Oscars 2018: 5 Awards The Academy Got Right (And 8 They Got Wrong)
And the Oscar goes to... WHAT?!
So that was the Oscars 2018.
The 90th instalment of the Academy Awards took place at the Dolby Theatre in Los Angeles last night, with Jimmy Kimmel hosting and much of the chatter dominated by the Me Too and Time's Up movements.
They were rightfully paid attention to, but in between that there were a lot of awards to hand out and some big questions to be answered. It was, heading into the night, the most open Best Picture race we'd seen in years. The Shape of Water vs Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri was the headline bout, but Dunkirk and Get Out both had a chance thanks to the preferential voting system.
Ultimately it was Shape that ended up the big winner, taking home four awards overall, including Best Picture. Elsewhere, all four of the Acting categories went with the awards season form, Jordan Peele scooped the Best Original Screenplay prize for Get Out, and Faye Dunaway and Warren Beatty avoided another La La Land/Moonlight style mix up. They read out the correct names, but which ones were the right winners, and which were the mistakes? (Caveat: in terms of Got Right, we're only looking at those categories where there was a close race, rather than, saying, Phantom Thread's obvious win for Costume Design or Darkest Hour taking home Best Makeup.)
Got Right...
5. Best Original Song - Remember Me, Coco
Coco was a lock for Best Animated Feature, but less so when it came to Original Song, where it was involved in an extremely tight two-horse race with The Greatest Showman's This Is Me. And, given the legs the latter has had at the box-office, it wouldn't have been too much of a surprise to say it go that way, especially as Pixar's had some big misses here before.
While Greatest Showman's songs are excellent, This Is Me doesn't quite match the emotional power of Coco's Remember Me, which comes at the end of the film as a perfect, poignant summation of the movie's themes and messages.
It's a gorgeous, happy-sad mix that serves as a haunting reminder of loved ones who've lost and the way we hold them in our memories long afterwards, and the crux of Coco's devastating denouement.
4. Best Production Design - The Shape Of Water
This one could just as easily have gone to Blade Runner 2049, since that film also took home Cinematography and Visual Effects, and undoubtedly many will think it should've done.
But whereas Blade Runner 2049 is great, it's more built upon what we've already seen in the original, and more of an achievement in cinematography above all else, along with some great VFX work (although not necessarily the best).
The Shape of Water looks like you'd imagine the inside of del Toro's mind does, a blend of monster movie homage, small-town America of the late-50s/early-60s, and a lush fantasy setting. Everything is beautifully realised in painstaking detail, from the overstuffed apartments to the colour palettes that match the characters, to the incredible bathroom flooding sequence, and it's a labour of love and imagination.
3. Best Original Screenplay - Get Out
A hotly contested category this, especially as it included the two Best Picture frontrunners The Shape of Water and Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri, along with the acclaimed Lady Bird and The Big Sick.
It could've went to any of them, really, but Get Out was the most deserving. It felt like it really needed to be rewarded somewhere, given how it's remained such a big part of the zeitgeist for so long, and while there were better-directed movies and better movies overall, its screenplay is a thing of wonder.
Not only is the film a success as an extremely dark comedy, but the screenplay perfectly blends that with its genuine horror elements and adds in a biting, razor-sharp social commentary for a stunningly original mix. It's extremely layered with symbolism, double meanings, and foreshadowing, and manages to be both political and populist entertainment. For the sheer balance achieved in bringing all those seemingly disparate strands together, along with its genuine originality, Get Out was the choice here.
2. Best Picture - The Shape Of Water
As mentioned, this was a pretty open race: Three Billboards had picked up some big awards, but it was a divisive film, and The Shape of Water isn't your typical Oscars fare, meaning something that was generally well-liked had a chance of sneaking it.
Despite that, though, it ultimately went to one of the two favourites, and definitely the right one. The Shape of Water, while perhaps not the best in some individual categories like Screenplay or Director, is brilliant across the board: it's beautifully shot, the production design is gorgeous, it has a swooning, magical score, the screenplay somehow to turn a monster movie into a heartfelt romance mixed with a thriller mixed with an adult fairytale, all under the direction of the great Guillermo del Toro, and the performances are all superb.
1. Best Cinematography - Blade Runner 2049
Given Roger Deakins' previous 13 nominations wielded zero wins, there were no guarantees that it'd be 14th time lucky for the legendary DP, with strong competition from Dan Laustsen (The Shape of Water), Rachel Morrison (Mudbound), and especially Hoyte van Hoytema (Dunkirk).
Thankfully, though, Deakins did take home the prize, and it's so much more than a lifetime achievement award - indeed, there's a strong argument that Blade Runner 2049 is his finest work to date (though The Assassination of Jesse James would put up a good fight).
Every frame of this movie is like its own work of art, but put together it's something even more special: a dystopian nightmare meets an ethereal, dreamlike beauty, that no other film can compete with.
Got Wrong...
8. Best Visual Effects - Blade Runner 2049
What Should've Won: War for the Planet of the Apes
Blade Runner 2049 is a stunning film, and one that deserved more nominations than it received, so it's hard to begrudge its win here too much. And yet, when it comes to VFX work, War for the Planet of the Apes should've taken home the gold.
The movie once again broke new ground in what can be conveyed through motion-capture, with a sublime performance from Andy Serkis, and combined that with truly great blockbuster action sequences. The managed to add greater nuance to Caesar, both in terms of his appearance - he's aged visibly - and his movements as he becomes older and weaker, with Serkis and his team adding new levels of depth to the character, while achieving a lot with newcomer Bad Ape too (more dialogue and those big eyes only extended the amount of VFX work necessary, and they pulled it off with aplomb).
7. Best Adapted Screenplay - Call Me By Your Name
What Should've Won: Molly's Game
Although it boasts a sublime, star-making performance from Timothée Chalamet, Call Me By Your Name - while very good - isn't the best adapted screenplay of the bunch.
The movie itself does suffer a little from a lack of intimacy, cutting the gay sex scene and toning down the peach scene in translating the book to the screen, but there are simply better screenplays here anyway.
Logan would've been worthy, but best of all is Aaron Sorkin's Molly's Game, which is the best, most Sorkin-y script we've had since The Social Network - and in the hands of a better, showier director, likely would've received more acclaim. It's got that trademark rat-a-tat style that allows the film's 140 minutes run time to breeze by, accompanied by humour, excitement, incredible dialogue (obviously), and it allows for showcase performances from Jessica Chastain and Idris Elba.
6. Best Editing - Dunkirk
What Should've Won: Baby Driver
Dunkirk took home three awards in total, and while it's hard to argue with its two Sound prizes - because the movie is LOUD and EPIC - it's Editing, while great, was bettered by that of Baby Driver.
A win for Edgar Wright's movie seemed unlikely, since it didn't have a Best Picture nomination to go with it (which this category generally demands), but he and his team - Paul Machliss and Jonathan Amos - should've been taking the statue for the way they so perfectly and joyously synced every beat to the expertly curated soundtrack.
The editing in Baby Driver is both seamless and a feat of real ingenuity, allowing the action and the music to blend together in true harmony while the movie zooms along faster than Baby in a getaway, while still ensuring to hit the romantic and heartfelt beats when necessary.
5-2. All The Acting Categories
Who Should've Won: Daniel Day-Lewis / Margot Robbie / Willem Dafoe / Laurie Metcalf
All four of the acting categories appeared to be locked in heading into the Oscars, and there were no surprises on the night, with Gary Oldman, Frances McDormand, Sam Rockwell, and Allison Janney all adding to their considerable awards season hauls.
Oldman is good, rather than truly great, in Darkest Hour, with the prosthetics doing a lot of the heavy lifting and it being an impersonation of a real person, and the movie itself being the weakest of the Best Picture bunch. Day-Lewis is far more understated in Phantom Thread, and it's a more subtle performance than he typically gives overall, which has likely cost him the win but makes it all the better. He shows genuine vulnerability, a great deal of emotional maturity, and has a number of tics and affectations that are key to the character and help make him so memorable, rather than for show.
McDormand and Rockwell are both great in Three Billboards, so it's slightly harder to contest those, but it would've been nice to see Robbie and Dafoe take the prizes. While McDormand is a fiery ball of rage in Billboards, Robbie conveys an astonishing range of strength and vulnerability in I, Tonya; she's at times unlikable, and yet you can't help but root for her. Dafoe, meanwhile, gives a quietly powerful performance - he's the rock of the broken world in The Florida Project, with a performance of wonderful authenticity that only occasionally flickers towards the kind of showiness that landed Rockwell the win.
Janney in I, Tonya does an excellent job playing against type with the brash, acerbic mother who'll do whatever it takes to drive her daughter to glory. Laurie Metcalf, however, does all that just as well, but balances it with great nuance; there's a warmth and sense of compassion to the character, and a much stronger bond formed with her daughter, that makes it that much more a varied and appealing performance.
1. Best Director - Guillermo del Toro, The Shape Of Water
Who Should've Won: Christopher Nolan
Guillermo del Toro does some wonderful direction on The Shape of Water, and he realises a vision that is purely his. It's the deserving Best Picture winner but, on this occasion, the Academy should've split the awards between Picture and Director.
Nolan's Dunkirk may not be the director's best movie, but it's definitely up there in terms of his oeuvre and represents pure filmmaking. He's a director who talks a lot about what cinema is and should be, and while the full merits of what he says are debatable, when you see Dunkirk you're seeing his belief in what *cinema* is. It's an incredibly crafted spectacle that explodes on the screen; the kind of fully immersive experience that makes your ears bleed, eyes burst, and heart pound.
What do you think the Oscars got right/wrong? Share your thoughts down in the comments.