Co-written by Damon Lindelof, we expected that Ridley Scott's epic Prometheus would leave us with a fair few unanswered questions but not the tidal wave we have been left with since its release a few weeks back. The Prometheus script has to be one of the worst examples of modern day science fiction writing. It's lazy, full of plot holes and cheese. In true Lindelof style, there are lots of nice ideas that have a lot of potential for scope but eventually they all lead to an unsatisfying conclusion. The film looked spectacular, the cinematography was amazing and Michael Fassbender did a brilliant job as the android David. It's just a shame the rest of the film was a mess. The following is a list of twenty questions and problems we had with the film, some have already been picked up before but this is my take on all the things that made Prometheus one of the most disappointing films of recent times. Here we go.....
1: Downloading Error
Early on in the film we see David learning languages from films, specifically Lawrence of Arabia. I presume this is so that he can talk to whoever they meet on the assumption that these beings can speak something that resembles a language on Earth. This is fine, it's a long journey and he needs something to do, I guess. But if hes a robot, why don't they just download all this information into him in the first place? It seems like the smart thing to do because then you can make sure all the information is in there. So why is David learning stuff from a film when it's much easier to program him? Click "next" below to read the next entry...
2: 36 Hours?
When they awake from hyper-sleep, David explains that they have been asleep for 2 years, 4 months, 18 days, 36 hours, 15 minutes. If he is using established temporal units to measure time, then shouldn't he have actually said ''2 years, 4 months, 19 days, 12 hours and 15 minutes?'' Why 36 hours?? Also, how did they travel all that distance in such a short time? The nearest star to us is Proxima Centauri which is just over 4 light years away. That means it takes light 4 years to travel that distance. We also know that the speed of light is a universal barrier that cant be broken so then how did they get where they wanted to in just 2 years? Wormhole? Warp drive?
3: Christmas Tree
The first thing the captain does (rather than act like a professional and sort himself out) is decorate a Christmas tree. That is fine but shouldn't he have more important things to do? Also, when he is informed that there is a mission briefing, something that should be important to him considering he is the captain, he decides that he wants to get something to eat. How about instead of messing around with a Christmas tree, you spend that time sorting your shit out and eat so you can be ready for the briefing. It's to demonstrate to the audience that the captain is a bit of a laid back rebel but done in the worst, haphazard way. The captain is useless in this film and i'll give a couple of examples to show you why. When he takes the Prometheus into the atmosphere, instead of performing a scan first, he decides to ask about the make up of the atmosphere just as he makes contact with it. It's a good thing that it didn't contain anything that might damage the ship! And as two of his crew are ''lost'' in a cave (even though hes been watching them on a 3D map) he thinks that it's the best time to go have sex with Charlize Theron in what has to be the crappiest scene from any film this year. Along with every time he's on screen, he continually makes you wonder how did this man work his way up to captaining is own ship? And after spending most of the film behaving like he would rather be watching TV at home, he and two other crew members suddenly decide to turn into heroes and make the ultimate sacrifice by crashing their ship into the alien one. All because Shaw (Noomi Rapace) said so. Considering they are about to kill themselves, all three act like they are going on a road trip and deliver some of the cheesiest lines in the film. This whole sequence is so random, I sat in the cinema shaking my head.
4: Do I Know You?
The crew on the ship don't come across like people who are too interested in details. They don't seem to be too bothered about the discoveries they make, they are not worried when some of their colleagues go missing and they didn't seem to care to find out what the mission was about before they signed up for it. A couple of the crew can be overheard trying to guess what the mission is, why did these people go on a mission without asking any questions? Before accepting to go and making all the arrangements to go on a long space flight, finding out why you are going might be a question on the top of your list. To add insult to injury, the crew also don't seem to know each other. When they first wake up, the scientist and geologist have a conversation that makes it clear they have just met. Charlize Theron at the briefing says says hello to the people she hired personally, and then introduces herself to the rest. For an important and expensive mission like this, would she not already have met everyone? Did everyone just climb into the pods before entering hyper sleep without introducing themselves?
4: I dont its what I choose to believe.
During the briefing, someone has the sense to ask Elizabeth Shaw are they are all here because ''...of a map you two kids found in a cave?'' Shaw tells everyone that ''its not a map, its an invitation'' from aliens she calls Engineers. When she is rightly asked how does she know all this, Shaw reassures everyone by saying I dont its what I choose to believe. If I had traveled all this way because someone had faith rather than hard facts, I would have had some serious questions to ask at this point, but I would have asked all these before i got on the ship. The crew are more vacant than David and just sit there like this is all making sense. I almost felt like I should step in on their behalf and stop this exploitation. And in the same briefing, how did Weyland's hologram know where to look? Were the seating arrangements prearranged just so they matched up with what the hologram would be doing?
5: What Are You Doing?????
I'm no scientist but even I know that there can be toxins in the air that you may not be able to smell, Co2 being an example. So when the scientists all take their helmets off because they detect a breathable atmosphere, I was screaming ''what are you doing?????'' (in my head.) What about diseases, microbes and other stuff that could be in the atmosphere? But they all act like morons and take their protective helmets off and leave themselves open to any infection that might be waiting. And even before you go exploring the cave, shouldn't you map if first? It would make everything much easier.
6: Goo?
The black goo is bad, I got that. But what was the black goo? Was it different from the other goo David was touching? Where did that other goo come from? Obviously it was there to make you think of the stuff that a Xenomorph leaves behind but why is it there? It makes no sense!
7: What's The Emergency?
What were the Engineers running from in the recordings? It's not explained in anyway. Did something go wrong with the goo? We just see them running into a chamber. What was so urgent that one of them ended up decapitated? None of this is explained because the writers don't know. It's just stuff that happens.
8: ''I'm a geologist, I fucking love rocks!''
The scientist and geologist travel all that way only to run scared of a discovery that should have had them crying tears of awe. They have just discovered an alien corpse but instead of having some degree of scientific curiosity, their first reaction is to run. We all know the real reason this was in the script was to get these two characters separated, but it was done in the most lazy way and they had the worst motivation for doing so. You are scientists! Are you not wondering anything about what you have found? You are one of the first humans to see it! And wouldn't they have been pretested before the long and expensive space flight so that you knew they would actually do their job rather than run. Why is no one on the ship telling them to shut up and stay put. Charlize Theron was very quick to to tell Holloway and Shaw that they are ''employees'' because Weyland funded the trip, so does that not apply to the others? And before anyone says that one of them is a geologist and that his specialty is rocks, I got that when he shouted 'IM A GEOLOGIST..I FUCKING LOVE ROCKS!!'' But he's still a scientist and he should have shown a slight interest in what they found. Also, how did they get lost when the cave was mapped in 3D and their positions were being tracked? We know the script writers wanted them to separate from the group and get killed but we also know that they cant get lost because there is a detailed map on the ship with which they are in direct communication with. The writers wanted these two to get killed and didn't care about how many plot holes they made in getting these two to their doom. Lazy!
9: Storm
The captain informs the scientist and geologist that they cant be rescued because of a huge storm that's suddenly appeared. But he tells them that it's ok, it will pass by the morning and then they will be rescued. How does he know this? He didn't know the storm was coming until it was right on top of them. Does the ship not have sensors that are detecting weather patterns to keep the crew safe? And why was the captain acting like a jerk when he was telling them that they couldn't be rescued? They are on an alien planet, shouldn't he be concerned for their safety?
10: Douchbag
Can someone explain to me why Holloway was such a douchbag? He finds what can be best described as a monumental discovery in the history of mankind, but instead of being humbled by the experience, he gets drunk and behaves like a dick because he didn't get to talk to the aliens. And instead of showing any interest in the head that Shaw went to so much trouble to bring back, during the examination he sits at the back of the room getting drunk. I know he's supposed to be a ''cool'' archeologist/scientist but if you traveled all that way and found something that could change the foundations of human evolution, would sulking and getting drunk be the first things you do? He was also the idiot who would not wait to start the exploration of the cave even though the captain told him it would be the best thing to do as there was only six hours of light left. And lets not forget how quickly he took his helmet off, putting himself and the others in danger.
11: Flame Grilled
For what reason was Holloway infected? Did Weyland tell David to do it or did David do it on his own accord? If so, why did David decide to infect Holloway? In fairness, if I had to infect anyone on that crew, I would have picked Holloway for being so annoying but I might think twice if I was stuck on an alien planet where he is one of the key members of the team. Are there no other members of the crew that are more expendable? Even after he was infected, we didn't see the end result of the infection apart from a worm in his eye (what was that about?). As soon as he starts looking a bit sick, Charlize Theron fries him with a flamethrower in a scene that has none of the emotional gravitas it should. It's laughable the way he's shouting ''do it'' and notice that no one has a go at Charlize Theron for killing him.
12: Isn't It Cute?
The Scientist who initially ran at the sight of a corpse finally starts to behave like his job description suggests he should. He meets the alien sticking out of the black goo and genuinely seems amazed at what hes seeing. But instead of following some sort of a protocol for when you meet a species for the first time, he decides to act like hes just seen a new puppy for the first time. It's coming out of the water, he cant see all of it, how does he know whats on the other end of the tentacle? Why is he trying to touch it? In a situation like that you have to take extreme care just in case the creature can be hurt by you touching it and not to mention that it might be lethal.....and in this case it was.
13: Amazing Recovery
Having a Cesarian section is a very traumatic event to go through, both physically and mentally. So it was amusing to see Shaw have the procedure and then get up and run around like she just had a plaster put over a cut. Putting aside the metal trauma, the physical damage to the body should have meant that she was keeled over and unable to move. According to BabyCenter.co.uk, after a Cesarian, the following is how you will feel after a c-section; ''Just to make small movements, such as shifting up the bed, you'll probably need something or someone to hold onto. It will hurt to cough or laugh.'' It's moments like this that completely removed me from the film. The scene was written to compete with the chest-bursting scene in Alien. Obviously they could not top that because the shock factor has gone, so they tried to take it up a notch and introduce elements like self-abortion to make the scene memorable. But the problem with that is you can't ignore or change how a body will react if you inflict trauma like that to it. This is up there with the supernova that could ''destroy the galaxy'' in Star Trek (2009)
14: Fatttttthhhhherrrrrr......
What was the point in the ''big'' revelation that Charlize Theron was Weyland's daughter? What did it actually bring to the story? It could have been left ambiguous but no, the script writers treat the audience like morons and make her say ''Fatttttthhhhherrrrrr......'' like it's very important that we now know that she is his daughter. It's then completely dropped and not mentioned again in the film.
15: David's Motives
David's motives throughout the film are all over the place. Fassbender's acting was fine, it was just his character that hadn't been thought through properly. Is he good, is he bad or something in between? We don't know. He starts the film tapping into the crews dreams which could be considered an invasion of privacy. He appears to show more concern for the crew than the captain does. He sneaks on board a deadly substance and uses it to infect Holloway. During the climax he warns Shaw that the Engineer is coming to find her. He's all over the place. People say that is what makes him interesting. But his character hasn't been designed like that, it's because the people writing the film have no idea. When he was needed to set another event in motion, they wrote lines to make it happen with any thought about character.
16: Chimps?
If we are created from the Engineers, where does the other DNA on Earth come from? Science can trace the evolution of the human quite clearly so how do the Engineers fit into that? From what I gathered, the Engineer at the beginning of the film falls into the water and his DNA creates humans, that is why the DNA is an identical match. But what about chimps whose DNA is 98% similar? I don't think the writers cared about any of this when they were writing it and that is why the film fails. Not everyone watching this film is a moron. It also raises the question that if the Engineer made the ultimate sacrifice to start life on Earth, then why did they suddenly decide to wipe it out? No explanation is given for this. The Engineer they find on the planet wakes up angry and we don't know why. Is it something David said to piss him off when he was talking to him? This was another moment I was totally baffled in this film, what is the point in writing an antagonist and then not give him good motivation that we can understand and go with? This is basic stuff which the writers forgot or didn't care about. And why would the engineers leave maps on Earth that leads to a weapon research facility?
17: Sideways!!!
This had me laughing so much. This scene looked great and it was an awesome special effect. But logic would suggest that if a huge wheel is rolling a particular direction, it will keep rolling in that direction until it looses momentum and topple over. So, just like everything else in this film, no one does the logical thing of running sideways away from the rolling ship but instead they run in front of it. This is another moment that makes no sense. You cant write a big scene like this and leave an obvious way to get around the danger. I was shouting ''run to the side....run to the fucking side'' but neither of them listened and Charlize Theron ended up getting squashed. Nonsense!
18: Why Guy Pearce?
What was the point in casting Guy Pearce in the film? I can understand for the viral videos where he plays the younger Weyland but unless that younger Weyland is going to make a re-appearance, what was the point in making Guy Pearce wear all that fake make up? Could they not find an older actor to play the part? Making an actor look old by using prosthetics is always difficult, the end result never works. So it's strange they went to all the effort and expense to make Guy Pearce look old when finding an older actor would have been the best thing to do. Also, why was Weyland pretending to be dead? Was it so that the crew don't ask questions about the real reasons behind the mission? It's already been made clear that the crew is not bothered about small details like that and it might also explain why no one seemed shocked to find Weyland on the ship. In any case, Weyland is killed off so quickly, the whole thing seems pointless. What was the point of him being there? Did the dynamic of the film change thanks to him? Why would he spend so much money and travel such a long distance of the off chance he might meet his maker? It was just another ill thought idea that sounded good but no substance behind it to flesh it out.
19: Rushing To Climax
The ending of Prometheus is definitely the worst part of the film, it's so muddled. Somehow David knows that the pissed off Engineer is coming to find Shaw. We don't know how he knows this but he decides to be nice and warn her. You think that this is going to lead into a long cat and mouse sequence between the Engineer and Shaw, but as soon as the Engineer smashes his way into the room, Shaw presses a button and the engineer is attacked by the ''facehugger.'' There is no tension, no build up and no logic. Shaw decides that instead of going back to Earth, she is going to take David's head and one of the alien ships to go find more of these Engineers that tried to kill her and get ''answers.'' What will she be eating on this trip? Do they have a toilet on the ship? Maybe she will enter hyper sleep but is there a pod she can use on the ship? Is it configured for a human being? And can she trust David because hes been so trustworthy so far!
20: Prometheus?
Prometheus in Greek mythology was the Titan that was given the job by Zeus to create Man. He gave mankind a number of gifts including fire. Prometheus also tricked Zeus into giving Man the best parts of animals that were sacrificed for the gods. This annoyed Zeus who sentenced Prometheus to be chained to a rock and have his liver eaten by an eagle. Apart from the tenuous link about creating man, what else does anything in the film have to do with Prometheus? Not much, it's just an illusion to make you think that the film has depth. It's a film that would love to be thought of as raising questions about where we come from and how wondrous the universe is, but in fact it fails miserably. Just like Lost, Lindelof raises lots of interesting ideas initially and then takes them nowhere. He does this because all he can do is create a fake aura of mystery with nothing behind it to give you a satisfying conclusion. He thinks that by throwing lots of unanswered questions into a script, it will be enough for people to think the film has depth because they will endlessly debate them on the internet. That does not make a film deep or interesting, it makes it annoying. Films like 2001, Blade Runner and Star Trek" The Motion Picture done it right, Prometheus would love to be seen in the same group as those films but it's let down by a week script that has no thought behind it. The only thing you question when you leave the cinema is the script meetings where non of these issues were ironed out.