Ranking Every Godzilla Incarnation

Long live the king of the Monsterverse

By Dalan Overstreet /

It is time to think bigger as Godzilla: King of the Monsters is set to hit cinemas worldwide this weekend. KOTM will be the second Godzilla film and third entry into Legendary's Monsterverse.

Advertisement

Since the monster's debut in 1954, Godzilla has been a steady presence on screen. As of today Godzilla tops such properties as James Bond and the Marvel Cinematic Universe as the longest running movie franchise of all-time.

With such a long and storied history Godzilla has taken many different forms. Every generation has been treated to their own version of the beast, some marveling at a larger than life God-like figure that protects the planet. Others were given a destructive force and apocalyptic threat to humanity. A lucky few even got to see Godzilla on water skis in an ad for Snickers (real thing that actually happened).

Considering that Godzilla is a large, atomic breath having, prehistoric beast it is amazing just how many iterations we have seen so far. Some have been better and more memorable than others, so before he graces our screens again lets take time to reflect on the King of the Monsters.

10. TriStar (Zilla)

Tristar Pictures is responsible for one of the most unforgettable iterations of Godzilla we have ever seen. The only problem is we would all rather forget. Directed Roland Emmerich, starring Matthew Broderick and featuring more Simpsons cast members than you realized at the time, TriStar's Godzilla film was one of the biggest film blunders of its decade.

Advertisement

This incarnation was shunned by Godzilla fans for virtually every reason, from the origin as a mutated iguana to the lizard's evasive fighting style. To list all of the problems, we would not know where the criticism of the monster ends and criticism of the movie itself begins.

Toho despised the creation even more than fans, disavowing the monster entirely. The creature is now known as Zilla, which arguably negates its entry on this list (the film is named Godzilla, so sadly it still counts).

If you're the glass half-full type, the accompanying Saturday morning cartoon fared far better. The ridiculous design from the film was still used, but Zilla actually engaged in some entertaining monster mayhem. Still, the film was too high a price to pay for the solid animated outing.

If presented in a vacuum as a completely original creation, and assuming it ever got made without the Godzilla name attached, Tristar's Zilla would have been relegated to pop culture obscurity. If only it were that lucky.

9. Hanna-Barbera

Yes, the same people that brought you The Flintstones and Huckleberry Hound also dabbled in leviathans. Hanna-Barbera's Godzilla Power Hour ran for two 13-episode seasons, first airing in 1978.

Advertisement

The show followed a team of scientists on ocean research expeditions. Every episode the team would run into a huge problem that only Godzilla, who they summoned with sonar signal, could solve. The show also introduced Godzilla's nephew, Godzooky, who did much of the comedic heavy lifting.

After revisiting the show, it isn't hard to imagine Hanna-Barbera's take on Godzilla being entertaining at the time, but it hasn't aged particularly well. At a time in which animation was still evolving, the monster battles in this show don't quite hold up.

Historically Godzilla has leaned more on the cheesy side, which this show often channels. The problem is this doesn't exactly travel seamlessly through the decades. Where kids could surely wake up on a Saturday morning and watch Magilla the Gorilla and The Jetsons, the Godzilla Power Hour is just filled with too much cringe.

The Godzilla Power Hour was the first stab at an animated Godzilla and was fairly decent for its time. However, it is very much a product of the 70s and should probably stay there.

8. Anime

With Godzilla's storied history and Japanese roots, it is difficult to believe an anime version of the character took so long. In 2017, Godzilla finally received an anime adaptation in the form of Godzilla: Planet of the Monsters. Two sequels, Godzilla: The City on the Edge of Battle and Godzilla: The Planet Eater, would soon follow.

Advertisement

In this world, Godzilla is a planet-destroying behemoth that drove humanity off world. After 20,000 years, mankind returns to Earth in an attempt to take the planet back from its new ruler. This Kaiju, dubbed Godzilla Earth, is by far the largest incarnation to date, standing over 300 meters tall.

The films, which are all currently streaming on Netflix, have their merits and their downfalls. To start positively, the animation is beautiful and the Godzilla-centric world is well-crafted. On the other hand we spend way too much time with poorly fleshed-out human characters and Godzilla himself, although clearly a threat, isn't as imposing as we would've hoped.

Watching these three films won't be the highlight of your week, but they are not a bad way to spend an evening. More importantly, they prove that Godzilla can work in this medium and warrant future anime adaptations.

7. Millennium Era

The Millennium Series kicked off in 1999 and lasted until 2004, producing six films in the span. Originally Sony was tasked to bring Godzilla into the new millennia, but following the 1998 film's tanking, Toho decided to bring the creation back under their own house.

Advertisement

What separates this period from other eras is that there is no continuity, electing to create an anthology series instead. This was also a period that saw the best use of visual effects, no longer solely relying on miniatures and rubber suits. With this said, most films in the era fall within the average, featuring new, often generic monsters even some Godzilla diehards wouldn't recognize.

Although the films were not great, at least they gave audiences a much-needed palate cleanser. To mark the 50th anniversary, the final film in this series, Godzilla: Finals Wars, threw any and all subtlety out the window and pit Godzilla against his American studio counterpart Zilla. What followed was a quick, decisive victory for Godzilla that sent the Sony-Tristar creation back to his maker.

Other than handing the biggest mistake in the franchise a beat down this era doesn't offer much, but should get some points for experimenting with the continuity a bit. You won't find the best Godzilla movies during this period, but this series was proof that Godzilla could survive in the 21st Century.

6. Comics/Manga

Although technically not just one iteration, Godzilla's history in comics and manga deserves mention. Godzilla comics, while often short on written material, feature some extradorinary artwork and some epic monster battles.

Advertisement

Godzilla's time on the page date back to his earliest days on the screen, with the first manga hitting shelves in Japan in 1954. With the exception of King Kong vs. Godzilla, every Toho-produced film of the 20th century received a manga adaptation. Along with the adaptations, Godzilla also received a few original mangas, starting with The Last Godzilla, a direct sequel to the 1954 film.

Godzilla has a lengthy history with American publishers as well, beginning with the one-off promotional comic Godzilla vs. Megalon in 1976. Godzilla comics have been produced under monikers such as Dark Horse, IDW Publishing and, most notably, Marvel. The King of The Monsters received a 24-issue run with Marvel between 1977-79, tangling with the likes of the Fantastic Four and the Avengers.

Today, Legendary is producing supplemental comics for the Monsterverse. These comics have given background on human characters, introduced Godzilla's first antagonist, the Shinomura, and further connected the Monsterverse.

Few characters that have originated on the big screen have a longer history on the page than Godzilla. The character's tenure in both manga and comics is a testament to his lasting appeal.

5. Showa Era

Where it all started. The Showa Era kicked off in 1954, lasting more than two decades. It is by far the longest series in Godzilla's canon with 15 feature length films.

Advertisement

If you asked a regular person to summarize the franchise, they will likely describe the Showa Era. With the exception of a couple entries, these Godzilla movies were campy and comically absurd. Only with this set of films will you find the King of the Monsters dancing, pitching boulders as if they were baseballs and flying through the air to deliver drop kicks.

Along with Godzilla, this era introduced the most noteworthy monsters in Toho's catalog, including Anguirus, Mechagodzilla, Gigan and Hedorah. Godzilla's more infamous company, Rodan, Mothra and King Ghidorah, all debuted in their own self-titled outings.

The Showa Series was a cinematic universe in a way, one that Legendary has surely used for inspiration. Look no further than 1962's King Kong vs. Godzilla, which first pit the two most notorious giants against one another.

Despite its cheesiness, the Showa Era Godzilla remains the most influential iteration to date. Unless you're looking for a B-movie, these flicks probably won't have much entertainment value for anyone other than Godzilla fanatics. However, with the longetvity of its creations and the Monsterverse rebooting some of its signature showdowns, the era will never be forgotten.

4. Legendary Monsterverse

When the Legendary-produced Godzilla hit theaters in 2014, American studios didn't have the best track record adapting the King of the Monsters. What we have now is not only the best interpretation of Godzilla a western nation has ever produced, but one of the best in the kaiju's 65-year history.

Advertisement

Legendary's Godzilla is the anchor to their Monsterverse. In this shared universe, monsters are prehistoric animals that retreated to hollowed points in the Earth as the world became less radiated. Due to human actions these monsters, labeled Titans, are resurfacing with Godzilla serving as the World's protector of the natural order.

2014's Godzilla was generally well-received, although most agree the film could have used more of the titular character. Legendary's take is about as grounded a Godzilla as we will probably ever get, using the behavior patterns and physical characteristics from real animals to create their beast.

Somewhat grounding the ancient lizard and other Kaiju have allowed the creators to give commentary on real-world issues in previous Monsterverse movies. Godzilla and Kong: Skull Island have dealt with topics such as environmental calamity, weapons of mass destruction and war. These very issues are the reason Godzilla was created.

With the release of Godzilla: King of the Monsters we will see how this universe is further shaped and how the stage for Godzilla vs Kong is set. In any case, we are witnessing one of the best and faithful incarnations of Godzilla ever.

3. Shin Godzilla

As Godzilla anchors Legendary's Monsterverse, Toho chose to develop a new live-action titan of their own. Premiering in 2016, Shin Godzilla ushered in a new era of live-action, Toho-produced Godzilla films and arguably the most unique version of the character ever.

Advertisement

Shin Godzilla's origin doesn't deviate from previous incarnations as it is a product of humanity's reckless use of radioactive materials. In a return to roots, and in contrast to Legendary's concept, Shin Godzilla is a mindless, hostile force that does nothing but destroy.

What separates Shin Godzilla from other incarnations is its appearance. As Legendary's take is meant to resemble animals in nature, Shin Godzilla is truly an unnatural creature born of radiation and mutation. This is the first Godzilla that transforms as the film progresses, featuring five distinct forms.

The fourth form is the most physically intimidating Godzilla ever created. Standing at 118 meters, it was the tallest live-action Godzilla by a comfortable margin. Shin Godzilla also features dozens of razor sharp teeth, red scales reminiscent of radioactive burns and a jaw that can unhinge and separate when delivering violent atomic blasts.

Although Godzilla is often depicted as a protector, there is plenty of entertainment value in watching a violent and aggressive interpretation. Toho has plans for a shared cinematic universe so it is likely we will see Shin Godzilla again soon in all his abominable glory.

2. Heisei Era

The Heisei Era follows the Showa Period and is the second longest series in the Godzilla franchise, beginning in 1984 and lasting through 1995. This era began with The Return of Godzilla, which was technically released with the Showa Era of films. However, since it is the beginning of a new continuity it is officially placed with the Heisei Series. This serves as a reminder that confusing timelines are universal.

Advertisement

The Return of Godzilla is the 16th film in the series, but serves as a direct follow-up to the 1954 original. This move was understandable as this era would prove to be a return to form for the character. This time the monster had a ferociousness and gravity many of the Showa Era films lacked. In this series, Godzilla was shown to be an enemy and, at times, a tentative ally to mankind.

Although it didn't debut household names like Mothra and King Ghidorah, The Heisei Period introduced fans to some of the most vicious enemies Godzilla has ever encountered, including Biollante, Mecha-King Ghidorah and Destoroyah, the latter of which killed Godzilla's son. At the time, this series featured the most brutal monster fights put to screen, many of which are still enjoyable today.

Heisei Era may not be quite the best incarnation of Godzilla, but it is currently the best period in Godzilla's storied history.

1. The Original

Sometimes the original is best. Godzilla debuted to Japanese audiences in 1954 with a classic monster movie that sparked fear in audiences and created a legend. Although canonically the first film in the Showa Era, this Godzilla is radically different than the rest of the period.

Advertisement

This iteration of Godzilla was awoken after American Hydrogen Bomb tests in the Pacific. Once out of its slumber, Godzilla began ravaging Japan, obliterating Tokyo and the fictional island of Odo. It is only through the development of their own super-weapon, the Oxygen Destroyer, can Japanese Military forces put an end to the destruction.

The 1954 original is a not-so-subtle commentary on weapons of mass destruction, namely the atomic bombs that devastated Japan in World War 2. Less than ten years after the calamity, Japan was still reeling and Godzilla served as an allegory for the paranoia and havoc that plagued the country. Sometimes, a giant monster knocking over buildings can articulate feelings and fears better than words ever could.

Sixty-five years later and no other interpretation has been able to match the one that started it all. 1954's Godzilla stands shoulder-to-shoulder with 1933's King Kong as the most influential giant monster movies of all-time.

Advertisement