Oscars 2021 Review: 8 Ups & 8 Downs

The weirdest Oscar season ever finally comes to a close.

By Jack Pooley /

Pixar & Sony Pictures Classic

The absolute slog that is this year's Oscar season has finally, finally come to an end, with the 93rd Academy Awards largely delivering the results most pundits and fans had picked weeks if not months ago.

Advertisement

Indeed, it wasn't a particularly exciting or surprising night for viewers - with one major exception, at least - and despite the producers' attempts to deliver a glitzy ceremony for the age of COVID, some of the lavish special sauce of a "proper" Oscar show definitely felt missing this year.

If some highly questionable creative calls were made behind-the-scenes, Oscar voters should at least be commended for spreading the wealth and rewarding a broad swath of films, such that The Trial of the Chicago 7 was the only Best Picture nominee to go home empty-handed.

Advertisement

As next year will (hopefully) be back to business as usual for the Oscars, which are currently scheduled for February 27, we should all try and luxuriate in the abject, once-in-a-lifetime weirdness of this year's ceremony.

If nothing else, it was like no Oscar show anyone will ever see again, for better and worse...

Advertisement

Downs...

8. The In-Person Ceremony Is A Weird Mess

ABCR

This year's Oscar ceremony was always going to differ hugely from the norm, though with the Academy forging ahead with an in-person ceremony split across several countries and co-producer Steven Soderbergh promising an ambitious "cinematic" Oscars, expectations were high for the best of all the COVID-era awards shows.

Advertisement

On one hand it was definitely refreshing to see so many nominees together in the same room, and staging the main hub in Los Angeles' Union Station gave it an undeniably intimate feel.

But there were also numerous head-scratching creative decisions which made the show feel patently less-than compared to a typical Oscars broadcast.

Advertisement

Worst of all, most categories didn't feature any clips of their respective films, and the categories that did show clips were seemingly picked at semi-random. For casual audiences who might not be aware of every nominee, it seemed like a totally thoughtless oversight.

Though the lack of reliance on Zoom calls was a plus, and the show got off to a promising start with Regina King's Ocean's Eleven-style entrance to Union Station, it's tough to feel like Soderbergh and co. really delivered a diverting Oscars for the pandemic era, even accepting the obvious challenges involved.

Advertisement

All in all, though, the biggest mistake of the night wasn't at all related to the pandemic, but that misguided calculation to shake up the running order of the awards - but we'll get to that later.

7. Best Animated Feature Film: Soul Beats Wolfwalkers

Pixar

Academy members generally voted along incredibly predictable lines this year, and though for the most part that wasn't an issue given the fine work they rewarded, it was a shame to see voters playing things so safe and unadventurous away from the "major" film categories.

Advertisement

Best Animated Film, for instance, predictably went to Pixar's Soul, which has effortlessly steamrolled its way to the Oscar podium despite the arguably superior - and broadly better-reviewed - Wolfwalkers being ripe for the win.

If interviews with anonymous Oscar voters in recent years have proven anything, it's that many voters don't even bother watching the five animated nominees and will generally just defer to the Pixar movie rather than abstaining.

Advertisement

That's not to say Soul isn't a great film, but the Pixar win feels so depressingly foregone almost every single year because many Oscar voters are too lazy to do the actual leg-work.

6. Best Documentary Feature: My Octopus Teacher Beats Four Better Movies

Netflix

The most bizarre success story of this Oscar season has unquestionably been Netflix's nature documentary My Octopus Teacher - a visually stunning if shamelessly lightweight film about a filmmaker who becomes obsessed with an octopus.

Advertisement

It's a fine enough film, but its awards momentum is baffling considering the superior quality and more urgent topicality of every single other nominee.

Romanian documentary Collective, a chilling indictment of political corruption in the country, felt like the natural winner of the group, but Crip Camp, The Mole Agent, and Time were also very strong films about disability, ageing, and systemic racism.

Advertisement

The fact that My Octopus Teacher is easily the most accessible and least-depressing of the nominees appears to have worked in its favour, offering escapist entertainment in an extremely difficult year for everyone.

5. The Cringe-Worthy "Oscar Trivia" Segment

ABC

Though this year's Oscar ceremony was well-paced and fast-moving for the most part, the final moments of the show were agonisingly bloated out by an horrendous "Oscar trivia" segment in which Lil Rel Howery quizzed a few members of the audience on their Oscar music knowledge.

Advertisement

Andra Day soon enough talked of her love for Prince's "Purple Rain" - which was snubbed for a nomination back in 1985 - before Howery turned his attention to Glenn Close.

What followed was a blatantly scripted but no-less-awkward skit in which Close identified E.U.'s 1988 one-hit wonder track "Da Butt," before getting up and effectively twerking.

Advertisement

While on one hand it was mildly amusing to see Close letting loose, it overall felt like such a desperately contrived attempt to create a Viral Moment in what's sure to be one of the least-watched Oscar shows in history that most of the fun was sucked right out.

At this point in the show most European viewers were very eager to get to bed, and distending the otherwise pacy ceremony with this nonsense just wasn't worth it.

Advertisement

4. Best International Feature Film: Another Round Beats Quo Vadis, Aida?

Nordisk Film

The Best International Feature Film Oscar predictably went to the Mads Mikkelsen-starring drama Another Round, which while a thoroughly entertaining film in its own right, didn't hit nearly as hard as the category's two strongest nominees.

Advertisement

Bosnian war drama Quo Vadis, Aida? - a towering and important achievement that's arguably superior to most of the Best Picture nominees - likely turned out too bleak for Oscar voters craving some more relatable escapism this year.

The same is true for Romanian documentary Collective, a vital indictment of systemic corruption which, in a year defined by so many reasons to feel cynical about the world, simply didn't connect in the way that Another Round did.

Advertisement

The voting rationale is easy to understand, though if we're voting on films strictly by their quality - as we should - Another Round would be mid-tier in this category.

3. The Rushed In Memoriam Segment

ABC

One of the heart-wrenching highlights of any Oscar ceremony is the annual In Memoriam segment, which touchingly honours those members of the film community who passed away since the previous ceremony.

Advertisement

Yet this year's montage was widely criticised for how speedily it rushed through the names, flashing most names and images on the screen for scarcely a second each, such that viewers struggled to even read their names and make sense of who they were.

Though this past year saw an above-the-odds number of deaths around the world, rushing through the list was clearly the wrong solution, when it's never before been a complaint that the In Memoriam segment of all things is too long.

Advertisement

Increasing the feeling of ick is the fact that some of the bigger names, such as Sean Connery and Chadwick Boseman, were lingered on for far longer than lesser-known talents, which at best feels mildly gross and at worst flat-out disrespectful.

This is without even getting into the fact that a number of talents were conspicuously snubbed from the montage entirely: Arrested Development's Jessica Walter, Glee star Naya Rivera, broadway actor Nick Cordero, and Oscar-nominated songwriter Adam Schlesinger.

Advertisement

2. Best Makeup & Hairstyling: Ma Rainey's Black Bottom Beats Pinocchio

Netflix

Another disappointing-yet-predictable calculation from the Academy was the decision to award the Best Makeup & Hairstyling Oscar to Ma Rainey's Black Bottom over Pinocchio.

Advertisement

Though the winning film certainly did a fine job with its makeup and hair work - particularly that applied to a perennially sweaty Viola Davis - Pinocchio's next-level makeup truly felt innovative and groundbreaking in ways that Ma Rainey's Black Bottom just didn't.

The fact that a quick glance at Pinocchio's face would likely leave most viewers assuming he was a CGI fabrication is all the proof you need of the gorgeously textured and contoured makeup job for not only the title character but all the fantastical creations throughout the film.

Advertisement

Sadly Pinocchio was easily the least well-known of the five nominees, and considering most Oscar voters clearly didn't even watch it, it didn't stand much of a chance.

1. Saving Best Actor For Last Backfires Spectacularly

ABC

The Academy took a bold gamble with the awards running order this year, by announcing the Best Picture Oscar before Best Actress or Best Actor, despite it traditionally always being saved for last.

Advertisement

It's clear that the show's producers were confident of a Chadwick Boseman Best Actor win to end the night on an emotional, news-worthy high, but when Anthony Hopkins scored the upset victory, it couldn't help but end the show on a perversely hilarious anti-climax.

Beyond viewers being denied the catharsis of a devastating speech from the late Boseman's wife Taylor Simone Ledward, Hopkins wasn't present to accept his award, so the show ended with presenter Joaquin Phoenix sheepishly accepting it on his behalf before the feed was promptly killed.

Advertisement

The cynical short-sightedness of producers banking on an Oscar win for Boseman is gross and frustrating for several reasons: it confirms they contrived excessively to make a Moment out of a posthumous win, it undeniably took away from what should've been a wonderful moment for Hopkins - attendance or not - and also made Nomadland's Best Picture win two awards prior feel a little less special.

It is a decision that served nobody well, though should make it unlikely that anyone will attempt to toy with the running order so radically ever again. Yikes.

Advertisement

But these gripes aside, here's what this year's Academy Awards actually got right...

Ups...

8. The Shorter Runtime & Fast-Paced Show

ABC

At "only" 3 hours and 19 minutes in length, this was the shortest Oscars broadcast in almost a decade, ensuring the typically torturously bloated broadcast was a little easier to sit through than usual.

Advertisement

This was in part due to the sound categories being combined, meaning there was one less Oscar to give out, and the five musical performances for the Best Original Song category being relegated to the pre-show.

Though it was still a relatively lengthy ceremony for the standards of most pandemic-era awards shows, the fact that it spent less time on guff skits - apart from the aforementioned trivia round - while giving winners seemingly unlimited time to make their speeches was a major improvement.

Advertisement

Nobody needs this thing to creep close to four hours as it has in previous years.

7. Best Adapted Screenplay: The Father Beats Nomadland

Sony Pictures Classics

One of the most hotly contested awards this year was Best Adapted Screenplay, for though the favourite going into the show was Nomadland, it was far from a sure thing with The Father beating it to the BAFTA a few weeks prior.

Advertisement

As wonderfully written as Nomadland might be, the nimbleness with which Christopher Hampton and Florian Zeller adapt Zeller's own play to the cinematic medium is extremely impressive.

Considering how virtually every other nominated movie adapted from a play this year felt at least a little stage-y, that The Father is wholly cinematic in every fiber of its being is a testament to not only the direction and acting but the fantastic script.

Advertisement

6. No Play-Off Music During Acceptance Speeches

ABC

One of the major, undeniable improvements of this year's show was the decision not to introduce play-off music for any winner whose acceptance speech was deemed to be running "too long."

Advertisement

In previous years the Academy's producers have been rightly dragged for trying to speedily usher winners off the stage inside of a tight 90 seconds, while typically proving stricter with winners in "lesser" categories.

Most infamously, 2013's Oscars saw winners played off with John Williams' iconic Jaws theme, but this year there wasn't any such mean-spiritedness.

Advertisement

Though in part a result of the show's low-key presentation, it was neat to see winners from all categories given as much time as needed to say their thank-yous, particularly Another Round director Thomas Vinterberg, who had time to pay moving tribute to his late daughter Ida.

One suspects Soderbergh's involvement as co-producer may have had a hand in organising this, himself an Oscar-winner who can surely appreciate the pressures placed upon victorious artists.

Advertisement

5. Daniel Kaluuya Gives The Speech Of The Night

ABC

Though the more stripped-down nature of the night meant that there were disappointingly few awards winners who took to the stage to give boozy acceptance speeches, Daniel Kaluuya still became the night's MVP with his meme-worthy speech.

Advertisement

Accepting the Best Supporting Actor Oscar for his sublime performance as Fred Hampton in Judas and the Black Messiah, Kaluuya was as coolly charming as ever, until it came time to pay tribute to his mother, Damalie Namusoke, who was in attendance at the show.

Kaluuya hilariously said, "My mum met my dad, they had sex, it's amazing!," which in of itself is one of the strangest things ever said on any Oscar podium ever.

Advertisement

To hammer the hilarity home, though, the producers immediately cut to the bemused facial expression of his dear mum. Brilliant.

4. ChloƩ Zhao's Historic Best Director Win

ABC

One of the night's most predictable but also most satisfying wins saw Nomadland writer-director-producer-editor ChloƩ Zhao take home a well-deserved Best Director Oscar.

Advertisement

This was especially significant because it not only made Zhao just the second woman in Oscar history to win Best Director - behind Kathryn Bigelow for The Hurt Locker in 2010 - but the first non-white woman ever to win Best Director.

In a year which saw the Academy pick their most diverse slate of nominees ever - including two female Best Director nominees - it's massively satisfying that one of the most prestigious awards went to an under-represented demographic, and an artist who was also thoroughly deserving of the win.

Advertisement

3. Best Supporting Actress: Youn Yuh-Jung Prevents A Glenn Close Victory

ABC

Though the Best Supporting Actress Oscar race swung in favour of Minari's Youn Yuh-jung in recent weeks, her win was by no means guaranteed with well-supported heavyweights like Olivia Colman (The Father) and Glenn Close (Hillbilly Elegy) in the mix.

Advertisement

Given that this was Close's eighth win without a nomination, she's the Oscars' current go-to "over-deserving" darling, and so it wouldn't have been at all surprising if voters effectively gave her a career Oscar for the Ron Howard drama.

But given that Hillbilly Elegy is in no way nomination-worthy and this is surely the weakest of all Close's nominated performances - more the fault of the script than her work - it's a relief that she didn't take home the gold for undeserving work.

Advertisement

Considering that Close is imminently due to begin shooting a movie adaptation of the musical Sunset Boulevard - for which Close won a Best Actress Tony Award back in 1995 - there's a very solid chance she'll take home the gong for that film. Everyone wins.

2. Trent Reznor & Atticus Ross Win Second Oscars

ABC

Unsurprisingly, Soul won the Best Original Score Oscar, scoring a first-time gong for jazz pianist Jon Batiste and second Oscars for composers Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross.

Advertisement

Few Nine Inch Nails fans could've ever anticipated that Reznor would become an Oscar fave, but a decade after he and Ross won their first Oscars for scoring The Social Network, they're now picking up awards for a Pixar film of all things. Surreal.

It's all the more impressive an achievement considering they were effectively competing against themselves with their Mank score also in contention, and history dictates how this often leads to a split vote that causes nominees to win neither award.

Advertisement

Thankfully that wasn't the case here, and two of the most talented composers working today received another well-earned Oscar each.

1. Shocker: Anthony Hopkins Beats Chadwick Boseman For Best Actor

Sony Pictures Classics

Again, the big shock of this year's show was Anthony Hopkins winning the Best Actor Oscar over season-long favourite Chadwick Boseman.

Advertisement

Though it's frustrating how cynically the Academy bet on a Boseman win by having this category close out the night, ultimately Hopkins' performance is a monumental feat of acting that surpasses anything else in the category this year.

While it's easy to sniff at the Academy for rewarding an old white guy who already has an Oscar to his name, this absolutely wasn't a case where Oscar voters' typically milquetoast prejudices showed them up.

Advertisement

Hopkins' monolithic turn is an absolute all-timer, and ranks among the very best Oscar-winning performances of all time.

As such, any ire about the outcome should be directed at the producers of the show for setting expectations otherwise, rather than an 83-year-old man for simply delivering the work of a lifetime.

Advertisement