Ranking All Batman Vs. Superman Fights In Animation
Batman v Superman: Dawn of Animated Justice.
When Zack Snyder's Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice was first announced, it was a highly anticipated event like no other. The Caped Crusader and The Last Son of Krypton have always been a dream crossover and matchup in live-action. The thought of it finally happening felt like a dream come true, impossible just a few years before the golden age of superhero movies.
It is a different story in the world of animation. In this medium, the two icons of the superhero world always clash. If they meet for the first time (and they always do), there will be a battle. Even when the story is that they have known each other for years, they will somehow end up at each other's throats. There is always someone mind-controlling Clark. There is always a war of ideologies. It's a Monday in the DC Universe, and no one wants it any other way. This leaves the question: of all the Batman vs. Superman fights in animation, which one is the best?
The greatest gladiator match in the history of the world, God vs. Man, Day vs. Night, Son of Krypton vs. Bat of Gotham! Place your bets.
11. Superman: Red Son
In this animated adaptation of Superman: Red Son, Superman is an authoritarian dictator in Stalin-era Russia whose idea of rehabilitation is lobotomizing criminals into good behavior. Batman experienced life during his reign and has grown up into a rebel, opposing The Comrade of Steel. Since the two superheroes are darker versions of their traditional selves, their battle together is more brutal and tragic than usual.
This Caped Crusader had no problem kidnapping Wonder Woman by tying her up in her own lasso to lure the monstrous Supes out. When our favorite dictator took the bait, it turned out the entire place was lit up with red sun energy that neutralized Kryptonian powers. The Dark Knight pummelled his prey to a bloody pulp.
The appeal of this universe was that it took these iconic characters to grey areas. Only in this universe can Bruce threaten Clark with being trapped in a cold basement forever under a red light. Only here can Batman blow himself up with a bomb lodged inside of him to escape the Kryptonian's lobotomy.
If the characterization in this movie was stronger, it could have been one of the better matches. At least in its form now, it is unique in its gritty implications.
10. Batman Beyond S03 E08 - The Call, Part 2
Batman Beyond is set in a futuristic Gotham City, with Terry McGinnis as the new Batman, and Bruce Wayne serving as his mentor. In this future of the DC Animated Universe, fans have been wondering what happened to the iconic characters of DC’s past. When Superman appeared in season three, still on active duty as the leader of the future Justice League, it was a big event two-part episode. The shocking revelation was that he was the villain of the storyline because the parasitic Starro secretly latched onto the Man of Steel’s chest, so controlled his every move.
This was an underdog tale where the rookie hero faced off against the world’s greatest, including a chase scene where Terry needed to go full speed on the flying Batmobile to get away from the unstoppable god. The Bat won because he was not fighting the man; he was fighting the parasite on him. When he electrified the monster off Clark’s chest, he saved the man attached to it.
Throughout the two-parter, the Justice League questioned Terry's status as a worthy Dark Knight. Yet, when placed in the impossible situation of facing the best, he remained collected and beat the odds.
In the end, Batsy did not need the League’s approval. It was a strong arc, worthy of an appearance from Superman.
9. Justice League: War (Second Fight)
An army of Parademons is kidnapping thousands of people into their tower, where the people themselves will be converted to Parademons by DeSaad. One of the kidnapped is Superman. It is up to Batman to rescue him.
This battle of the heroes was heightened by the setup of Bruce's resourceful step-by-step process until he could get near the Son of Krypton. First, he disguised himself as a regular civilian so a Parademon would take him. When he got into the tower, he attacked the Parademon to move freely. DeSaad was painfully experimenting on Clark, and The Bat disguised himself as a Parademon to get near them. He figured out where the power button was on the device torturing Clark by how DeSaad was holding a knife.
When Clark got released from his torture table, he was a brainwashed rage monster. It became a show of the Gothamite's agility in dodging while he reasoned with Clark's humanity. The downside is that we never got to see when The Bat got him out of the trance. We can just assume it worked when they both showed up to defeat Darkseid.
Everything Bruce has done to rescue Clark could not have been done by other heroes in the Justice League, even with all their powers. This shows how essential The World's Greatest Detective is to the group despite being just a man.
8. The Batman S05 E02 - The Batman-Superman Story, Part 2
This clash is a combination of the battles in Batman: Hush and Batman: The Dark Knight Returns. Despite having all the cliches of every Batman vs. Superman fight involving a brainwashed Kryptonian, kryptonite, and battle armor, it kept things fresh with multiple locations.
The locations went from Lex Luthor’s lab, to the rooftop, to the Batcave, to the streets, and into a factory. Every location change highlights how relentless of a hunter The Man of Steel is. No matter how many times Bats slowed him down, the man kept on coming back, and the intermediate breaks were only used for preparation for the inevitable next round.
The only reason a mortal like Bruce had a fighting chance of survival, was that Robin kept on saving him at the last minute, highlighting the value of teamwork and Batman’s complete trust in his sidekick.
It had an original ending, with Bruce luring Clark into a plant-killer chemical factory to kill the mind-controlling plant spores inside the Kryptonian. Somehow, even with all the cliches, this animated episode got very creative.
The downside of this fight is that it got too long and Superman looked ineffective with multiple defeats.
7. The Batman/Superman Movie: World's Finest
This fight was quick but made an impression as one of the better meetings between The World’s Finest. Batman was on one of his missions, and The Man of Steel walked in, expecting his strength to keep The Bat in line. Then he got shocked when Batman tossed him across the room, showing that Batman can lift and move stronger opponents.
The humbled Man of Steel exercised his strength by pinning Batman to a wall. Superman then pressed on with his advantage by using his X-ray vision to take a peak in the cowl and threatened Bruce Wayne not to operate in his town. Bruce showed how prepared he was by taking out a slither of Kryptonite to repel the Last Son of Krypton and then disappearing.
Later that night, when Clark had already removed his suit and was about to get ready for bed, he discovered a small tracking device on his cape. When he used his super sight to see in the distance, he discovered Batman looking through his apartment with binoculars. Batman waves and then leaves.
The moment showed the two as equals—both in competence, skill, and intelligence. Mutual respect will come later, but they recognize each other’s skills and know that the other will be a formidable opponent. It was quick and to the point, but it was effective.
6. Lego DC Comics Super Heroes: Justice League – Cosmic Clash (First Fight)
As a kid-friendly Lego version of the DC Universe, one would think that this fight would feel less tense than the more serious versions. However, when Clark showed up and merged with Brainiac to try and kill Batman, he proved to be the scariest evil version of Superman out there. As a result, any physical altercation between the two is just as tense, if not more so, than the other versions.
The secret is that this Son of Krypton is a jolly and overly friendly Man of Steel who is always up for games and fun. So, when he became evil and still had that unbreakable friendly smile on his face and made threatening remarks, it was disturbing.
Not to mention that The Bat was no match for him. It was technically not a battle; it was just a struggle for survival versus a god who was treating the whole situation as fun and games.
The genius move was to take advantage of how wholesome this Krpytonian is. Nothing bothers this guy, and as an enemy, that is the scariest thing in the world. Superman became as disturbing as he did because he came from a script written specifically for children. How ironic is that?
5. Batman: The Brave And The Bold S03 E01 - The Battle Of The Superheroes
The third season of Batman: The Brave and the Bold started with a bang with The Battle of the Superheroes — a homage to the Silver Age era of The Man of Steel, full of Easter eggs and jokes.
Batman: Brave and the Bold has a campy kid-friendly vibe, and the show’s idea of an evil Man of Steel is that he puts cats on trees as a little girl cries. As a result, the fight between the two heroes cannot be taken seriously. However, a campy tone is a perfect platform for fan service and fun. Since Batsy battling Supes is inherently a fan service concept, it is perfect.
It is only in this series that Superman can say, "Faster than a speeding bullet... more powerful than a locomotive... able to leap tall buildings in a single bound" while beating up Batman as the Caped Crusader is wearing his battle armor from The Dark Knight Returns so that the battle can recreate iconic comic book panels.
Other projects can make the mistake of making the super friends overly serious for people who wear pyjamas to save the world. Batman: The Brave and the Bold reminds us that superheroes fighting each other just needs to be fun.
4. Lego DC Comics Super Heroes: Justice League – Cosmic Clash (Second Fight)
As a total surprise, the second and final match between Batman and Superman in Lego DC Comics Super Heroes: Justice League – Cosmic Clash is one of the best clashes of the titans in animation. The credit goes a long way towards the creepiest evil version of CK ever put to screen, animation or otherwise.
No matter what Bruce did, the Kryptonian just kept wearing a cheerful smile and kept cracking jokes. The best part was when he started singing about how pointless the fight was. Even mocking Bruce, the only use of Batman's battle armor was for it to be melted with Superman's laser vision while it was still on the Caped Crusader.
When Kryptonite was introduced into the equation, the subversion was that Batman did not use it. Instead, he grabbed a device that concentrates yellow sun energy so he could power up his friend so much his body would reject Brainiac in his system.
It’s a nice character bit, as it proved that the Dark Knight’s goal was not to defeat a villain, he wanted to help his friend in need. Thus, completing the Detective’s character arc by admitting he sees the Justice League as his friends.
Put this battle sequence into a more serious-toned project, and it will work just as well.
3. Batman: The Dark Knight Returns, Part 2
This iconic Superman vs. Batman action felt straight off the page of the iconic The Dark Knight Returns comic book, right down to Bruce's bulky armor and iconic lines. New sequences were added in between so that the battle can move on from just one street to crashing through walls of apartment buildings, and then to a construction site. What really captured the spirit of the comics, is that the story retained its subversion of superhero values.
The Dark Knight Return’s argument was that classical depictions of superheroes are secretly authoritative and fascistic. The dystopian future setting was the strain of time that brought it to its extreme, that their values got eroded. The Man of Steel’s dramatically muscular form and The Dark Knight’s ogrish design were how they presented that they had become a parody of their former selves. Nuclear Fallout Superman and Battle Armor Batman were the final forms of moral decay.
This battle was the final explosion of that building tragedy. Both characters departed so much from their morals, their relationship turned from being best friends to being enemies.
2. Batman: Hush
One of the more famous brawls in the comics was the duo's battle in Batman: Hush. When the comic was adapted into an animated form, it was one of the crucial moments the film needed to get right - and it did.
The battle was well animated and well choreographed with dynamic changes in settings; it started from a high floor of a building, with Bruce falling to the sea to escape, then under the sewers, and then up to the streets. All The Dark Knight’s moves were on-the-spot quick thinking to survive and slow the mind-controlled Man of Steel down.
The chief complaint about the idea of these two titans fighting is that it is unbelievable that Superman cannot just end the fight in a second. The storyline justified this by explaining that Clark was resisting mind control while simultaneously still attacking. It was an unbelievable excuse to let The Bat have a fighting chance, but also an impressive way to show the Detective’s intelligence as he improvised ways to take advantage (or trust) of his opponent’s good heart to distract him.
Both heroes look good after this fight — Kent showed his incorruptible heart, while Wayne showed his mad intelligence and confidence in his friend's heart.
1. Justice League: War (First Fight)
What makes this fight so great is the fast-paced animation and choreography on display, which made everything feel exciting. The Gothamite tried everything in his arsenal in quick succession to slow down or get away from Superman, but all the valiant efforts went to waste in front of The Man of Steel.
The animation gives off The Bat’s quick thinking, agility, and desperation, following every fast dodge with an attack. No dynamic movement felt wasted, as the Caped Crusader never repeated the same move twice. He did everything he could think of, while the Big Blue Boy Scout just kept on talking casually as he toyed with Bruce.
Green Lantern joined in the fight to assist The Dark Knight, but it became just the two of them trying to survive the onslaught of attacks. Even as the all-powerful god was charging at him, Batman never panicked, maintaining full control of the situation by holding his ground without a stutter.
The World's Greatest Detective revealed to Superman that he knows his secret identity as Clark Kent. Batman stopped the fight because all of his intelligence-gathering abilities were being used for diplomacy. Gotham's iconic hero showed complete trust that Kal-El would not kill him, and he showed this further by letting the Last Son of Krypton peek into his cowl. In return, Batman and Green Lantern gained a powerful ally.