For me, the Best Supporting Actor category is the most difficult category to predict this far out from the actual nominations. This is not atypical either as this category is annually, almost without fail, the toughest to foresee. The reasons for my particularly foggy clairvoyant skills on this specific matter are two-fold. First, given the types of movies being made in this day and age, the abundance of choice supporting roles with potentially Oscar-worthy prospects is just ridiculous. They're as plentiful as water in the ocean, and this plethora of promising performers, while a boon for fans of cinema, is a nightmare for an Oscar protagonist such as myself trying to pull off the illusion that I retain some unique insight into these awards that your regular laymen could never hope to attain. This year's crop of potential players makes this job an especially Herculean effort because they include so many recognizable names. Brad Pitt, Phillip Seymour Hoffman, Javier Bardem, Joaquin Phoenix, Bradley Cooper, Matthew McConaughey, Bill Murray, and Ewan McGregor is just a sampling of names that have a performance in a film (some two) that, on paper, looks like it could garner the attention of members of the Academy. A list with this many A-listers makes it none too easy to decide on what basis one performance deserves ranking above the other. Then of course there is the issue of whether a particular performance even belongs in this category. The Academy is notoriously bad on clearly and consistently defining what exactly constitutes a "supporting" performance". Many cried category fraud over Christoph Waltz's win in this category last year, while other examples (such as Morgan Freeman's Best Actor nomination for his role in The Shawshank Redemption, despite the fact that Tim Robbins' character is clearly the protagonist), feel misplaced in the opposite direction. Regardless to say, the delineation is fuzzy at best. In large ensemble pieces, it is also difficult to say, sight unseen, whether a specific performance is significant enough to warrant Oscar attention. Before having actually seen the film, just by looking at the cast of Argo last year, it would have been hard to have said between John Goodman, Alan Arkin, and Bryan Cranston, which one had the best chances of securing an Oscar nod. After laying eyes on the film, it was pretty obvious Arkin's performance was the most flashy of the bunch. For a film like the upcoming Monuments Men, it's damn near impossible to guess with any certainty which of Bill Murray's, John Goodman's, or Jean Dujardin's performance will pick up the most awards traction. I could hardly look at myself in the mirror and proclaim to be a self-respecting Oscar protagonist if I didn't at least hazard a guess at 2014's Best Supporting Actor lineup, no matter how foolhardy the task. Here then is my, extremely preliminary, stab at which of this year's supporting male performers will catch the fancy of the Academy's eye. I will next be previewing the Best Supporting Actress category, so be on the look out for that as well...
Advertisement
10. Mark Ruffalo - Foxcatcher
You likely know Mark Ruffalo best as The Hulk's alter ego, Dr. Bruce Banner, in last summer's mammoth summer blockbuster, The Avengers. Mr. Ruffalo though has been doing good supporting work for sometime. He has one Oscar nomination to his name for his role as the biological father of two kids raised by lesbian parents in The Kids Are All Right, which was indeed a fine performance, but he has also done superb work in films such as Shutter Island, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, and my personal favorite of Ruffalo's performances, Zodiac. This type of consistently fine character work usually doesn't go unnoticed forever, and I suspect 2014 may be the year Mark Ruffalo finally gets some appropriate Oscar approval. The role that I believe may finally add the adjective "Oscar-winner" to his name in every subsequent movie he appears in is that of former Olympic wrestler David Schultz in Bennett Miller's Foxcatcher. The film tells the story of the affluent inheritor of the du Pont fortune, John du Pont, who was a tad touched in the head, to say the least. Du Pont was apparently quite the wrestling fan which, given his nearly endless disposal of monetary funds, led him to set up his own wrestling training facility on his compound. Du Pont employed David Schultz, along with his bother Mark (Channing Tatum), to train him in the art of wrestling. While they all got along as friends at first, du Pont's mental illness eventually got the better of him, and (minor spoiler alert for the uniformed) du Pont was charged with the murder of David Schultz, becoming one of the wealthiest Americans ever to be charged with murder. Needless to say, it's an appropriately dramatic role that the Academy is sure to appreciate. Director Bennett Miller has had a good track record with the Academy thus far in his very young career, which also spells good news for Mr. Ruffalo. Finally, just looking at the physical transformation in the picture above, you have to like Ruffalo's chances to, at the very least, receive a nomination, and maybe even win the whole thing. Above all others, I feel most confident of Ruffalo's chances, at least at this point.
9. Michael Fassbender - Twelve Years A Slave
We all know at some point, Michael Fassbender will get an Oscar nomination. He's just too damn good not to. This is why I included him in the tail end of my list of ten potential Best Actor nominees for his role in the upcoming Cormac McCarthey-penned and Ridley Scott-helmed, The Counselor, but I'm a little skeptical on that film's Oscar potential given Mr. Scott's recent output. I am more confident however in Fassbender's chances at receiving a Best Supporting Actor nomination for his third collaboration with director Steve McQueen in McQueen's third feature film, Twelve Years a Slave. The film is based on the memoirs of Solomon Northup (Chiwetel Ejiofor), a mid-19th Century Africa-American man living in upstate New York who was tricked and then forced into involuntary servitude in the Deep South for twelve years of his life. During his dozen years as a slave, Mr. Northup was forced to serve many different owners, including one by the name of Edwin Epps, which is the character Mr. Fassbinder is tasked with portraying. Edwin Epps had the reputation of being a particularly cruel slave owner and he made Northup the plantation's "driver", which was a slave supervisor of sorts charged with overseeing that slaves did their work properly and punished those that did not. While the subject matter may sound appealing to Academy types (as evidenced by Django Unchained's success at the Oscars last year), I worry from early reports that the film may be too stark and bleak for the Academy's decidedly middle-brow taste. Director Steve McQueen's uncompromising vision in chronicling taboo subject likely already cost Mr. Fassbender one Oscar nomination for his performance in Shame, although the Actors branch illustrated they're not totally adverse to nominating strong performances in films a tad austere for their liking as proven by the three acting nominations for Paul Thomas Anderson's chilly L. Ron Hubbard riff, The Master. There is also the issue of Fassbender's performance not being substantial enough to merit nomination or being obscured by his fellow cast-mates potentially strong performances. When a film has a myriad of terrific supporting performances (which with a cast that includes Brad Pitt, Paul Giamatti, Benedict Cumerbatch, Scoot McNairy, Paul Dano, and Michael K. Williams, is a strong possibility), the Academy's typical response is to simply nominate no one (Killing Them Softly anyone?), which would be unfortunate for Mr. Fassbender. Given these very real possibilities, it may be a case of wishful thinking, but I still like Fassbender's odds.
8. Josh Brolin - Labor Day
The first time I remember knowing who Josh Brolin was came in his performance in the Coen Brother's Best Picture-winning adaptation of the Cormac McCarthy novel, No Country for Old Men. Despite the film's massive critical success and relative popularity, Brolin's performance largely went unnoticed. With the mesmerizing performance given by his costar Javier Bardem, it's somewhat understandable why Brolin's performance was relatively ignored (as protagonists roles often are when eccentric villains are involved), but his fantastically realized sense of desperation is at the heart of what drives the film, and it's a performance that I feel is still undervalued to this day. Since his breakout role in No Country for Old Men, Brolin has continued to give a number of strong (mostly supporting) performances, even earning a Best Supporting Actor nomination for his role in Gus Van Sant's Milk. This year Brolin's best shot at becoming a two-time Oscar nominee is likely to come in Jason Reitman's Labor Day (sorry Gangster Squad). Based on a novel by Joyce Manard, the film sees a mother (Kate Winslett) and her son (Gattlin Griffith) unwittingly aide an escaped convict in his attempt to evade the law. Brolin plays the man on the lamb, and while I haven't read the book, the synopsis of the role sounds Oscar worthy, as the nature of the character's past life apparently becomes more clear as the film progresses. As I've stated in past previews, Reitman's films have been fairly successful at receiving Oscar nominations. Only when his films have been especially biting and satirical (Thank You for Smoking and Young Adult) has he missed out on Oscar's approval. In cases where Reitman's films have had a whiff of serious-mindedness and sentimentality (Juno and Up in the Air), Reitman has been successful in gathering awards kudos. Given the material he's working with here, I think it's safe to say Labor Day is in the camp of the latter, which is good news for Mr. Brolin's awards prospects. The other issue to consider for Mr. Brolin is categorization. I have seem some Oscar pundits list Brolin as a potential contender for the lead acting category, which may be a very real possibility given the fact no one has seen the film yet. My gut tells me we will probably have another Christoph Waltz in Django Unchained and Phillip Seymour Hoffman in The Master situation on our hands, where you could really make a successful argument for the inclusion in either category. Given the likely crowded and more clearly defined candidates for the lead category though, much as with the two aforementioned examples, I expect strategically it will make most sense to campaign Brolin as a supporting actor, which is why for now I have included him in this list.
7. Jared Leto - Dallas Buyers Club
Some may balk at the inclusion of the lead singer of 30 Seconds to Mars on a list of potential Oscar nominees, but it wouldn't be the first time a singer/actor has won an Oscar (Cher in Moonstruck, for example). Leto himself though was first an actor and has worked with such highly esteemed directors as Terrence Malick, David Fincher and Darren Aronofsky in such well regarded films as The Thin Red Line, Fight Club and Requiem for a Dream, respectively. In other words, you shouldn't knock Mr. Leto's chances, whatever your opinion of him may be. In particular, I think we need to take Leto's Oscar prospects quite seriously given the role he plays in the Matthew McConaughey vehicle, Dallas Buyers Club. The movie is a loosely true telling of the life of Ron Woodruff, a man who was surprisingly diagnosed with AIDS during the height of the epidemic in the mid-1980's. Given only a month to live, Woodruff began to illegally smuggle in non-FDA approved drugs and sold them to AIDS patients in order to extend their lives as long as possible. Mr. Leto's role in the film is that of Rayon, a transsexual AIDS patient who became a partner in Ron Woodruff's mission to sell illegal medicine to AIDS patients, provided they had the prerequisite level of monetary funds to join the, "Dallas Buyers Club". As you can see from the photo above, Mr. Leto has gone all out in becoming his character. As with Matthew McConaughey, Jared Leto, already a relatively svelte man, has lost a significant amount of weight, to the point of being dangerously thin, for the role. This sort of physical dedication to a role never fails to impress fellow actors, and even if the movie is not all that beloved itself, I expect both Mr. McConaughey and Mr. Leto to receive attention for their performances. We also have to consider, even if it may sound a bit crude, that the Academy has a history of rewarding gender bending roles. Whether it be Felicity Huffman in Transamerica, Jaye Davidson in The Crying Game, or Hillary Swank in Boys Don't Cry, sexual ambiguity and androgyny has a history of striking Oscar's fancy. For this very reason alone, Leto is worth considering as a potential Oscar nominee, but when you add in some of the other factors at work going on in Dallas Buyers Club, I think we have a very serious contender.
6. Jeremy Renner - American Hustle
Jeremy Renner was a hardly noticed workman of an actor until The Hurt Locker became the critical sensation that it did, eventually winning the Oscar for Best Picture despite its measly box office receipts. Along with the movie, Jeremy Renner's performance rightfully received a mountain of kudos, earning him his first Oscar nomination for Best Actor. The very next year, Renner followed that up with a Best Supporting Actor nomination for his work in Ben Affleck's sophomore directorial effort, The Town. Since then, Renner has mostly cashed in on his new high profile by appearing in a number of action flicks, from Mission Impossible: Ghost Protocol, to The Bourne Legacy, to The Avengers. He may once again though become a name uttered on the lips of Academy members with his upcoming performance in David O. Russell's newest feature, American Hustle. If you haven't yet heard of the movie, the film is a cinematic interpretation of the FBI's Abscam operation. The purpose of the operation was to expose corrupt politicians in the Tri-State area during the late 70's and early 80's by setting up a bribery sting using ex-con artists posing as Arab investors. One of the main targets of the sting operation was the popular Democratic Mayor of Camden, New Jersey, Angelo Errichetti, who Jeremy Renner portrays in the film. Errichetti was a descendant of first-generation Italian immigrants and apparently was quite the character. It will be interesting to see Renner take on what sounds like a fairly eccentric character, more so at least than some of the previous characters Renner has played. If he pulls it off with gusto and aplomb, I expect him to be in the thick of the Oscar race. The biggest obstacle for Renner, as is the case with some other potential Best Supporting Actor nominees, is what appears to be the ensemble nature of the film. David O. Russell has been red hot with the Academy over his last two features, particular with getting his actors Oscar nominations and victories, but with a cast that includes Christian Bale, Amy Adams, Jennifer Lawrence, Bradley Cooper, Robert De Niro, and Louis C.K., there is simply not going to be enough kudos to go around for everybody. While I have no doubt that Renner will be categorized as a supporting actor, it's unclear which categories some of his fellow thespians on the film will be placed in, which could significantly hurt his Oscar hopes.
5. Will Forte - Nebraska
If some of you balked at my inclusion of Steve Carell in my preview of possible 2014 Best Actor contenders, you're likely to flip your lid over the prospects of former SNL alum Will Forte joining the ranks of Oscar nominated actors. While this reaction is kind of understandable, I warn you, laugh at your own risk, because you may very well be eating a steady diet of crow come nine months time. The reason why this unlikely Oscar prospect has suddenly become quite the contender is fairly simple, he's appearing in the newest Alexander Payne movie. The Academy has been fairly kind to the actors appearing in Payne's movies, even when they aren't the sexiest names in the business, such as Thomas Hayden Church, who received a best supporting actor nomination for his role in Sideways. Payne's Oscar prowess appears to be only increasing as well, considering his last two films both earned Best Picture nominations and earned two Best Director nominations for Payne himself. Payne's newest film, currently premiering at Cannes, follows an estranged father (Bruce Dern) and son (Will Forte) who take a road trip from Montana to Nebraska in order to claim a million dollar Mega Sweepstakes Prize the father believes he has won. The film appears in black-and-white, which should add some esteem to the proceedings even for those who do not consider themselves avid Payne fanatics. It also sounds like the perfect father-son relationship movie, with just enough opportunities for comedy and levity but leaving appropriate room for touching emotional breakthroughs, that should have Academy members eating out of Payne's hands. All this is serious reason to consider Forte's play for an Oscar nomination. These types of "dramedic" roles are often where the Academy stays its usual embargo on comedians and lets them in the lounge for a cocktail or two before asking them politely to leave (see Bill Murray's sole nomination for Lost in Translation). It's the sort of transitional role that allows a comedian to show their range, but doesn't throw them so far off into the deep end as to disturb anyone's preconceived notions of what the comedian is, and should be, capable of. Of course, if the movie proves unpopular or middling, then all this analysis is moot, but assuming the movie goes over well enough (which I'm sure it will), then get use to the idea of hearing Will Forte's name being mentioned for a possible Oscar nomination.
4. Daniel Bruhl - The Fifth Estate
You may think you are not familiar with the Spanish-born, German-citizen (his mother hails from Spain while his father is a known German director), but chances are you've seen Daniel Bruhl's works and didn't even know it. Particularly if you're a fan of Quentin Tarantino's work (and who isn't?), you'll remember Mr. Bruhl for his terrific performance as Frederick Zoller, German war hero turned movie star who romantically pursued the secretly Jewish cinema owner, Shosanna (Melanie Laurent), to his own demise in Inglourious Basterds. If you somehow have still not seen Inglourious Basterds and are unaware of some of Mr. Bruhl's other mainstream work (such as The Bourne Ultimatum), fear not, you will know Daniel Bruhl's name soon enough. Bruhl is scheduled to appear in at least three movies this year and not in insignificant roles either. He will be a central figure in German Intelligence trying to ascertain the true nature of a recent Muslim immigrant in Anton Corbijn's spy thriller, A Most Wanted Man, and he will star as F-1 champion driver Niki Lauda in Ron Howard's biopic, Rush. Bruhl's best chance at garnering the attention of awards bodies though will likely come with his portrayal of Daniel Domscheit-Berg, the early supporter and friend of WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange who eventually went his separate ways with the world's most famous hackivist and wrote a tell-all book of which The Fifth Estate is partially based on. Playing the partner of a revolutionary leader, whether they lead a massively influential political movement or an inconsequential small-time gang of street thugs, is often ripe dramatic material and an opportune chance for an actor to show their stuff. I believe Bruhl has the ability to be an actor of some importance, but whether this particular role can secure him his first Oscar nomination will largely depend on the reception of the film itself. The film is being written by former The West Wing writer Josh Singer, which sounds promising enough, but the film's director is none other than Bill Condon. Mr. Condon is coming off double duty on closing out the wildly popular tween film franchise, Twilight, directing the series' final two features, The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn Part 1 and The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn Part 2. It's not exactly the typical "previous features" an Oscar-contending director has in their oeuvre, but Condon has met with some Oscar success in the past with films such as Gods and Monsters, Kinsey, and Dreamgirls. At the very least though, I think it would be fair to categorize the director as inconsistent, which puts a big question mark on the awards prospects of The Fifth Estate. If, however, the film receives warm critical reception and turns out to be bona fide Oscar player, mark my words, Daniel Bruhl will be name-checked by more than a few awards bodies.
3. Matthew McConaughey - The Wolf of Wall Street
I currently believe McConaughey to be the front-runner for this year's Best Actor race for his physically transformative role as the AIDS-ridden drug smuggler Ron Woodruff in the forthcoming Dallas Buyers Club, but I think there is a good chance McConaughey may find himself a double nominee this year with an accompanying Best Supporting Actor nomination for his role in Martin Scorsese's The Wolf of Wall Street. McConaughey has had a career metamorphosis that may be unrivaled in the the history of cinema, giving one of the single most seminal years of acting in 2012 with his performances in films such Bernie, Magic Mike, Killer Joe, and The Paperboy. He has hardly rested on his laurels this year either, with a strong performance in Jeff Nichol's Mud, the aforementioned Dallas Buyers Club, and further in the future, the starring role in Christopher Nolan's next film, Interstellar. Given his new found career trajectory and critical cache, you better believe people will be keen to watch his first effort directed by Martin Scorsese, awards bodies included. The Wolf of Wall Street is based on the autobiography of the same name by Jordan Belfort (Leonardo DiCaprio). Belfort became a highly successful stockbroker in the 1990's, living the high life to the extreme. Belfort's hedonistic affluence and arrogance would soon get the best of him though, as the corrupt practices of both Belfort and his firm were eventually exposed by the FBI, landing Belfort in jail for a number of years. Belfort's life story already served as the inspiration for one film, Boiler Room, and while that film missed out on any Oscar opportunities, I don't think the Scorsese-lead effort will suffer the same fate. Mr. McConaughey's role in the proceedings is that of playing one Mark Hanna. Hanna apparently served as a mentor of sorts to Mr. Belfort, showing him the ropes when Belfort was just breaking into the business. Oscar history has shown that the mentor role can be very prosperous indeed, so if the part is substantial enough, it will be considered for recognition by Academy members. The likely biggest obstacle to McConaughey's chance at an Oscar nomination for the film will be, like so many other potential contenders, other actors in the cast. While there is no question Leonardo DiCaprio is the star of this film, there are a number of supporting characters, filled by big name actor, who will all be vying for the audience's attention along with Mr. McConaghey. If Matthew doesn't receive a nomination for his role in the movie, his fellow cast mates just might.
2. Jonah Hill - The Wolf of Wall Street
Including Jonah Hill. While Mr. McConaughey is tasked with playing DiCaprio's mentor, Hill is a said to play DiCaprio's friend and confidant, who partakes in enjoying all the material excesses Belfort's enormous wealth afforded him. Hill has proved apt at playing the "friend" before, albeit in more comedic fare, so it's not like the role is out of his league. In the more dramatic settings of The Wolf of Wall Street though, whatever talents Mr. Hill has of portraying companionship are likely to be more appreciated than some of his efforts in the past. Hill started out his career as a member of the Judd Apatow troupe, appearing in and starring in such Apatow produced films as Knocked Up, Superbad, Funny People, and Get Him to the Greek. While Hill became popular to the masses through these broad comedies, he has since built up some clout among a number of lofty auteurs. Appearing in films from directors such as Quentin Tarantino and Bennett Miller, Hill even received an Oscar nomination for his work with the latter director playing Billy Beane's right-hand man in Moneyball, a rare feat for a comedic actor as young as Hill. Hill then must be considered as a potential nominee in the supporting field, especially considering the fact he is working with the vaunted Martin Scorsese. Scorsese has directed an astounding 20 Oscar-nominated performances in his career, starting with Ellen Burstyn (who won) and Diane Ladd in Scorsese's easily most underrated film, Alice Doesn't Live Here Anymore, and ending most recently with Mark Wahlberg's tough-guy cop performance in The Departed. Scorsese has even shown talent directing natural comedians in more serious fare as he famously did with Jerry Lewis in The King of Comedy (although Lewis was not nominated for an Oscar), so Hill is definitely in good hands. As with McConaughey though, the ensemble cast of The Wolf of Wall Street may be Hill's biggest hindrance. For instance, it is very conceivable that votes for Hill and McConaughey could "cancel" each other out if one does not clearly stick out over the other as worthy of awards nominations. Also, with a cast that includes Jean Dujardin, Jon Favreau, and Rob Reiner, it is possible a third-party player could steal the attention from under the feet of both McConaughey and Hill.
1. James Franco - Spring Breakers
This entry is unique in my series of articles previewing the 2014 Oscars in the fact that it is the first entry in the series that puts a spotlight on a film which has already been released this year. If you happened to miss it (and if you did, you did yourself a disservice), Spring Breakers chronicles the misadventures of four college-age vixens (played by Selena Gomez, Vanessa Hudgens, Ashley Benson, and Rachel Kornine) who are obsessed with taking the youthful rite of passage they feel they deserve. The party-hardy trip turns out to be quite the journey, fracturing the quartet and bringing out aspects of the girls' personalities that forever transform their lives. The film was the newest flick from off-beat auteur Harmony Kormine, whose previous films include Trash Humpers, a controversial film which followed a group of sociopathic elderly people in Nashville, Tennessee. Spring Breakers is another entry in what seems to be the growing "montage as movie" genre (the person I saw the film with described it as "Terrance Malick does spring break"). While the film sports an uber-hip score from none other than the dub-step maestro himself, Skrillex, it undoubtedly befuddled a number of vapid college-goers who were expecting something closer to reality TV than an experimental art film. The standout feature of the film though is undoubtedly the performance given by James Franco as aspiring-rapper and gangster going by the name of Alien. Based on the underground rap artist Dangeruss (although most believe it is based on another rapper by the name of Riff Raff), Franco is like you've never seen him before, embodying the fatalistic, short-term outlook of the rap/gangster world. While he slips out of the accent a tad here and there, this is a very minor quibble with an otherwise fantastic performance. With cornrows in his hair and white-man-acting-ghetto persona, Franco is everything this dark, Millennial Gen fairy tale needs him to be, and it's quite the mesmerizing performance. Now you may think my obvious appreciation of this performance may be blinding my otherwise sterling analytical abilities when it comes to prognosticating the Oscars, but hear me out for a second. While the film is far too under the radar to receive major Oscar attention (and opened to a overall mixed critical response as well), out of those who professed to like the film (and there were some significantly praiseworthy reviews among those who did like it), they were all ecstatic about Franco's performance. A number of Oscars pundits even declared the performance worthy of an Oscar nomination, and while they simultaneously dismissed his chances, this is the type of secretly-held consensus that spurs on the crowning of cult films and performances. While Franco's performance may not currently be the topic of conversation, much like Matthew McConaughey's performance in Magic Mike last year, I wouldn't be surprised to see Franco's name being mentioned in a lot of papers and cinematic rags on their year's end "best lists". If that happens and begins to avalanche on itself, then it's only a matter of if Franco's campaign can build up enough momentum to overcome whatever competition he may face. It may be a long shot, but I believe it is a realistic one. That concludes my list, but it only scratches the surface of terrific viable candidates this year for Best Supporting Actor. I had to make a lot of difficult decisions and cut out some big name players off my list, so feel free to name some of this year's coming male supporting performers that you think may be included in 2014's Best Supporting Actor lineup.