Oscars 2019: 9 Ups & 8 Downs

Miles Morales basically won an Oscar.

By Jack Pooley /

Sony & AMPAS

The Academy Awards have come and gone for another year, with the 91st edition of Hollywood's biggest awards show dishing out gold statues to a fairly predictable set of winners, yet there were certainly a few surprises in the mix.

Advertisement

Though the broadcast threatened to be a trainwreck in light of many recent PR blunders on the Academy's part, the show itself was actually one of the most efficient and to-the-point in recent memory, even if the winners themselves were typically a hugely mixed bag.

While the contentious Best Picture victor is likely to be one of the most vociferously argued-about for years, the Academy did show better judgement elsewhere, casting aside traditional prejudices and not being overly blinded by the temptation to give out "career Oscars" to industry titans.

Advertisement

It wasn't a show for the ages, but the format does feel like a step in the right direction, even if some of the winners felt like anything but. And with that in mind, let's kick things off with what went wrong...

Downs...

8. Queen's Rough Opening Performance

ABC & AMPAS

The show kicked off on a downer with an iffy musical performance from Queen, who ripped through a medley of "We Will Rock You" and "We Are the Champions" to a wildly mixed response from both the live audience and viewers at home.

Advertisement

Between singer Adam Lambert's inability to match the gravitas of Freddie Mercury - a tall order if there ever was one, admittedly - to the wince-inducing cuts to various A-listers awkwardly rocking back and forth to the music (or in Christian Bale's case, doing nothing at all), it wasn't quite the rabble-rouser the producers clearly hoped it would be.

Brian May's still got it, for sure, and it was preferable to a bloated 15-minute opening speech, but an oddly flat way to open the show regardless.

Advertisement

7. Bohemian Rhapsody Wins Three Technical Oscars (For Some Reason)

ABC & AMPAS

Bohemian Rhapsody ended up winning the most Oscars of the night, scooping a baffling four Academy Awards, three of which were in technical categories no less.

Advertisement

Firstly, proving that most Academy voters know little about sound, the Queen biopic won the Best Sound Editing & Sound Mixing Oscars, despite the film's glaringly inconsistent sound work compared to, say, fellow nominee First Man.

Clearly, the thought process here was "musical movie = best sound", rather than applying any actual critical thought to it.

Advertisement

The more eyebrow-raising win came later, though, when John Ottman won the Best Film Editing Oscar, despite Bohemian Rhapsody being by far the worst-edited of the five nominated films (its competition being BlacKkKlansman, The Favourite, Green Book and Vice).

Given that the lip sync in Bohemian Rhapsody was occasionally off and film editing forms one of the most basic poles of filmmaking, it was an extremely odd move to give it the gong here.

Advertisement

6. Mahershala Ali Beats Richard E. Grant (Best Supporting Actor)

ABC & AMPAS

To the surprise of absolutely nobody, Mahershala Ali won his second Best Supporting Actor Oscar for his performance in Green Book, beating out passionate fan fave Richard E. Grant for his stellar work on Can You Ever Forgive Me?

Advertisement

Grant was always a long shot, but considering that this was his first ever Oscar nomination over a 30+ year career, and his movie was so much better than Green Book, it's a damn shame he didn't take the gong home.

That's not to dump on Ali's work: he did fine with what he had, but Green Book's screenplay is so facile and underwritten that Ali wasn't really given the chance to give a truly Oscar-worthy performance. The Academy clearly disagreed.

Advertisement

5. Green Book Wins Best Original Screenplay

ABC & AMPAS

You could practically see the disbelief on Samuel L. Jackson's face when he announced that Green Book had won the Best Original Screenplay Oscar, beating out The Favourite, First Reformed, Roma and Vice.

Advertisement

Given that all four of the other nominees had more nuanced and intelligent scripts, this set the alarm bells ringing early that audiences might be in for a Green Book Best Picture win.

As amusing as it is that the writer-director of Dumb and Dumber now has some Oscars to his name, history surely won't look kindly on the Academy rewarding Green Book over its vastly superior competition in this category.

Advertisement

4. The Favourite, BlackKkKlansman, First Man, A Star Is Born & If Beale Street Could Talk Win A Single Oscar Each

ABC & AMPAS

This year's Oscars decided to "spread the love" across a lot of movies, if you will, but the unfortunate result was that a number of the year's best movies ended up going home with just a single Oscar each.

Advertisement

The Favourite, long considered a front-runner in many categories with 10 nominations, won only a Best Actress Oscar for Olivia Colman, surprisingly losing out on Best Costume Design and Best Production Design to Black Panther.

Elsewhere, BlacKkKlansman won just Best Adapted Screenplay for Spike Lee, First Man won Best Visual Effects but lost both sound awards to Bohemian Rhapsody, A Star Is Born's early front-runner status totally cooled off with a single win for Best Original Song (Lady Gaga's "Shallow"), and If Beale Street Could Talk scooped merely Best Supporting Actress for Regina King, with Black Panther stealing away its much-deserved Best Original Score award.

Advertisement

Given some of the unconvincing winners the gold was ultimately given to, it's shocking that such acclaimed movies fell by the wayside over the course of Oscar season. They all deserved more.

3. Dick Miller, Carol Channing, Stanley Donen & Others Snubbed From In Memoriam Segment

Orion Pictures

As affecting as the annual In Memoriam segment is at the Oscars, it's also routinely pilloried for "snubbing" numerous actors who died since the last ceremony, and 2019 was certainly no different.

Advertisement

Among the more egregious and complained-about omissions were legendary character actor Dick Miller (The Terminator, Gremlins), Singin' in the Rain director Stanley Donen (who died three days before the ceremony, but that's no excuse), Oscar-nominated actresses Sondra Locke (The Heart Is a Lonely Hunter) and Carol Channing (Thoroughly Modern Millie), Oscar-nominated actor R. Lee Ermey (Full Metal Jacket) and Austin Powers star Verne Troyer.

Obviously time is a factor when determining who makes the cut, but was it really worth snubbing such acclaimed and recognisable actors for the sake of saving maybe a minute of air time?

Advertisement

2. Rami Malek Wins Best Actor

ABC & AMPAS

Another result that wasn't terribly surprising but was nevertheless disappointing: Rami Malek won the Best Actor Oscar for his performance as Freddie Mercury in Bohemian Rhapsody.

Advertisement

Though Malek certainly gave a solid performance, his work was ultimately hamstrung by the sloppy writing and direction, making this a win undeniably influenced by the general public's fondness for Mercury himself.

Was Malek's all-teeth performance really better than Christian Bale (Vice), Bradley Cooper (A Star Is Born), Willem Dafoe (At Eternity's Gate) and Viggo Mortensen (Green Book)? You can argue for the latter, but the rest? Not a chance.

Advertisement

But Malek has been an aggressive and charming campaigner on the circuit, which no doubt helped him grease the palms of Oscar voters ahead of the Big One. It's a shame, because with a better core movie he certainly could've been a deserving winner.

1. Green Book Is The Worst Best Picture Winner Since Crash

ABC & AMPAS

Despite many crossing their fingers that Roma would win the Best Picture Oscar - scooping Netflix its first Best Picture win in the process - those hopes were scuppered when Julia Roberts announced the winner to be Green Book.

Advertisement

There's something quite surreal about seeing the Academy give a feel-good movie about racism written and directed by white men the biggest honour in film merely two years after they gave it to Moonlight.

From the rather surface-deep acceptance speech - talking in platitudes while ignoring the systemic issues that define racism - to the discomforting visual of so many white people appearing on stage to champion a film about the black experience in America, Green Book couldn't be a more tone-deaf winner.

Advertisement

This makes Green Book by far the most controversial - and we'd argue, the worst - winner since Crash back in 2006, and one of the weakest winners of the modern era.

Needless to say, it'll be a mark of embarrassment for the Academy in the years to come, just like overly simplistic Best Picture-winning race dramas Driving Miss Daisy and Crash.

Advertisement

Above all else, it's proof that the nebulous preferential ballot system needs to be reworked, because Green Book likely won Best Picture through sheer virtue of being the least "offensive" and most accessible of the eight nominees. Oof.

And now that we're done complaining, here's everything the Academy actually got right...

Advertisement

Ups...

9. The Host-Less Oscars Really Works

ABC & AMPAS

After Kevin Hart "stepped down" from hosting the Oscars following a PR controversy, the Academy decide to move forward with a host-less Oscars, which was met with a lot of pre-show scepticism by fans and commentators alike.

Advertisement

But you know what? The result was the least cringe-worthy and most slickly paced Oscar ceremony in years if not decades. Clocking in at around 3 hours and 20 minutes, it was more than 30 minutes shorter than some recent Oscar ceremonies, and the shortest since 2012.

Gone was the typically bloated, overbaked opening speech - replaced with a quick intro from Tina Fey, Amy Poehler and Maya Rudolph - and there was a surprising lack of the usual "skits" peppered throughout the show.

Advertisement

Nobody ordered food for the ceremony's attendees, there were no selfies, and nothing involving random members of the general public.

Even with the overabundance of commercial breaks, this was a fast-moving show that kept the focus on awards without needing to sacrifice any of the 24 nominees (as was originally planned).

Advertisement

Regardless of how the show's ratings turn out, this should be the formula moving forward, and if they can get it even closer to a square three hours, all the better.

8. The MCU Wins Its First Three Oscars

ABC & AMPAS

The Marvel Cinematic Universe finally won not only its first ever Oscar but its first three Oscars this year, with Black Panther scooping the gongs for Best Costume Design, Best Production Design and Best Original Score.

Advertisement

All three wins were relatively surprising given the intense competition in each case, but it was undeniably nice to see the franchise finally score its first Oscar love given that the universe has been a critical and commercial mammoth for over a decade.

Plus, Suicide Squad won the DC Extended Universe an Oscar back in 2017, so it was neat to see the MCU not only even the score but take a firm lead.

Advertisement

7. Alfonso Cuarón Makes History With Best Cinematography Win

ABC & AMPAS

It certainly wasn't a surprise that Alfonso Cuarón won the Best Cinematography Oscar for his incredible lensing on Roma, but it did mark a unique achievement in the field of cinematography, because it's the first time a director has ever been nominated for the Oscar, let alone won it, for working as the DP on their own film.

Advertisement

If nothing else it's yet another incredible testament to Cuaron's immensely multi-faceted talents, now having Best Director, Best Film Editing and Best Cinematography Oscars to his name.

He "only" needs Best Picture and a screenplay win to complete the set, and given his status as an awards darling, it's probably just a matter of time.

Advertisement

6. Spider-Man: Into The Spider-Verse Wins Best Animated Film

ABC & AMPAS

Though Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse was the easy critical and awards circuit favourite going into the Oscars, the Academy's general voting block has a historic favouritism towards Pixar, so many fans were still anxious that they'd give the Best Animated Film Oscar to Incredibles 2.

Advertisement

But thankfully that wasn't the case, and Into the Spider-Verse scooped the gong, becoming by far the most deserving win in the category since Toy Story 3 triumphed back in 2011.

Writer-producer Phil Lord, producer Chris Miller and Peter Ramsey took to the stage to give some brief but poignant speeches about the importance of diversity, though sadly, co-director Bob Persichetti was cut off just as he began to speak, apparently planning to pay tribute to the late Stan Lee. Boo!

Advertisement

5. Mike Myers & Dana Carvey's Wayne's World Reunion

ABC & AMPAS

Though Bohemian Rhapsody didn't have much business being in contention for many "serious" Oscars, its inclusion did lead to one of the most crowd-pleasing moments of the night, when Wayne's World duo Mike Myers and Dana Carvey showed up to introduce the film.

Advertisement

The pair took the stage, looking mighty sharp no less, as they recalled a few quick quips from the iconic 90s comedy to the crowd's delight, before paying tribute to Bohemian Rhapsody as both a song and a film.

Given that the iconic tune made the opening scene of Wayne's World an instantly unforgettable classic, picking the duo to fill this slot was an extremely inspired choice.

Advertisement

So, Wayne's World 3?

4. First Man Wins Best Visual Effects

ABC & AMPAS

After losing both sound awards to Bohemian Rhapsody, it was starting to look like First Man might get shut out completely from the gold, but thankfully, the Academy finally saw sense and gave it the Best Visual Effects Oscar.

Advertisement

It's an especially impressive win given that Damien Chazelle's Neil Armstrong biopic was up against the might of Avengers: Infinity War, which did some truly boundary-pushing work with the absurdly convincing renderings of Thanos (Josh Brolin).

But what First Man achieved on a mere $60 million budget is nothing short of remarkable, expertly combining practical and digital effects to create a seamless, stunning whole.

Advertisement

It's outrageous that First Man wasn't in wider Oscar contention, but at least it gingerly avoided being completely snubbed.

3. Spike Lee FINALLY Wins An Oscar

ABC & AMPAS

It's tough to believe that the Academy has never given Spike Lee an Oscar over the course of his storied 30+ year career, but thankfully that all changed with his Best Adapted Screenplay win for BlacKkKlansman.

Advertisement

Presented by a delighted Samuel L. Jackson (alongside Brie Larson), the award is pretty much a career Oscar for the legendary filmmaker, who many feel should've won Best Director way back in 1990 for Do the Right Thing, yet was inexplicably only nominated for Best Original Screenplay.

Lee sadly only ended up with the single gong, but as recognition for his contributions as one of cinema's most singular and vocal voices, it's a damn relief to see him finally given the most "important" gold statue there is.

Advertisement

2. Shocker! Olivia Colman Beats Glenn Close For Best Actress

ABC & AMPAS

Surely the most crowd-pleasing surprise of the entire night was Olivia Colman's shock Best Actress win for her sublime performance in The Favourite.

Advertisement

Colman had pretty much been trailing Glenn Close all season long, who was widely expected to win a career Oscar on her seventh nomination.

But in a welcome twist, Colman's name was read out, and the Brit actress took to the stage to give a characteristically shell-shocked acceptance speech.

Advertisement

Close gave a very good performance in a merely decent film, but Colman's fantastic work in an almost equally fantastic film ultimately felt far more deserving.

Colman confirmed herself as speech-giver of the night with her closing inspirational gambit, "Any little girl that's practising her speech on the telly, you never know."

Advertisement

Sophie from Peep Show is now an Academy Award winner. What a crazy world.

1. Alfonso Cuarón Keeps The Mexican Best Director Streak Alive

ABC & AMPAS

As has been extremely common in recent years, there was yet another split between Best Picture and Best Director awards, with Best Picture of course going to Green Book while Best Director mercifully went to Alfonso Cuarón for Roma.

Advertisement

This marked Cuarón's fourth overall Oscar win and second Best Director victory, in what was one of the few truly, indisputably deserved wins of the night. Roma is an uncompromising film composed of a filmmaker's singular, unimpeded vision, and expertly executed to boot.

It also kept the recent winning streak alive for Mexican directors in the category. Of the last six winners, five of them have been Mexican: Cuarón for Gravity, Alejandro G. Iñárritu's back-to-back wins for Birdman and The Revenant, Guillermo del Toro for The Shape of Water, and now Cuarón again for Roma. Damien Chazelle was the streak-breaker for La La Land back in 2017.

Advertisement

Clearly there's something in the water over there, and given the mind-boggling talent between these three Mexican directors alone, it's a streak that can happily endure.

What did you think of this year's Oscars? Shout it out in the comments!

Advertisement