and Jeff Pope's script that are done very well and warrant a higher ranking among the nominees than last place. The film excellently balances the viewpoints between Martin Sixsmith, a modern cynical atheist who looks down on those that don't subscribe to the same enlightened ideas as himself, and Philomena, a sweet, simple Catholic traditionalist who very concretely feels the presence of God and the church in her life. Sixsmith's righteous indignation over the wrongs committed against Philomena by the Catholic Church ultimately lead Philomena to discover the truth about her lost son, alleviating her of the years of silent suffering over not knowing what happened to him. At the same time, the cynical bitterness necessary to rouse Sixsmith's anger makes him a miserable and slightly uncaring person who is hard to be around. In contrast, Philomena's naïve understanding of the world and the nature of humanity made her a prime target for the abuse and lies she suffered at the hands of the church, but these same aspects of her personality also make her a genuinely caring person, and even with all the hardships of her life, Philomena is undoubtedly the happier individual of the two characters. Particularly in the film's final scenes, after the big revelation occurs and we see the characters' polar opposite reactions to the uncovering of the truth, the unique and differing nature of the two characters' disposition is made abundantly clear, but in a manner that is genuinely empathetic towards both protagonists. Despite these strengths though, the film's clichéd use of the prototypical "old batty woman" for comedic moments is, at times, like nails against a chalkboard. Not that these moments are never humorous or well written, but the movie goes back to this well over and over again, to the point where the comic relief becomes a very obvious crutch with which the screenplay relies on, heavily. It also gives the film the feeling of being aggressively middle-brow (as paradoxically as that may sound) and subverts the more intelligent aforementioned aspects of the screenplay in the rather crude interest of being an "audience pleaser". The final result then is, as previously stated, a mixed bag. There are a lot of aspects of the script to be admired, enough so that I don't begrudge the film of its nomination in this category, and a lot of aspects that deserve criticism. In the perspective of Oscar history though, Philomena is far from the worst nominee for Best Adapted Screenplay.

4. Billy Ray - Captain Phillips

This is yet another nominee whose dualistic nature makes it a difficult film to arbitrate. The film's screenplay starts with terribly on the nose dialogue between Phillips (Tom Hanks) and his wife (Catherine Keener) that spells out the movie's overarching themes in no uncertain terms, namely, that the shifting and uncertain landscape of society in the early 21st Century is an unnerving time that may lead people to desperate measures. The cinematic equivalent of a 7th grade essay that very obviously places the thesis statement in the opening paragraph to get the check mark from teacher, the film's super-liminal (to borrow from one of my all-time favorite Simpsons jokes) beginning was nearly enough to automatically rank it fifth among five. However, cooler heads prevailed, and despite the screenplay's decimation of the meaning of the word subtext, there is a lot to like about Billy Ray's work. Inarguably, the film is more of a director's showcase than it is an illustration of writing prowess. With a heavy emphasis on action sequences, such as the Somali pirates attempting to board the ship, the Somali pirates search for all the crew members on the ship, the Somali pirates escape with Phillips as a hostage on the smaller vessel, and the U.S. Military 's operation to save Phillips, Captain Phillips isn't exactly the most dialogue-heavy piece of cinema you'll find. Particularly in the hands of director Paul Greengrass, whose trademark "documentary" brand of cinematography and choppy editing style distracts even further from any merits the film's screenplay might have, it is a tad surprising that the screenplay for Captain Phillips was singled out by the Academy. What the writers responded to I suspect, and the thing that does make Billy Ray's work commendable, is the excellent characterization of the Somali pirates and their interaction amongst one anther, as well as with Captain Phillips. As the film progresses, especially once the pirates enter the smaller boat with Captain Phillips, the film increasingly relies on the screenplay to ratchet up the tension, and boy does it succeed in this task. The infighting between Muse (Barkhad Abdi) and his cohorts, the relationship between Muse and Phillips, which seems to be one of genuine respect and makes Muse reluctant to commit to the tough decisions he needs to make, and Philips scrambling to outthink his adversaries and come out alive, is all right there in the screenplay (heavily assisted by good acting) and earns Ray his nomination. Definitely not without its flaws, Captain Phillips is nevertheless a good example of strong action/drama hybrid screenwriting.

3. Terrence Winter - The Wolf Of Wall Street

Perhaps more than any other film this year, The Wolf of Wall Street has been a force to be reckoned with. Recently crossing the $300 million mark globally, making The Wolf of Wall Street Martin Scorsese's highest grossing movie ever, it's clear that despite all the moral handwringing and controversy over whether the film celebrates, condones, or condemns the extreme behavior of its criminal characters, the public sure endorses the film. Based on the memoir of Jordan Belfort, a sleazy stockbroker who scammed who knows how many people out of countless amounts of money, pocketing millions for himself along the way, the film is an excessive film about excess. Written by Terrence Winter, a former writer for HBO's The Sopranos and the creator and showrunner of the network's current hit show, Boardwalk Empire, the film ran into a bit of trouble for what some saw as a 3-hour glamorization of greedy, hedonistic Wall Street pigs without any clear moral clarification on the crimes committed in the film or sympathy for the plight of Belfort's victims. While I clearly side with Scorsese and Co. in terms of portraying his characters as they are, without didactic moral messaging, the film does present an interesting quandary when it comes to filmmaking, and screenwriting in particular. The Wolf of Wall Street essentially amounts to a string of repetitive (yet usually highly entertaining) scenes of eccentric and narcissistic characters indulging themselves in their most primal desires, which apparently are to take drugs and have sex, with the occasional midget tossing thrown in for good measure. Supposedly highly improvised (which probably means slightly rewritten on the day of the shoot, not literally improvised as the camera rolled) , however much of it was thought up directly by Winter and however much was created by Scorsese and his actors, doesn't really matter. Within the scenes themselves, and over short spans of the movie, both the actual dialogue and the set pieces are adroitly written, creating some of the most memorable moments of the year in cinema. Anyone who has spent time watching Winter's television shows can tell you that the man can write a good scene and has an appropriate taste for the dramatic without going overboard, which he illustrates yet again in his script for The Wolf of Wall Street. Where The Wolf of Wall Street does stumble a bit is in its narrative structure. While the film engages you throughout and is rather quick for its 180 minute runtime, at the end it never quite adds up to the sum of its pieces. Winter gives the film the old "rise and fall" trope in order to make the movie feel like it's actually moving somewhere, but while this worked well in Scorsese's previous films such as Goodfellas and Casino, without the threat of impending death that existed in those films, the stakes just don't feel all that high in The Wolf of Wall Street and the narrative decision feels more lazy than anything else. Of course though, the whole point of The Wolf of Wall Street seems to be that people such as Jordan Belfort run off of the excess of immediate gratification, so the fact the film's narrative is a joy ride to nowhere in particular becomes part of the subtext itself, and this is where the quandary come in. How do you make a movie about the banality of excess, mirroring the spirit of the characters and story, without become excessive yourself? I'm not sure if there is a solution to that riddle, but if they didn't exactly solve it, you must give Winter and Scorsese credit for making it one hell of an entertaining ride.

2. John Ridley - 12 Years a Slave

A film critic, in arguing why he believed Philomena should win Best Adapted Screenplay over 12 Years a Slave, recently dismissed the effort of John Ridley by saying something to the effect that, "then Solomon hangs from a tree, then Solomon is forced to whip Patsey" more or less writes itself. While it's true that these scene were not solely the creations of the mind of Mr. Ridley, as they were actual events that took place in the life of Solomon Northup, this is an incredibly reductive view of both the film's script, and 12 Years a Slave itself. The idea that 12 Years a Slave is some obligatory racial reconciliation project unfortunately seems to be more widespread than it should be, because it really dismisses what the film accomplishes on an artistic level. While the film's beginning does come off as a bit of historical documentation while we watch Solomon as he goes through the inhumane selling process that numerous amounts of slaves had to endure, as Solomon begins developing relationships with his fellow slaves and slaveholders, first the relatively benign Ford (Benedict Cumberbatch) then the sadistically unstable Edwin Epps (Michael Fassbender), 12 Years a Slave becomes a human drama that is not simply beholden to the subject matter of slavery. Those who view the film this way seem to be interjecting their crass notion of the "awards bait" genre where films take on weighty subject matter for the express purpose of getting a giant pat on the back for its social progressiveness. Unfortunately, there have been films made in the past with exactly this purpose, so the film's critics are not unfounded from a historical sense, but their cynicism has grown to the point where any film that takes on "tough" subject matter is automatically convicted of being intellectually dishonest, which just isn't the case with 12 Years a Slave. What makes Ridley's script so fascinating and powerful is not the milking of highly dramatic and intense moments, but rather the myriad of human dynamics simultaneously occurring in the film. First off, there is Solomon's relationship to the rest of his fellow slaves. While he clearly sympathizes with them, as a formerly free man, he also holds himself apart from them. Not only does Solomon having the feeling of superiority towards his fellow slaves (not in any malicious sense but simply from the de facto standards of the era), but he also has the sense of being a particularly tragic victim, more so than his peers, since he was a freed man. It is not until many years of repression have worn down his idea of a particularly special dignity that Solomon finally identifies himself with the rest of the slaves, in one of the most powerful scenes of the year, as he joins in a funeral chorus of Role Jordan Role. The relationship between Edwin Epps and both Patsey and Solomon is also powerfully written. As the director Steve McQueen has stated a number of times, Epps is clearly infatuated with Patsey, which creates quite the state of cognitive dissonance in his mind given his views on the inferiority of the black race. Epps' relationship with Solomon is also full of contradictions. On the one hand, Epps' can certainly tell Solomon is not a typical slave and can't help but subconsciously afford the man a slight amount of respect that he would never afford his other slaves. On the other hand, the idea that he should show any of his slaves (his property in his view) a level of respect abhors him, making him hate Solomon all the more. These paradoxical views drive an already unstable man all the crazier, which only means pain and suffering for Solomon and Patsey. These dynamics, which make 12 Years a Slave the great film it is, did not simply write themselves. While based on actual events, these themes were carefully weaved throughout this historical tale of survival by the film's screenwriter, John Ridley, who furnished quite the fine script. If Ridley wins, as I suspect he will, it will be an Oscar earned through intelligent writing, not simply because he was lucky enough to write the "slavery movie".

1. Julie Delpy, Ethan Hawke, and Richard Linklater - Before Midnight

I feel somewhat guilty placing Before Midnight as the should-be Oscar winner of Best Adapted Screenplay, because it seems a bit like cheating. Unlike the other four nominees in the category, Before Midnight is almost an entirely original story developed from the minds of its three writers: co-stars Julie Delpy and Ethan Hawke, and the director Richard Linklater. The third film in their real-time relationship series, the only restriction placed on Delpy, Hawke, and Linklater were their characters pasts that had been played out in the previous two films. Other than that, they could go wherever the wanted, unlike the other writers nominated who were strictly adapting stories of real peoples lives as laid out in their memoirs or biographical equivalents. It's a bit weird that simply because the characters have been established in previous films, even though the story itself is wholly original, the Academy considers Before Midnight to be an "adaptation", but that is their decision on how to treat sequels. Doesn't make much sense, but it's the way it is. Despite then whatever advantage Before Midnight may or may not have over its competition due to the Academy's awkward categorization, it is a fantastic screenplay, so I can't feel too badly for rewarding it. The film's continuation of the epic yet familiar relationship between Celine (Julie Delpy) and Jessie (Ethan Hawke), Before Midnight takes place nine years after the events of Before Sunset. After reigniting their relationship in Before Sunset, we find out that Jessie left his wife to be with Celine, and now the couple have two twin daughters of their own. Vacationing in Greece, we watch as Celine and Jessie deal with the realities of their now old hat relationship and how or if they can come to a new understanding of one another under much less romantic circumstances than their whirlwind beginnings. As with the the previous two Before films, Before Midnight is essentially an extended conversation between two characters, so in other words, a writer's dream picture. However, too often films with prolific amounts of dialogue are considered "good writing" while films with sparse amounts of dialogue are somehow considered inferior. This is an utter fallacy, for writing a screenplay amounts to much more than putting words in the characters mouths, as elements such a narrative, arc, subtext, theming, and structure and pacing, which are not associated with writing as often as they should be (although admittedly the director and editor can have a big effect on these elements as well), are essential to a good screenplay and, ultimately, a good movie. In the case of Before Midnight though, the kudos for the film's script are truly deserved, not simply because there is so much conversation in the movie, but because how fascinating and resonating the dialogue is. Always the armchair philosopher, Richard Linklater's films often contain philosophical suppositions that are like heroin to the amateur philosopher (the ultimate example of this being Waking Life, where Celine and Jessie make cameo appearances), and Before Midnight is no different. Particularly in the early sections of the film, when Celine and Jessie are part of a larger conversation among friends and the conversations veer from any number of topics that range from the philosophical to Jessie's ideas for his next book, the dialogue is pure gold, as the film sustains itself on nothing other than top rate conversational dialogue. As the film wears on and Celine and Jessie are isolated, the film becomes about relationships again, and the difficulty of maintaining a healthy one as reality begins to set in and fantasy starts to fade. By the end, the argument gets rather nasty and cutthroat, and while this "realism" seems to be what the critics responded to most, I think the film overdoes it a bit and tries too hard to bring home the point (running into some of the same issues as the similarly themed Blue Valentine). However, the film is never less than engaging, primarily because of its script, and although my personal favorite film (and script) of the trilogy is Before Sunrise, which is the most overtly cinematic of the three films, Before Midnight still stands as quite the achievement. There simply aren't very many people who could or would write a screenplay such as Before Midnight, and for this I think that among the nominees, Before Midnight is most deserving of Best Adapted Screenplay.