Oscars 2014: Ranking Best Pictures From Worst To Best

An ordered list of exactly who's most likely to pick up the most prestigious gong come March 2nd.

By Robert Kojder /

2013€™s Best Picture nominations involve a free man wrongfully sold into slavery for 12 years, David O. Russell getting more wild performances out of his actors in a madcap tale of con-men, an enlightening and special effects-dazzling display of deterministic survival in deep space, the McConaiassance reaching a new all-time high with a powerful performance as a man coping with Aids, Leonardo DiCaprio on drugs for 3 hours and sticking lit candles in his a**, Joaquin Phoenix falling in love with an OS voiced by the lovely Scarlett Johansson, and more. Undoubtedly, this year features both the strangest and strongest line-up of nominations in quite some time, and truthfully they all are deserving of their nomination. And so, taking these nine excellent films and ranking them from worst to best is no easy feat. It€™s almost like being asked to rank your children, but with movies; really, really fascinating movies. Someone has to tackle the daunting task though, and the inevitable criticism that will come regardless of each film€™s placement. Even the best films have their shortcomings too, so aside from simply ranking them with some positive thoughts, their faults will also be analyzed too in an effort to separate the pack. So without further ado, it€™s time to rank the 2013 Best Picture nominees. Before clicking Next, here is an alphabetical refresher of the nominees: 12 Years A Slave, American Hustle, Captain Phillips, Dallas Buyers Club, Gravity, Her, Nebraska, Philomena, and The Wolf of Wall Street. Shall we begin?

9. Philomena

While Philomena being slotted at #9 isn€™t surprising anyone reading this, that isn€™t to say it€™s a bad film. It€™s actually a pretty fantastic film that is unfortunately being overlooked in favour of the more approachable and marketed nominations. The film stars Judi Dench as an elderly woman named Philomena, who comes to a mental crossroad and decides to seek out her long-lost son, €“ instead of locking up his existence inside her - who was taken from her and sold to America by nuns; strict nuns that clearly feel early pregnancy out of wedlock is a sin beyond redemption. Philomena receives assistance in the form of an atheist journalist brilliantly played an against-type Steve Coogan. Together they not only crack the case, but explore each other€™s values and beliefs. It can come across overly sentimental at times, but there€™s also a lot of interesting subtext to example regardless of your stance on religion. Philomena€™s only real flaw is its unfaithfulness to the true version of the story, instead opting for a movie that feels intentionally crafted to pull at your heart strings rather than going about it naturally. The core of the story is still fascinating and downright shocking, escalated by two amazing lead performances.

8. Captain Phillips

Director Paul Greengrass is an accomplished action auteur with some strong titles under his belt €“ most notably the second and third Bourne films €“ but has always seemed destined for greater things. Captain Phillips is his first truly astonishing film, fusing the visceral and shaky action he has come to be known for with some deep characterisation, expertly expressed by one of the all-time greats Tom Hanks. Paul Greengrass also does an admirable job of shying away from falling into stereotypical villain traps. The Somali pirates overtaking the titular Captain Phillips€™ ship aren€™t presented as your average one-dimensional villains, but as real people with moral conundrums. Captain Phillips sympathises with their plight and despite being captured, he understands why they€™re holding him hostage. It€™s commonly accepted however that the true defining moment of greatness €“ alongside being one of 2013€™s most emotional scenes €“ is Tom Hank€™s unbelievable expression of traumatic release after everything is all over, complete with some of the most believable crying ever seen on screen. The only reason it isn€™t higher on the list is due to its iffy pacing in the middle. It truly does feel that some of the film could have been nixed to keep the tension consistently at extreme heights. Also, Greengrass€™ indulgence in shaking the camera is often just distracting, and not something that feels necessary to building atmosphere.

7. American Hustle

American Hustle may be nominated for 10 Academy Awards, but that doesn€™t mean it€™s the best of the Best Picture nominations. No one will deny that the movie has one of the greatest ensemble casts ever and that it's film is endlessly entertaining from beginning to end, but it€™s an experience that quickly leaves you afterwards. Scenes like Jennifer Lawrence energetically cleaning the house while singing along to Live And Let Die, Bradley Cooper and Louis C.K bantering about an ice fishing story, Amy Adams playing every single character to the point where even the audience has absolutely no idea who€™s side she is on, another physical Christian Bale transformation, and Jeremy Renner playing a crooked yet sympathetic politician trying to better his community, all make for award worthy performances. But that€™s all American Hustle is €“ an exercise in outstanding acting. David O. Russell has even admitted that he disregards actual storytelling when shooting films, preferably just letting his actors loose and unhinged. American Hustle deserves its nomination for the fact that it is an uproarious riot with phenomenal acting, but it lacks a real kick to keep it lingering around in your mind.

6. Dallas Buyers Club

It€™s no surprise that the performance steamrolling Matthew McConaughey to a plethora of Best Acting awards is also a fantastic film overall, with a Best Picture nomination to its name. McConaughey plays the Aids stricken homophobic Ron Woodroof spectacularly, showcasing a range of layers and emotions as the film progresses. His unlikely partnership and friendship with a transvestite portrayed by Jared Leto only heighten the characterization into something truly special. And while Jared Leto completely transforms himself into a role that will assuredly win him the Best Supporting Actor Oscar, ultimately this is McConaughey€™s film. Dallas Buyers Club is a window into the life of a man determined to live and make a difference in the battle against Aids. Similar to American Hustle though, Dallas Buyers Club mitigates good storytelling with exceptional acting. Various aspects of the ending feel rushed, as if the filmmakers knew of a point in Ron€™s life they wanted to reach, but became apparently unsure of where to go from there. Also, while the film does explore some relevant subject matter and an important true story, the remaining films are simply more memorable or tell more emotional stories.

5. Gravity

Building on that last thought, Gravity isn€™t one of the remaining films that's higher up on the list because it tells a riveting story that will heavily impact your outlook on the world. The story isn€™t terrible €“ it actually gets a little too much unwarranted flak €“ but there€™s simply no denying that Gravity€™s greatest strength lies in its groundbreaking and revolutionary special effects. Watching Doctor Ryan Stone in deep space facing constant peril is a nerve-wrecking and nail-biting experience full of dazzling scenes. Director Alfonso Cuaron also makes some brilliant decisions along the way too, like playing with the sound of silence and choreographing single shots that last upwards to 17 minutes long. It would also be completely unfair to discuss Gravity€™s praise without discussing Sandra Bullock€™s complex performance, which had her learning different variations of hyperventilation and more. Also, due to how technologically advanced the digital facial mapping process was, every scene had to have its dialogue and actions planned out and executed without being a single second off course. Gravity is an unprecedented visual experience unlike anything we€™ve ever seen, but it is held back a bit from a mediocre story.

4. Nebraska

Alexander Payne is a master at crafting intelligent films that carry a humanistic quality to them, and Nebraska is no different. Aside from being nominated for multiple awards €“ including Best Picture obviously €“ it€™s also undeniably Payne€™s greatest filmmaking achievement. And it's not just because various themes are presented from filming it in black and white. Nebraska stars Bruce Dern as a dementia-stricken, senile old man named Woody who has fallen for a sweepstakes scam, and wants to do nothing else but travel to Nebraska to claim his $1million. It€™s quickly becoming his only reason to live, as he continuously leaves his house and just walks in a direction aimlessly, deluding himself into thinking he€™s headed there. His wife is at a breaking point and ready to place him in a nursing home, while his son David needs a break from his every-day life. Although David knows the sweepstake is a sham, he drives Woody anyway, embarking on one of the most bittersweet road trips in cinema. Bruce Dern may not have many lines, but everything from his crippling walk to his facial mannerisms €“ which perfectly showcases a man without much going on upstairs €“ portray a depressing shell of a man. Will Forte is also completely out of his element here, but delivers a brilliantly nuanced and deadpan performance. It€™s incredibly easy to connect with him, as the subject material hits close to home for undoubtedly many viewers. Yes, at times Nebraska is funny, but underneath that is something much more depressing. So why isn€™t it #1? As excellent as Nebraska is, the film does occasionally drag and is hindered by some painfully slow moments. Still, no one involved has anything to be ashamed of.

3. The Wolf Of Wall Street

Nobody explores anti-heroes and corrupted men like Martin Scorsese. He takes characters that would wholly disgust us in real life, and completely glamorises them into loveable criminals. The Wolf of Wall Street is no exception, and gets absolutely filthy diving into greed, hedonism, drug abuse, and more unsavory elements that are commonly associated with the proverbial American Dream. And who better to chronicle all the madness than Scorsese€™s current muse, Leonardo DiCaprio in a role that completely unhinges him, allowing him to reveal even more range. DiCaprio is a nonstop blitzkrieg of energy that helps the mammoth running time of 179 minutes fly by. Every time he takes the stage to fuel his fellow greedy stockbrokers with misguided ambition, he gives the audience a hefty boost of adrenaline too. The supporting cast also plays a pivotal part in making the film as outrageous and memorable as it is. Everyone from Jonah Hill to Matthew McConaughey, to Rob Reiner, to Margot Robbie, and all in between deserve praise for fearlessly tackling all of the obscene material presented. With that said, we€™re reaching a point where the remaining films are essentially flawless. Whittling down and ranking these top three was tough, but ultimately the rest are more important films that leave a stronger impression.

2. 12 Years A Slave

It€™s always admirable when a director €“ in this case it€™s the talented Steve McQueen €“ chooses to present controversial material without rose tinted glasses, and instead lays it all out there regardless of how brutal it is, or the fact that many moviegoers won€™t have the stomach to see it through to the end. In this case, that subject is the memoirs of Solomon Northup; a free man kidnapped and unjustly sold into slavery. Steve McQueen also makes the bold decision of not privileging viewers a chronological timeline to follow. It doesn€™t matter if we€™re witnessing day 7, day 50, year 4, or year 12 because frankly, the movie is about suffering. And 12 Years A Slave makes it a point to flow from one disturbing scene to another, without leaving viewers with one opportunity to suck in some serenity. An outstanding ensemble cast involving Chiwetel Ejiofor €“ who could tell the entire grueling story solely with facial expressions and body language if he wanted to €“ Michael Fassbender as a psychotic slave owner, Lupita Nyong€™o as a similarly tortured soul, and more also make the brutality feel real. With a lesser cast, you just don't get the heartbreaking emotion presented here. 12 Years A Slave as a result, is far and away the greatest film ever made about American slavery, along with being one of the most important films ever made, but there€™s one film that just edges it out.

1. Her

On the surface, it€™s about a man beginning a relationship with an OS voice modulator. Her is about something much deeper though; our unnerving reliance on technology that continues to grow, the fear of direct contact in relationships, and a first-hand look at some possible directions the world is heading. Joaquin Phoenix does a fantastic job playing Theodore Twombly, but the true effectiveness of the film falls on Scarlett Johansson, who has to act out a calming, relaxing, and enchanting voice that can convince viewers into believing that an introverted and reclusive man could actually fall in love with a voice. Phoenix and Johansson then have to maintain conversations that feel real and natural despite being nowhere near each other. And then there are some unforgettably uncomfortable scenes €“ most notably one involving a surrogate for sexual stimulation €“ that add further intrigue into this stunningly near possible future Spike Jonze had shown us. Not only is Her a thought provoking and intelligently relevant watch, but no other 2013 film sticks with you like it. Do you agree or disagree? Feel free to post your own rankings below!