Oscars 2018 Nominations: 18 Shocks & Snubs

Oscar nominee The Boss Baby, folks.

By Jack Pooley /

DreamWorks & AMPAS

This year's Academy Award nominations are out, and as usual, film buffs are busy singing the praises of their favourite movies that were recognised, while foaming at the mouth at those "instant classics" that were snubbed by the backwards-thinking Academy voters.

Advertisement

With a greater sense of diversity among its nominees, the 90th Academy Awards was certainly a step in the right direction even if there's still plenty to be done, considering the number of stereotypical "Oscar bait" movies that fared better than they probably should have.

Still, the horror, sci-fi fantasy and superhero genres were given better-than-expected representation in the nominations list, and regardless of who ends up winning, it's great to see the Academy not just settling for the same stuffy, boring movies starring middle-aged white people all the time.

Advertisement

There were shock nominations and depressing omissions sure to result in elation and outrage in near-equal measure, but on the whole, it wasn't a bad showing from the Academy at all. And now comes the agonising five-week wait for the March 4th ceremony...

18. Shock: Kong: Skull Island (Best Visual Effects)

Warner Bros.

Kong: Skull Island scooped a surprising Best Visual Effects nomination despite featuring, well, largely mediocre and forgettable VFX work.

Advertisement

Sure, Kong looked fine when stood still, but much of the digital action was blurry and aesthetically unpleasant, making this nod extremely suspect.

It's all the more bizarre as Kong beat out widely-expected nominee Dunkirk, which presumably suffered due to the movie's focus on practical effects and more subtle, subdued use of CGI.

Advertisement

Kong hasn't got a hope in hell of winning up against heavyweight nominees like Blade Runner 2049 and War for the Planet of the Apes, but it's still a travesty that the Academy even considers it in the same league.

17. Snub: Holly Hunter (Best Supporting Actress - The Big Sick)

StudioCanal

Back in the summer, Holly Hunter was considered an early favourite to take home the Best Supporting Actress Oscar for her fantastic work in The Big Sick, but her momentum began to cool as awards season picked up steam, and she ultimately didn't even end up with a nomination.

Advertisement

It's especially shocking as this category had two fairly surprising nominations with Lesley Manville (Phantom Thread) and Octavia Spencer (The Shape of Water) making the cut, while the more consistently-lauded Hunter has been left with nothing.

It most likely speaks to the indie dramedy being released outside of Oscar season more than anything, but considering that The Big Sick was nominated elsewhere by the Academy, Hunter's exclusion is still rather baffling.

Advertisement

16. Shock: Logan Is The First Superhero Movie Nominated For Its Screenplay

Fox

Though some were upset that Wonder Woman didn't score a single nomination, one of this year's most crowd-pleasing nods was the Best Adapted Screenplay nomination for Logan, deemed by many to be the year's strongest superhero offering.

Advertisement

The screenplay categories are always fun because they do allow more populist fare to sneak nominations every now and then - Straight Outta Compton received an Original Screenplay nod in 2016 - and while Logan was never going to score much "serious" consideration, the fact it's the first-ever superhero film to receive a screenplay nomination is incredibly significant.

Given that even The Dark Knight missed out on a screenplay nod back in 2009, it's clear that the Academy is starting to come around to the idea of these "silly" movies being worthy of awards. It hasn't got a chance of winning, but the nomination is very clearly the win here.

Advertisement

15. Snub: The Greatest Showman & Murder On The Orient Express (Best Costume Design)

20th Century Fox

Hugh Jackman's other big movie this year fared a little more middlingly with Oscar voters, for though The Greatest Showman scored an expected Best Original Song nomination, it ended up missing out on Best Costume Design, which given the film's lavish array of threads, was pretty surprising.

Advertisement

Elsewhere, Murder on the Orient Express' dapper designs were also snubbed, with The Shape of Water and Victoria and Abdul instead scoring semi-surprising nominations.

With Phantom Thread's focus on costume design within its narrative, it's set to steamroll this category, so it's all for naughty anyway. Still, it was pretty damn unexpected that these two extravagant productions both missed out on being recognised.

Advertisement

14. Shock: The Boss Baby (Best Animated Feature)

Dreamworks

The Boss Baby is now an Oscar nominated movie. Let that sink in for a moment. Though the film has its loyal army of defenders, it was incredibly surprising to see the divisive movie beat out both The Lego Batman Movie and Cars 3 to land a nod.

Advertisement

Even if the movie's subject matter wasn't thoroughly daft, the fact that it's ultimately a fairly mediocre concoction of poopy pants gags and vaguely subversive humour makes it surprising that the animated branch, who also nominated classier fare like The Breadwinner and Loving Vincent, would spring for something so blatantly juvenile.

Now Fox gets to slap a bunch of Oscar logos over the movie's Blu-ray boxes. That's on you, Academy.

Advertisement

13. Snub: Armie Hammer (Best Supporting Actor - Call Me By Your Name)

Sony Pictures Classic

Armie Hammer gave one of the year's best performances in Call Me by Your Name, and while his co-star Timothee Chalamet was always going to scoop the lion's share of the film's awards attention, it's a damn shame Hammer didn't land a spot in the Best Supporting Actor line-up.

Advertisement

It's certainly arguable that he was more deserving than Richard Jenkins (The Shape of Water) and Christopher Plummer (All the Money in the World), though it's possible that their being significantly older than Hammer drove the Academy to throw nods their way, especially in the case of the 88-year-old Plummer and the special circumstances surrounding his role.

Hammer will hopefully be encouraged to seek out more artistic dramatic fare in the future, because he proved himself beyond any and all doubt in this splendid movie.

Advertisement

12. Shock: On Body & Soul (Best Foreign Language Film)

Netflix

The Best Foreign Language Film category is always a bit of a crap shoot as far as predictions go, but it was still a surprise to see acclaimed Hungarian drama On Body and Soul make the final five, beating out widely expected nominee In the Fade, which won the Golden Globe for Best Foreign Film but didn't even score a nomination here.

Advertisement

This makes the year's eventual winner even tougher to figure out, for though higher-profile movies like Loveless, The Square and A Fantastic Woman are all far safer bets, perhaps the clear passion for this film could see it all the way to the finish line. Stranger things have happened.

11. Snub: James Franco (Best Actor - The Disaster Artist)

A24

Despite being nominated for just about every major precursor acting award and even winning the Best Actor (Comedy) Golden Globe, James Franco missed out on a nomination for his hilarious performance as Tommy Wiseau in The Disaster Artist, to the surprise of many.

Advertisement

Denzel Washington (Roman J. Israel, Esq.) ended up stealing the fifth spot, likely due to the recent sexual harassment controversy surrounding Franco, which emerged shortly before the nomination voting deadline closed.

For the sake of Franco's PR, it's probably easier if he bows out at this stage rather than have to field questions about his prior behaviour all the way to Oscar night, though it's a shame that his alleged behaviour has cast a dark pall over an otherwise terrific performance.

Advertisement

10. Shock: John Williams Gets Nominated For The Wrong Musical Score

Lucasfilm

John Williams once again broke his own record as the most-nominated person in Oscar history by scoring his 51st nomination for Star Wars: The Last Jedi's musical score.

Advertisement

Though on paper this perhaps doesn't sound that surprising, it is when you consider that Williams' other score last year, for Steven Spielberg's The Post, was widely expected to be the one to land a nomination.

Considering that The Post's score was effortlessly superior to The Last Jedi's more workmanlike and over-familiar musical arrangement, it feels like people just voted for comfortable familiarity and for Williams' legacy rather than anything else.

Advertisement

9. Snub: Denis Villeneuve (Best Director - Blade Runner 2049)

Warner Bros.

The Best Director field is where a lot of auteur filmmakers can flourish even if their movies struggle to score much in other areas.

Advertisement

To that end, there was a lot of hope that Denis Villeneuve might score his second consecutive Best Director nod for his sublime work on Blade Runner 2049, driven by passion for his singular, uncompromising vision for the film.

Sadly, Villeneuve wasn't quite so lucky, and though the final line-up features a fantastically eclectic collection of filmmakers who did splendid work last year, were they all really superior to Villeneuve? Not a chance.

Advertisement

8. Shock: Victoria & Abdul (Best Makeup & Hairstyling)

Focus Features

Despite releasing without much fanfare, Victoria and Abdul managed to score an additional nomination (on top of its Best Costume Design nod) for Best Makeup and Hairstyling, beating out a number of other hopefuls, namely Bright, I, Tonya and Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2

Advertisement

Considering Victoria and Abdul's makeup and hair work doesn't exactly draw much attention to itself, especially compared to Bright's fantastic orcs and the larger-than-life Marvel superheroes, it's pretty surprising the film managed to triumph over them.

The award is definitely going to Darkest Hour, though, so the movie will have to settle for the unexpected nomination.

Advertisement

7. Snub: Beauty & The Beast's "Evermore" (Best Original Song)

Disney

The Best Original Song category is always fairly unadventurous, in that it rarely steps outside the box and nominates anything more than milquetoast pop music, so it seemed like Beauty and the Beast's "Evermore", widely agreed to be the best original composition from the new movie, was a lock for a nomination.

Advertisement

Call Me by Your Name, Coco and The Greatest Showman had three slots sewn up, but Mudbound's "Mighty River" was less of a sure thing, and either way, it really seemed like a movie as popular as Beauty and the Beast would get in here no problem.

Perhaps the auto-tuning and digital treatments applied to almost every song in Beauty and the Beast dissuaded people from voting for it, but whatever the reason, the film had to settle for just two nods for Costume Design and Production Design.

Advertisement

6. Shock: Jordan Peele (Best Director)

Universal Pictures

The nomination that so many people wanted to see but didn't actually expect to was Jordan Peele land a Best Director nod for his fantastic work on Get Out.

Advertisement

Given the Academy's historic prejudice against horror films and Peele being a first-time filmmaker, it seemed far more likely that Martin McDonagh (Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri) would take the fifth spot, but Peele nevertheless managed to snag it.

Considering how the film industry still has a ways to go with hiring more filmmakers of colour, recognising Peele's achievement is at least a step in the right direction, especially as he's totally deserving of it outside of any awards politics debates.

Advertisement

5. Snub: Jane (Best Documentary)

National Geographic

Much like the Best Foreign Language Film category, Best Documentary Feature can often shock and snub in equal measure, both in terms of nominations and the eventual winner itself.

Advertisement

Though the Academy did well to recognise Netflix documentary hits Icarus and Strong Island, curiously omitted was one of 2017's best-reviewed documentaries, Jane, a look at the life and times of beloved conservationist Jane Goodall.

Abacus: Small Enough to Jail stealing Jane's spot was especially surprising considering that it was a more broadly-acclaimed doc, while Jane received near-universal raves and was basically deemed a lock for a nomination. Madness.

Advertisement

4. Shock: The Big Sick (Best Original Screenplay)

StudioCanal

Though Holly Hunter sadly missed out on a Best Supporting Actress nomination, The Big Sick did scoop a single nod for Best Original Screenplay.

Advertisement

With the film's awards buzz cooling down in recent months, it seemed like it would risk being totally shut out of the Oscars, with The Florida Project possibly stealing away its screenplay nod.

Ultimately, though, writer-star Kumail Nanjiani and co-writer Emily V. Gordon, who wrote the story based on their own experiences, prevailed with a well-earned nod for their sweetly affecting culture clash dramedy.

Advertisement

In another timeline it would've been easy to imagine the film performing much better, but that mid-summer release date was probably a mistake in retrospect.

3. Snub: The Florida Project (Best Picture)

A24

Sean Baker's The Florida Project was one of 2017's greatest films, so it's a shame it received only a single nomination for William Dafoe's sublime performance, missing out on well-deserved nods for Best Actress (Brooklynn Prince), Best Original Screenplay, Best Director and, most tragically of all, Best Picture.

Advertisement

The film seemed like a Best Picture lock for quite some time, but with the Oscars' preferential ballot system seemingly preventing the full 10 potential nominees usually being filled out, The Florida Project was ultimately steamrolled by more conventional contenders such as Darkest Hour and The Post.

As far as Best Picture snubs go, this is most certainly one of the more egregious of recent years. What a shame.

Advertisement

2. Shock: Phantom Thread Scores Six Nominations

Focus Features

Though there was never any doubt that Phantom Thread would land nominations for Best Actor (Daniel Day-Lewis) and Best Costume Design, the film massively overshot most expectations by scoring additional nods for Best Supporting Actress (Lesley Manville), Best Original Score, Best Director (Paul Thomas Anderson) and even Best Picture itself.

Advertisement

Given Anderson's tendency to polarise Oscar voters, his success here was never a sure thing, but he clearly benefited from the passionate support of his dedicated fans in the industry.

While the film is unlikely to win anything beyond Best Costume Design, it's still great to see one of the year's most singular and fearless dramas be recognised for its efforts.

Advertisement

1. Shock: Mudbound Bags Netflix Its First "Serious" Oscar Nominations

Netflix

Over the last four years, Netflix has scored a scattering of Oscar nominations for its documentary feature and documentary shorts, with the streaming giant even winning its first Oscar last year for Best Documentary Short.

Advertisement

However, 2018 saw the company's first ever narrative feature score "serious" Oscar consideration, with Dee Rees' terrific Mudbound earning four nominations for Best Supporting Actress (Mary J. Blige), Best Original Song, Best Adapted Screenplay and Best Cinematography.

The latter nomination is especially meaningful as it's the first time a woman has ever been nominated for Best Cinematography.

Advertisement

But considering that Netflix has struggled to break out of the documentary awards categories until now, Mudbound being recognised in meatier categories is an encouraging step forward for the streaming platform and the Academy's approval of it.

What do you make of this year's Oscar nominations? Shout them out in the comments!

Advertisement