Scream Review: 6 Ups & 4 Downs
Scream's latest sequel is an entertaining - if uneven - addition to the franchise.
While other horror franchises have come and gone, falling by the wayside amid a glut of increasingly terrible sequels, Scream has enjoyed impressive longevity over the last 25 years.
This is undeniably in part because the filmmakers - typically late director Wes Craven and writer Kevin Williamson - only rustled up a new movie when they actually had something worthwhile to offer. Scream 3 excepted, of course.
And now the fifth Scream is here, at once ironically sharing the title of the 1996 original and doing so because, as we all know, numbered sequels beyond three represent a risk to that ever-precious box office.
Though this new Scream doesn't get close to the tenacity or cleverness of the first two films in the series, this is a respectably mid-tier entry that, in the very least, has something to say about the state of modern horror and how we consume entertainment as a whole.
Few are likely to come away feeling that it was a necessary sequel or has carved a particularly interesting direction for future installments, but it at least seems to confirm that Scream 3's mediocrity was a mere unfortunate blip...
Downs...
4. Not Enough Sidney Or Gale
Perhaps the single biggest disappointment of Scream is how it deals with two of its three biggest legacy characters - but don't worry, this isn't a spoiler.
Though Dewey (David Arquette) gets an impressively fleshed-out arc and a ton of screen time with the new characters, the inclusions of Gale (Courteney Cox) and especially Sidney (Neve Campbell) feel considerably more forced and unnatural.
While this is admittedly a "legacy sequel" that itself makes fun of legacy sequels, the fact that it makes two of the series' most iconic characters feel like afterthoughts is itself a sin that so many other "requels" are guilty of.
Cox and Campbell are clearly game for what the script has to offer them, but their presence ultimately seems more like a fan-driven obligation than one necessitated by the story.
3. There Are Some Lazy Storytelling Choices
James Vanderbilt and Guy Busick's script clearly relishes poking fun at some of the more unsavory aspects of modern cinema, namely excessively franchised IP, artsy "elevated horror," and also the entitlement of toxic fandom.
This is all well and good, but there are times where it feels like the script uses these meta elements as a crutch to paper over some of its weaker and more contrived storytelling elements.
Yes, Scream has always been inherently convoluted, but there are times where this movie's script gets dangerously close to becoming the very thing the series has sent up from the beginning.
The third act in particular requires the audience to buy some fairly sizable conveniences, and when it indulges some of the most-loathed tropes of the very thing it's critiquing - that is, the legacy sequel - the script ends up feeling like a mixed bag of smart meta-narrative commentary and lazy storytelling.
2. The Uneven Pacing
The Scream films have all been on the longer side for horror movies - close to two hours or in the case of Scream 2 exactly two hours - and the new one is no different.
But at 114 minutes, Scream 2022 feels it length more than any of the other films due to the somewhat wonky pacing.
The second act in particular is a little saggy, the overlong downtime between set-pieces most obviously where a few minutes could've been trimmed.
Perhaps that runtime might've been permissible were Scream doing anything particularly daring or fresh with the series' formula, but given that it largely plays a revised version of the hits for the current era, it really could've been tightened up during editing.
1. The Big Reveals Are A Mixed Bag
There won't be even the vaguest hint of spoilers here, but if you're hoping that the fifth Scream manages to deliver a battery of climactic plot twists and reveals on par with the better ones in the series (that is, 1 and 4), you should probably lower your expectations.
There are certainly some interesting ideas at play late in the movie, but the basic whodunnit aspect of the film is fairly standard fare for the series and arguably even quite predictable.
While no Scream sequel could be blamed for failing to meet the brilliance of the original Billy/Stu reveal, what transpires here doesn't feel nearly as smart or well thought-out as even the Jill/Charlie reveal in Scream 4.
That's not to say the third act payoff is bad because it absolutely isn't, but it simply lacks the wow factor fans will unavoidably be expecting.
These issues aside, though, Scream is certainly still a worthy addition to the franchise. Here's what it gets right...
Ups...
6. The Meta Satire Is Smart & Hilarious
The single defining trait of the Scream franchise above all others has always been its giddy, shameless self-awareness, using the template of a slasher movie to make fun of not only slasher movies but the horror genre as a whole.
And the fifth Scream unsurprisingly doesn't stray from that tradition, with the film's themes and commentary hinged around criticising Hollywood's obsession with nostalgia-baiting legacy sequels.
That's not the only iron in the fire, though: there's also blatant mockery of toxic fandom, gentle ribbing of the aforementioned elevated horror, and also the frequent indication that humanity is just a little too reliant on the conveniences of technology.
For long-time fans of the series who also count themselves as horror fiends, these aspects will land with good humour and sly wit, even if in their specificity to the current era of horror one suspects they won't age quite as well as, say, Scream 4's massively ahead of its time social media critique.
Still, in the moment as viewed today, the satire absolutely works, even if the script sometimes leans a little too hard on satire to hand-wave some of its lazier screenwriting choices.
5. David Arquette Steals The Show
Of the series' three major legacy characters, Dewey is by far the one best-serviced in this new movie, getting a generous amount of screen time as the washed-up, strung-out former sheriff dragged back into the field when another Ghostface emerges.
This is easily David Arquette's best work playing Dewey, as he evolves from a quasi-joke character into a genuinely well-realised person with palpable, relatable emotions about where he's landed in his life.
Though Dewey gets a generally more serious-minded treatment in this installment, that's not to say he isn't party to some funny moments too, and Arquette of course knows how to nail the tone either way.
Arquette certainly gives the strongest and most evocative performance in the film, and unlike Gale and Sid, Dewey actually feels like a totally necessary piece of the puzzle.
4. The BRUTAL Death Scenes
The fourth Scream film famously upped the gore in a few key moments to pass hilarious commentary on the uptick of torture porn movies releasing at the time, and the new movie carries on where it left off with arguably the series' most savage and visceral batch of kills to date.
Directors Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett proved with Ready or Not that they know how to stage a creatively gory death scene, and while certainly not as over-the-top as that movie, Scream's kill scenes are a lot of grisly fun.
The filmmakers linger on some absolutely brutal violence as Ghostface dismantles their victims, ensuring the screen is flooded with blood at times, and an impressive marriage of practical and visual effects was presumably employed to achieve some of the more ambitiously disgusting outcomes.
At least a few of the series' best-ever kills occur in this movie, which alone would probably be enough to give it a passing grade.
3. The New Cast Kills It
It's always a concern with legacy sequels that the new younger cast simply won't cut it, but thankfully Scream's cast of new victims are for the most part pretty great.
The clear standouts among the pack are Jenna Ortega as protagonist Sam's (Melissa Barrera) sister Tara, Jack Quaid as Sam's exasperated older boyfriend Richie, and perhaps best of all Jasmin Savoy Brown as Randy's niece Mindy, who is basically exactly what you'd expect Randy's niece to be in the best way possible.
While it'd be practically impossible for the new cast to live up to the iconic original set, they certainly feel fleshed out as distinct characters in their own right, no matter that some of them are clearly designed as modern updates of the originals.
2. The Direction Is Worthy Of Wes Craven's Legacy
One of the biggest worries about Scream 5 was that it's the first not to be directed by Wes Craven, who of course died in 2015 and receives a dedication at the start of this movie's end credits.
For a while, Craven's death felt like the categorical death of the franchise also, but directors Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett have proven here that other skilled filmmakers can deliver respectful continuations of his vision.
Bettinelli-Olpin and Gillett smartly don't try to deviate much from the series' existing style, though despite costing barely half what Scream 4 did it's actually much better-looking, ditching that film's hideous soft, overlit aesthetic for something darker and more dramatic.
Beyond the visuals, the pair also know how to craft a suspenseful set-piece, ensuring that this new take on Scream slots comfortably alongside the previous four and doesn't stick out in any major way.
1. The Fan Service (Mostly) Works
It's a Scream movie so of course it's hilariously aware of itself and its own legacy, but the new film's relentless mockery of nostalgia-bait sequels ensures it also ends up delivering its own fair share of fan service.
While there are certainly times where the homages to previous death scenes or set-pieces feel a little excessive or pandering, for the most part fans are likely to feel appropriately served by the many nods and tributes to what came before.
Beyond its narrative, this thing is also packed with Easter eggs, many of which surely won't be spotted until the VOD release.
Overall there's just a lot of love for the previous films in Scream's script and visuals, yet in a way that makes sense while not taking itself too seriously or holding itself with the bizarre excessive sentiment of, say, Ghostbusters: Afterlife.