Pacific Rim Vs. Transformers - Which Is Better?

Who would win in a fight?

By Ashleigh Millman /

As technology progresses and we stumble ever onwards into the future, films have aptly reflected our experience of what could be just around the corner for humankind. Science fiction is a haven of artificial intelligence, aliens, and of course, robots, with everything from Wall-E to the Terminator depicting scenarios for our favourite metal companions.

Advertisement

With that in mind then, it's only right that we face off the biggest and baddest of those creations against each other to find out who would REALLY win in a fight. It's time to ask the question: which is better out of a world of giant alien robots versus other giant alien robots, and a world of giant robots versus giant aliens. Wait, what?

Of course, I’m talking about Transformers and Pacific Rim, the only films that matter when it comes to huge metallic smackdowns in the name of saving earth. Whilst it may seem pretty obvious from the outset who would squash the other like a car compactor into a tiny metal cube of shame, we’re going to take a look at it all the same.

Buckle up, shut up, and sit yourself down for some serious debate over which giant robot is best suited to planet-protecting glory. Earth is only big enough for one race of machine behemoths, after all.

7. Size

Getting straight into the nitty gritty, this is definitely the largest disparity between our two beloved robot pals, and I’m sorry to say it guys, but size definitely does matter.

Advertisement

Del Toro’s Jaegers come in at over 250 foot tall, with the largest, Cherno Alpha, sitting at a whopping 280 ft. To put that to scale, they come in at just under the height of the statue of liberty, which is certifiably crazy when you image a giant mechanical beast wandering around your city.

On the other hand, Transformers vary in size, and the leader of the Autobots Optimus Prime comes in at a meek 28 ft, making him literally 10 times smaller than the ocean defenders of Pacific Rim. Whilst there's comic book variations of the Decepticons that could put all of our contenders to shame, we're going strictly on the films - so I think it’s fair to say that the well-endowed Jaegers have this one in the bag.

Winner: Pacific Rim

6. Manoeuvrability

Of course, being small isn’t that much of a hindrance when it comes to smashing sh*t up; and Transformers more than make up for their feeble size in their sheer determination to whizz around like the cast of Jersey Shore on a coke binge in all of Michael Bay’s insane depictions.

Advertisement

Able to transform (get it) into all sorts of human machinery and repurpose their bodies into whatever is most useful at the time, Autobots are designed to disable Decepticons through a range of quick, tactile movements embellished with missiles, guns, and all manner of explosive add-ons - making them very good at maneuvering through tight spaces.

Jaegers are limited by their construction - they can’t utilise weapons that will maim kaijus in the same way as Transformers as the blood is toxic and will devastate water supplies, making their main sources of combat sheer blunt force in hand-to-hand scenarios. They need to be sturdy, strong, and destructive in a different way - and this is a sacrifice to their agility.

Transformers snips it when considering Jaegers can be disabled by the mental connection between the pilots dropping out like bad AOL dial-up, rendering them all but useless.

Winner: Transformers

5. Sword-Wielding Ability

There’s no way we’re going through these films without a solemn nod to the ludicrous notion of fully optimised robot fighters hashing it out with giant swords. But who does it better?

Advertisement

In one particularly outrageous scene, Pacific Rim’s Gypsy Danger activates a previously hidden sword mechanism, slicing open a kaiju in what can be accurately marked as the point in time where Guillermo Del Toro completely gave in to the film’s B-Movie heritage. Whilst it’s a short moment compared to the ongoing melee throughout the Transformers movies, it’s one that’s so badass it’s at least on par with Optimus Prime and gang, and then played out through Uprising. It’s just such a perfect set up.

On the actual handling of swords, it’s got to be a tie: the fact that both of them do it at all is enough to make both of them winners really.

Winner: Draw

4. Strength

This is another no brainer. Should a Jaeger catch hold of a pesky Transformer during a face off, there’s no way it isn’t getting crushed like a tin can under a steam roller. They can wield cargo ships like baseball bats, are implemented with plasma cannons, and the OGs are fuelled by a !*$% nuclear reactor.

Advertisement

Transformers do have a deceptive strength, but comparatively it's feeble when pitted against the powerhouses designed to utilise their environment like literal toys. One wrong step and the Transformers would be flattened under the sheer size, weight, and might of a Jaeger - though it would probably feel the same as treading on a lego does for us, so I wouldn't recommend this method of robot desctruction.

Changing into a fancy car is a neat gimmick, but Jaegers literally use them as weapons to bounce off kaiju heads for fun. Try zipping around in a lamborghini when there’s a gravity sling throwing you about.

Winner: Pacific Rim

3. Functionality

This is an interesting section to speculate, as deep down, we’re pitting advanced human technology, and humans themselves, against an ancient alien race trained in taking down other giant robotic creatures. The Transformers have existed for thousands of years both on and off Earth, and have repeatedly defeated Decepticons bigger and badder than they are multiple times.

Advertisement

Jaegers, sometimes to their disadvantage, are powered by two human minds meshing with drift technology, requiring inherent understanding of each other and a neural awareness that stops them from ‘chasing the rabbit’. We’re only as good as our technology, and as it stands, that technology is perfect for alien bashing as demonstrated on the kaijus. However, whether it would be as effective on something as self-aware and intelligent as a Transformer is an arguable case.

Handing a single human the reigns of a Jaeger is nearly impossible, whereas Autobots are self-sufficient enough to plough through. Completely irregardless of their strength and size, the minds of the alien transformers beat out our brutish human counterparts.

Winner: Transformers

2. As Films

Let’s be blunt, one is directed by Michael Bay, and one is directed by Guillermo Del Toro. In filmic terms, it’s like pitting Sharknado: Oh Hell No against Jaws. That’s not to say all shark films aren’t great, just one clearly has a bit of extra bite. Bay is blood in the water. You know where I’m going with this fin-ale...

Advertisement

Tastes vary and the films are offering two very different sci-fi universes, with one rife in explosive action and playing on the nostalgia of our youth, and the other a visionary experience that subverts genre expectation with nuanced characters and development.

Pacific Rim on the whole knows what it is and what it wants to achieve much more clearly than the tonally confused Transformers, and relays it in a much easier to watch fashion than the mangled metallic messes of Michael Bay’s mind that appear in sloppy fight scenes.

Winner: Pacific Rim

1. Verdict

It’s a victory royale for Pacific Rim.

Advertisement

In the face of a 25 story robot charged with nuclear power, armed with an abundance of ridiculous weaponry, and able to withstand attacks of almost any force - the manoeuvrable and logical Transformers don’t stand a chance. Elementary, my guys.

Again, this is through looking at the films alone, so a completely different outcome would be on the cards if the entire Transformers history could be taken into play, and the now extended Pacific Rim universe.

Either way, Jaegers are a mighty fine choice for defending the Earth from extraterrestrial and even interdimensional threats - so hopefully we get to see more of them as the Pacific Rim franchise grows and improves. Here's to the chainsword.

Do you agree with the outcome? What else is there to consider in robot WWE? Share your thoughts in the comment section below.

Advertisement